Vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE) are a leading cause of nosocomial infections in patients worldwide. VRE contamination in food of animal origin may create a risk for human health. This study was conducted to estimate the pooled prevalence of VRE in food of animal origin worldwide, to assess the result heterogeneity, and to determine cumulative evidence and the trend of the prevalence over time. Relevant studies were retrieved from PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. A random-effects model was used to calculate the pooled prevalence of VRE in food of animal origin. Subgroup meta-analysis was used to assess the heterogeneity of the results. A cumulative meta-analysis and meta-regression were conducted to determine cumulative evidence and the trend of the prevalence of VRE in food of animal origin over time, respectively. Of the 1352 retrieved studies, 50 articles were included. The pooled prevalence of VRE in food of animal origin was 11.7% (95% confidence interval [95% CI] = 8.4 to 16.0). Subgroup meta-analyses showed a significant difference in the prevalence of VRE for two characteristics. First, for the source of food, the prevalence of VRE was highest in aquatic food (43.4% [95% CI = 28.4 to 59.7]) and lowest in dairy food (4.1% [95% CI = 1.7 to 9.8]). Second, for continents, the prevalence of VRE was highest in Africa (18.5% [95% CI = 12.8 to 26.1]) and lowest in North America (0.3% [95% CI = 0.1 to 1.1]). Cumulative evidence showed two distinct features in two different periods. The pooled prevalence of VRE rapidly decreased from 79.3% in 1998 to 13.1% in 2003; it has slightly fluctuated between 10.5% and 20.5% since 2004. The results of the meta-regression indicated that the prevalence gradually decreased over time. In conclusion, the estimate of overall VRE prevalence worldwide in food of animal origin was ∼12%, indicating the burden of VRE contamination in food of animal origin.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhmedMO, BaptisteKE. Vancomycin-resistant enterococci: A review of antimicrobial resistance mechanisms and perspectives of human and animal health. Microb Drug Resist, 2018; 24:590–606.
2.
Akpınar KankayaD, TuncerY. Antibiotic resistance in vancomycin-resistant lactic acid bacteria (VRLAB) isolated from foods of animal origin. J Food Process Preserv, 2020; 44:e14468.
3.
BanlaLI, SalzmanNH, KristichCJ. Colonization of the mammalian intestinal tract by enterococci. Curr Opin Microbiol, 2019; 47:26–31.
4.
BeggCB, MazumdarM. Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias. Biometrics, 1994; 50:1088–1101.
5.
BiswasK, SharmaP, JoshiSR. Co-occurrence of antimicrobial resistance and virulence determinants in enterococci isolated from traditionally fermented fish products. J Glob Antimicrob Resist, 2019; 17:79–83.
6.
BusaniL, Del GrossoM, PaladiniC, GrazianiC, PantostiA, BiavascoF, CaprioliA. Antimicrobial susceptibility of vancomycin-susceptible and -resistant enterococci isolated in Italy from raw meat products, farm animals, and human infections. Int J Food Microbiol, 2004; 97:17–22.
7.
CamargoCH, Bruder-NascimentoA, LeeSH, JúniorAF, KanenoR, RallVL. Prevalence and phenotypic characterization of Enterococcus spp. isolated from food in Brazil. Braz J Microbiol, 2014; 45:111–115.
8.
ÇetinkayaF, Elal MusT, SoyutemizG, CibikR. Prevalence and antibiotic resistance of vancomycin-resistant enterococci in animal originated foods. Turkish J Vet Anim Sci, 2013; 37:588–593.
9.
Chajęcka-WierzchowskaW, ZadernowskaA, García-SolacheM. Ready-to-eat dairy products as a source of multidrug-resistant Enterococcus strains: Phenotypic and genotypic characteristics. J Dairy Sci, 2020; 103:4068–4077.
10.
ChingwaruW, MpuchaneSF, GasheBA. Enterococcus faecalis and Enterococcus faecium isolates from milk, beef, and chicken and their antibiotic resistance. J Food Prot, 2003; 66:931–936.
11.
ChoJI, JooIS, ChoiJH, JungKH, ChoiEJ, HanMK, JeongSK, SonNR, LeeSH, HwangIJ. Prevalence and antimicrobial resistance of Enterococcus spp. isolated from meat and fishery production in Korea. Food Sci Biotechnol, 2013; 22:161–165.
12.
ChotinantakulK, ChansiwN, OkadaS. Antimicrobial resistance of Enterococcus spp. isolated from Thai fermented pork in Chiang Rai Province, Thailand. J Glob Antimicrob Resist, 2018; 12:143–148.
13.
ÇitakS, YucelN, OrhanS. Antibiotic resistance and incidence of Enterococcus species in Turkish white cheese. Int J Dairy Technol, 2004; 57:27–31.
14.
