Human skin equivalents (HSEs) are three-dimensional culture models that are used as a model for native human skin. In this study the barrier properties of two novel HSEs, the fibroblast-derived matrix model (FDM) and the Leiden epidermal model (LEM), were compared with the full-thickness collagen model (FTM) and human skin. Since the main skin barrier is located in the lipid regions of the upper layer of the skin, the stratum corneum (SC), we investigated the epidermal morphology, expression of differentiation markers, SC permeability, lipid composition, and lipid organization of all HSEs and native human skin. Our results demonstrate that the barrier function of the FDM and LEM improved compared with that of the FTM, but all HSEs are more permeable than human skin. Further, the FDM and LEM have a relatively lower free fatty acid content than the FTM and human skin. Several similarities between the FDM, LEM and FTM were observed: (1) the morphology and the expression of the investigated differentiation markers were similar to those observed in native human skin, except for the observed expression of keratin 16 and premature expression of involucrin that were detected in all HSEs, (2) the lipids in the SC of all HSEs were arranged in lipid lamellae, similar to human skin, but show an increase in the number of lipid lamellae in the intercellular regions and (3) the SC lipids of all HSEs show a less densely packed lateral lipid organization compared with human SC. These findings indicate that the HSEs mimic many aspects of native human skin, but differ in their barrier properties.
AlepeeN., TornierC., RobertC., AmsellemC., RouxM.H., DoucetO., PachotJ., MeloniM., de Brugerolle de FraissinetteA.A catch-up validation study on reconstructed human epidermis (SkinEthic RHE) for full replacement of the Draize skin irritation test. Toxicol In Vitro, 24:257. 2009.
NetzlaffF., LehrC.M., WertzP.W., SchaeferU.F.The human epidermis models EpiSkin, SkinEthic and EpiDerm: an evaluation of morphology and their suitability for testing phototoxicity, irritancy, corrosivity, and substance transport. Eur J Pharm Biopharm, 60:167. 2005.
7.
El GhalbzouriA., SiamariR., WillemzeR., PonecM.Leiden reconstructed human epidermal model as a tool for the evaluation of the skin corrosion and irritation potential according to the ECVAM guidelines. Toxicol In Vitro, 22:1311. 2008.
8.
CarlsonM.W., Alt-HollandA., EglesC., GarlickJ.A.Three-dimensional tissue models of normal and diseased skin. Curr Protoc Cell BiolChapter 19, Unit 19.92008.
9.
EngelhartK., El HindiT., BiesalskiH.K., PfitznerI.In vitro reproduction of clinical hallmarks of eczematous dermatitis in organotypic skin models. Arch Dermatol Res, 297:1. 2005.
10.
GarlickJ.A.Engineering skin to study human disease—tissue models for cancer biology and wound repair. Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol, 103:207. 2007.
11.
MildnerM., JinJ., EckhartL., KezicS., GruberF., BarresiC., StremnitzerC., BuchbergerM., MlitzV., BallaunC., SterniczkyB., FodingerD., TschachlerE.Knockdown of filaggrin impairs diffusion barrier function and increases UV sensitivity in a human skin model. J Invest Dermatol, 130:2286. 2010.
12.
BoelsmaE., GibbsS., FallerC., PonecM.Characterization and comparison of reconstructed skin models: morphological and immunohistochemical evaluation. Acta Derm Venereol, 80:82. 2000.
13.
El-GhalbzouriA., GibbsS., LammeE., Van BlitterswijkC.A., PonecM.Effect of fibroblasts on epidermal regeneration. Br J Dermatol, 147:230. 2002.
14.
PonecM., BoelsmaE., WeerheimA., MulderA., BouwstraJ., MommaasM.Lipid and ultrastructural characterization of reconstructed skin models. Int J Pharm, 203:211. 2000.
15.
El GhalbzouriA., LammeE., PonecM.Crucial role of fibroblasts in regulating epidermal morphogenesis. Cell Tissue Res, 310:189. 2002.
16.
BoehnkeK., MiranceaN., PavesioA., FusenigN.E., BoukampP., StarkH.J.Effects of fibroblasts and microenvironment on epidermal regeneration and tissue function in long-term skin equivalents. Eur J Cell Biol, 86:731. 2007.
