Deliberative democrats tend to be skeptical about elections as mechanisms for deliberation, and with good reason. But the reality is that elections will likely persist as the primary means by which we make decisions–indirectly–about how we are governed. By contrast, deliberative democracy will likely continue in a supplementary role because of its feasibility problem, something that many pragmatic deliberative democrats now accept. It therefore pays to reflect on what kinds of elections best serve deliberative ideals and sensibilities.
Although some deliberative democrats have rejected the idea of compulsory voting, I argue that they should be more open to the idea due to the fact that compulsory voting elections are more inclusive and less subject to distortions of unequal political power than are voluntary ones. They are also better able to reflect the objective interests of voters and to protect the conditions necessary for deliberation to occur.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbrahamH.J.1955. “‘Of Apathy and Idiots' and Compulsory Voting,” Social Education, January1955: 27–30.
2.
ArnoldD.R.1990. The Logic of Congressional Action (New Haven: Yale University Press.
3.
BenhabibS.1996. “Towards a Deliberative Model of Democratic Legitimacy,” in BenhabibS. (ed.), Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
4.
BennettS.E. and ResnickD.1990. “The Implications of Nonvoting for Democracy in the United States,” American Journal of Political Science, 34 (3): 771–802.
5.
BeramendiP. and AndersonC.J.2008. Democracy, Inequality and Representation, New York, Russell Sage Foundation.
6.
BirchS.2009. Full Participation: A Comparative Study of Compulsory Voting, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
7.
BlaisA.2010. “Political Participation,” in LeDucL., NiemiR.G., and NorrisP. (eds.), Comparing Democracies 3: Elections and Voting in the 21st Century, London: Sage: 165–183.
8.
BlaisA., GidengilE., NevitteN., and NadeauR.2004. “Where Does Turnout Decline Come From?,” European Journal of Political Research, 43(2): 221–236.
9.
BohmanJ.1998. “Survey Article: The Coming of Age of Deliberative Democracy,” Journal of Political Philosophy, 6(4): 400–425.
10.
BradyH.E., VerbaS., and SchlozmanK.1995. “Beyond SES: A Resource Model of Political Participation,” American Political Science Review, 89(2) 271–94.
11.
BrennanJ.2009. “Polluting the Polls: When Citizens Should Not Vote,” Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 87(4): 535–549.
12.
BrodyR. and PageB.1973. “Indifference, Alienation and Rational Decisions,” Public Choice, 15: 1–17.
13.
BurnhamW.D.1987. “The Turnout Problem,” in RichlyJ. (ed.), Elections American Style, Washington D.C.: Brookings Institution.
14.
ButtonJ.W.1989. Blacks and Social Change: Impact of the Civil Rights Movement in Southern Communities, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
15.
ChambersS.2003. “Deliberative Democratic Theory,” Annual Review of Political Science, 6: 307–26.
16.
ChongA. and OliveraM.2005. “On Compulsory Voting and Income Inequality in a Cross-Section of Countries,” Inter-American Development Bank Research Department Working Paper # 533, May2005.
17.
CohenJ.1998. “Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy,” in HamlinA. and PettitP. (eds.), The Good Polity, Oxford: Blackwell.
18.
CohenJ.2009. Philosophy, Politics, Democracy: Selected Essays, New Haven: Harvard University Press.
19.
CooreyP.2005. “Few Back Minchin on Voluntary Vote,” Advertiser (Adelaide), May2, 21.
20.
DahlR.A.1971. After the Revolution: Authority in a Good Society, New Haven: Yale University Press.
21.
DahlR.1979. “Procedural Democracy,” in LaslettP. and FishkinJ. (eds.), Philosophy, Politics and Society, 5th Series, New Haven: Yale University Press.
DowdingK., GoodinR., and PatemanC.2004. “Introduction,” in DowdingK., GoodinR., and PatemanC. (eds.), Justice and Democracy: Essays for Brian Barry, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
24.
DowdingK. and Van HeesM.2003. “The Construction of Rights,” American Political Science Review, 97(2): 281–293.
25.
DryzekJ.2000. Deliberative Democracy and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestations, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
26.
DryzekJ.2001. “Legitimacy and Economy in Deliberative Democracy,” Political Theory. 29(5): 651–699.