CostaL, RadhouaniH, GomesC, IgrejasG, PoetaP. High prevalence of extended-spectrum β-lactamases Escherichia coli and vancomycin-resistant enterococci isolates from chicken products. A problem of public health. J Food Saf, 2010; 30:141–153.
15.
Del GrossoM, CaprioliA, ChinzariP, FontanaMC, PezzottiG, ManfrinA, GiannataleED, GoffredoE, PantostiA. Detection and characterization of vancomycin-resistant enterococci in farm animals and raw meat products in Italy. Microb Drug Resist, 2000; 6:313–318.
16.
DingH, GaoY-M, DengY, LambertonPHL, LuD-B. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the seroprevalence of Toxoplasma gondii in cats in mainland China. Parasit Vectors, 2017; 10:27.
17.
DolkaB, Chrobak-ChmielD, MakraiL, SzeleszczukP. Phenotypic and genotypic characterization of Enterococcus cecorum strains associated with infections in poultry. BMC Vet Res, 2016; 12:129–129.
18.
Donado-GodoyP, ByrneBA, LeónM, CastellanosR, VanegasC, CoralA, ArevaloA, ClavijoV, VargasM, ZuñigaJJR, TafurM, Pérez-GutierrezE, SmithA. Prevalence, resistance patterns, and risk factors for antimicrobial resistance in bacteria from retail chicken meat in Colombia. J Food Prot, 2015; 78:751–759.
19.
DonskeyCJ, ChowdhryTK, HeckerMT, HoyenCK, HanrahanJA, HujerAM, et al.Effect of antibiotic therapy on the density of vancomycin-resistant enterococci in the stool of colonized patients. N Engl J Med, 2000; 343:1925–1932.
20.
DuckováV, ČanigováM, KrockoM, LavovaM. Antibiotic susceptibility and biofilm-forming capacity of enterococci isolated from food of animal origin. Med Weter, 2014; 70:36–37.
21.
DuvalS, TweedieR. Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics, 2000; 56:455–463.
22.
EggerM, Davey SmithG, SchneiderM, MinderC. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ, 1997; 315:629–634.
23.
FifadaraN, RaduS, HassanZ, BeuchatLR, RusulG. Hemolytic and nonhemolytic vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecalis isolated from beef imported to Malaysia. J Food Prot, 2003; 66:1845–1850.
24.
GilmoreMS, LebretonF, van SchaikW. Genomic transition of enterococci from gut commensals to leading causes of multidrug-resistant hospital infection in the antibiotic era. Curr Opin Microbiol, 2013; 16:10–16.
25.
GousiaP, EconomouV, SakkasH, LeveidiotouS, PapadopoulouC. Antimicrobial resistance of major foodborne pathogens from major meat products. Foodborne Pathog Dis, 2011; 8:27–38.
26.
Guerrero-RamosE, CorderoJ, Molina-GonzálezD, PoetaP, IgrejasG, Alonso-CallejaC. Antimicrobial resistance and virulence genes in enterococci from wild game meat in Spain. Food Microbiol 2016a;53:156–164.
27.
Guerrero-RamosE, Molina-GonzalezD, Blanco-MoranS, IgrejasG, PoetaP, Alonso-CallejaC, CapitaR.Prevalence, antimicrobial resistance, and genotypic characterization of vancomycin-resistant enterococci in meat preparations. J Food Prot, 2016b;79:748–756.
28.
HaradaT, MitoY, OtsukiK, MuraseT. Resistance to gentamicin and vancomycin in enterococcal strains isolated from retail broiler chickens in Japan. J Food Prot, 2004; 67:2292–2295.
29.
HayesJR, EnglishLL, CarterPJ, ProescholdtT, LeeKY, WagnerDD, WhiteDG. Prevalence and antimicrobial resistance of Enterococcus species isolated from retail meats. Appl Environ Microbiol, 2003; 69:7153–7160.
HollenbeckBL, RiceLB. Intrinsic and acquired resistance mechanisms in enterococcus. Virulence, 2012; 3:421–433.
32.
HosseiniSM, ZeyniB, RastyaniS, JafariR, ShamlooF, TabarZK. Presence of virulence factors and antibiotic resistances in Enterococcus sp. collected from dairy products and meat. Der Pharm Lett, 2016; 8:138–145.
33.
IgbinosaEO, BeshiruA. Antimicrobial resistance, virulence determinants, and biofilm formation of Enterococcus species from ready-to-eat seafood. Front Microbiol, 2019; 10:728.
34.
JahanM, KrauseDO, HolleyRA. Antimicrobial resistance of Enterococcus species from meat and fermented meat products isolated by a PCR-based rapid screening method. Int J Food Microbiol, 2013; 163:89–95.
35.
