Impact of Active Versus Receptive Music Interventions on Psychosocial and Neurological Outcomes in People with Multiple Sclerosis: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Introduction:

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory autoimmune disease that affects nearly 1 million people in the United States and 2.9 million people worldwide. The symptoms vary substantially but can include fatigue, lower extremity weakness, cognitive dysfunction, and mood impairment. The use of music to improve cognition, mood, and movement has been studied in numerous patient populations, yet the implementation for people with MS (PwMS) is understudied. This systematic review evaluates the effect of music-based interventions implemented with PwMS.

Methods:

The search used four electronic databases: PubMed/MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, and Web of Science from January 1, 2002 to June 30, 2024. The inclusion criteria were (1) individuals diagnosed with MS, (2) music interventions, and (3) randomized controlled trials, quasi-experimental (nonrandomized controlled trials), and mixed methods studies. Outcomes included anxiety, depression, quality of life, and cognitive and functional (gait, balance, fatigue, dexterity) impairment. The risk of bias was evaluated with the National Institutes of Health Quality Assessment Tool.

Results:

A total of 15 studies were included, representing 623 participants. Most studies were conducted in Europe (n = 9). Ten studies were randomized controlled trials, and the remaining studies were quasi-experimental (case and match controlled). Intervention lengths varied from 1 session (n = 5) to 36 sessions. Most studies used receptive music engagement; the most common application was music listening while walking. Gait parameters and physical fatigue were the most common outcomes. These studies showed improved gait outcomes in music listening and active control groups. However, participants in the music interventions had less physical fatigue with activity. Four studies evaluated active music engagement interventions. Most active interventions were one session and evaluated memory through immediate and delayed recall of words sung to a melody compared with spoken words. In total, 73% of the studies evaluating motor neurological outcomes (gait, dexterity, and balance) had significant between-group improvements. Sixty-two percent of studies evaluating nonmotor neurological outcomes (cognitive functioning, fatigue, mood, and quality of life) showed significant between-group improvements. Methodological quality was assessed as fair or good for all the studies in the review. Safety and adverse event data were reported in 6/15 studies.

Discussion:

Music-based interventions show promise in improving motor and nonmotor outcomes in PwMS. However, the effectiveness of music-based interventions remains uncertain due to inconsistencies in methodologies and outcome measurements. Gaps in the research include active music engagement interventions, the impact of learning to play an instrument on cognition, and the delivery of interventions online and at home.

Registration:

PROSPERO #CRD42022338291.