27.
ElsterJ.1998. “Deliberation and Constitution Making,” in ElsterJ. (ed.), Deliberative Democracy, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 97–122.
28.
FishkinJ.2009. When the People Speak: Deliberative Democracy and Public Consultation, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
29.
FowlerA.2013. “Electoral and Policy Consequences of Voter Turnout: Evidence from Compulsory Voting in Australia,” Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 8(2): 159–182.
30.
FreemanS.2000. “Deliberative Democracy: A Sympathetic Comment,” Philosophy and Public Affairs, 29(4): 371–418.
31.
GallegoA.2010. “Understanding Unequal Turnout: Education and Voting in Comparative Perspective,” Electoral Studies, 29(2): 239–248.
32.
GansC.B.1978. “The Empty Ballot Box: Reflections on Nonvoters in America,” Public Opinion, 1: 54–57.
33.
GershtensonJ.2003. “Mobilization Strategies of the Democrats and Republicans, 1956–2000,” Political Research Quarterly, 56: 293–308.
34.
GoodinR.2000. “Democratic Deliberation Within,” Philosophy and Public Affairs, 29: 81–109.
35.
GriffinJ.D. and NewmanB.2005. “Are Voters Better Represented?,” Journal of Politics, 67(4): 1206–1227.
36.
GrönlundK. and SetäläM.2007. “Political Trust, Satisfaction and Voter Turnout,” Comparative European Politics, 5(4): 400–422.
37.
GutmannA. and ThompsonD.1996. Democracy and Disagreement, Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
38.
HasenR.1996. “Voting Without Law,” Pennsylvania Law Review, 144(5): 2135–2179.
39.
HennM., WeinsteinM., and ForrestS.2005. “Uninterested Youth? Young People's Attitudes towards Party Politics in Britain,” Political Studies, 53(4): 556–578.
40.
HicksA.M. and SwankD.H.1992. “Politics, Institutions, and Welfare Spending in Industrialized Countries, 1960–82,” American Political Science Review, 86: 658–74.
41.
HightonB. and WolfingerR.E.2001. “The Political Implications of Higher Turnout,” British Journal of Political Science, 31(1): 179–223.
42.
HillK.Q., LeighleyJ.E., and Hinton-AndersonA.1995. “Lower-class Mobilization and Policy Linkage in the US States,” American Journal of Political Science, 39(1): 75–86.
43.
HillK.Q. and LeighleyJ.E.1992. “The Policy Consequences of Class Bias in State Electorates,” American Journal of Political Science, 36(2): 351–65.
44.
HillL.2002. “On the Reasonableness of Compelling Citizens to Vote: The Australian Case,” Political Studies, 50: 80–101.
45.
HillL.2002a. “Compulsory Voting: Residual Problems and Potential Solutions,” Australian Journal of Political Science, 37(3): 437–455.
46.
HillL.2010. “Public Acceptance of Compulsory Voting: Explaining the Australian Case,” Representation, 46(4): 425–438.
47.
HirczyW.1994. “The Impact of Mandatory Voting Laws on Turnout: A Quasi-Experimental Approach,” Electoral Studies, 13(1): 64–76.
48.
HoD.E. and ImaiK.2008. “Estimating Causal Effects of Ballot Order from a Randomized Natural Experiment: The California Alphabet Lottery, 1978–2002,” Public Opinion Quarterly, 72(2): 216–40.
49.
HoogheM. and PelleriauxK.1998. “Compulsory Voting in Belgium: An Application of the Lijphart Thesis,” Electoral Studies, 17(4): 419–424.
50.
HughesC. and CostarB.2006. Limiting Democracy: The Erosion of Electoral Rights in Australia, Sydney: UNSW Press.
51.
IrwinG.1974. “Compulsory Voting Legislation: Impact on Voter Turnout in the Netherlands,” Comparative Political Studies, 7(3): 292–315.
52.
JackmanS.1999. “Non-compulsory voting in Australia?: What Surveys Can (and Can't) Tell Us,” Electoral Studies, 18(1), 29–48.
53.
JonesW.H.M.1954. “In Defence of Apathy: Some Doubts on the Duty to Vote,” Political Studies, 2(1): 25–37.
