Accidental invalid voting is a scourge of voting because an elector has acted contrary to their intentions. This problem has been shown to be more acute in settings where the requirement to vote is mandatory and the electoral regime is complex. In this article, we explore the interaction between convenience voting and accidental invalidity to evaluate whether the former helps reduce the incidence of the latter. We investigate whether two popular forms of convenience voting—postal and early voting—have potential to minimize rates of accidental invalidity under taxing voting rules in five recent subnational elections from Australia. Aggregate-level data is used to explore correlations between different voting modes and rates of accidental invalid voting. The findings suggest that convenience voting has a negative relationship with the incidence of accidental invalid ballots, but that the size of the effect is small. Hence, the more familiar forms of convenience voting appear to have some but modest benefits for reducing accidental invalidity.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AldashevG., and MastrobuoniG.. 2019. “Invalid Ballots and Electoral Competition.” Political Science Research and Methods, 7(2): 289–310.
2.
Alvarez R. M.T. Hall, and SinclairB.. 2008. “Whose Absentee Votes Are Counted: The Variety and Use of Absentee Ballots in California.” Electoral Studies, 27(4): 673–683.
3.
AlvarezR. M., LevinI., and SinclairJ.. 2012. “Making Voting Easier: Convenience Voting in the 2008 Presidential Election.” Political Research Quarterly, 65(2): 248–262.
4.
AnsolabehereS., BurdenB., MayerK., and StewartC.. 2018. “Learning from Recounts.” Election Law Journal, 17(2): 100–116.
5.
AnsolabehereS., and StewartC.. 2005. “Residual Votes Attributable to Technology.” Journal of Politics, 67(2): 365–389.
6.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). 2006. “Western Australia.” Australian Census 2006. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics.
7.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). 2011. “Western Australia.” Australian Census 2011. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics.
8.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS). 2016. “Western Australia.” Australian Census 2016. Canberra: Australian Bureau of Statistics.
9.
Australian Electoral Commission (AEC). 2018. Analysis of Informal Voting—2016 House of Representatives Elections. Canberra: Australian Electoral Commission.
10.
Australian Electoral Commission. 2020. Report on the Conduct of the 2019 Federal Election. Submission to the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters, inquiry into and report on all aspects of the conduct of the 2019 Federal Election and matters related thereto. Submission 120, 1–48. Canberra: Australian Electoral Commission.
11.
BanducciS., and KarpJ.. 2000. “Going Postal: How All-Mail Elections Influence Turnout.” Political Behaviour, 22(3): 223–239.
12.
BarbaletJ.2002. “Secret Voting and Political Emotions.” Mobilization: An International Quarterly, 7(2): 129–140.
13.
BarryC., DaceyP., PickeringT., and EvansT.. 2002. eVolution Not Revolution. Electronic Voting Status Report. Canberra: Australian Electoral Commission.
14.
BernhardM., BenalohJ., HaldermanJ., RivestA., RonaldL., RyanP., StarkP., TeagueV., VoraP., and WallachD.. 2017. “Public Evidence from Secret Ballots.” In Electronic Voting, eds. KrimmerRobert, VolkamerMelanie, Braun BinderNadja, KerstingNorbert, PereiraOlivier, SchürmannCarsten. Second International Joint Conference, EVote-ID 2017. Bregenz, Austria, October 24–27, 2017 Proceedings. Cham: Springer.
15.
BiggersD., and HanmerM.. 2015. “Who Makes Voting Convenient? Explaining the Adoption of Early and No-Excuse Absentee Voting in the American States.” State Politics and Policy Quarterly, 15(2): 192–210.
16.
BlaisA.1988. “The Classification of Electoral Systems.” European Journal of Political Research, 16: 99–110.
17.
BlaisA., and DobrzynskaA.. 1998. “Turnout in Electoral Democracies.” European Journal of Political Research, 33: 239–261.
18.
