Are Food Animals Responsible for Transfer of Antimicrobial-Resistant Escherichia coli or Their Resistance Determinants to Human Populations? A Systematic Review
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online August, 2018
Are Food Animals Responsible for Transfer of Antimicrobial-Resistant Escherichia coli or Their Resistance Determinants to Human Populations? A Systematic Review
The role of farm animals in the emergence and dissemination of both AMR bacteria and their resistance determinants to humans is poorly understood and controversial. Here, we systematically reviewed the current evidence that food animals are responsible for transfer of AMR to humans. We searched PubMed, Web of Science, and EMBASE for literature published between 1940 and 2016. Our results show that eight studies (18%) suggested evidence of transmission of AMR from food animals to humans, 25 studies (56%) suggested transmission between animals and humans with no direction specified and 12 studies (26%) did not support transmission. Quality of evidence was variable among the included studies; one study (2%) used high resolution typing tools, 36 (80%) used intermediate resolution typing tools, six (13%) relied on low resolution typing tools, and two (5%) based conclusions on co-occurrence of resistance. While some studies suggested to provide evidence that transmission of AMR from food animals to humans may occur, robust conclusions on the directionality of transmission cannot be drawn due to limitations in study methodologies. Our findings highlight the need to combine high resolution genomic data analysis with systematically collected epidemiological evidence to reconstruct patterns of AMR transmission between food animals and humans.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Al-GhamdiMS, El-MorsyF, et al.Antibiotic resistance of Escherichia coli isolated from poultry workers, patients and chicken in the eastern province of Saudi Arabia. Trop Med Int Health, 1999; 4:278–283.
2.
AminovRI, MackieRI. Evolution and ecology of antibiotic resistance genes. FEMS Microbiol Lett, 2007; 271:147–161.
3.
BarberDA. New perspectives on transmission of foodborne pathogens and antimicrobial resistance. J Am Vet Med Assoc, 2001; 218:1559–1561.
4.
BeckerRA, WilksAR. mapdata: Extra Map Databases, version 2.30. 2016.
5.
BeckerRA, WilksAR. maps: Draw Geographical Maps version 3.3.0. 2017.
6.
Centre for Reviews Dissemination. Systematic Reviews: CRD's Guidance for Undertaking Reviews in Health Care. York, UK: Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, University of York, 2009.
7.
ChangQ, WangW, et al.Antibiotics in agriculture and the risk to human health: How worried should we be?. Evol Appl, 2015; 8:240–247.
8.
CiccozziM, GiufreM, et al.Phylogenetic analysis of multidrug-resistant Escherichia coli clones isolated from humans and poultry. New Microbiol, 2013; 36:385–394.
9.
DahmsC, HubnerNO, et al.Occurrence of ESBL-Producing Escherichia coli in Livestock and Farm Workers in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, Germany. PLoS One, 2015; 10:e0143326.
10.
DaviesSC. Infections and the Rise of Antimicrobial Resistance–Annual Report of the Chief Medical Officer, ed. Vol. 2. London: Department of Health, 2011.
11.
de BeenM, LanzaVF, et al.Dissemination of cephalosporin resistance genes between Escherichia coli strains from farm animals and humans by specific plasmid lineages. PLoS Genet, 2014; 10:e1004776.
12.
De MaioN, WuC-H, et al.New routes to phylogeography: A bayesian structured coalescent approximation. PLoS Genet, 2015; 11:1005421.
13.
DengY, ZengZ, et al.Dissemination of IncFII plasmids carrying rmtB and qepA in Escherichia coli from pigs, farm workers and the environment. Clin Microbiol Infect, 2011; 17:1740–1745.
14.
DidelotX, GardyJ, et al.Bayesian inference of infectious disease transmission from whole-genome sequence data. Mol Biol Evol, 2014; 31:1869–1879.
15.
DierikxCM, van der GootJA, et al.Presence of ESBL/AmpC -Producing Escherichia coli in the broiler production pyramid: A descriptive study. PLoS One, 2013; 8:e79005.
16.
DohmenW, BontenMJM, et al.Carriage of extended-spectrum beta-lactamases in pig farmers is associated with occurrence in pigs. Clin Microbiol Infect, 2015; 21:917–923.
17.
GiufreM, GrazianiC, et al.Escherichia coli of human and avian origin: Detection of clonal groups associated with fluoroquinolone and multidrug resistance in Italy. J Antimicrob Chemother, 2012; 67:860–867.
