Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2016-06
Underconnected,But Not Broken? Dynamic Functional Connectivity MRI Shows Underconnectivity in Autism Is Linked to Increased Intra-Individual Variability Across Time
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is characterized by core sociocommunicative impairments. Atypical intrinsic functional connectivity (iFC) has been reported in numerous studies of ASD. A majority of findings has indicated long-distance underconnectivity. However, fMRI studies have thus far exclusively examined static iFC across several minutes of scanning. We examined temporal variability of iFC, using sliding window analyses in selected high-quality (low-motion) consortium datasets from 76 ASD and 76 matched typically developing (TD) participants (Study 1) and in-house data from 32 ASD and 32 TD participants. Mean iFC and standard deviation of the sliding window correlation (SD-iFC) were computed for regions of interest (ROIs) from default mode and salience networks, as well as amygdala and thalamus. In both studies, ROI pairings with significant underconnectivity (ASD<TD) were identified. Mediation analyses showed that decreased mean iFC in the ASD groups was significantly affected by increased SD-iFC. Our study is the first to identify temporal variability across time as a significant contributing factor to the common finding of static underconnectivity in ASD. Since peak connectivity across time was not significantly reduced in ASD, static underconnectivity findings may have to be reinterpreted, suggesting that connections are not actually “broken” in ASD, but subject to greater intra-individual variability across time. Our findings indicate the need for dynamic approaches to iFC in clinical functional connectivity MRI (fcMRI) investigations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbbottAE, NairA, KeownCL, DatkoMC, JahediA, FishmanI, et al.2015. Patterns of atypical functional connectivity and behavioral links in autism differ between default, salience, and executive networks. Cerebral Cortex. DOI: 10.1093/cercor/bhv191.
2.
AbramsDA, LynchCJ, ChengKM, PhillipsJ, SupekarK, RyaliS, et al.2013. Underconnectivity between voice-selective cortex and reward circuitry in children with autism. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 110:12060–12065.
3.
AllenEA, DamarajuE, PlisSM, ErhardtEB, EicheleT, CalhounVD. 2014. Tracking whole-brain connectivity dynamics in the resting state. Cereb Cortex, 24:663–676.
4.
AnticevicA, RepovsG, ShulmanGL, BarchDM. 2010. When less is more: TPJ and default network deactivation during encoding predicts working memory performance. Neuroimage, 49:2638–2648.
5.
AssafM, JagannathanK, CalhounVD, MillerL, StevensMC, SahlR, et al.2010. Abnormal functional connectivity of default mode sub-networks in autism spectrum disorder patients. Neuroimage, 53:247–256.
6.
BucknerRL, KrienenFM, YeoBT. 2013. Opportunities and limitations of intrinsic functional connectivity MRI. Nat Neurosci, 16:832–837.
CDC. 2015. Estimated prevalence of autism and other developmental disabilities following questionnaire changes in the 2014 National Health Interview Survey. National Health Statistics Reports, 87:1–20.
9.
CerlianiL, MennesM, ThomasRM, Di MartinoA, ThiouxM, KeysersC. 2015. Increased functional connectivity between subcortical and cortical resting-state networks in autism spectrum disorder. JAMA Psychiatry, 72:767–777.
10.
ChangC, GloverGH. 2010. Time-frequency dynamics of resting-state brain connectivity measured with fMRI. Neuroimage, 50:81–98.
ChangC, MetzgerCD, GloverGH, DuynJH, HeinzeHJ, WalterM. 2013b. Association between heart rate variability and fluctuations in resting-state functional connectivity. Neuroimage, 68:93–104.
13.
CoxRW. 1996. AFNI: software for analysis and visualization of functional magnetic resonance neuroimages. Comput Biomed, 29:162–173.
14.
Di MartinoA, KellyC, GrzadzinskiR, ZuoXN, MennesM, MairenaMA, et al.2011. Aberrant striatal functional connectivity in children with autism. Biol Psychiatry, 69:847–856.
15.
Di MartinoA, RossK, UddinLQ, SklarAB, CastellanosFX, MilhamMP. 2009. Functional brain correlates of social and nonsocial processes in autism spectrum disorders: an activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis. Biol Psychiatry, 65:63–74.
16.
Di MartinoA, YanCG, LiQ, DenioE, CastellanosFX, AlaertsK, et al.2014. The autism brain imaging data exchange: towards a large-scale evaluation of the intrinsic brain architecture in autism. Mol Psychiatry, 19:659–667.
Doyle-ThomasKA, LeeW, FosterNE, TryfonA, OuimetT, HydeKL, et al.2015. Atypical functional brain connectivity during rest in autism spectrum disorders. Ann Neurol, 77:866–876.