BlaisA., DobrzynskaA., and LoewenP.. 2007. “Potential Impacts of Extended Advance Voting on Voter Turnout.” Working Paper Series, September, Elections Canada, Quebec,1–43.
19.
BochslerD.2010. “Can Internet Voting Increase Political Participation? Remote Electronic Voting and Turnout in the Estonian 2007 Parliamentary Elections.” Prepared for presentation at the Internet and Voting Conference, Fiesole, June. 3–4.
20.
BruterM., and HarrisonS.. 2017. “Understanding the Emotional Act of Voting.” Nature Human Behaviour, 1: 1–3.
21.
BurdenB. C., CanonD. T., MayerK. R., and MoynihanD. P.. 2014. “Election Laws, Mobilization, and Turnout: The Unanticipated Consequences of Election Reform.” American Journal of Political Science, 58(1): 95–109.
22.
CarmanC., MitchellJ., and JohnsR.. 2008. “The Unfortunate Natural Experiment in Ballot Design: The Scottish Parliamentary Elections of 2007.” Electoral Studies, 27(3): 442–459.
23.
ChoiH., MerriënboerJ. J. G. van, and PaasF.. 2014. “Effects of the Physical Environment on Cognitive Load and Learning: Towards a New Model of Cognitive Load.” Educational Psychology Review, 26(2): 225–244.
24.
CohenM.2018. “A Dynamic Model of the Invalid Vote: How a Changing Candidate Menu Shapes Null Voting Behaviour.” Electoral Studies, 53: 111–121.
25.
ColemanS.2013. How Voters Feel. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
26.
Colmar Brunton. 2019. Victorian Electoral Commission—Evaluation of Services at the 24 November Victorian State Election. April 18.
27.
Community Development and Justice Standing Committee (CDJSC). 2018. 2017 WA State Election: Maintaining Confidence in Our Electoral Process. Report No. 2, February. Parliament of Western Australia.
28.
DerakshanN., and EysenckM. W.. 2009. “Anxiety, Processing Efficiency, and Cognitive Performance: New Developments from Attentional Control Theory.” European Psychologist, 14(2): 168–176.
29.
DriscollA., and NelsonM. J.. 2014. “Ignorance or Opposition? Blank and Spoiled Votes in Low-Information, Highly Politicized Environments.” Political Research Quarterly, 67(3): 547–561.
30.
DriskellJ. E., MullenB., JohnsonC., HughesS., and BatchelorC.. 1992. Development of Quantitative Specifications for Simulating the Stress Environment, Report No. AL-TR-1991-0109, Wright-Patterson AFB, Armstrong Laboratory, Ohio.
31.
Elections ACT. 2017. Report on the ACT Legislative Assembly Election 2016. Canberra: Government of ACT.
32.
Election Matters Committee (ECM). 2020. Inquiry into the Conduct of the 2018 Victorian State Election. Victorian Government Printer.
33.
FatkeM., and HeinsohnT.. 2017. “Invalid Voting in German Constituencies.” German Politics, 26(2): 273–291.
34.
FinseraasHenning, and VernbyKåre. 2014. “A Mixed Blessing for the Left? Early Voting, Turnout and Election Outcomes in Norway.” Electoral Studies, 33: 278–291.
35.
FornosC. A., PowerT. J., and GarandJ. C.. 2004. “Explaining Voter Turnout in Latin America, 1980 to 2000.” Comparative Political Studies, 37: 909–940.
36.
FranklinM.1999. “Electoral Engineering and Cross-National Turn-Out Differences: What Role for Compulsory Voting?” British Journal of Political Science, 29(1): 205–216.
37.
GalatasS.2008. “‘None of the Above?’ Casting Blank Ballots in Ontario Provincial Elections.” Politics & Policy, 36(3): 448–73.
38.
GarnettH.2019. “Early Voting: Comparing Canada, Finland, Germany, and Switzerland.” Election Law Journal, 18(2): 116–131.
39.
GoodmanN., and StokesL. C.. 2018. “Reducing the Cost of Voting: An Evaluation of Internet Voting's Effect on Turnout.” British Journal of Political Science, 50: 1155–1167.