JametE, AkaryE, PoissonMA, ChambaJF, BertrandX, SerrorP. Prevalence and characterization of antibiotic resistant Enterococcus faecalis in French cheeses. Food Microbiol, 2012; 31:191–198.
36.
JohnningA, MooreERB, Svensson-StadlerL, ShoucheYS, LarssonDGJ, KristianssonE. Acquired genetic mechanisms of a multiresistant bacterium isolated from a treatment plant receiving wastewater from antibiotic production. Appl Environ Microbiol, 2013; 79:7256–7263.
37.
KimHJ, KooM. Occurrence, antimicrobial resistance and molecular diversity of Enterococcus faecium in processed pork meat products in Korea. Foods, 2020; 9:1283.
38.
KimM-C, ChaM-H, RyuJ-G, WooG-J. Characterization of vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecalis and Enterococcus faecium isolated from fresh produces and human fecal samples. Foodborne Pathog Dis, 2017; 14:195–201.
39.
KimNH, KimHW, ParkSM, SeoGH, ChoTJ, YuHR, et al.Virulence patterns and prevalence of seven Enterococcus species isolated from meats and leafy vegetables in South Korea. Food Control, 2020; 108:106867.
40.
KolumanA, AkanLS, ÇakirogluFP. Occurrence and antimicrobial resistance of enterococci in retail foods. Food Control, 2009; 20:281–283.
41.
KooM, ChoA, JeongA, KimH, ParkYH, KwakH, HwangI. Antibiotic susceptibility and molecular typing of Enterococcus faecalis from retail pork meat products in Korea. J Korean Soc Appl Biol Chem, 2013; 56:295–299.
42.
KrockoM, CanigovaM, DuckovaV, ArtimovaA, BezekovaJ, PostonJ. Antibiotic resistance of Enterococcus species isolated from raw foods of animal origin in South West part of Slovakia. Czech J Food Sci, 2011; 29:654–659.
43.
KwonKH, HwangSY, KimSH, MoonBY, ParkBK, YoonJW, ParkYH. Characterization of Enterocccus faecalis isolates from the pork meat production chain and comparison with human clinical isolates. J Food Saf, 2013; 33:190–196.
44.
LarssonDGJ.Pollution from drug manufacturing: Review and perspectives. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci, 2014; 369:20130571.
45.
LeeY.Biofilm formation and antimicrobial resistance in enterococcus. Infect Chemother, 2017; 49:236–237.
46.
LemckeR, BülteM. Occurrence of the vancomycin-resistant genes vanA, vanB, vanCl, vanC2 and vanC3 in Enterococcus strains isolated from poultry and pork. Int J Food Microbiol, 2000; 60:185–194.
47.
LópezM, SáenzY, Rojo-BezaresB, MartínezS, del CampoR, Ruiz-LarreaF, et al.Detection of vanA and vanB2-containing enterococci from food samples in Spain, including Enterococcus faecium strains of CC17 and the new singleton ST425. Int J Food Microbiol, 2009; 133:172–178.
48.
MacK, Wichmann-SchauerH, PetersJ, EllerbroekL. Species identification and detection of vancomycin resistance genes in enterococci of animal origin by multiplex PCR. Int J Food Microbiol, 2003; 88:305–309.
49.
MannuL, PabaA, DagaE, ComunianR, ZanettiS, DupreI, SechiLA. Comparison of the incidence of virulence determinants and antibiotic resistance between Enterococcus faecium strains of dairy, animal and clinical origin. Int J Food Microbiol, 2003; 88:291–304.
50.
Martin-PlateroAM, ValdiviaE, MaquedaM, Martínez-BuenoM. Characterization and safety evaluation of enterococci isolated from Spanish goats' milk cheeses. Int J Food Microbiol, 2009; 132:24–32.
51.
MeleseA, GenetC, AndualemT. Prevalence of vancomycin resistant enterococci (VRE) in Ethiopia: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Infect Dis, 2020; 20:124.
52.
MessiP, GuerrieriE, de NiederhausernS, SabiaC, BondiM. Vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE) in meat and environmental samples. Int J Food Microbiol, 2006; 107:218–222.
53.
MillerWR, MunitaJM, AriasCA. Mechanisms of antibiotic resistance in enterococci. Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther, 2014; 12:1221–1236.
54.
MirandaJM, GuarddonM, MondragonA, VázquezBI, FenteCA, CepedaA, FrancoCM. Antimicrobial resistance in Enterococcus spp. strains isolated from organic chicken, conventional chicken, and turkey meat: A comparative survey. J Food Prot, 2007; 70:1021–1024.
55.
MoghimbeigiA, MoghimbeygiM, DoustiM, KianiF, SayehmiriF, SadeghifardN, NazariA. Prevalence of vancomycin resistance among isolates of enterococci in Iran: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Adolesc Health Med Ther, 2018; 9:177–188.