18.
GodfrayHCJ, DonnellyCA, et al.A restatement of the natural science evidence base relevant to the control of bovine tuberculosis in Great Britain. Proc Biol Sci, 2013; 280:20131634.
19.
GradYH, LipsitchM, Epidemiologic data and pathogen genome sequences: A powerful synergy for public health. Genome Biol, 2014; 15:538.
20.
GrazianiC, LuzziI, et al.Phylogenetic background and virulence genotype of ciprofloxacin-susceptible and ciprofloxacin-resistant Escherichia coli strains of human and avian origin. J Infect Dis, 2009; 199:1209–1217.
21.
HammerumAM, LarsenJ, et al.Characterization of extended-spectrum [beta]-lactamase (ESBL)-producing Escherichia coli obtained from Danish pigs, pig farmers and their families from farms with high or no consumption of third- or fourth-generation cephalosporins. J Antimicrob Chemother, 2014; 69:2650–2657.
22.
HammerumAM, SandvagD, et al.Detection of sul1, sul2 and sul3 in sulphonamide resistant Escherichia coli isolates obtained from healthy humans, pork and pigs in Denmark. Int J Food Microbiol, 2006; 106:235–237.
23.
HoP-L, WongRC, et al.Genetic identity of aminoglycoside-resistance genes in Escherichia coli isolates from human and animal sources. J Med Microbiol, 2010; 59:702–707.
24.
HoPL, WongRC, et al.Distribution of integron-associated trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole resistance determinants among Escherichia coli from humans and food-producing animals. Lett Appl Microbiol, 2009; 49:627–634.
25.
HowellsCH, JoynsonDH. Possible role of animal feeding-stuffs in spread of antibiotic-resistant intestinal coliforms. Lancet Infect Dis, 1975; 1:156–157.
26.
HuYY, CaiJC, et al.Molecular typing of CTX-M-Producing Escherichia coli isolates from environmental water, swine feces, specimens from healthy humans, and human patients. Appl Environ Microbiol, 2013; 79:5988–5996.
27.
HuijbersPMC, van HoekAHAM, et al.Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and extended-spectrum and AmpC beta-lactamase-producing Escherichia coli in broilers and in people living and/or working on organic broiler farms. Vet Microbiol, 2015; 176:120–125.
28.
JakobsenL, BortolaiaV, et al.Limited similarity between plasmids encoding CTX-M-1 beta-lactamase in Escherichia coli from humans, pigs, cattle, organic poultry layers and horses in Denmark. J Global Antimicrob Resist, 2015; 3:132–136.
29.
JakobsenL, GarneauP, et al.Microarray-based detection of extended virulence and antimicrobial resistance gene profiles in phylogroup B2 Escherichia coli of human, meat and animal origin. J Med Microbiol, 2011; 60:1502–1511.
30.
JakobsenL, KurbasicA, et al.Escherichia coli isolates from broiler chicken meat, broiler chickens, pork, and pigs share phylogroups and antimicrobial resistance with community-dwelling humans and patients with urinary tract infection. Foodborne Pathogens Dis, 2010; 7:537–547.
31.
JakobsenL, SpangholmDJ, et al.Broiler chickens, broiler chicken meat, pigs and pork as sources of ExPEC related virulence genes and resistance in Escherichia coli isolates from community-dwelling humans and UTI patients. Int J Food Microbiol, 2010; 142:264–272.
32.
JohnsonJR, KuskowskiMA, et al.Similarity between human and chicken Escherichia coli isolates in relation to ciprofloxacin resistance status. J Infect Dis, 2006; 194:71–78.
33.
JohnsonTJ, LogueCM, et al.Associations between multidrug resistance, plasmid content, and virulence potential among extraintestinal pathogenic and commensal Escherichia coli from humans and poultry. Foodborne Pathogens Dis, 2012; 9:37–46.
34.
JorgensenST. Relatedness of chloramphenicol resistance plasmids in epidemiologically unrelated strains of pathogenic Escherichia coli from man and animals. J Med Microbiol, 1983; 16:165–173.
35.
KahleD, WickhamH. ggmap: Spatial Visualization with ggplot2. The R Journal, 2013; 5:144–161.
36.
KangHY, JeongYS, et al.Characterization of antimicrobial resistance and class 1 integrons found in Escherichia coli isolates from humans and animals in Korea. J Antimicrob Chemother, 2005; 55:639–644.
