Comparison of the Laparoscopic and Open Methods of Gastrostomy at Neonates and Infants Up To Three Months of Age

Abstract

Abstract

Background:

An open surgical intervention is a common approach for gastrostomy tube placement in neonates and infants. Also available, however less often used, is a laparoscopic technique for low-profile gastrostomy tube (button) placement. In this study we compare the pre-, intra-, and post-procedural outcomes of each technique.

Methods:

We retrospectively evaluated all open and laparoscopically inserted gastrostomies at our department from January 2002 to December 2016 and compared them in terms of operative parameters and outcomes.

Results:

In the study interval, 44 open and 90 laparoscopically placed low-profile (button) gastrostomies were performed. There were no significant differences in gender distribution, mean age (42.54 versus 34.16 days), and mean weight (3311 versus 3476 g). The frequency of concomitant Nissen fundoplication was higher in the laparoscopy group (18% versus 47%; P < .05). The duration of G-tube placement by laparotomy was significantly longer (mean difference 16 minutes), than by laparoscopy, as were time periods between G-tube insertion and the onset of first feeding (mean differences 8.4 and 19.6 hours, respectively). Children in the laparoscopy group spent nearly 15 fewer days in the hospital than those who received a G-tube by laparotomy (29.0 versus 13.9; P < .05). Major complications were observed in 3 (6.82%) patients in the laparotomy group in the form of gastric content leak into the abdominal cavity and resulting peritonitis; complications were lower in the laparoscopy group (68.18% versus 13.33%; P = .03).

Conclusions:

Compared with open gastrostomy, the laparoscopic approach appears to be advantageous with respect to procedural duration, initiation of feedings, hospitalization duration, and rate of complications. Another difference was the frequency of concomitant Nissen fundoplication. Further prospective studies may determine the role of these patient-specific factors regarding who benefits most from the laparoscopic technique.