Since the 2020 election, hundreds of bills have been introduced to state legislatures with new voting restrictions, while many states have made voting more accessible. Undergirding the operation of these laws are a set of rules, procedures, technologies, and local election officials that shape the voting process across the U.S. (Alvarez et al. 2013, 31). Despite evidence documenting election administration matters, little research has investigated the combined impact of multiple state election laws and election administration capacity, using two comprehensive nationwide indices, on voter behavior. Employing administrative data with vote histories from a national voter file over time (2012 to 2020 presidential elections), we test the effects of both election administration and election laws. Applying statistical matching, we find more restrictive state election laws reduce voter turnout, while more election administration capacity has a mixed effect on turnout. Despite a low correlation, these two factors can interact, with quality state election administration partially offsetting the negative effects of restrictive voting laws. The interaction effect is stronger in 2012 and 2020. Academics and policy makers need to consider election administration in models of voter turnout.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlvarezR. Michael, and HallThad. E. (2006). “Controlling Democracy: The Principal–Agent Problems in Election Administration.” Policy Studies Journal, 34(4), 491-510.
2.
AlvarezR. Michael, BaileyDelia, and Katz.Jonathan N. (2008). “The Effect of Voter Identification Laws on Turnout.”. California Institute of Technology Social Science Working Paper (1267R).
3.
AlvarezR. Michael, AtkesonLonna Rae, and HallThad E.. (2013). Evaluating Elections: A Handbook of Methods and Standards. Cambridge University Press.
4.
AmosBrian, SmithDaniel A., and SteCasey. (2017). “Reprecincting and Voting Behavior.” Political Behavior,, 39(1), 133-156.
5.
AnsolabehereStephen, and KoniskyDavid M.. (2006). “The Introduction of Voter Registration and Its Effect on Turnout.” Political Analysis. 83-100.
6.
AnsolabehereStephen, and HershEitan. (2012). “Validation: What Big Data Reveal About Survey Misreporting and the Real Electorate.” Political Analysis 20 (4):. 437-459.
7.
AnsolabehereStephen, FragaBernard L., and SchaffnerBrian F.. (2022). “The Current Population Survey Voting and Registration Supplement Overstates Minority Turnout.” The Journal of Politics, 84(3), 1850-1855.
8.
AnsolabehereS., SchaffnerB. Fraga and B. F. (2021). “The CPS Voting and Registration Supplement Overstates Minority Turnout”. Journal of Politics. In press.
9.
AtkesonLonna Rae, and SaundersKyle L.. (2007). “The Effect of Election Administration on Voter Confidence: A local Matter?” PS: Political Science and Politics, 40(4), 655-660.
10.
AtkesonLonna Rae, BryantLisa Ann, HallThad E., SaundersKyle, and AlvarezMichael. (2010). “A New Barrier to Participation: Heterogeneous Application of Voter Identification Policies.” Electoral Studies, 29(1), 66-73.
11.
AtkesonLonna Rae, KerevelYann P., AlvarezR. Michael, and HallThad E.. (2014). “Who Asks for Voter Identification? Explaining Poll-Worker Discretion.” The Journal of Politics,, 76(4), 944-957.
12.
BarretoMatt A., Cohen-MarksMara, and WoodsNathan D.. (2009). “Are All Precincts Created Equal? The Prevalence of Low-Quality Precincts in Low-Income and Minority Communities.” Political Research Quarterly, 62(3), 445-458.
13.
BarretoMatt A., NunoStephen A., and SanchezGabriel R.. (2009). “The Disproportionate Impact of Voter-ID Requirements on the Electorate: New Evidence from Indiana.” PS: Political Science and Politics, 42(1), 111-116.
14.
BarretoMatt A., NuñoStephen, SanchezGabriel R., and WalkerHannah L.. (2019). “The Racial Implications of Voter Identification Laws in America.” American Politics Research, 47(2), 238-249.
15.
BeckNathaniel, and KatzJonathan N.. (1995). “What to Do (and Not to Do) with Time-Series Cross-Section Data.” American Political Science Review, 89(3), 634-647.
16.
BerinskyAdam J. (2005). “The Perverse Consequences of Electoral Reform in the United States.” American Politics Research, 33(4), 471-491.
17.
BlackwellMatthew, IacusStefano, KingGary, and PorroGiuseppe. (2009). “cem: Coarsened exact matching in Stata.” The Stata Journal, 9(4), 524-546.
18.
BowlerShaun, BrunellThomas, DonovanTodd, and GronkePaul. (2015). “Election Administration and Perceptions of Fair Elections.” Electoral Studies, 38, 1-9.
