The practice of heading in soccer has become a public concern because of the potential for subconcussive impacts to cause cumulative concussive-like effects; however, experimental evidence for this hypothesis has been mixed. This systematic review used pre-defined search parameters to assess primary literature that examined changes in cognitive, behavioral, structural, and/or biological processes after acute heading exposure in youth and young adult soccer players. The findings were synthesized into a concise and comprehensive summary of the research following the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) format, and suggestions for standardization of acute heading protocols are described. A total of 1189 articles were considered for this review, with 19 articles meeting all of the inclusion criteria for full analysis. An attempt was made to identify methods with significant sensitivity and reliability by grouping studies based on their outcome measures. Because of lack of standardization across intervention types and data collection protocols, no sensitive and reliable methods could be identified conclusively to assess the effects of acute heading exposure in soccer players. Based on this review, there is not enough evidence to either support or refute the potential of effects of subconcussive events from acute soccer heading exposure. Recommendations for standardization of acute heading exposure studies based on the included literature are discussed. Standardization is required to better understand the impact of acute heading exposure in soccer players, while allowing for the development of guidelines that mitigate any potential risks and allowing athletes to remain active and develop their skills.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
KunzM. (2007). 265 million playing football. FIFA Mag. 7, 11–15.
2.
About Us | Canada Soccer. (Date unknown). Available at: www.canadasoccer.com/about-s14644.
3.
Who is US Youth Soccer? | US Youth Soccer. (Date unknown). Available at: www.usyouthsoccer.org/about/who-is-us-youth-soccer/.
4.
ShendrukA. (2014). Soccer vs. hockey: Who plays what in Canada. Macleans: Toronto. Canada.
5.
HanlonE. (2009). Biomechanics of heading in youth soccer. Dissertation.
6.
KirkendallD.T., JordanS.E., and GarrettW.E. (2001). Heading and head injuries in soccer. Sports Med. 31, 369–386.
7.
SpiottaA.M., BartschA.J., and BenzelE.C. (2012). Heading in soccer: dangerous play?. Neurosurgery, 70, 1–11.
8.
StewartW.F., KimN., IfrahC.S., LiptonR.B., BachrachT.A., ZimmermanM.E., KimM., and LiptonM.L. (2017). Symptoms from repeated intentional and unintentional head impact in soccer players. Neurology, 88, 901–908.
9.
BailesJ.E., PetragliaA.L., OmaluB.I., NaumanE., and TalavageT. (2013). Role of subconcussion in repetitive mild traumatic brain injury. J. Neurosurg. 119, 1235–45.
10.
KoerteI.K., LinA.P., MuehlmannM., MerugumalaS., LiaoH., StarrT., KaufmannD., MayingerM., SteffingerD., FischB., KarchS., HeinenF., Ertl-WagnerB., ReiserM., SternR.A., ZafonteR., and ShentonM.E. (2015). Altered neurochemistry in former professional soccer players without a history of concussion. J. Neurotrauma, 32, 1287–1293.
11.
LiptonM.L., KimN., ZimmermanM.E., KimM., StewartW.F., BranchC.A., and LiptonR.B. (2013). Soccer heading is associated with white matter microstructural and cognitive abnormalities. Radiology, 268, 850–857.
12.
WitolA.D., and WebbeF.M. (2003). Soccer heading frequency predicts neuropsychological deficits. Arch. Clin. Neuropsychol. 18, 397–417.
13.
ComstockR.D., CurrieD.W., PierpointL.A., GrubenhoffJ.A., and FieldsS.K. (2015). An evidence-based discussion of heading the ball and concussions in high school soccer. JAMA Pediatr. 169, 830–837.
14.
LevyM.L., KasasbehA.S., BairdL.C., AmeneC., SkeenJ., and MarshallL. (2012). Concussions in soccer: a current understanding. World Neurosurg. 78, 535–544.
15.
MackayD.F., RussellE.R., StewartK., MacLeanJ.A., PellJ.P., and StewartW. (2019). Neurodegenerative disease mortality among former professional soccer players. N. Engl. J. Med. 381, 1801–1808.
16.
FIFA. (2018). FIFA Activity Report 2018. Available at: www.fifa.resources.com.
17.
WimoA., GuerchetM., AliG.C., WuY.T., PrinaA.M., WinbladB., JönssonL., LiuZ., and PrinceM. (2017). The worldwide costs of dementia 2015 and comparisons with 2010. Alzheimers Dement. 13, 1–7.
