Racial Differences in Do-Not-Resuscitate Orders among Pediatric Surgical Patients in the United States

Abstract

Background:

Very few studies have investigated the racial differences in do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders in children, and these studies are limited to oncological cases. We aim to characterize the racial difference in DNR orders among U.S. pediatric surgical patients.

Methods:

We retrospectively evaluated the mortality of all children who underwent an inpatient surgery between 2012 and 2017 from the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program. We used log-binomial models to estimate the relative risk (RR) and 95% confidence interval (CI) of DNR use comparing white with African American (AA) children. To estimate the risk-adjusted difference in DNR orders, we controlled the analyses for age, prematurity status, emergent case status, American Society of Anesthesiologists class, year of operation, surgical specialty, and surgical complexity.

Results:

Between 2012 and 2017, a total of 276,917 children underwent inpatient surgery, of whom 0.8% (n = 1601) died within 30 days of operation. Of the 1601 mortality cases, we retained 1212 children who were of either AA (26.0%, n = 350) or white (63.9%, n = 862) race. Most children were neonates, had an American Society of Anesthesiologists class ≥4 (70.0%, n = 811), and developed one or more postoperative complications (68.7%, n = 833). Overall, AA children were more likely to be neonates at the time of surgery (42.0% vs. 40.3%, p < 0.001), to be premature (66.3% vs. 49.0%, p < 0.001), and develop one or more postoperative complications (73.7% vs. 66.7%, p = 0.017). White children were three times more likely to have a DNR order than their AA peers (adjusted RR: 3.01, 95% CI: 1.09–8.56, p = 0.044).

Conclusion:

Among pediatric surgical patients in the United States, children of white race were three times more likely to have a DNR order in place than their AA peers despite the latter being “sicker” and more likely to develop postoperative complications. The mechanisms underlying this racial difference deserve further elucidation to improve shared decision making and goal-concordant care.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Nelson

: Unequal treatment: Confronting racial and ethnic disparities in health care. J Natl Med Assoc, 2002; 94:666–668.

Bach

, Cramer

, Warren

, et al.: Racial differences in the treatment of early-stage lung cancer. N Engl J Med, 1999; 341:1198–1205.

Byrne

, O'Malley

, Suarez-Almazor

.: Ethnic differences in health preferences: Analysis using willingness-to-pay. J Rheumatol, 2004; 31:1811–1818.

De Lew

, Weinick

: An overview: Eliminating racial, ethnic, and SES disparities in health care. Health Care Financ Rev, 2000; 21:1–7.

Edmonds

, Fager

, Srinivas

, et al.: Racial and ethnic differences in use of intubation for periviable neonates. Pediatrics, 2011; 127:E1120–E1127.

Smith

, McCarthy

, Paulk

, et al.: Racial and ethnic differences in advance care planning among patients with cancer: Impact of terminal illness acknowledgment, religiousness, and treatment preferences. J Clin Oncol, 2008; 26:4131–4137.

Taylor

, Brown

, Prescott

, et al.: Dying well: How equal is end of life care among gynecologic oncology patients?. Gynecol Oncol, 2016; 140:295–300.

Harris

, Links

, Walsh

, et al.: A systematic review of race/ethnicity and parental treatment decision-making. Clin Pediatr, 2018; 57:1453–1464.

Baker

, Rai

, Liu

, et al.: Race does not influence Do-Not-Resuscitate status or the number or timing of end-of-life care discussions at a pediatric oncology referral center. J Palliat Med, 2009; 12:71–76.

10.

Lyon

, Williams

, Woods

, et al.: Do-not-resuscitate orders and/or hospice care, psychological health, and quality of life among children/adolescents with acquired immune deficiency syndrome. J Palliat Med, 2008; 11:459–469.

11.

Moaed

, Mordechai

, Ben-Arush

, et al.: Factors influencing Do-Not-Resuscitate status in children during last month of life: Single institution experience. J Ped Hematol Oncol, 2019; 41:E201–E205.

12.

Bailoor

, Shafie-Khorassani

, Lank

, et al.: Time trends in race-ethnic differences in Do-Not-Resuscitate orders after stroke. Stroke, 2019; 50:1641–1647.

13.

McFarlin

, Hailey

, Qi

, et al.: Associations between patient characteristics and a new, early Do-Not-Attempt resuscitation order after intracerebral hemorrhage. J Palliat Med, 2018; 21:1161–1165.

14.

Messinger-Rapport

, Kamel

: Predictors of do not resuscitate orders in the nursing home. J Am Med Dir Assoc, 2005; 6:18–21.

