Spinal cord injury (SCI) results in deleterious skeletal muscle adaptations, such as relevant atrophy and loss of force. In particular, the relevant loss of lower-limb force-generating capacity may limit functional mobility even if neuronal control was sufficient. Currently, methods of assessing maximal force-generating capacity using neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) are limited in individuals who cannot tolerate higher stimulation amplitudes, such as those with residual sensation and those at risk of fracture. In this study, we examined the relationship between NMES amplitude and muscle torque exerted (recruitment curve) in order to determine whether maximal torque output can be characterized by a submaximal marker. Recruitment curves for knee extensors, knee flexors, and ankle plantarflexors were recorded from 30 individuals with motor complete SCI. NMES was delivered starting with an amplitude of 5 mA, and increasing by 5 mA for every subsequent stimulation until either the participant requested to stop the stimulation or the maximum stimulation amplitude (140 mA) was reached. Significant correlations between peak slope of the recruitment curve and peak torque for all muscle groups were found (knee extensors, r = 0.75; p < 0.0001; knee flexors, r = 0.68; p < 0.0001; ankle plantarflexors, r = 0.91; p < 0.0001), indicating that muscles that show greater peak slope of the recruitment curve tend to generate a greater peak torque. This suggests that peak slope, which was achieved at an average stimulation intensity (55.0 mA) that was 43% smaller than that corresponding to peak torque (97.4 mA), may be used as a submaximal marker for characterizing maximal torque output in individuals with SCI.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
DurozardD., GabrielleC., and BaverelG. (2000). Metabolism of rat skeletal muscle after spinal cord transection. Muscle Nerve, 23, 1561–1568.
2.
HiraizumiY., FujimakiE., and TachikawaT. (1990). Long-term morphology of spastic or flaccid muscles in spinal cord-transected rabbits. Clin. Orthop. Relat. Res. 260, 287–296.
3.
LandryE., FrenetteJ., and GuertinP.A. (2004). Body weight, limb size, and muscular properties of early paraplegic mice. J. Neurotrauma, 21, 1008–1016.
4.
ShahP.K., StevensJ.E., GregoryC.M., PathareN.C., JayaramanA., BickelS.C., BowdenM., BehrmanA.L., WalterG.A., DudleyG.A., and VandenborneK. (2006). Lower-extremity muscle cross-sectional area after incomplete spinal cord injury. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 87, 772–778.
5.
GorgeyA.S., and DudleyG.A. (2007). Skeletal muscle atrophy and increased intramuscular fat after incomplete spinal cord injury. Spinal Cord, 45, 304–309.
6.
ThomasC.K., ZaidnerE.Y., CalancieB., BrotonJ.G., and Bigland-RitchieB.R. (1997). Muscle weakness, paralysis, and atrophy after human cervical spinal cord injury. Exp. Neurol. 148, 414–423.
7.
ShieldsR.K. (1995). Fatigability, relaxation properties, and electromyographic responses of the human paralyzed soleus muscle. J. Neurophysiol. 73, 2195–2206.
8.
ShieldsR.K. (2002). Muscular, skeletal, and neural adaptations following spinal cord injury. J. Orthop. Sports Phys. Ther. 32, 65–74.
9.
EserP., FrotzlerA., ZehnderY., WickL., KnechtH., DenothJ., and SchiesslH. (2004). Relationship between the duration of paralysis and bone structure: a pQCT study of spinal cord injured individuals. Bone, 34, 869–880.
10.
ShieldsR.K., Dudley-JavoroskiS., BoaldinK.M., CoreyT.A., FogD.B., and RuenJ.M. (2006). Peripheral quantitative computed tomography: measurement sensitivity in persons with and without spinal cord injury. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 87, 1376–1381.
11.
ShieldsR.K., and Dudley-JavoroskiS. (2006). Musculoskeletal plasticity after acute spinal cord injury: effects of long-term neuromuscular electrical stimulation training. J. Neurophysiol. 95, 2380–2390.
12.
GiangregorioL.M., WebberC.E., PhillipsS.M., HicksA.L., CravenB.C., BugarestiJ.M., and McCartneyN. (2006). Can body weight supported treadmill training increase bone mass and reverse muscle atrophy in individuals with chronic incomplete spinal cord injury?. Appl. Physiol. Nutr. Metab. 31, 283–291.
13.
