Black women living with HIV (BWLWH) face adversities, including discrimination (race, HIV, and gender related) and trauma. This study examines which latent profiles of resilience (R) and adversity (A) are most prevalent and their relationships to mental health among 119 BWLWH [age = 44.1 (standard deviation = 10.9)]. Questionnaires measured resilience (post-traumatic growth, trait/coping resilience, religious coping, social support), adversity (discrimination, trauma, microaggressions), and mental health [post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms, post-traumatic cognitions (PTC), and depressive symptoms]. Four salient profiles emerged through latent profile analysis and mental health differences were evaluated. Profile 1 (19.8%) reported lowest scores on 4 resilience measures, lowest traumas, and second lowest on discrimination (low resilience/low adversity—LR/LA). Profile 2 (13.8%) had second lowest on 3 resilience measures but second highest social support, highest/second highest on traumas and discrimination and microaggressions (low resilience/high adversity—LR/HA). Profile 3 (59.5%) exhibited higher scores on resilience and lowest scores on 3 of 4 adversity measures (high resilience/low adversity—HR/LA). Profile 4 (6.9%) reported high on 3 resilience measures, but third lowest on social support, and second highest/highest traumas, discrimination, and microaggressions (high resilience/high adversity—HR/HA). For PTC, the HR/LA group had significantly lower scores compared with the LR/LA and LR/HA groups; and LR/HA had higher PTC scores than the HR/HA group. PTSD scores were significantly lower for HR/LA than all profiles. Depression scores were significantly higher for LR/LA and LR/HA groups than HR/LA. Findings indicate that lower adversity alongside higher resilience leads to better mental health. Policies must address intersectional discrimination and prevent trauma impacting BWLWH; interventions are needed to improve social support and healing.
Clinical Trial Registration number NCT02764853.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CDC. HIV Surveillance Report, 2018 (Updated). Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2020.
2.
RaoD, AndrasikMP, LipiraL. HIV stigma among black women in the United States: Intersectionality, support, resilience. Am J Public Health, 2018; 108:446–448.
3.
BowlegL. The problem with the phrase women and minorities: Intersectionality-an important theoretical framework for public health. Am J Public Health, 2012; 102:1267–1273.
4.
RobertsAL, GilmanSE, BreslauJ, et al.Race/ethnic differences in exposure to traumatic events, development of post-traumatic stress disorder, and treatment-seeking for post-traumatic stress disorder in the United States. Psychol Med, 2011; 41:71–83.
5.
WilliamsMT, MetzgerIW, LeinsC, et al.Assessing racial trauma within a DSM-5 framework: The UConn Racial/Ethnic Stress & Trauma Survey. Pract Innovat, 2018; 3:242.
6.
ChinnJJ, MartinIK, RedmondN. Health equity among black women in the United States. J Womens Health, 2021; 30:212–219.
7.
McGuireTG, MirandaJ. New evidence regarding racial and ethnic disparities in mental health: Policy implications. Health Affairs (Project Hope), 2008; 27:393–403.
8.
BrownleyJR, FallotRD, Wolfson BerleyR, et al.Trauma history in African-American women living with HIV: Effects on psychiatric symptom severity and religious coping. AIDS Care, 2015; 27:964–971.
9.
BaileyRK, MokonoghoJ, KumarA. Racial and ethnic differences in depression: Current perspectives. Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat, 2019:603–609.
10.
BergerMT.Workable Sisterhood: The Political Journey of Stigmatized Women with HIV/AIDS. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 2010.
11.
The Combahee River Collective. A Black Feminist Statement. Womens Stud Quart, 2014; 42:271–280.
12.
CrenshawKW.On Intersectionality: Essential Writings. New York: The New Press; 2017.
13.
DaleSK, SafrenSA. Gendered racial microaggressions associated with depression diagnosis among black women living with HIV. J Urban Health, 2020; 97:377–386.
14.
DaleSK, SafrenSA. Gendered racial microaggressions predict posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms and cognitions among Black women living with HIV. Psychol Trauma Theory Res Pract Policy, 2019; 11:685–694.
15.
SouthwickSM, BonannoGA, MastenAS, et al.Resilience definitions, theory, and challenges: Interdisciplinary perspectives. Eur J Psychotraumatol, 2014; 5:25338.
16.
DorvilS, VuM, HaardorferR, et al.Experiences of adverse childhood events and racial discrimination in relation to depressive symptoms in college students. Coll Stud J, 2020; 54:295–308.
17.