15.

Kwak

, Haley

: Current research findings on end-of-life decision making among racially or ethnically diverse groups. Gerontologist, 2005; 45:634–641.

16.

Ormseth

, Falcone

, Jasak

, et al.: Minority patients are less likely to undergo withdrawal of care after spontaneous intracerebral hemorrhage. Neurocrit care, 2018; 29:419–425.

17.

Kraemer

, Cohen

, Liu

, et al.: Development and evaluation of the American College of Surgeons NSQIP Pediatric Surgical Risk Calculator. J Am Coll Surg, 2016; 223:685–693.

18.

Langham

Jr. , Walter

, Boswell

, et al.: Identifying children at risk of death within 30 days of surgery at an NSQIP pediatric hospital. Surgery, 2015; 158:1481–1491.

19.

American College of Surgeons (ACS), National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP): ACS NSQIP Operations

Manual

, 2018. https://www.facs.org/quality-programs/acs-nsqip/joinnow/hospitalreq/scrtrain (last accessed February 5, 2020).

20.

Saklad

: Grading of patients for surgical procedures. Anesthesiology, 1941; 2:281–284.

21.

Anesthesiologists ASo: ASA physical status classification system. 2014. https://www.asahq.org/standards-and-guidelines/asa-physical-status-classification-system. (Last accessed December 10, 2019).

22.

Curatolo

, Goldberg

, Maerz

, et al.: ASA physical status assignment by non-anesthesia providers: Do surgeons consistently downgrade the ASA score preoperatively?. J Clin Anesth, 2017; 38:123–128.

23.

Nasr

, DiNardo

, Faraoni

: Development of a pediatric risk assessment score to predict perioperative mortality in children undergoing noncardiac surgery. Anesth Analg, 2017; 124:1514–1519.

24.

Hawley

, Morris

: Cultural challenges to engaging patients in shared decision making. Patient Educ Couns, 2017; 100:18–24.

25.

Legare

, Ratte

, Gravel

, Graham

: Barriers and facilitators to implementing shared decision-making in clinical practice: update of a systematic review of health professionals' perceptions. Patient Educ Couns, 2008; 73:526–535.

26.

Burns

, Sellers

, Meyer

, et al.: Epidemiology of death in the PICU at five U.S. teaching hospitals*. Crit Care Med, 2014; 42:2101–2108.

27.

Trowbridge

, Walter

, McConathey

, et al.: Modes of death within a children's hospital. Pediatrics, 2018; 142:e20174182.

28.

Kaye

, Gushue

, DeMarsh

, et al.: Impact of race and ethnicity on end-of-life experiences for children with cancer. Am J Hosp Palliat Care, 2019; 36:767–774.

29.

Eggly

, Harper

FWK

, Penner

, et al.: Variation in question asking during cancer clinical interactions: A potential source of disparities in access to information. Patient Educ Couns, 2011; 82:63–68.

30.

Bird

, Cohen-Cole

: The three-function model of the medical interview. An educational device. Adv Psychosom Med, 1990; 20:65–88.

31.

Nagarajan

, Rahman

, Boss

: Are there racial disparities in family-reported experiences of care in inpatient pediatrics?. Clin Pediatr, 2017; 56:619–626.

32.

Gordon

, Street

, Sharf

, et al.: Racial differences in trust and lung cancer patients' perceptions of physician communication. J Clin Oncol, 2006; 24:904–909.

33.

Ilowite

, Cronin

, Kang

, et al.: Disparities in prognosis communication among parents of children with cancer: The impact of race and ethnicity. Cancer, 2017; 123:3995–4003.

34.

Jean-Pierre

, Fiscella

, Griggs

, et al.: Race/ethnicity-based concerns over understanding cancer diagnosis and treatment plan. J Natl Med Assoc, 2010; 102:184–189.

35.

Akbilgic

, Langham

Jr ., Davis

: Race, preoperative risk factors, and death after surgery. Pediatrics, 2018; 141:2017–2221.

36.

Ghaferi

, Birkmeyer

, Dimick

: Variation in hospital mortality associated with inpatient surgery. N Engl J Med, 2009; 361:1368–1375.

37.

Delgado-Guay

, Chisholm

, Williams

, et al.: The association between religiosity and resuscitation status preference among patients with advanced cancer. Support Palliat Care, 2015; 13:1435–1439.

38.

Nathens

, Rivara

, Wang

, et al.: Variation in the rates of do not resuscitate orders after major trauma and the impact of intensive care unit environment. J Trauma, 2008; 64:81–88.