19.
EbischSJ, GalleseV, WillemsRM, MantiniD, GroenWB, RomaniGL, et al.2011. Altered intrinsic functional connectivity of anterior and posterior insula regions in high-functioning participants with autism spectrum disorder. Hum Brain Mapp, 32:1013–1028.
20.
FishmanI, DatkoM, CabreraY, CarperRA, MüllerR-A. 2015. Reduced integration and differentiation of the imitation network in autism: a combined functional connectivity magnetic resonance imaging and diffusion-weighted imaging study. Ann Neurol, 78:958–969.
21.
FishmanI, KeownCL, LincolnAJ, PinedaJA, MüllerR-A. 2014. Atypical cross talk between mentalizing and mirror neuron networks in autism spectrum disorder. JAMA Psychiatry, 71:751–760.
22.
FoxMD, SnyderAZ, VincentJL, RaichleME. 2007. Intrinsic fluctuations within cortical systems account for intertrial variability in human behavior. Neuron, 56:171–184.
23.
FoxMD, SnyderAZ, ZacksJM, RaichleME. 2006. Coherent spontaneous activity accounts for trial-to-trial variability in human evoked brain responses. Nat Neurosci, 9:23–25.
GeurtsHM, GrasmanRP, VerteS, OosterlaanJ, RoeyersH, van KammenSM, et al.2008. Intra-individual variability in ADHD, autism spectrum disorders and Tourette's syndrome. Neuropsychologia, 46:3030–3041.
26.
GottsSJ, SimmonsWK, MilburyLA, WallaceGL, CoxRW, MartinA. 2012. Fractionation of social brain circuits in autism spectrum disorders. Brain, 135(Pt 9):2711–2725.
27.
GrelottiDJ, KlinAJ, GauthierI, SkudlarskiP, CohenDJ, GoreJC, et al.2005. fMRI activation of the fusiform gyrus and amygdala to cartoon characters but not to faces in a boy with autism. Neuropsychologia, 43:373–385.
28.
HaighSM, HeegerDJ, DinsteinI, MinshewN, BehrmannM. 2014. Cortical variability in the sensory-evoked response in autism. J Autism Dev Disord, 45:1176–1190.
HardanAY, MinshewNJ, MelhemNM, SrihariS, JoB, BansalR, et al.2008. An MRI and proton spectroscopy study of the thalamus in children with autism. Psychiatry Res, 163:97–105.
31.
HindsO, ThompsonTW, GhoshS, YooJJ, Whitfield-GabrieliS, TriantafyllouC, et al.2013. Roles of default-mode network and supplementary motor area in human vigilance performance: evidence from real-time fMRI. J Neurophysiol, 109:1250–1258.
32.
HoneyCJ, SpornsO, CammounL, GigandetX, ThiranJP, MeuliR, et al.2009. Predicting human resting-state functional connectivity from structural connectivity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 106:2035–2040.
33.
HughesJR. 2007. Autism: the first firm finding = underconnectivity?. Epilepsy Behav, 11:20–24.
34.
HutchisonRM, WomelsdorfT, AllenEA, BandettiniPA, CalhounVD, CorbettaM, et al.2013. Dynamic functional connectivity: promise, issues, and interpretations. Neuroimage, 80:360–378.
35.
JannK, FederspielA, GiezendannerS, AndreottiJ, KottlowM, DierksT, et al.2012. Linking brain connectivity across different time scales with electroencephalogram, functional magnetic resonance imaging, and diffusion tensor imaging. Brain Connect, 2:11–20.
36.
JoHJ, SaadZS, SimmonsWK, MilburyLA, CoxRW. 2010. Mapping sources of correlation in resting state FMRI, with artifact detection and removal. Neuroimage, 52:571–582.
37.
JollesDD, van BuchemMA, CroneEA, RomboutsSA. 2013. Functional brain connectivity at rest changes after working memory training. Hum Brain Mapp, 34:396–406.
38.
JustMA, CherkasskyVL, KellerTA, MinshewNJ. 2004. Cortical activation and synchronization during sentence comprehension in high-functioning autism: evidence of underconnectivity. Brain, 127(Pt 8):1811–1821.
39.
JustMA, KellerTA, MalaveVL, KanaRK, VarmaS. 2012. Autism as a neural systems disorder: a theory of frontal-posterior underconnectivity. Neurosci Biobehav Rev, 36:1292–1313.
40.