ForrestG.F., SistoS.A., BarbeauH., KirshblumS.C., WilenJ., BondQ., BentsonS., AsselinP., CirnigliaroC.M., and HarkemaS. (2008). Neuromotor and musculoskeletal responses to locomotor training for an individual with chronic motor complete AIS-B spinal cord injury. J. Spinal Cord. Med. 31, 509–521.
14.
GiangregorioL.M., HicksA.L., WebberC.E., PhillipsS.M., CravenB.C., BugarestiJ.M., and McCartneyN. (2005). Body weight supported treadmill training in acute spinal cord injury: impact on muscle and bone. Spinal Cord, 43, 649–657.
15.
CrameriR.M., CooperP., SinclairP.J., BryantG., and WestonA. (2004). Effect of load during electrical stimulation training in spinal cord injury. Muscle Nerve, 29, 104–111.
16.
MohrT., PodenphantJ., Biering-SorensenF., GalboH., ThamsborgG., and KjaerM. (1997). Increased bone mineral density after prolonged electrically induced cycle training of paralyzed limbs in spinal cord injured man. Calcif. Tissue Int. 61, 22–25.
17.
CrameriR.M., WestonA., ClimsteinM., DavisG.M., and SuttonJ.R. (2002). Effects of electrical stimulation-induced leg training on skeletal muscle adaptability in spinal cord injury. Scand. J. Med. Sci. Sports, 12, 316–322.
18.
ChilibeckP.D., JeonJ., WeissC., BellG., and BurnhamR. (1999). Histochemical changes in muscle of individuals with spinal cord injury following functional electrical stimulated exercise training. Spinal Cord, 37, 264–268.
19.
ScreminA.M., KurtaL., GentiliA., WisemanB., PerellK., KunkelC., and ScreminO.U. (1999). Increasing muscle mass in spinal cord injured persons with a functional electrical stimulation exercise program. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 80, 1531–1536.
20.
ShieldsR.K., and Dudley-JavoroskiS. (2007). Musculoskeletal adaptations in chronic spinal cord injury: effects of long-term soleus electrical stimulation training. Neurorehabil. Neural Repair, 21, 169–179.
21.
GerritsH.L., HopmanM.T., SargeantA.J., JonesD.A., and De HaanA. (2002). Effects of training on contractile properties of paralyzed quadriceps muscle. Muscle Nerve, 25, 559–567.
22.
Ploutz-SnyderL.L., ManiniT., Ploutz-SnyderR.J., and WolfD.A. (2002). Functionally relevant thresholds of quadriceps femoris strength. J. Gerontol. A Biol. Sci. Med. Sci. 57, B144–B152.
23.
KimC.M., and EngJ.J. (2003). The relationship of lower-extremity muscle torque to locomotor performance in people with stroke. Phys. Ther. 83, 49–57.
24.
ArpinD.J., DaviesB.L., and KurzM.J. (2016). Multiple sclerosis influences the precision of the ankle plantarflexon muscular force production. Gait Posture, 45, 170–174.
25.
GregoryC.M., BowdenM.G., JayaramanA., ShahP., BehrmanA., KautzS.A., and VandenborneK. (2007). Resistance training and locomotor recovery after incomplete spinal cord injury: a case series. Spinal Cord, 45, 522–530.
26.
HubliM., and DietzV. (2013). The physiological basis of neurorehabilitation—locomotor training after spinal cord injury. J. Neuroeng. Rehabil. 10, 5.
27.
HarkemaS.J., HillyerJ., Schmidt-ReadM., ArdolinoE., SistoS.A., and BehrmanA.L. (2012). Locomotor training: as a treatment of spinal cord injury and in the progression of neurologic rehabilitation. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 93, 1588–1597.
28.
RejcE., AngeliC.A., AtkinsonD., and HarkemaS.J. (2017). Motor recovery after activity-based training with spinal cord epidural stimulation in a chronic motor complete paraplegic. Sci. Rep. 7, 13476.
29.
RejcE., AngeliC.A., BryantN., and HarkemaS.J. (2017). Effects of stand and step training with epidural stimulation on motor function for standing in chronic complete paraplegics. J. Neurotrauma, 34, 1787–1802.
30.
AngeliC.A., EdgertonV.R., GerasimenkoY.P., and HarkemaS.J. (2014). Altering spinal cord excitability enables voluntary movements after chronic complete paralysis in humans. Brain, 137, 1394–1409.
31.
HarkemaS., GerasimenkoY., HodesJ., BurdickJ., AngeliC., FerreiraC., WillhiteA., RejcE., GrossmanR.G., EdgertonV.R. (2011). Effect of epidural stimulation of the lumbosacral spinal cord on voluntary movement, standing, and assisted stepping after motor complete paraplegia: a case study. Lancet, 377, 1938–1947.