40.
GronkeP., Galanes-RosenbaumE., and MillerP. A.. 2007. “Early Voting and Turnout.” PS: Political Science & Politics, 40(4): 639–645.
41.
GronkeP., Galanes-RosenbaumE., MillerP. A., and ToffeyD.. 2008. “Convenience Voting.” Annual Review of Political Science, 11: 437–455.
42.
HasherL., ZacksR., and MayC.. 1999. “Inhibitory Control, Circadian Arousal and Age.” In Attention and Performance XVII, eds. GopherD., and KoriatA., 653–675. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
43.
HerrnsonP., HanmerMichael J., and KohHo Youn. 2019. “Mobilization Around New Convenience Voting Methods: A Field Experiment to Encourage Voting by Mail with a Downloadable Ballot and Early Voting.” Political Behavior, 41: 871–895.
44.
HillL., and YoungS.. 2007. “Protest or Error? Informal Voting and Compulsory Voting.” Australian Journal of Political Science, 42(3): 515–521.
45.
HillL., and YoungS.. 2009. “Uncounted Votes: Informal Voting in the House of Representatives as a Marker of Political Exclusion in Australia.” Australian Journal of Politics and History, 55(1): 64–79.
HoogheM., MarienS., and PauwelsT.. 2011. “Where Do Distrusting Voters Turn to If There Is No Viable Exit of Voice Option? The Impact of Political Trust on Electoral Behaviour in the Belgian Regional Elections of June 2009.” Government and Opposition, 46(2): 245–73.
Joaquim R.C. Ribeiro, and FerreiraP.. 2010. “Improving Remote Voting Security with CodeVoting.” In Towards Trustworthy Elections. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, eds. ChaumD.et al., 310–329. Heidelberg: Springer.
50.
KarpJ., and BanducciS.. 2001. “Absentee Voting, Mobilization, and Participation.” American Politics Research, 29(2): 183–195.
51.
KarpJ., and BanducciS.. 2008. “Political Efficacy and Participation in Twenty-Seven Democracies: How Electoral Systems Shape Political Behavior.” British Journal of Political Science, 38(2): 311–334.
52.
KellyN.2012. Directions in Australian Electoral Reform: Professionalism and Partisanship in Electoral Management. Canberra: ANU Press.
53.
KimballD. C., and KropfM.. 2005. “Ballot Design and Unrecorded Votes on Paper-Based Ballots.” Public Opinion Quarterly, 69(4): 508–529.
54.
KohnN. A.2008. “Cognitive Impairment and the Right to Vote: Rethinking the Meaning of Accessible Elections.” Canadian Journal of Elder Law, 1(1): 29–52.
55.
KontorovichE., and McGinnisJ.. 2014. “The Case Against Early Voting.” Politico Magazine. January28.
56.
KoubaK., and LysekJ.. 2016. “Institutional Determinants of Invalid Voting in Post-Communist Europe and Latin America.” Electoral Studies, 41: 92–104.
57.
KoubaK., and LysekJ.. 2019. “What Affects Invalid Voting? A Review and Meta-Analysis.” Government and Opposition, 54(4): 745–775.
58.
LagoI., and BlaisA.. 2019. “Early Voting and Satisfaction with Vote Choice.” Representation, 55(2): 225–233.
59.
LaingM., MiragliottaN., and Thornton-Smith.P.2018. A Review of Convenience Voting in the State of Victoria. Commissioned report prepared for the Electoral Research Regulation Network, Victoria, Australia.
60.
LeeY., and BrandJ. L.. 2010. “Can Personal Control over the Physical Environment Ease Distractions in Office Workplaces?” Ergonomics, 53(3): 324–335.
61.
MackerrasM., and McAllisterI.. 1999. “Compulsory Voting, Party Stability and Electoral Advantage in Australia.” Electoral Studies, 18(2): 217–233.
62.