KanaRK, KellerTA, MinshewNJ, JustMA. 2007. Inhibitory control in high-functioning autism: decreased activation and underconnectivity in inhibition networks. Biol Psychiatry, 62:198–206.
KennedyDP, CourchesneE. 2008. The intrinsic functional organization of the brain is altered in autism. Neuroimage, 39:1877–1885.
43.
KhanAJ, NairA, KeownCL, DatkoMC, LincolnAJ, MüllerR-A. 2015. Cerebro-cerebellar resting state functional connectivity in children and adolescents with autism spectrum disorder. Biol Psychiatry, 78:625–634.
44.
KleinhansNM, RichardsT, JohnsonLC, WeaverKE, GreensonJ, DawsonG, et al.2011. fMRI evidence of neural abnormalities in the subcortical face processing system in ASD. Neuroimage, 54:697–704.
45.
KleinhansNM, RichardsT, SterlingL, StegbauerKC, MahurinR, JohnsonLC, et al.2008. Abnormal functional connectivity in autism spectrum disorders during face processing. Brain, 131(Pt 4):1000–1012.
46.
LaufsH, KrakowK, SterzerP, EgerE, BeyerleA, Salek-HaddadiA, et al.2003. Electroencephalographic signatures of attentional and cognitive default modes in spontaneous brain activity fluctuations at rest. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 100:11053–11058.
47.
LewisCM, BaldassarreA, CommitteriG, RomaniGL, CorbettaM. 2009. Learning sculpts the spontaneous activity of the resting human brain. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 106:17558–17563.
48.
LynchCJ, UddinLQ, SupekarK, KhouzamA, PhillipsJ, MenonV. 2013. Default mode network in childhood autism: posteromedial cortex heterogeneity and relationship with social deficits. Biol Psychiatry, 74:212–219.
49.
MacDonaldSW, NybergL, BackmanL. 2006. Intra-individual variability in behavior: links to brain structure, neurotransmission and neuronal activity. Trends Neurosci, 29:474–480.
50.
MacKinnonDP, FairchildAJ, FritzMS. 2007. Mediation analysis. Ann Rev Psychol, 58:593–614.
51.
MasonMF, NortonMI, Van HornJD, WegnerDM, GraftonST, MacraeCN. 2007. Wandering minds: the default network and stimulus-independent thought. Science, 315:393–395.
52.
MennesM, ZuoXN, KellyC, Di MartinoA, ZangYF, BiswalB, et al.2011. Linking inter-individual differences in neural activation and behavior to intrinsic brain dynamics. Neuroimage, 54:2950–2959.
53.
MilneE. 2011. Increased intra-participant variability in children with autistic spectrum disorders: evidence from single-trial analysis of evoked EEG. Front Psychol, 2:51.
54.
MonkCS, PeltierSJ, WigginsJL, WengSJ, CarrascoM, RisiS, et al.2009. Abnormalities of intrinsic functional connectivity in autism spectrum disorders. Neuroimage, 47:764–772.
55.
MüllerR-A, ShihP, KeehnB, DeyoeJR, LeydenKM, ShuklaDK. 2011. Underconnected, but how? A survey of functional connectivity MRI studies in autism spectrum disorders. Cerebral Cortex, 21:2233–2243.
56.
MurphyER, Foss-FeigJ, KenworthyL, GaillardWD, VaidyaCJ. 2012. Atypical functional connectivity of the amygdala in childhood autism spectrum disorders during spontaneous attention to eye-gaze. Autism Res Treat, 2012:652408.
57.
NairA, CarperRA, AbbottAE, ChenCP, SoldersS, NakutinS, et al.2015. Regional specificity of aberrant thalamocortical connectivity in autism. Hum Brain Mapp, 36:4497–4511.
58.
NairA, KeownCL, DatkoM, ShihP, KeehnB, MüllerRA. 2014. Impact of methodological variables on functional connectivity findings in autism spectrum disorders. Hum Brain Mapp, 35:4035–4048.
59.
NairA, TreiberJM, ShuklaDK, ShihP, MüllerR-A. 2013. Thalamocortical connectivity in autism spectrum disorder: a study of functional and anatomical connectivity. Brain, 136(Pt 6):1942–1955.
60.
OlafssonV, KunduP, WongEC, BandettiniPA, LiuTT. 2015. Enhanced identification of BOLD-like components with multi-echo simultaneous multi-slice (MESMS) fMRI and multi-echo ICA. Neuroimage, 112:43–51.
61.
PowerJD, BarnesKA, SnyderAZ, SchlaggarBL, PetersenSE. 2012. Spurious but systematic correlations in functional connectivity MRI networks arise from subject motion. NeuroImage, 59:2142–2154.