ThulinEJ, HeinzeJE, ZimmermanMA. Adolescent adverse childhood experiences and risk of adult intimate partner violence. Am J Prevent Med, 2021; 60:80–86.
18.
LeathS, JonesMK, Butler-BarnesS. An examination of ACEs, the internalization of the Superwoman Schema, and mental health outcomes among Black adult women. J Trauma Dissociation, 2022; 23:307–323.
19.
TsuyukiK, Al-AlusiNA, CampbellJC, et al.Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) are associated with forced and very early sexual initiation among Black women accessing publicly funded STD clinics in Baltimore, MD. PLoS One, 2019; 14:e0216279.
20.
JasthiDL, Nagle-YangS, FrankS, et al.Associations between adverse childhood experiences and prenatal mental health and substance use among urban, low-income women. Community Ment Health J, 2022; 58:595–605.
21.
TanyaN, AlimMD, Adriana FederMD, et al.Trauma, resilience, and recovery in a high-risk African-American population. Am J Psychiatry, 2008; 165:1566–1575.
22.
HallJC, EverettJE, Hamilton-MasonJ. Black women talk about workplace stress and how they cope. J Black Stud, 2012; 43:207–226.
23.
BaileyZD, KriegerN, AgénorM, et al.Structural racism and health inequities in the USA: Evidence and interventions. Lancet, 2017; 389:1453–1463.
24.
American Psychological Association. The road to resilience. 2004. http://helping.apa.org/resilience/
25.
EgelandB, CarlsonE, SroufeLA. Resilience as process. Dev Psychopathol, 1993; 5:517–528.
26.
WalshF.Strengthening Family Resilience. New York: Guilford Publications; 2015.
27.
GunnestadA. Resilience in a cross-cultural perspective: How resilience is generated in different cultures. JICC, 2006; 11:1.
28.
WuG, FederA, CohenH, et al.Understanding resilience. Front Behav Neurosci, 2013; 7:10.
29.
DavidsonJRT, TharwaniHM, ConnorKM. Davidson Trauma Scale (DTS): Normative scores in the general population and effect sizes in placebo-controlled SSRI trials. Depression Anxiety, 2002; 15:75–78.
30.
JacelonCS. The trait and process of resilience. J Adv Nurs, 1997; 25:123–129.
31.
DaleSK, ReidR, SafrenSA. Factors associated with resilience among Black women living with HIV and histories of trauma. J Health Psychol, 2021; 26(5):758–766.
32.
SpiesG, SeedatS. Depression and resilience in women with HIV and early life stress: Does trauma play a mediating role? A cross-sectional study. BMJ Open, 2014; 4:e004200.
33.
PolizziCP, LynnSJ. Regulating emotionality to manage adversity: A systematic review of the relation between emotion regulation and psychological resilience. Cogn Ther Res, 2021; 45:577–597.
34.
PangalloA, ZibarrasL, LewisR, et al.Resilience through the lens of interactionism: A systematic review. Psychol Assess, 2015; 27:1–20.
35.
GottertA, McClairTL, PulerwitzJ, et al.What shapes resilience among people living with HIV? A multi-country analysis of data from the PLHIV Stigma Index 2.0. AIDS, 2020; 34(Suppl. 1):S19–S31.
36.
CatabayCJ, StockmanJK, CampbellJC, et al.Perceived stress and mental health: The mediating roles of social support and resilience among black women exposed to sexual violence. J Affect Disord, 2019; 259:143–149.
37.
DaleSK, SafrenSA. Resilience takes a village: Black women utilize support from their community to foster resilience against multiple adversities. AIDS Care, 2018; 30:S18–S26.
38.
CalhounLG, TedeschiRG. Handbook of Posttraumatic Growth: Research and Practice. London: Routledge; 2014.
39.
RzeszutekM, GruszczyńskaE. Posttraumatic growth among people living with HIV: A systematic review. J Psychosomat Res, 2018; 114:81–91.
40.
EvansSD, WilliamsBE, LeuC-S. Correlates of posttraumatic growth among African Americans living with HIV/AIDS in Mississippi. Online J Rural Urban Res, 2013; 3:1–16.
41.
QiaoS, IngramL, DealML, et al.Resilience resources among African American women living with HIV in Southern United States. AIDS, 2019; 33(Suppl. 1):S35–S44.
42.
DaleS, CohenM, WeberK, et al.Abuse and resilience in relation to HAART medication adherence and HIV viral load among women with HIV in the United States. AIDS Patient Care STDs, 2014; 28:136–143.
43.