18.
US Soccer. (2016). Implementation guidelines for U.S. Soccer's Player Safety Campaign: concussion initiatives & heading for youthpPlayers. Available at:
19.
ArnettJ.J. (2000). Emerging adulthood: a theory of development from the late teens through the twenties. Am. Psychol. 55, 469–480.
20.
RutherfordA., StephensR., and PotterD. (2003). The neuropsychology of heading and head trauma in Association Football (soccer): a review. Neuropsychol. Rev. 13, 153–179.
21.
MaherM.E., HutchisonM., CusimanoM., ComperP., and SchweizerT.A. (2014). Concussions and heading in soccer: a review of the evidence of incidence, mechanisms, biomarkers and neurocognitive outcomes. Brain Inj. 28, 271–285.
22.
CacceseJ.B., and KaminskiT.W. (2016). Minimizing head acceleration in soccer: a review of the literature. Sports Med. 46, 1591–1604.
23.
PeekK., ElliottJ.M., and OrrR. (2020). Higher neck strength is associated with lower head acceleration during purposeful heading in soccer: a systematic review. J. Sci. Med. Sport, 23, 453–462.
24.
Checklists and notes. (Date unknown). Available at: www.sign.ac.uk/checklists-and-notes.
25.
Feed | Mendeley. (Date unknown). Available at: www.mendeley.com/newsfeed.
26.
BroglioS.P., GuskiewiczK.M., SellT.C., and LephartS.M. (2004). No acute changes in postural control after soccer heading. Br. J. Sports Med. 38, 561–567.
27.
HaranF.J., TierneyR., WrightW.G., KeshnerE., and SilterM. (2013). Acute changes in postural control after soccer heading. Int. J. Sports Med. 34, 350–354.
28.
HwangS., MaL., KawataK., TierneyR., and JekaJ.J. (2017). Vestibular dysfunction after subconcussive head impact. J. Neurotrauma, 34, 8–15.
29.
MangusB.C., WallmannH.W., and LedfordM. (2004). Analysis of postural stability in collegiate soccer players before and after an acute bout of heading multiple soccer balls. Sport. Biomech. 3, 209–220.
30.
KaminskiT.W., ThompsonA., WahlquistV.E., and GluttingJ. (2020). Self-reported head injury symptoms exacerbated in those with previous concussions following an acute bout of purposeful soccer heading. Res. Sport. Med. 28, 217–230.
31.
Di VirgilioT.G., HunterA., WilsonL., StewartW., GoodallS., HowatsonG., DonaldsonD.I., and IetswaartM. (2016). Evidence for acute electrophysiological and cognitive changes following routine soccer heading. EBioMedicine, 13, 66–71.
32.
GutierrezG.M., ConteC., and LightbourneK. (2014). The relationship between impact force, neck strength, and neurocognitive performance in soccer heading in adolescent females. Pediatr. Exerc. Sci. 26, 33–40.
33.
SchmittD.M., HertelJ., EvansT.A., OlmstedL.C., and PutukianM. (2004). Effect of an acute bout of soccer heading on postural control and self-reported concussion symptoms. Int. J. Sports Med. 25, 326–331.
34.
AzadA.M., Al JumaS., BhattiJ.A., and DelaneyJ.S. (2016). Modified Balance Error Scoring System (M-BESS) test scores in athletes wearing protective equipment and cleats. BMJ Open Sport Exerc. Med. 2, e000117.
35.
FitzpatrickR.C., and DayB.L. (2004). Probing the human vestibular system with galvanic stimulation. J. Appl. Physiol. 96, 2301–2316.
36.
PutukianM., EchemendiaR. J., and MackinS. (2000). The acute neuropsychological effects of heading in soccer: a pilot study. Clin. J. Sport Med. 10, 104–109.
37.
RiederC., and JansenP. (2011). No neuropsychological consequence in male and female soccer players after a short heading training. Arch. Clin. Neuropsychol. 26, 583–591.
38.
KennyR.A., MayoC.D., KennedyS., VargaA.A., Stuart-HillL., Garcia-BarreraM.A., McQuarrieA., ChristieB.R., and GawrylukJ.R. (2019). A pilot study of diffusion tensor imaging metrics and cognitive performance pre and post repetitive, intentional sub-concussive heading in soccer practice. J. Concussion, 3, 2059700219885503.