32.
DelittoA., StrubeM.J., ShulmanA.D., and MinorS.D. (1992). A study of discomfort with electrical stimulation. Phys. Ther. 72, 410–421.
33.
LakeD.A. (1992). Neuromuscular electrical stimulation. An overview and its application in the treatment of sports injuries. Sports Med. 13, 320–336.
34.
WaringW.P.III, Biering-SorensenF., BurnsS., DonovanW., GravesD., JhaA., JonesL., KirshblumS., MarinoR., MulcaheyM.J., ReevesR., ScelzaW.M., Schmidt-ReadM., and SteinA. (2010). 2009 review and revisions of the international standards for the neurological classification of spinal cord injury. J. Spinal Cord Med. 33, 346–352.
35.
ShieldsR.K., ChangY.J., Dudley-JavoroskiS., and LinC.H. (2006). Predictive model of muscle fatigue after spinal cord injury in humans. Muscle Nerve, 34, 84–91.
36.
FittsR.H., McDonaldK.S., and SchluterJ.M. (1991). The determinants of skeletal muscle force and power: their adaptability with changes in activity pattern. J. Biomech. 24, Suppl. 1, 111–122.
37.
RätyH.P., KujalaU., VidemanT., KoskinenS.K., KarppiS.L., and SarnaS. (1999). Associations of isometric and isoinertial trunk muscle strength measurements and lumbar paraspinal muscle cross-sectional areas. J. Spinal Disord. 12, 266–270.
38.
HolzbaurK.R., DelpS.L., GoldG.E., and MurrayW.M. (2007). Moment-generating capacity of upper limb muscles in healthy adults. J. Biomech. 40, 2442–2449.
39.
AagaardP., AndersenJ.L., Dyhre-PoulsenP., LeffersA.M., WagnerA., MagnussonS.P., Halkjaer-KristensenJ., and SimonsenE.B. (2001). A mechanism for increased contractile strength of human pennate muscle in response to strength training: changes in muscle architecture. J. Physiol. 534, 613–623.
40.
GregoryC.M., and BickelC.S. (2005). Recruitment patterns in human skeletal muscle during electrical stimulation. Phys. Ther. 85, 358–364.
41.
BickelC.S., GregoryC.M., and DeanJ.C. (2011). Motor unit recruitment during neuromuscular electrical stimulation: a critical appraisal. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. 111, 2399–2407.
42.
FeiereisenP., DuchateauJ., and HainautK. (1997). Motor unit recruitment order during voluntary and electrically induced contractions in the tibialis anterior. Exp. Brain Res. 114, 117–123.
43.
CabricM., AppellH.J., and ResicA. (1988). Fine structural changes in electrostimulated human skeletal muscle. Evidence for predominant effects on fast muscle fibres. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. Occup. Physiol. 57, 1–5.
44.
HeytersM., CarpentierA., DuchateauJ., and HainautK. (1994). Twitch analysis as an approach to motor unit activation during electrical stimulation. Can. J. Appl. Physiol. 19, 451–461.
45.
TrimbleM.H., and EnokaR.M. (1991). Mechanisms underlying the training effects associated with neuromuscular electrical stimulation. Phys. Ther. 71, 273–280.
46.
HennemanE., SomjenG., and CarpenterD.O. (1965). Functional significant of cell size in spinal motoneurons. J. Neurophysiol. 28, 560–580.
47.
EnokaR.M. (2002). Activation order of motor axons in electrically evoked contractions. Muscle Nerve, 25, 763–764.
48.
KnightC.A., and KamenG. (2005). Superficial motor units are larger than deeper motor units in human vastus lateralis muscle. Muscle Nerve, 31, 475–480.
49.
VanderthommenM., DepresseuxJ.C., DauchatL., DegueldreC., CroisierJ.L., and CrielaardJ.M. (2002). Blood flow variation in human muscle during electrically stimulated exercise bouts. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. 83, 936–941.
50.
VanderthommenM., DepresseuxJ.C., BauvirP., DegueldreC., DelfioreG., PetersJ.M., SluseF., and CrielaardJ.M. (1997). A positron emission tomography study of voluntarily and electrically contracted human quadriceps. Muscle Nerve, 20, 505–507.
51.
VanderthommenM., DepresseuxJ.C., DauchatL., DegueldreC., CroisierJ.L., and CrielaardJ.M. (2000). Spatial distribution of blood flow in electrically stimulated human muscle: a positron emission tomography study. Muscle Nerve, 23, 482–489.