MaglebyD.1987. “Participation in Mail Ballot Elections.” Western Political Quarterly, 41: 79–91.
63.
MarcusG., and MackuenM.. 1993. “Anxiety, Enthusiasm, and the Vote: The Emotional Underpinnings of Learning and Involvement During Presidential Campaigns.” American Political Science Review, 87(3): 672–685.
64.
Martinez i ComaF. and A. Werner.2019. “Compulsory Voting and Ethnic Diversity Increase Invalid Voting While Corruption Does Not: An Analysis of 417 Parliamentary Elections in 73 Countries.” Democratization, 26(2): 288–308.
65.
McAllisterI.1986. “Compulsory Voting: Turnout and Party Advantage in Australia.” Politics, 21: 89–93.
66.
McAllisterI., and MakkaiT.. 1993. “Institutions, Society or Protest? Explaining Invalid Votes in Australian Elections.” Electoral Studies, 12(1): 23–40.
67.
McAllisterI., and MullerD.. 2018. “Early Voting, Election Campaigning and Party Advantage in Australia.” Electoral Studies, 52: 103–110.
68.
McDermottR.2002. “Experimental Methods in Political Science.” Annual Review of Political Science, 5(1): 31–61.
69.
McSweeneyD.2011. “Early Voting and Informed Voters in America.” Parliamentary Affairs, 64(3): 552–563.
70.
MercurioB.2002. “Overhauling Australian Democracy: The Benefits and Burdens of Internet Voting.” University of Tasmania Law Review, 21(2): 23–63.
71.
NeimanJ., GiuseffiK., SmithK., FrenchJ., Waismel-ManorI., and HibbingJ.. 2015. “Voting at Home Is Associated with Lower Cortisol Than Voting at the Polls.” PLoS One, 10(9): 1–9.
72.
NordlingerG.2003. “Early Voting: How It Is Changing Campaign Strategies, Timing and Costs.” Campaigns & Elections, 24(7): 27–29.
73.
OrrG.2004. “The Ritual and Aesthetic in Electoral Law.” Federal Law Review, 32: 425–450.
74.
OrrG.2014. Convenience voting: The end of election day?. Alternative Law Journal, 39(3): 151–155.
75.
OrrG.2016. Ritual and Rhythm in Electoral Systems: A Comparative Legal Account. New York, NY: Routledge.
76.
OrrG.2019. The Law of Politics: Elections, Parties and Money in Australia, 2nd edition. Alexandria, NSW: Federation Press.
77.
PattersonS., and CaldieraG.. 1985. “Mailing the Vote: Correlates and Consequences of Absentee Voting.” American Journal of Political Science, 29(4): 766–788.
78.
PachónM., CarrollR., and BarragánH.. 2017. “Ballot Design and Invalid Votes: Evidence from Colombia.” Electoral Studies, 48: 98–110.
79.
Parliament of Victoria. 2017. Inquiry into the Electronic Voting. Prepared by the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters (May). Melbourne: Victorian Government Printer.
80.
PereiraP. T., and SilvaJ. A. e. 2009. “Citizens' Freedom to Choose Representatives: Ballot Structure, Proportionality, and “Fragmented” Parliaments.” Electoral Studies, 28(1): 101–110.
81.
PowerT., and GarandJ.. 2007. “Determinants of Invalid Voting in Latin America.” Electoral Studies, 26(2): 432–444.
82.
PowerT., and RobertsT.. 1995. “Compulsory Voting, Invalid Ballots, and Abstention in Brazil.” Political Research Quarterly, 48: 795–826.
83.
QvortrupM.2005. ‘First past the postman: Voting by mail in comparative perspective’, The Political Quarterly, 76(3): 414–419.
ReaderN.2015. “Who Votes Early in Victoria? Assessing the Demographic Correlates of Early Voting in Person at Victorian State Elections, 2006 to 2014.” Electoral Regulation Research Network/Democratic Audit of Australia Joint Working Paper Series, No. 31 (1–21).
86.