BouwstraJ., PilgramG., GoorisG., KoertenH., PonecM.New aspects of the skin barrier organization. Skin Pharmacol Appl Skin Physiol, 14,Suppl 1:52. 2001.
19.
WhiteS.H., MirejovskyD., KingG.I.Structure of lamellar lipid domains and corneocyte envelopes of murine stratum corneum. An X-ray diffraction study. Biochemistry, 27:3725. 1988.
20.
McIntoshT.J., StewartM.E., DowningD.T.X-ray diffraction analysis of isolated skin lipids: reconstitution of intercellular lipid domains. Biochemistry, 35:3649. 1996.
21.
BouwstraJ.A., GoorisG.S., van der SpekJ.A., BrasW.Structural investigations of human stratum corneum by small-angle X-ray scattering. J Invest Dermatol, 97:1005. 1991.
22.
BouwstraJ.A., GoorisG.S., DubbelaarF.E., PonecM.Phase behavior of lipid mixtures based on human ceramides: coexistence of crystalline and liquid phases. J Lipid Res, 42:1759. 2001.
DamienF., BonchevaM.The extent of orthorhombic lipid phases in the stratum corneum determines the barrier efficiency of human skin in vivo. J Invest Dermatol, 130:611. 2010.
25.
BathejaP., SongY., WertzP., Michniak-KohnB.Effects of growth conditions on the barrier properties of a human skin equivalent. Pharm Res, 26:1689. 2009.
26.
SchmookF.P., MeingassnerJ.G., BillichA.Comparison of human skin or epidermis models with human and animal skin in in-vitro percutaneous absorption. Int J Pharm, 215:51. 2001.
27.
NetzlaffF., KacaM., BockU., Haltner-UkomaduE., MeiersP., LehrC.M., SchaeferU.F.Permeability of the reconstructed human epidermis model Episkin in comparison to various human skin preparations. Eur J Pharm Biopharm, 66:127. 2007.
28.
Schafer-KortingM., BockU., DiembeckW., DusingH.J., GamerA., Haltner-UkomaduE., HoffmannC., KacaM., KampH., KersenS., KietzmannM., KortingH.C., KrachterH.U., LehrC.M., LiebschM., MehlingA., Muller-GoymannC., NetzlaffF., NiedorfF., RubbelkeM.K., SchaferU., SchmidtE., SchreiberS., SpielmannH., VuiaA., WeimerM.The use of reconstructed human epidermis for skin absorption testing: results of the validation study. Altern Lab Anim, 36:161. 2008.
29.
AsbillC., KimN., El-KattanA., CreekK., WertzP., MichniakB.Evaluation of a human bio-engineered skin equivalent for drug permeation studies. Pharm Res, 17:1092. 2000.
30.
AckermannK., BorgiaS.L., KortingH.C., MewesK.R., Schafer-KortingM.The Phenion full-thickness skin model for percutaneous absorption testing. Skin Pharmacol Physiol, 23:105. 2010.
31.
Marjukka SuhonenT., Pasonen-SeppanenS., KirjavainenM., TammiM., TammiR., UrttiA.Epidermal cell culture model derived from rat keratinocytes with permeability characteristics comparable to human cadaver skin. Eur J Pharm Sci, 20:107. 2003.
32.
ZghoulN., FuchsR., LehrC.M., SchaeferU.F.Reconstructed skin equivalents for assessing percutaneous drug absorption from pharmaceutical formulations. Altex, 18:103. 2001.
33.
GibbsS., VicanovaJ., BouwstraJ., ValstarD., KempenaarJ., PonecM.Culture of reconstructed epidermis in a defined medium at 33 degrees C shows a delayed epidermal maturation, prolonged lifespan and improved stratum corneum. Arch Dermatol Res, 289:585. 1997.
34.
KennedyA.H., GoldenG.M., GayC.L., GuyR.H., FrancoeurM.L., MakV.H.Stratum corneum lipids of human epidermal keratinocyte air-liquid cultures: implications for barrier function. Pharm Res, 13:1162. 1996.
35.