62.
PowerJD, MitraA, LaumannTO, SnyderAZ, SchlaggarBL, PetersenSE. 2014. Methods to detect, characterize, and remove motion artifact in resting state fMRI. NeuroImage, 84:320–341.
63.
PowerJD, SchlaggarBL, PetersenSE. 2015. Recent progress and outstanding issues in motion correction in resting state fMRI. Neuroimage, 105C:536–551.
64.
Rack-GomerAL, LiuTT. 2012. Caffeine increases the temporal variability of resting-state BOLD connectivity in the motor cortex. Neuroimage, 59:2994–3002.
65.
SadaghianiS, ScheeringaR, LehongreK, MorillonB, GiraudAL, KleinschmidtA. 2010. Intrinsic connectivity networks, alpha oscillations, and tonic alertness: a simultaneous electroencephalography/functional magnetic resonance imaging study. J Neurosci, 30:10243–10250.
66.
SatterthwaiteTD, ElliottMA, et al.2013. An improved framework for confound regression and filtering for control of motion artifact in the preprocessing of resting-state functional connectivity data. NeuroImage, 64:240–256.
67.
SchölvinckML, MaierA, YeFQ, DuynJH, LeopoldDA. 2010. Neural basis of global resting-state fMRI activity. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 107:10238–10243.
68.
SekhonJS. 2011. Multivariate and propensity score matching software with automated balance optimization: the matching package for R. J Stat Softw, 42:1–52.
69.
ShehzadZ, KellyAM, ReissPT, GeeDG, GotimerK, UddinLQ, et al.2009. The resting brain: unconstrained yet reliable. Cereb Cortex, 19:2209–2229.
70.
ShihP, KeehnB, OramJK, LeydenKM, KeownCL, MüllerR-A. 2011. Functional differentiation of posterior superior temporal sulcus in autism: a functional connectivity magnetic resonance imaging study. Biol Psychiatry, 70:270–277.
71.
SmithSM, JenkinsonM, WoolrichMW, BeckmannCF, BehrensTE, Johansen-BergH, et al.2004. Advances in functional and structural MR image analysis and implementation as FSL. NeuroImage, 23(Suppl. 1):S208–S219.
72.
StevensWD, BucknerRL, SchacterDL. 2010. Correlated low-frequency BOLD fluctuations in the resting human brain are modulated by recent experience in category-preferential visual regions. Cereb Cortex, 20:1997–2006.
73.
SupekarK, UddinLQ, KhouzamA, PhillipsJ, GaillardWD, KenworthyLE, et al.2013. Brain hyperconnectivity in children with autism and its links with social deficits. Cell Rep, 5:738–747.
74.
TagliazucchiE, von WegnerF, MorzelewskiA, BrodbeckV, LaufsH. 2012. Dynamic BOLD functional connectivity in humans and its electrophysiological correlates. Front Hum Neurosci, 6:339.
75.
TyszkaJM, KennedyDP, PaulLK, AdolphsR. 2014. Largely typical patterns of resting-state functional connectivity in high-functioning adults with autism. Cereb Cortex, 24:1894–1905.
76.
UddinLQ, SupekarK, LynchCJ, KhouzamA, PhillipsJ, FeinsteinC, et al.2013a. Salience network-based classification and prediction of symptom severity in children with autism. JAMA Psychiatry, 70:869–879.
77.
UddinLQ, SupekarK, MenonV. 2013b. Reconceptualizing functional brain connectivity in autism from a developmental perspective. Front Hum Neurosci, 7:458.
78.
Van DijkKR, HeddenT, VenkataramanA, EvansKC, LazarSW, BucknerRL. 2010. Intrinsic functional connectivity as a tool for human connectomics: theory, properties, and optimization. J Neurophysiol, 103:297–321.
79.
von dem HagenEA, StoyanovaRS, Baron-CohenS, CalderAJ. 2012. Reduced functional connectivity within and between ‘social’ resting state networks in autism spectrum conditions. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci, 8:694–701.
80.
WangL, SaalmannYB, PinskMA, ArcaroMJ, KastnerS. 2012. Electrophysiological low-frequency coherence and cross-frequency coupling contribute to BOLD connectivity. Neuron, 76:1010–1020.
81.
WashingtonSD, GordonEM, BrarJ, WarburtonS, SawyerAT, WolfeA, et al.2013. Dysmaturation of the default mode network in autism. Hum Brain Mapp, 35:1284–1296.
82.
WassS. 2011. Distortions and disconnections: disrupted brain connectivity in autism. Brain Cogn, 75:18–28.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