KeechW.1968. The Impact of Negro Voting: The Role of the Vote in the Quest for Equality, Chicago: Rand McNally.
56.
KelsenH.1955. “Foundations of Democracy,” Ethics, 66: 1–101.
57.
KenworthyL. and PontussonJ.2005. “Rising Inequality and the Politics of Redistribution in Affluent Countries,” Perspectives on Politics, 3(3): 449–71.
58.
KingA. and LeighA.2009. “Are Ballot Order Effects Heterogeneous?,” Social Science Quarterly, 90(1): 71–87.
59.
KnightJ. and JohnsonJ.1997. “What Sort of Equality Does Deliberative Democracy Require?,” in BohmanJ. and RehgW. (eds.), Deliberative Democracy, Cambridge: MIT Press
60.
LeverA.2010. “Compulsory Voting: A Critical Perspective,” British Journal of Political Science, 40(4), 897–915.
61.
LijphartA.1997. “Unequal Participation: Democracy's Unresolved Dilemma,” American Political Science Review, 19: 1–14.
62.
LoewenP.J., MilnerH., and HicksB.M.2008. “Does Compulsory Voting Lead to More Informed and Engaged Citizens? An Experimental Test,” Canadian Journal of Political Science, 41(3): 655–672.
63.
LomaskyL, and BrennanG., 2000. “Is There a Duty to Vote?,” Social Philosophy and Policy, 17(1): 62–86.
64.
LouthJ. and HillL.2005. “Compulsory Voting in Australia: Turnout With and Without It,” Australian Review of Public Affairs, 6(1): 25–37.
65.
LundellK.2012. “Compulsory Voting, Civic Participation and Political Trust. Representation,” 48(2): 221–234.
66.
McAllisterI., MackerrasM., and BoldistonC.1997. Australian Political Facts, 2nd ed., South Melbourne: Macmillan.
MahlerV. A.2008. “Electoral Turnout and Income Redistribution by the State: A Cross-National Analysis of the Developed Democracies,” European Journal of Political Research, 47, 161–183.
69.
ManinB.1987. “On Legitimacy and Political Deliberation,” Political Theory, 15: 133–171.
70.
MartinP.S.2003. “Voting's Rewards: Voter Turnout, Attentive Publics and Congressional Allocation of Federal Money,” American Journal of Political Science, 47(1): 110–27.
71.
MillerJ.M. and KrosnickJ.A.1998. “The Impact of Candidate Name Order on Election Outcomes,” Public Opinion Quarterly, 62 (3): 291–330.
72.
MuellerD.C. and StratmannT.2003. “The Economic Effects of Democratic Participation,” Journal of Public Economics, 87(9–10): 2129–55.
73.
NagelJ.H. and McNultyJ.E., 1996. “Partisan Effects of Voter Turnout in Senatorial and Gubernatorial Elections,” American Political Science Review, 90: 780–793.
74.
NownesA.J.1992. “Primaries, General Elections, and Voter Turnout: A Multinomial Logit Model of the Decision to Vote,” American Politics Quarterly, 20: 205–226.
75.
OrrG., MercurioB., and WilliamsG.2003. “The Australian Electoral Tradition,” in OrrG., MercurioB., and WilliamsG. (eds.), Realising Democracy: Electoral Law in Australia, Leichhardt: The Federation Press.
76.
OrrG.2004. Australian Electoral Systems-How Well Do They Serve Political Equality?, Canberra: Democratic Audit of Australia.
77.
O'TooleF. and StroblE.1995. “Compulsory Voting and Government Spending,” Economics and Politics, 7(3): 271–280.
78.
PammetJ.H. and Le DucL.2003. Explaining the Turnout Decline in Canadian Federal Elections: A New Survey of Non-Voters, Ottawa: Elections Canada.
79.
PanagopoulosC.2008. “The Calculus of Voting in Compulsory Voting Systems,” Political Behaviour, 30(4): 455–467.
80.
ParkinsonJ.2003. “Legitimacy Problems in Deliberative Democracy,” Political Studies, 51(1): 180–196.
81.
PetrocikJ.1987. “Voter Turnout and Electoral Preferences: The Anomalous Reagan Elections,” in SchlozmanK. (ed.), Elections in American, New York: Allen and Unwin.