BurdenBarry C. (2018). “Disagreement Over ID Requirements and Minority Voter Turnout.” The Journal of Politics, 80(3), 1060-1063.
21.
BurdenBarry C., and MilyoJeffrey. (2015). “The Quantities and Qualities of Poll Workers.” Election Law Journal, 14(1), 38-46.
22.
BurdenBarry C., and NeiheiselJacob R.. (2013). “Election Administration and the Pure Effect of Voter Registration on Turnout.” Political Research Quarterly, 66(1), 77-90.
23.
BurdenBarry C., and StewartCharles, III. (2014). The Measure of American Elections, eds. Barry C. Burden and Charles Stewart, III. Cambridge University Press.
24.
BurdenBarry C., CanonDavid T., MayerKenneth R., and MoynihanDonald P. (2011). “Early Voting and Election Day Registration in the Trenches: Local officials' Perceptions of Election Reform.” Election Law Journal, 10(2), 89-102.
25.
BurdenBarry C., CanonDavid T., MayerKenneth R., and MoynihanDonald P. (2012). “The Effect of Administrative Burden on Bureaucratic Perception of Policies: Evidence from Election Administration.” Public Administration Review, 72(5), 741-751.
26.
BurdenBarry C., CanonDavid T., MayerKenneth R., MoynihanDonald P., and NeiheiselJacob R.. (2017). “What Happens at the Polling Place: Using Administrative Data to Look Inside Elections.” Public Administration Review, 77(3), 354-364.
27.
BurdenBarry C., CanonDavid T., MayerKenneth R., and MoynihanDonald P.. (2014). “Election Laws, Mobilization, and Turnout: The Unanticipated Consequences of Election Reform.” American Journal of Political Science,, 58(1), 95-109.
28.
CantoniEnrico and Vincent Pons (2021). “Strict ID Laws Don't Stop Voters: Evidence from a U.S. Nationwide Panel, 2008–2018.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 136 (4). 2615-2660.
ClaassenRyan L., MaglebyDavid B., MonsonJ. Quin, and PattersonKelly D.. (2008). “‘At Your Service’ Voter Evaluations of Poll Worker Performance.” American Politics Research, 36(4), 612-634.
31.
ClaassenRyan L., MaglebyDavid B., MonsonJ. Quin, and PattersonKelly D.. (2013). “Voter Confidence and the Election-Day Voting Experience.” Political Behavior, 35(2), 215-235.
32.
CollJoseph. (2022). “Waiting to Vote Safely: How Covid-19 Safety Measures Shaped In-Person Voter Wait Times During the 2020 Election.” Social Science Quarterly, 103(2), 380-398.
CottrellDavid, HerronMichael C., and SmithDaniel A.. (2021). “Voting Lines, Equal Treatment, and Early Voting Check-In Times in Florida.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 21(2), 109-138.
EriksonRobert S., and MinniteLorraine C.. (2009). “Modeling Problems in the Voter Identification—Voter Turnout Debate.” Election Law Journal, 8(2), 85-101.
38.
FitzgeraldMary. (2005). “Greater Convenience but Not Greater Turnout: The Impact of Alternative Voting Methods on Electoral Participation in the United States.” American Politics Research, 33(6), 842-867.
39.
FragaBernard L. (2018). The Turnout Gap: Race, Ethnicity and Political Inequality in a Diversifying America. Cambridge University Press.
40.
FragaBernard L. (2016). “Candidates or Districts? Reevaluating the Role of Race in Voter Turnout.” American Journal of Political Science 60 (1):. 97-122.
41.
FragaBernard, and HolbeinJohn. (2020). “Measuring Youth and College Student Voter Turnout.” Electoral Studies 65:. 102086.
42.
FragaBernard L., and MillerMichael G.. (2022). “Who Do Voter ID Laws Keep from Voting.” The Journal of Politics, 84(2), 1091-1105.
43.
FranklinDaniel P., and GrierEric E.. (1997). “Effects of Motor Voter Legislation: Voter Turnout, Registration, and Partisan Advantage in the 1992 Presidential Election.” American Politics Quarterly, 25(1), 104-117.
44.
FullmerElliott B. (2015). “Early Voting: Do More Sites Lead to Higher Turnout?” Election Law Journal, 14(2), 81-96.
45.
GimpelJames G., and SchuknechtJason E.. (2003). “Political Participation and the Accessibility of the Ballot Box.” Political Geography, 22(5), 471-488.
46.
GrimmerJustin, HershEitan, MeredithMarc, MummoloJonathan, and NallClayton. (2018). “Obstacles to Estimating Voter ID Laws' Effect on Turnout.” The Journal of Politics, 80(3), 1045-1051.