37.
KariukiS, GilksC, et al.Genotype analysis of Escherichia coli strains isolated from children and chickens living in close contact. Appl Environ Microbiol, 1999; 65:472–476.
38.
KariukiS, GilksCF, et al.Plasmid diversity of multi-drug-resistant Escherichia coli isolated from children with diarrhoea in a poultry-farming area in Kenya. Ann Trop Med Parasitol, 1997; 91:87–94.
39.
KluytmansJAJW, OverdevestITMA, et al.Extended-spectrum beta-lactamase-producing Escherichia coli from retail chicken meat and humans: comparison of strains, plasmids, resistance genes, and virulence factors. Clin Infect Dis, 2013; 56:478–487.
40.
LazarusB, PatersonDL, et al.Do human extraintestinal Escherichia coli infections resistant to expanded-spectrum cephalosporins originate from food-producing animals? A systematic review. Clin Infect Dis, 2015; 60:439–452.
41.
Leverstein-van HallMA, DierikxCM, et al.Dutch patients, retail chicken meat and poultry share the same ESBL genes, plasmids and strains. Clin Microbiol Infect, 2011; 17:873–880.
42.
LevySB. Emergence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria in the intestinal flora of farm inhabitants. J Infect Dis, 1978; 137:689–690.
43.
LiberatiA, AltmanDG, et al.The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: Explanation and elaboration. PLoS Med, 2009; 6:e1000097.
44.
LipsitchM, SingerRS, et al.Antibiotics in agriculture: When is it time to close the barn door?. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA, 2002; 99:5752–5754.
45.
LupinduAM, DalsgaardA, et al.Transmission of antibiotic-resistant Escherichia coli between cattle, humans and the environment in peri-urban livestock keeping communities in Morogoro, Tanzania. Prev Vet Med, 2015; 118:477–482.
46.
MarshallBM, LevySB. Food animals and antimicrobials: Impacts on human health. Clin Microbiol Rev, 2011; 24:718–733.
47.
MaynardC, BekalS, et al.Heterogeneity among virulence and antimicrobial resistance gene profiles of extraintestinal Escherichia coli isolates of animal and human origin. J Clin Microbiol, 2004; 42:5444–5452.
48.
MendelsonM, BalasegaramM, et al.Antibiotic resistance has a language problem. Nature, 2017; 545:23–25.
49.
MoodleyA, GuardabassiL. Transmission of IncN plasmids carrying bla(CTX-M-1) between commensal Escherichia coli in pigs and farm workers. Antimicrob Agents Chemother, 2009; 53:1709–1711.
50.
MulveyMR, SuskyE, et al.Similar cefoxitin-resistance plasmids circulating in Escherichia coli from human and animal sources. Vet Microbiol, 2009; 134:279–287.
51.
NeidhardtFC, IngrahamJL, et al.Escherichia coli and Salmonella: Cellular and Molecular Biology. 2nd edition. Washington, DC: American Society for Microbiology, 1996.
52.
O'NeillJ. Tackling Drug-Resistant Infections Globally: Final Report and Recommendations. The Review on Antimicrobial Resistance, 2016.
53.
OppegaardH, SteinumTM, et al.Horizontal transfer of a multi-drug resistance plasmid between coliform bacteria of human and bovine origin in a farm environment. Appl Environ Microbiol, 2001; 67:3732–3734.
54.
OrlekA, StoesserN, et al.Plasmid classification in an era of whole-genome sequencing: Application in studies of antibiotic resistance epidemiology. Front Microbiol, 2017; 8:182.
55.
OverdevestI, WillemsenI, et al.Extended-spectrum beta-lactamase genes of Escherichia coli in chicken meat and humans, the Netherlands. Emerg Infect Dis, 2011; 17:1216–1222.
56.
PhongpaichitS, LiamthongS, et al.Prevalence of class 1 integrons in commensal Escherichia coli from pigs and pig farmers in Thailand. J Food Prot, 2007; 70:292–299.
57.
R Core Team R. A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing, 2017.
58.
RiccobonoE, PallecchiL, et al.Carriage of antibiotic-resistant Escherichia coli among healthy children and home-raised chickens: A household study in a resource-limited setting. Microbial Drug Resist, 2012; 18:83–87.
59.
SchwaigerK, HoelzelC, et al.Resistance gene patterns of tetracycline resistant Escherichia coli of human and porcine origin. Vet Microbiol, 2010; 142:329–336.