82.
PettersenP.A., 1989. “Comparing Non-Voters in the USA and Norway,” European Journal of Political Research, 17(3): 351–9.
83.
RagsdaleL. and RuskJ.G.1993. “Who are Nonvoters? Profiles from the 1990 Senate Elections,” American Journal of Political Science, 37(3): 721–746.
84.
RinquistE.J., HillK.Q., LeighleyJ.E., and Hinton-AndersonA.1997. “Lower-class Mobilization and Policy Linkage in the U.S. States: A Correction,” American Journal of Political Science, 41(1): 339–344.
85.
RosemaM.2007. “Low Turnout: Threat to Democracy or Blessing in Disguise? Consequences of Citizens' Varying Tendencies to Vote,” Electoral Studies, 26(3): 612–623.
SaundersB.2010. “Increasing Turnout: A Compelling Case?,” Politics, 30(1): 70–77.
88.
SalisburyR.H.1975. “Research on Political Participation,” American Journal of Political Science, 1(2): 323–41.
89.
SaundersB.2012. “The Democratic Turnout ‘Problem,’” Political Studies, 60(2): 306–320.
90.
SelbP. and LachatR.2009. “The More, the Better? Counterfactual Evidence on the Effect of Compulsory Voting on the Consistency of Party Choice,” European Journal of Political Research, 48(5): 573–597.
91.
ShinemanV.A.2010. “Compulsory Voting as Compulsory Balloting: How Mandatory Balloting Laws Increase Informed Voting without Increasing Uninformed Voting,” Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, 2010, Toronto.
92.
ShinemanV.A.2009. “Isolating the Effects of Compulsory Voting on Political Sophistication: Exploiting Intra-national Variation in Mandatory Voting Laws Across the Austrian Provinces,” Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, 2009, Chicago, IL.
93.
SiaroffA. and MererJ.2002. “Parliamentary Election Turnout in Europe since 1990,” Political Studies, 50(5): 916–927.
94.
SinghS.P.2011. “How Compelling Is Compulsory Voting? A Multilevel Analysis of Turnout,” Political Behavior, 33(1): 95–111.
95.
SouthwellP.L.2008. “The Effect of Political Alienation on Voter Turnout, 1964–2000,” Journal of Political and Military Sociology, 36(1): 131–45.
96.
StudlarD.T. and WelchS.1986. “The Policy Opinions of British Non-Voters: A Research Note,” European Journal of Political Research, 14: 139–148.
97.
TexeiraR.A., 1992. The Disappearing American Voter, Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.
98.
TwomeyA.2013. “Deliberative Democracy, Compulsory Voting and the Will of the People,” Sydney Law School Legal Studies Research Paper No. 13/32<http://ssrn.com/abstract=2248385>. Consulted June6, 2013.
99.
VerbaS.2003. “Would the Dream of Political Equality Turn out to Be a Nightmare?,” Perspectives on Politics, 1(4): 663–679.
100.
VerbaS., SchlozmanK.L., BradyH., and NieN.H.1993. “Citizen Activity: Who Participates? What Do They Say?,” American Political Science Review, 87(2): 303–318.
101.
VerbaS. and NieN.H.1972. Participation in America: Political Democracy and Social Equality, New York: Harper and Row.
102.
WallA., AyoubA., DundanC.W., RukambeJ., and StainoS.2006. Electoral Management Design: The International IDEA Handbook. Stockholm: International IDEA.
103.
WattenbergM.2002. Where Have All the Voters Gone?, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
104.
WattenbergM.2003. “Why Don't More Americans Vote?,” Boston Globe, September21, 2003.
105.
WattenbergM.2008. Is Voting for Young People?. New York: Pearson.
106.
WielhouwerP.W.1995. “Strategic Canvassing by the Political Parties,” American Review of Politics, 16: 213–238.
107.
WielhouwerP.W.2000, “Releasing the Fetters: Parties and Mobilization of the African-American Electorate,” Journal of Politics, 62: 206–222.
108.
YoungS. and HillL.2009. “Uncounted Votes: Informal Voting in the House of Representatives as a Marker of Political Exclusion in Australia,” Australian Journal of History and Politics, 55(1): 64–79.