47.
GerkenHeather K.2009. The Democracy Index. Princeton University Press.
48.
GronkePaul, and MillerPeter. (2012). “Voting by Mail and Turnout in Oregon: Revisiting Southwell and Burchett.” American Politics Research, 40(6), 976-997.
49.
GronkePaul, and ToffeyDaniel Krantz. (2008). “The Psychological and Institutional Determinants of Early Voting.” Journal of Social Issues, 64(3), 503-524.
50.
GronkePaul, Galanes-RosenbaumEva, MillerPeter A., and ToffeyDaniel. (2008). “Convenience Voting.” Annual Review of Political Science, 11, 437-455.
51.
GrumbachJacob M., and HillCharlotte. (2022). “Rock the Registration: Same Day Registration Increases Turnout of Young Voters.” The Journal of Politics, 84(1), 405-417.
52.
HaleKathleen, and BrownMitchell. (2020). How We Vote: Innovation in American Elections. Georgetown University Press.
53.
HajnalZoltan, LajevardiNazita, and NielsonLindsay. (2017). “Voter Identification Laws and the Suppression of Minority Votes.” The Journal of Politics, 79(2), 363-379.
54.
HajnalZoltan, KukJohn, and LajevardiNazita. (2018). “We All Agree: Strict Voter ID Laws Disproportionately Burden Minorities.” The Journal of Politics, 80(3), 1052-1059.
HanmerM. J. (2009). Discount Voting: Voter Registration Reforms and Their Effects. Cambridge University Press.
57.
HerronMichael C., and SmithDaniel A. (2012). “Souls to the Polls: Early Voting in Florida in the Shadow of House Bill 1355.” Election Law Journal 11 (3):. 331-347.
58.
HanmerMichael J., and SmithDaniel A.. (2014). “Race, Party, and the Consequences of Restricting Early Voting in Florida in the 2012 General Election.” Political Research Quarterly, 67(3), 646-665.
59.
HerronMichael C., and SmithDaniel A.. (2015). “Precinct Closing Times in Florida During the 2012 General Election.” Election Law Journal, 14(3), 220-238.
60.
HershEitan D. (2015). Hacking the Electorate: How Campaigns Perceive Voters. Cambridge University Press.
61.
HershEitan D., and NallClayton (2016). “The Primacy of Race in the Geography of Income-Based Voting: New Evidence from Public Voting Records.” American Journal of Political Science 60 (2):. 289-303.
62.
HershEitan, and GhitzaYair. (2018). “Mixed Partisan Households and Electoral Participation in the United States.” PloS one,, 13(10), e0203997.
63.
HightonBenjamin. (2004). “Voter Registration and Turnout in the United States.” Perspectives on Politics. 507-515.
64.
HightonBenjamin. (2005). “Self-Reported Versus Proxy-Reported Voter Turnout in the Current Population Survey.” Public Opinion Quarterly, 69(1), 113-123.
65.
HightonBenjamin. (2006). “Long Lines, Voting Machine Availability, and Turnout: The Case of Franklin County, Ohio in the 2004 Presidential Election.” PS: Political Science and Politics, 39(1), 65-68.
66.
HightonBenjamin, and WolfingerRaymond E.. (1998). “Estimating the Effects of the National Voter Registration Act of 1993.” Political Behavior, 20(2), 79-104.
67.
HolbeinJohn B., and HillygusD. Sunshine. (2020). Making Young Voters: Converting Civic Attitudes into Civic Action. Cambridge University Press.
68.
HolbrookAllyson L., and KrosnickJon A.. (2010). “Social Desirability Bias in Voter Turnout Reports: Tests Using the Item Count Technique.” Public Opinion Quarterly, 74(1), 37-67.
69.
HoodM. V., and BullockCharles S.. (2012). “Much Ado About Nothing? An Empirical Assessment of the Georgia Voter Identification Statute.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 12(4), 394-414.
70.
HostetterJoshua D. (2022). “Do Electronic Poll Books Increase Voter Wait Times?” Election Law Journal, 21(4), 296-307.
71.
HurAram, and AchenChristopher H.. (2013). “Coding Voter Turnout Responses in the Current Population Survey.” Public Opinion Quarterly, 77(4), 985-993.
72.
IacusStefano M., KingGary, and PorroGiuseppe. (2012). “Causal Inference Without Balance Checking: Coarsened Exact Matching. ” Political Analysis 20 (1),1-24.