SmithMK, McCarragherTM, BrownGT. Struggles and resilience of African American women living with HIV or AIDS: A qualitative study. J Soc Work, 2015; 15:409–424.
44.
FaithE. Fletcher NRS, Whitney S. Rice, Ibrahim Yigit, et al.Resilience and HIV Treatment Outcomes Among Women Living with HIV in the United States: A Mixed-Methods Analysis. AIDS Patient Care and STDs, 2020; 34:356–366.
45.
ThurstonIB, HowellKH, KamodyRC, et al.Resilience as a moderator between syndemics and depression in mothers living with HIV. AIDS Care, 2018; 30:1257–1264.
46.
Campbell-SillsL, SteinMB. Psychometric analysis and refinement of the connor–davidson resilience scale (CD-RISC): Validation of a 10-item measure of resilience. J Traumat Stress, 2007; 20:1019–1028.
47.
KuiperH, van LeeuwenCCM, Stolwijk-SwüsteJM, et al.Measuring resilience with the Connor–Davidson Resilience Scale (CD-RISC): Which version to choose?. Spinal Cord, 2019; 57:360–366.
48.
AlobaO, OlabisiO, AlobaT. The 10-Item Connor–Davidson Resilience Scale: Factorial structure, reliability, validity, and correlates among student nurses in Southwestern Nigeria. J Am Psychiatr Nurses Assoc, 2016; 22:43–51.
49.
CoatesEE, PharesV, DedrickRF. Psychometric properties of the Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale 10 among low-income, African American men. Psychol Assess, 2013; 25:1349–1354.
50.
DambiJM, CortenL, ChiwaridzoM, et al.A systematic review of the psychometric properties of the cross-cultural translations and adaptations of the Multidimensional Perceived Social Support Scale (MSPSS). Health Qual Life Outcomes, 2018; 16:80.
51.
BronderEC, SpeightSL, WitherspoonKM, et al.John Henryism, depression, and perceived social support in black women. J Black Psychol, 2014; 40:115–137.
52.
PargamentK, FeuilleM, BurdzyD. The Brief RCOPE: Current psychometric status of a short measure of religious coping. Religions, 2011; 2:51–76.
53.
MesidorJK, WhaleyAL. Psychometric analysis of the haitian creole version of the posttraumatic growth inventory (PTGI) among the 2010 Earthquake Survivors. J Loss Trauma, 2021; 27:159–173.
54.
ManoveEE, LoweSR, BonumweziJ, et al.Posttraumatic growth in low-income Black mothers who survived Hurricane Katrina. Am J Orthopsychiatry, 2019; 89:144–158.
55.
RamosC, LealI, MarôcoAL, et al.The posttraumatic growth inventory: Factor structure and invariance in a sample of breast cancer patients and in a non-clinical sample. Spanish J Psychol, 2016; 19:E64.
56.
KalerME, ErbesCR, TedeschiRG, et al.Factor structure and concurrent validity of the Posttraumatic Growth Inventory–Short Form among veterans from the Iraq War. J Traumat Stress, 2011; 24:200–207.
57.
Garrido-HernansaizH, Rodríguez-ReyR, Alonso-TapiaJ. Posttraumatic growth inventory: Factor structure in Spanish-speaking people living with HIV. AIDS Care, 2017; 29:1320–1323.
58.
GrayMJ, LitzBT, HsuJL, et al.Psychometric properties of the life events checklist. Assessment, 2004; 11:330–341.
59.
BogartLM, WagnerGJ, GalvanFH, et al.Perceived discrimination and mental health symptoms among Black men with HIV. Cultur Divers Ethnic Minor Psychol, 2011; 17:295–302.
60.
NadalKL. The Racial and Ethnic Microaggressions Scale (REMS): Construction, reliability, and validity. J Counsel Psychol, 2011; 58:470.
61.
KlonoffEA, LandrineH. The schedule of sexist events: A measure of lifetime and recent sexist discrimination in women's lives. Psychol Women Quart, 1995; 19:439–472.
62.
LewisJA, NevilleHA. Construction and initial validation of the Gendered Racial Microaggressions Scale for Black women. J Counsel Psychol, 2015; 62:289–302.
63.
WilliamsCD, TaylorTR, MakambiK, et al.CES-D four-factor structure is confirmed, but not invariant, in a large cohort of African American women. Psychiatry Res, 2007; 150:173–180.
64.
KalichmanSC, RompaD, CageM. Distinguishing between overlapping somatic symptoms of depression and HIV disease in people living with HIV-AIDS. J Nervous Mental Dis, 2000; 188:662–670.
65.