52.
KesarT., ChouL.W., and Binder-MacleodS.A. (2008). Effects of stimulation frequency versus pulse duration modulation on muscle fatigue. J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol. 18, 662–671.
53.
GerritsH.L., De HaanA., HopmanM.T., van Der WoudeL.H., JonesD.A., and SargeantA.J. (1999). Contractile properties of the quadriceps muscle in individuals with spinal cord injury. Muscle Nerve, 22, 1249–1256.
54.
FunaseK., ImanakaK., and NishihiraY. (1994). Excitability of the soleus motoneuron pool revealed by the developmental slope of the H-reflex as reflex gain. Electromyogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 34, 477–489.
55.
KomiyamaT., KawaiK., and FumotoM. (1999). The excitability of a motoneuron pool assessed by the H-reflex method is correlated with the susceptibility of Ia terminals to repetitive discharges in humans. Brain Res. 826, 317–320.
56.
SekiguchiH., NakazawaK., and AkaiM. (2003). Recruitment gain of antagonistic motoneurons is higher during lengthening contraction than during shortening contraction in man. Neurosci. Lett. 342, 69–72.
57.
SayenkoD.G., AtkinsonD.A., DyC.J., GurleyK.M., SmithV.L., AngeliC., HarkemaS.J., EdgertonV.R., and GerasimenkoY.P. (2015). Spinal segment-specific transcutaneous stimulation differentially shapes activation pattern among motor pools in humans. J. Appl. Physiol. 118, 1364–1374.
58.
CollinsD.F., BurkeD., and GandeviaS.C. (2001). Large involuntary forces consistent with plateau-like behavior of human motoneurons. J. Neurosci. 21, 4059–4065.
59.
CollinsD.F. (2007). Central contributions to contractions evoked by tetanic neuromuscular electrical stimulation. Exerc. Sport Sci. Rev. 35, 102–109.
60.
IchinoseY., KawakamiY., ItoM., and FukunagaT. (1997). Estimation of active force-length characteristics of human vastus lateralis muscle. Acta Anat. (Basel) 159, 78–83.
61.
de BoerM.D., SeynnesO.R., di PramperoP.E., PisotR., MekjavićI.B., BioloG., and NariciM.V. (2008). Effect of 5 weeks horizontal bed rest on human muscle thickness and architecture of weight bearing and non-weight bearing muscles. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. 104, 401–407.
62.
TimminsR.G., ShieldA.J., WilliamsM.D., LorenzenC., and OparD.A. (2015). Biceps femoris long head architecture: a reliability and retrospective injury study. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 47, 905–913.
63.
JacobsR., and van Ingen SchenauG.J. (1992) Control of an external force in leg extensions in humans. J. Physiol. 457, 611–626.
64.
AagaardP., AndersenJ.L., Dyhre-PoulsenP., LeffersA.M., WagnerA., MagnussonS.P., Halkjaer-KristensenJ., and SimonsenE.B. (2001). A mechanism for increased contractile strength of human pennate muscle in response to strength training: changes in muscle architecture. J. Physiol. 534, 613–623.
65.
EdgertonV.R., SmithJ.L., and SimpsonD.R. (1975). Muscle fibre type populations of human leg muscles. Histochem. J. 7, 259–266.
66.
EngC.M., SmallwoodL.H., RainieroM.P., LaheyM., WardS.R., and LieberR.L. (2008). Scaling of muscle architecture and fiber types in the rat hindlimb. J. Exp. Biol. 211, 2336–2345.
67.
NegredoP., RiveroJ.L., GonzálezB., Ramón-CuetoA., and MansoR. (2008). Slow- and fast-twitch rat hind limb skeletal muscle phenotypes 8 months after spinal cord transection and olfactory ensheathing glia transplantation. J. Physiol. 586, 2593–2610.
68.
LieberR.L., and KellyM.J. (1991). Factors influencing quadriceps femoris muscle torque using transcutaneous neuromuscular electrical stimulation. Phys. Ther. 71, 715–721.
69.
MaffiulettiN.A. (2010). Physiological and methodological considerations for the use of neuromuscular electrical stimulation. Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. 110, 223–234.
70.
LevyM., MizrahiJ., and SusakZ. (1990) Recruitment, force and fatigue characteristics of quadriceps muscles of paraplegics isometrically activated by surface functional electrical stimulation. J. Biomed. Eng. 12, 150–156.