JansaJoshua M., MottaMatthew, and HerrickRebekah. (2022). “Finding DORI: Using Item Response Theory to Measure Difficulty of Registration in the U.S. and Its Impact on Voters.” American Politics Research, 50(3), 336-352.
75.
JenkinsC., WhiteIsmail K., HanmerMichael J., and BanksAntoine J.. (2017). “Vote Overreporting While Black: Identifying the Mechanism Behind Black Vote Overreporting.” Unpublished. Manuscript.
76.
JuelichCourtney L., and CollJoseph A.. (2020). “Rock the Vote or Block the Vote? How the Cost of Voting Affects the Voting Behavior of American Youth.” American Politics Research,, 48(6), 719-724.
77.
KarpJeffrey A., and BanducciSusan A.. (2000). “Going Postal: How All-Mail Elections Influence Turnout.” Political Behavior, 22(3), 223-239.
78.
KarpJeffrey A., and Brockington.David. “Social Desirability and Response Validity: A Comparative Analysis of Overreporting Voter Turnout in Five Counties.”. The Journal of Politics, 67(3), 825-840.
79.
KeeleLuke, and KellyNathan J.. (2006). “Dynamic Models for Dynamic Theories: The Ins and Outs of Lagged Dependent Variables.” Political Analysis, 14(2), 186-205.
80.
KimballDavid C., and BaybeckBrady. (2013). “Are All Jurisdictions Equal? Size Disparity in Election Administration.” Election Law Journal, 12(2), 130-145.
81.
KimballDavid C., KropfMartha, and BattlesLindsay. (2006). “Helping America Vote? Election Administration, Partisanship, and Provisional Voting in the 2004 Election.” Election Law Journal, 5(4), 447-461.
82.
KingBridgett. (2020). “Diversity and Descriptive Representation in Election Administration” In The Future of Election Administration, eds. Mitchell Brown, Kathleen Hale, and Bridgett A. King, (169-184). Palgrave. Macmillan.
83.
KingBridgett A. (2019). “State Online Voting and Registration Lookup Tools: Participation, Confidence, and Ballot Disposition.” Journal of Information Technology & Politics, 16(3), 219–235.
84.
KnackStephen. (1995). “Does Motor Voter Work? Evidence from State-Level Data.” The Journal of Politics, 57(3), 796-811.
85.
KropfMartha E. (2012). “Does Early Voting Change the Socio-Economic Composition of the Electorate?” Poverty and Public Policy, 4(1), 1-19.
86.
KropfMartha, VercellottiTimothy, and KimballDavid C.. (2013). “Representative Bureaucracy and Partisanship: The Implementation of Election Law.” Public Administration Review, 73(2), 242-252.
87.
KropfMartha, PopeJoEllen V., ShepherdMary Jo, and MohrZachary. (2020). “Making Every Vote Count: The Important Role of Managerial Capacity in Achieving Better Election Administration Outcomes.” Public Administration Review, 80(5), 733-742.
88.
KukJohn, HajnalZoltan, and LajevardiNazita. (2020). “A Disproportionate Burden: Strict Voter Identification Laws and Minority Turnout.” Politics, Groups, and Identities. 1-9.
89.
LambMatt.“Who Leaves the Line, Anyway? A Study of Who Leaves Polling Place Lines, and Why.”. Election Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy, 20(3), 301-314.
90.
LaroccaRoger, and KlemanskiJohn S.. (2011). “U.S. State Election Reform and Turnout in Presidential Elections.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly,, 11(1), 76-101.
91.
LeighleyJan E., and NaglerJonathan. (2013). Who Votes Now?: Demographics, Issues, Inequality, and Turnout in the United States. Princeton University Press.
92.
LiQuan, PomanteMichael J., and SchraufnagelScot. (2018). “Cost of Voting in the American States.” Election Law Journal, 17(3), 234-247.
93.
MaglebyDavid B. (1987). “Participation in Mail Ballot Elections.” Western Political Quarterly, 40(1), 79-91.
94.
McDonaldMichael P. (2008). “Portable Voter Registration.” Political Behavior, 30(4), 491-501.
95.
McDonaldMichael P. (2020, October 08). United States Elections Project. Retrieved June 19, 2021, from <http://www.electproject.org/>.
96.
MerivakiT., Smithand, AD.. (2016). “Casting and Verifying Provisional Ballots in Florida.” Social Science Quarterly, 97(3), 729-747.
97.
MillerPeter, and PowellSierra. (2016). “Overcoming Voting Obstacles: The Use of Convenience Voting by Voters with Disabilities.” American Politics Research, 44(1), 28-55.