56.
MoherD, LiberatiA, TetzlaffJ, AltmanDG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Med, 2009; 6:e1000097.
57.
NilssonO.Vancomycin resistant enterococci in farm animals—Occurrence and importance. Infect Ecol Epidemiol, 2012; 2. DOI: 10.3402/iee.v2i0.16959.
58.
NovaisC, CoqueTM, FerreiraH, SousaJC, PeixeL. Environmental contamination with vancomycin-resistant enterococci from hospital sewage in Portugal. Appl Environ Microbiol, 2005; 71:3364–3368.
59.
OnaranB, GoncuogluM, OrmancıFSB. Antibiotic resistance profiles of vancomycin resistant enterococci in chicken meat samples. Ankara Univ Vet Fak Derg, 2019; 66: 331–336.
60.
PaviaM, NobileCG, SalpietroL, AngelilloIF. Vancomycin resistance and antibiotic susceptibility of enterococci in raw meat. J Food Prot, 2000; 63:912–915.
61.
PesaventoG, CalonicoC, DucciB, MagnaniniA, Lo NostroA. Prevalence and antibiotic resistance of Enterococcus spp. isolated from retail cheese, ready-to-eat salads, ham, and raw meat. Food Microbiol, 2014; 41:1–7.
62.
PetersJ, MacK, Wichmann-SchauerH, KleinG, EllerbroekL. Species distribution and antibiotic resistance patterns of enterococci isolated from food of animal origin in Germany. Int J Food Microbiol, 2003; 88:311–314.
63.
RaduS, ToosaH, RahimRA. Reezal A, Ahmad M, Hamid AN, Rusul G, Nishibuchi M. Occurrence of the vanA and vanC2/C3 genes in Enterococcus species isolated from poultry sources in Malaysia. Diagn Microbiol Infect Dis, 2001; 39:145–153.
64.
SabiaC, de NiederhäusernS, GuerrieriE, MessiP, AnacarsoI, ManicardiG, BondiM. Detection of bacteriocin production and virulence traits in vancomycin-resistant enterococci of different sources. J Appl Microbiol, 2008; 104:970–979.
65.
SadeghifardN, KazemianH, MohebiR, SekawiZ, KhosraviA, ValizadehN, GhafourianS. Epidemiological alteration in pathogens found in ground meat in Iran: Unexpected predominance of vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecalis. GMS Hyg Infect Control, 2015; 10:Doc12.
66.
SanlibabaP, SenturkE. Prevalence, characterization and antibiotic resistance of enterococci from traditional cheeses in Turkey. Int J Food Prop, 2018; 2:1955–1963.
67.
Schlegelová J, Babák V, Klímová E, Lukásová J, Navrátilová P, Sustácková A, et al. Prevalence of and resistance to anti-microbial drugs in selected microbial species isolated from bulk milk samples J Vet Med B 2002;5:216–225.
68.
SustackováA, NápravníkováE, SchlegelováJ. Antimicrobial resistance of Enterococcus spp. isolates from raw beef and meat products. Folia Microbiol (Praha), 2004; 49:411–417.
69.
TalebiM, SadeghiJ, RahimiF, PourshafieMR. Isolation and biochemical fingerprinting of vancomycin-resistant Enterococcus faecium from meat, chicken and cheese. Jundishapur J Microbiol, 2015; 8:e15815.
70.
Terzić-VidojevićA, VeljovićK, BegovićJ, FilipićB, PopovićD, TolinačkiM, MiljkovićM, KojićM, GolićN. Diversity and antibiotic susceptibility of autochthonous dairy enterococci isolates: Are they safe candidates for autochthonous starter cultures?. Front Microbiol, 2015; 6:954.
71.
TorresC, AlonsoCA, Ruiz-RipaL, León-SampedroR, Del CampoR, CoqueTM. Antimicrobial resistance in Enterococcus spp. of animal origin. Microbiol Spectr, 2018; 6. DOI: 10.1128/microbiolspec.ARBA-0032-2018.
72.
Van den BraakN, van BelkumA, van KeulenM, VliegenthartJ, VerbrughHA, EndtzHP. Molecular characterization of vancomycin-resistant enterococci from hospitalized patients and poultry products in The Netherlands. J Clin Microbiol, 1998; 36:1927–1932.
73.
WijesekaraPNK, KumbukgollaWW, JayaweeraJAAS, RawatD. Review on usage of vancomycin in livestock and humans: Maintaining its efficacy, prevention of resistance and alternative therapy. Vet Sci, 2017; 4:6.
74.
YoungS, NayakB, SunS, BadgleyBD, RohrJR, HarwoodVJ. Vancomycin-resistant enterococci and bacterial community structure following a sewage spill into an aquatic environment. Appl Environ Microbiol, 2016; 82:5653–5660.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