ReedyJ., and GastilJ.. 2015. “Deliberating While Voting: The Antecedents, Dynamics, and Consequences of Talking While Completing Ballots in Two Vote-by-Mail States.” Journal of Public Deliberation, 11(1): 1–25.
87.
ReillyS., and UlbigS. G.. 2018. The Resilient Voter: Stressful Polling Places and Voting Behaviour. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
88.
ReynoldsA., and SteenbergenM.. 2006. “How the World Votes: The Political Consequences of Ballot Design, Innovation and Manipulation.” Electoral Studies, 25(3): 570–598.
89.
RicheyS.2005. “Who Votes Alone? The Impact of Voting by Mail on Political Discussion.” Australian Journal of Political Science, 40(3): 435–442.
90.
SheppardJ., and BeauregardK.. 2018. “Early Voting in Australia: The Costs and Benefits of Convenience.” Political Science, 70(2): 117–134.
91.
SmithR.2016. “Confidence in Paper-based and Electronic Voting Channels: Evidence from Australia.” Australian Journal of Political Science, 51(1): 68–85.
92.
SmithR., BrightwellI., BucklandR., DrumM., HarbordJ., McIverA., MillsS., MorganC., RadcliffeM., and Wen.R.2018. Implications of Changes to Voting Channels in Australia. Commission report prepared for the Electoral Research Regulation Network, Victoria, Australia.
93.
SteifboldR. P.1965. The Significance of Void Ballots in West German Elections.”. American Political Science Review, 59: 391–407.
94.
ThompsonD. F.2004. “Election Time: Normative Implications of Temporal Properties of the Electoral Process in the United States.” American Political Science Review, 98(1): 51–63.
95.
UgglaF.2008. “Incompetence, Alienation, or Calculation? Explaining Levels of Invalid Ballots and Extra-Parliamentary Votes.” Comparative Political Studies, 41(8): 1141–1164.
96.
ValentinoN., HutchingsV., BanksA., and DavisA.. 2008. “Is a Worried Citizen a Good Citizen? Emotions, Political Information Seeking, and Learning via the Internet.” Political Psychology, 29(2): 247–273.
97.
VasilevM. R., KirkbyJ. A., and AngeleB.. 2018. “Auditory Distraction During Reading: A Bayesian Meta-Analysis of a Continuing Controversy.” Perspectives on Psychological Science, 13(5): 567–597.
Victorian Electoral Commission (VEC). 2015. Evaluation of Services at the 29 November 2014 Victorian State Election. Prepared by Colmar Brunton Social Research, South Melbourne, Victoria.
WeeksJ. C., and HasherL.. 2014. “The Disruptive—and Beneficial—Effects of Distraction on Older Adults' Cognitive Performance.” Frontiers in Psychology, 5(133): 1–6.
102.
WeissJ. A., and TschirhartM.. 1994. “Public Information Campaigns as Policy Instruments,” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 13(1): 82–119.
103.
Western Australian Electoral Commission (WAEC). 2017a. 2017 State General Election Report. Perth: Government of Western Australia.
104.
Western Australian Electoral Commission (WAEC). 2017b. 2017 State General Election Results and Statistics. Perth: Government of Western Australia.
105.
Western Australian Electoral Commission (WAEC). 2017c. Report on the Western Australian Electoral Commission Survey of Voters—State General Election 2017. Report prepared by Perth Market Research (May), Fremantle: Australia.
106.
YoungS., and HillL.. 2009. “Uncounted Votes: Informal Voting in the House of Representatives as a Marker of Political Exclusion in Australia.” Australian Journal of Politics and History, 55(1): 64–79.
107.
Waismel-ManorI., IferganeG., and CohenH.. 2011. “When Endocrinology and Democracy Collide: Emotions, Cortisol and Voting at National Elections.” European Neuropsychopharmacology, 21(11): 789–795.
108.
ZulfikarpasicA.2001. “The Blank Vote: Civic Abstention or Political Expression?” (in French). Revue Française de Science Politique, 51: 247–268.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