39.
DorminyM., HoogeveenA., TierneyR.T., HigginsM., McDevittJ.K., and KretzschmarJ. (2015). Effect of soccer heading ball speed on S100B, sideline concussion assessments and head impact kinematics. Brain Inj. 29, 1158–1164.
40.
ZetterbergH., JonssonM., RasulzadaA., PopaC., StyrudE., HietalaM.A., RosengrenL., WallinA., and BlennowK. (2007). No neurochemical evidence for brain injury caused by heading in soccer. Br. J. Sports Med. 41, 574–577.
41.
BamaçB., TamerG.S., ColakT., ColakE., SeyrekE., DumanC., ColakS., and ÖzbekA. (2011). Effects of repeatedly heading a soccer ball on serum levels of two neurotrophic factors of brain tissue, BDNF and NGF, in professional soccer players. Biol. Sport, 28, 177–181.
42.
WirschingA., ChenZ., BevilacquaZ.W., HuibregtseM.E., and KawataK. (2019). Association of acute increase in plasma neurofilament light with repetitive subconcussive head impacts: a pilot randomized control trial. J. Neurotrauma, 36, 548–553.
43.
StalnackeB.M., and SojkaP. (2008). Repeatedly heading a soccer ball does not increase serum levels of S-100B, a biochemical marker of brain tissue damage: an experimental study. Biomark. Insights, 3, 87–91.
44.
WallaceC., SmirlJ.D., ZetterbergH., BlennowK., BrykK., BurmaJ., DierijckJ., WrightA.D., and Van DonkelaarP. (2018). Heading in soccer increases serum neurofilament light protein and SCAT3 symptom metrics. BMJ Open Sport Exerc. Med. 4, e000433.
45.
SatoC., BarthélemyN.R., MawuenyegaK.G., PattersonB.W., GordonB.A., Jockel-BalsarottiJ., SullivanM., CrispM.J., KastenT., KirmessK.M., KanaanN.M., YarasheskiK.E., Baker-NighA., BenzingerT.L.S., MillerT.M., KarchC.M., and BatemanR.J. (2018). Tau kinetics in neurons and the human central nervous system. Neuron, 97, 1284–1298.e7.
46.
RubensteinR., ChangB., YueJ.K., ChiuA., WinklerE.A., PuccioA.M., Diaz-ArrastiaR., YuhE.L., MukherjeeP., ValadkaA.B., GordonW.A., OkonkwoD.O., DaviesP., AgarwalS., LinF., SarkisG., YadikarH., YangZ., ManleyG.T., WangK.K., the TRACK-TBI Investigators; CooperS.R., Dams-O'ConnorK., BorrassoA.J., InoueT., MaasA.I.R., MenonD.K., SchnyerD.M., and VassarM.J. (2017). Comparing plasma phospho tau, total tau, and phospho tau–total tau ratio as acute and chronic traumatic brain injury biomarkers. JAMA Neurol. 74, 1063–1072.
47.
KawataK., TierneyR., PhillipsJ., and JekaJ.J. (2016). Effect of repetitive sub-concussive head impacts on ocular near point of convergence. Int. J. Sports Med. 37, 405–410.
48.
HarrissA.B., AbbottK., KimpinskiK., HolmesJ.D., JohnsonA.M., WaltonD.M., and DickeyJ.P. (2019). An evaluation of heart rate variability in female youth soccer players following soccer heading: a pilot study. Sports, 7, 229.
49.
BishopS.A., DechR.T., GuzikP., and NearyJ.P. (2018). Heart rate variability and implication for sport concussion. Clin. Physiol. Funct. Imaging, 38, 733–742.
50.
SakellariV., BronsteinA.M., CornaS., HammonC.A., JonesS., and WolsleyC.J. (1997). The effects of hyperventilation on postural control mechanisms. Brain, 120, 1659–1673.
51.
ZemkováE., ViitasaloJ., HannolaH., BlomqvistM., Konttine-NN., and MononenK. (2007). The effect of maximal exercise on static and dynamic balance in athletes and non-athletes. Medicina Sportiva, 11, 70–77 p.
52.
LepersR., BigardA.X., DiardJ.-P., GouteyronJ.-F., and GuezennecC.Y. (1997). Posture control after prolonged exercise. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. Occup. Physiol. 76, 55–61.