60.
SheppardAE, StoesserN, et al.Nested Russian doll-like genetic mobility drives rapid dissemination of the carbapenem resistance gene blaKPC. Antimicrob Agents Chemother, 2016; 60:3767–3778.
61.
SingerRS, WardMP, et al.Can landscape ecology untangle the complexity of antibiotic resistance?. Nat Rev Microbiol, 2006; 4:943–952.
62.
SmetA, MartelA, et al.Comparative analysis of extended-spectrum-β-lactamase-carrying plasmids from different members of Enterobacteriaceae isolated from poultry, pigs and humans: Evidence for a shared β-lactam resistance gene pool?. J Antimicrob Chemother, 2009; 63:1286–1288.
63.
StokesMO, CottellJL, et al.Detection and characterization of pCT-like plasmid vectors for bla(CTX-M-14) in Escherichia coli isolates from humans, turkeys and cattle in England and Wales. J Antimicrob Chemother, 2012; 67:1639–1644.
64.
TangKL, CaffreyNP, et al.Restricting the use of antibiotics in food-producing animals and its associations with antibiotic resistance in food-producing animals and human beings: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet Planet Health, 2017; 1:e316–e327.
65.
TsengS-P, WangS-F, et al.Characterization of fosfomycin resistant extended-spectrum beta-lactamase-producing Escherichia coli isolates from human and pig in Taiwan. PLoS One, 2015; 10:e0135864.
66.
UedaS, Bui Thi KimN, et al.Limited transmission of bla(CTX-M-9)-type-positive Escherichia coli between humans and poultry in vietnam. Antimicrob Agents Chemother, 2015; 59:3574–3577.
67.
ValentinL, SharpH, et al.Subgrouping of ESBL-producing Escherichia coli from animal and human sources: An approach to quantify the distribution of ESBL types between different reservoirs. Int J Med Microbiol, 2014; 304:805–816.
68.
van den BogaardAE, LondonN, et al.Antibiotic resistance of faecal Escherichia coli in poultry, poultry farmers and poultry slaughterers. J Antimicrob Chemother, 2001; 47:763–771.
69.
VieiraAR, CollignonP, et al.Association Between Antimicrobial Resistance in Escherichia coli Isolates from Food Animals and Blood Stream Isolates from Humans in Europe: An Ecological Study. Foodborne Pathogens Dis, 2011; 8:1295–1301.
70.
VoetsGM, FluitAC, et al.Identical plasmid AmpC beta-lactamase genes and plasmid types in E. coli isolates from patients and poultry meat in the Netherlands. Int J Food Microbiol, 2013; 167:359–362.
71.
WHO. Global Action Plan on Antimicrobial Resistance. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization, 2015.
72.
WHO. Global Priority List of Antibiotic-Resistant Bacteria to Guide Research, Discovery, and Development of New Antibiotics. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization, 2017.
73.
WickhamH, ChangW, WickhamM. ggplot2: Elegant Graphics for Data Analysis, version 2.2.1. Heidelberg, Germany: Springer. 2013.
74.
WinokurPL, VonsteinDL, et al.Evidence for transfer of CMY-2 AmpC beta-lactamase plasmids between Escherichia coli and Salmonella isolates from food animals and humans. Antimicrob Agents Chemother, 2001; 45:2716–2722.
75.
WooldridgeM. Evidence for the circulation of antimicrobial-resistant strains and genes in nature and especially between humans and animals. Rev Sci Tech, 2012; 31:231–247.
76.
WoolhouseM, WardM, et al.Antimicrobial resistance in humans, livestock and the wider environment. Philos Trans R Soc B Biol Sci, 2015; 370:20140083.
77.
XiaL-N, LiL, et al.A Survey of plasmid-mediated fluoroquinolone resistance genes from Escherichia coli isolates and their dissemination in Shandong, China. Foodborne Pathogens Dis, 2010; 7:207–215.
78.
ZhangXY, DingLJ, et al.Occurrence and characteristics of class 1 and class 2 integrons in resistant Escherichia coli isolates from animals and farm workers in northeastern China. Microb Drug Resist, 2009; 15:323–328.
79.
ZhaoJ, ChenZ, et al.Prevalence and Dissemination of oqxAB in Escherichia coli Isolates from Animals, Farmworkers, and the Environment. Antimicrob Agents Chemother, 2010; 54:4219–4224.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
