A Comparative Analysis Regarding the Osseointegration of Immediate Loaded Implants Using Two Different Implant Site Preparations: Erbium:Yttrium-Aluminum-Garnet Laser Versus Surgical Conventional Way—An In Vivo and Histological Animal Study

Abstract

Objective:

The aim of the study is to evaluate the possibility of preparing the implant site using the erbium:yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Er:YAG) laser scanner prototype and to reduce and/or eliminate time between primary (mechanical) stability and secondary (biological) stability, looking to the immediate occlusal loading in a single implant.

Background:

A prerequisite for successful osseointegration is the establishment of direct bone-to-implant contact without interposition of nonbone or connective tissue. In recent years, the use of laser radiation was presented as an alternative/adjunctive treatment for bone tissue ablation due to vaporization of the tissues in the absence of a smear layer.

Methods:

The experimental protocol included six minipigs, which underwent tooth extraction, followed (after 2 months) by implant bed preparation in two methods: using a conventional bur kit and using an Er:YAG laser scanner (X runner) protocol. Four implants were placed in positions 34, 37, 44, and 47 on each animal. The animals underwent the second surgical procedure for bone sample collection (including the implant) before their sacrifice at 45–60–90–120 days. The newly formed bone was evaluated on the bone samples using histological examination and quantitative evaluations of different histological parameters based on microscopical analysis.

Results:

The results that we obtained allow some interesting comparison in terms of different bone composition, depending on the method of implant site preparation and on healing periods. Moreover, it was possible to compare the bone composition, at different time stages, of implant sites prepared in the same way.

Conclusions:

Our research allowed us to demonstrate that the use of Er:YAG laser compared with traditional drill leads to the presence of a greater share of lamellar bone and a lower necrotic share in the implant site. We also showed the possibility of applying immediate occlusal loading on an in vivo animal model.