PonecM., WeerheimA., KempenaarJ., MulderA., GoorisG.S., BouwstraJ., MommaasA.M.The formation of competent barrier lipids in reconstructed human epidermis requires the presence of vitamin C. J Invest Dermatol, 109:348. 1997.
36.
PappinenS., HermanssonM., KuntscheJ., SomerharjuP., WertzP., UrttiA., SuhonenM.Comparison of rat epidermal keratinocyte organotypic culture (ROC) with intact human skin: lipid composition and thermal phase behavior of the stratum corneum. Biochim Biophys Acta, 1778:824. 2008.
37.
BouwstraJ.A., GoorisG.S., WeerheimA., KempenaarJ., PonecM.Characterization of stratum corneum structure in reconstructed epidermis by X-ray diffraction. J Lipid Res, 36:496. 1995.
38.
El GhalbzouriA., CommandeurS., RietveldM.H., MulderA.A., WillemzeR.Replacement of animal-derived collagen matrix by human fibroblast-derived dermal matrix for human skin equivalent products. Biomaterials, 30:71. 2009.
39.
BouwstraJ.A., GroeninkH.W., KempenaarJ.A., RomeijnS.G., PonecM.Water distribution and natural moisturizer factor content in human skin equivalents are regulated by environmental relative humidity. J Invest Dermatol, 128:378. 2008.
40.
ThakoersingV.S., PonecM., BouwstraJ.A.Generation of human skin equivalents under submerged conditions-mimicking the in utero environment. Tissue Eng Part A, 16:1433. 2009.
41.
De JagerM., GroeninkW., Bielsa i GuivernauR., AnderssonE., AngelovaN., PonecM., BouwstraJ.A novel in vitro percutaneous penetration model: evaluation of barrier properties with p-aminobenzoic acid and two of its derivatives. Pharm Res, 23:951. 2006.
42.
BlighE.G., DyerW.J.A rapid method of total lipid extraction and purification. Can J Biochem Physiol, 37:911. 1959.
43.
MottaS., MontiM., SesanaS., CaputoR., CarelliS., GhidoniR.Ceramide composition of the psoriatic scale. Biochim Biophys Acta, 1182:147. 1993.
44.
MasukawaY., NaritaH., ShimizuE., KondoN., SugaiY., ObaT., HommaR., IshikawaJ., TakagiY., KitaharaT., TakemaY., KitaK.Characterization of overall ceramide species in human stratum corneum. J Lipid Res, 49:1466. 2008.
45.
CaussinJ., GoorisG.S., JanssensM., BouwstraJ.A.Lipid organization in human and porcine stratum corneum differs widely, while lipid mixtures with porcine ceramides model human stratum corneum lipid organization very closely. Biochim Biophys Acta, 1778:1472. 2008.
46.
ChengT., TjabringaG.S., van Vlijmen-WillemsI.M., HitomiK., van ErpP.E., SchalkwijkJ., ZeeuwenP.L.The cystatin M/E-controlled pathway of skin barrier formation: expression of its key components in psoriasis and atopic dermatitis. Br J Dermatol, 161:253. 2009.
47.
BouwstraJ.A., GoorisG.S., BrasW., TalsmaH.Small angle X-ray scattering: possibilities and limitations in characterization of vesicles. Chem Phys Lipids, 64:83. 1993.
48.
JanssensM., GoorisG.S., BouwstraJ.A.Infrared spectroscopy studies of mixtures prepared with synthetic ceramides varying in head group architecture: coexistence of liquid and crystalline phases. Biochim Biophys Acta, 1788:732. 2009.
49.
GroenD., PooleD.S., GoorisG.S., BouwstraJ.A.Is an orthorhombic lateral packing and a proper lamellar organization important for the skin barrier function?Biochim Biophys Acta, 1808:1529. 2011.
50.
GoorisG.S., BouwstraJ.A.Infrared spectroscopic study of stratum corneum model membranes prepared from human ceramides, cholesterol, and fatty acids. Biophys J, 92:2785. 2007.
51.
MakV.H., CumpstoneM.B., KennedyA.H., HarmonC.S., GuyR.H., PottsR.O.Barrier function of human keratinocyte cultures grown at the air-liquid interface. J Invest Dermatol, 96:323. 1991.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