MohrZachary, PopeJoEllen V., KropfMartha E., and ShepherdMary Jo. (2019). “Strategic Spending: Does Politics Influence Election Administration Expenditure?” American Journal of Political Science, 63(2), 427-438.
National Voter Registration Act of 1993, Pub. L. No. 103-31, 107 Stat. 77 (1993).
105.
N.C. State Conference of the NAACP v. McCrory, 182 F. Supp. 3d 320 (M.D.N.C. 2016).
106.
NickersonD.W., Rogersand, T. (2014). “Political Campaigns and Big Data.” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 28(2), 51-74.
107.
PettigrewStephen. (2017). “The Racial Gap in Wait Times: Why Minority Precincts Are Underserved by Local Election Officials.” Political Science Quarterly, 132(3), 527-547.
108.
PettigrewStephen (2020). “The Downstream Consequences of Long Waits: How Lines at the Precinct Depress Future Turnout.” Electoral Studies,102188.
109.
PomanteMichael J., II., SchraufnagelScot, and LiQuan. (2023). The Cost of Voting in the American States. University Press of Kansas.
110.
PowellG. BinghamJr. (1986) “American Voter Turnout in Comparative Perspective.”. The American Political Science Review, 80(1), 17-43.
111.
RigbyElizabeth, and SpringerMelanie J.. (2011). Does Electoral Reform Increase (or Decrease) Political Equality?”. Political Research Quarterly,, 64(2), 420-434.
112.
RitterMichael. (2023). “Assessing the Impact of the United States Postal System and Election Administration on Absentee and Mail Voting in the 2012 to 2020 US Midterm and Presidential Elections.” Election Law Journal, 22(2), 166-184.
113.
RitterMichael, and TolbertCaroline J.. (2020). Accessible Elections: How the States Can Help Americans Vote. Oxford University Press.
114.
RochaRene R., and MatsubayashiTetsuya. (2014). “The Politics of Race and Voter ID Laws in the States: The Return of Jim Crow?” Political Research Quarterly, 67(3), 666-679.
115.
RogersTodd, and AidaMasahiko. (2014). “Vote Self-Prediction Hardly Predicts Who Will Vote, and Is (Misleadingly) Unbiased.” American Politics Research 42 (3):. 503-528.
116.
RugeleyCynthia, and JacksonRobert A.. (2009). “Getting on the Rolls: Analyzing the Effects of Lowered Barriers on Voter Registration.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 9(1), 56-78.
117.
SchraufnagelScot, IIMichael J. Pomante, and Li.Quan (2020.) “Cost of Voting in the American States: 2020.”. Election Law Journal, 19(4): 503-509.
118.
SouthwellPriscilla L., and BurchettJustin I.. (2000). “The Effect of All-Mail Elections on Voter Turnout.” American Politics Quarterly, 28(1), 72-79.
119.
SpringerMelanie Jean. (2014). How the States Shaped the Nation. University of Chicago Press.
120.
SteinRobert M., and VonnahmeGreg. (2012). “Effect of Election Day Vote Centers on Voter Participation.” Election Law Journal, 11(3), 291-301.
121.
SteinRobert M., and VonnahmeGreg. (2014). “Polling Place Practices and the Voting Experience.” In The Measure of American Elections, eds. Barry C. Burden and Charles Stewart, III, Cambridge University Press.
122.
SteinRobert, MannChristopher, and IIICharles Stewart. (2020). “Polling Place Quality and Access.” In The Future of Election Administration, eds. Mitchel Brown, Kathleen Hale, and Bridgett A. King, (83-100). Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
123.
SteinRobert M., MannChristopher, IIICharles Stewart, BirenbaumZachary, FungAnson, GreenbergJed, alFarhan Kawsar et. (2020). “Waiting to Vote in the 2016 Presidential Election: Evidence from a Multi-County Study.” Political Research Quarterly, 73(2), 439-453.
124.
StewartC., (2020). “The Elections Performance Index: Past, Present, and Future.” In. The Future of Election Administration, eds. Mitchel Brown, Kathleen Hale, and Bridgett A. King, (119-153).Palgrave Macmillan.
125.
WalkerH. L., Herron, C.M., Smithand, D.A. (2019). “Early Voting Changes and Voter Turnout: North Carolina in the 2016 General Election.” Political Behavior, 41, 841-869.
126.
WolfingerRaymond E., and Rosenstone.Steven J. (1980). Who Votes?. Yale University Press.
127.
XuJun. (2005). “Why Do Minorities Participate Less? The Effects of Immigration, Education, and Electoral Process on Asian American Voter Registration and Turnout.” Social Science Research, 34(4), 682-702.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