53.
JoyceJ., GraydonJ., McMorrisT., and DavrancheK. (2009). The time course effect of moderate intensity exercise on response execution and response inhibition. Brain Cogn. 71, 14–19.
54.
RodriguesA.C., LasmarR.P., and CaramelliP. (2016). Effects of soccer heading on brain structure and function. Front. Neurol. 7, 38.
55.
CantuR.C., and HymanM. (2012). Concussions and our kids: America's leading expert on how to protect young athletes and keep sports safe. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt: Boston,MA.
56.
ArbogastK.B., and MarguliesS.S. (1999). A fiber-reinforced composite model of the viscoelastic behavior of the brainstem in shear. J. Biomech. 32, 865–870.
57.
HesseC., RosengrenL., AndreasenN., DavidssonP., VandersticheleH., VanmechelenE., and BlennowK. (2001). Transient increase in total tau but not phospho-tau in human cerebrospinal fluid after acute stroke. Neurosci. Lett. 297, 187–190.
58.
RosengrenL.E., KarlssonJ.E., KarlssonJ.-O., PerssonL.I., and WikkelsøC. (1996). Patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and other neurodegenerative diseases have increased levels of neurofilament protein in CSF. J. Neurochem. 67, 2013–2018.
59.
PortelaL.V., TortA.B., SchafD. V, RibeiroL., NoraD.B., WalzR., RottaL.N., SilvaC.T., BusnelloJ. V, KapczinskiF., GonçalvesC.A., and SouzaD.O. (2002). The serum S100B concentration is age dependent. Clin. Chem. 48, 950–952.
60.
ZhangM.R., RedS.D., LinA.H., PatelS.S., and SerenoA.B. (2013). Evidence of cognitive dysfunction after soccer playing with ball heading using a novel tablet-based approach. PLoS One, 8, e57364.
61.
MatserJ.T., KesselsA.G., JordanB.D., LezakM.D., and TroostJ. (1998). Chronic traumatic brain injury in professional soccer players. Neurology, 51, 791–796.
62.
HarrissA., JohnsonA.M., WaltonD.M., and DickeyJ.P. (2019). Head impact magnitudes that occur from purposeful soccer heading depend on the game scenario and head impact location. Musculoskelet. Sci. Pract. 40, 53–57.
63.
ThelinE.P., JohannessonL., NelsonD., and BellanderB.M. (2013). S100B Is an important outcome predictor in traumatic brain injury. J. Neurotrauma, 30, 519–528.
64.
ErcoleA., ThelinE.P., HolstA., BellanderB.M., and NelsonD.W. (2016). Kinetic modelling of serum S100b after traumatic brain injury. BMC Neurol. 16, 93.
65.
LingD.I., ChengJ., SantiagoK., AmmermanB., JivanelliB., HannafinJ., and CaseyE. (2020). Women are at higher risk for concussions due to ball or equipment contact in soccer and lacrosse. Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res. 478, 1469–1479.
66.
FieldM., CollinsM.W., LovellM.R., and MaroonJ. (2003). Does age play a role in recovery from sports-related concussion?. A comparison of high school and collegiate athletes. J. Pediatr. 142, 546–553.
67.
ToledoE., LebelA., BecerraL., MinsterA., LinnmanC., MalekiN., DodickD.W., and BorsookD. (2012). The young brain and concussion: imaging as a biomarker for diagnosis and prognosis. Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev. 36, 1510–31.
68.
HunterL.E., Freudenberg-HuaY., DaviesP., KimM., LiptonR.B., StewartW.F., SrinivasanP., HuS., and LiptonM.L. (2020). Associations of apolipoprotein E epsilon4 genotype and ball heading with verbal memory in amateur soccer players. JAMA Neurol. 77, 419–426.
69.
CorderE.H., SaundersA.M., StrittmatterW.J., SchmechelD.E., GaskellP.C., SmallG.W., RosesA.D., HainesJ.L., and Pericak-VanceM.A. (1993). Gene dose of apolipoprotein E type 4 allele and the risk of Alzheimer's disease in late onset families. Science, 261, 921–923.
70.
DezmanZ.D., LedetE.H., and KerrH.A. (2013). Neck strength imbalance correlates with increased head acceleration in soccer heading. Sports Health Approach, 5, 320–326.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