CochranSD, MaysVM. Depressive distress among homosexually active African American men and women. Am J Psychiatry, 1994; 151:524–529.
66.
FoaEB, EhlersA, ClarkDM, et al.The Posttraumatic Cognitions Inventory (PTCI): Development and validation. Psychol Assess, 1999; 11:303–314.
67.
ZlotnickC, DavidsonJ, SheaMT, et al.Validation of the Davidson Trauma Scale in a sample of survivors of childhood sexual abuse. J Nervous Ment Dis, 1996; 184:255–257.
68.
McDonaldSD, BeckhamJC, MoreyRA, et al.The validity and diagnostic efficiency of the Davidson Trauma Scale in military veterans who have served since September 11th, 2001. J Anxiety Disord, 2009; 23:247–255.
69.
NylundKL, AsparouhovT, MuthénBO. Deciding on the number of classes in latent class analysis and growth mixture modeling: A Monte Carlo Simulation Study. Struct Equat Model Multidiscipl J, 2007; 14:535–569.
70.
AsparouhovT, MuthénB. Auxiliary variables in mixture modeling: Three-step approaches using Mplus. Struct Equat Model Multidiscipl J, 2014; 21:329–341.
71.
Statistical Analysis With Latent Variables Mplus User's Guide [computer program]. Version. Los Angeles, CA: Muthen & Muthen; 1998–2017.
72.
AdamsLM, WilsonTE, MerensteinD, et al.Using the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale to assess depression in women with HIV and women at risk for HIV: Are somatic items invariant?. Psychol Assess, 2018; 30:97–105.
73.
VilagutG, ForeroCG, BarbagliaG, et al.Screening for Depression in the General Population with the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression (CES-D): A systematic review with meta-analysis. PLoS One, 2016; 11:e0155431.
74.
DavidsonJRT, BookSW, ColketJT, et al.Assessment of a new self-rating scale for post-traumatic stress disorder. Psychol Med, 1997; 27:153–160.
75.
Connor–Davidson. Table 1b. Mean (SD) CD-RISC 10-Item Scores in General Population Samples. http://www.connordavidson-resiliencescale.com/user-guide.php [Last accessed: June 6, 2022].
76.
GalvanFH, DavisEM, BanksD, et al.HIV stigma and social support among African Americans. AIDS patient care and STDs, 2008; 22:423–436.
77.
DaleSK, WeberKM, CohenMH, et al.Resilience moderates the association between childhood sexual abuse and depressive symptoms among women with and at-risk for HIV. AIDS Behav, 2015; 19:1379–1387.
78.
OjikutuBO, MayerK. HIV Prevention Among Black Women in the US—Time for Multimodal Integrated Strategies. JAMA Netw Open, 2021; 4:e215356.
79.
EngstromM, AlfordS, HamptonK, et al.Evaluation of SISTA and Safety Counts in “real-world” settings with African American women in Chicago. J HIV/AIDS Soc Serv, 2019; 18:213–228.
80.
WingoodGM, DiClementeRJ, MikhailI, et al.A randomized controlled trial to reduce HIV transmission risk behaviors and sexually transmitted diseases among women living with HIV: The WiLLOW Program. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr, 2004; 37(Suppl. 2):S58–S67.
81.
WagmanJA, GrayRH, CampbellJC, et al.Effectiveness of an integrated intimate partner violence and HIV prevention intervention in Rakai, Uganda: Analysis of an intervention in an existing cluster randomised cohort. Lancet Global Health, 2015; 3:e23–e33.
82.
WilliamsJK, GloverDA, WyattGE, et al.A sexual risk and stress reduction intervention designed for HIV-positive bisexual African American men with childhood sexual abuse histories. Am J Public Health, 2013; 103:1476–1484.
83.
KondoMC, AndreyevaE, SouthEC, et al.Neighborhood Interventions to Reduce Violence. Annu Rev Public Health, 2018; 39:253–271.
84.
LehmanJS, CarrMH, NicholAJ, et al.Prevalence and public health implications of state laws that criminalize potential HIV exposure in the United States. AIDS Behav, 2014; 18:997–1006.
85.
Best Practices Guide to Reform HIV-Specific Criminal Laws to Align with Scientifically-Supported Factors. Civil Rights Division: Department of Justice; 2014. Available from: https://www.hivlawandpolicy.org/sites/default/files/DOj-HIV-Criminal-Law-Best-Practices-Guide.pdf
86.
SpenceAB, MichelK, WangC, et al.Viral suppression is associated with HIV treatment self-efficacy in a cohort of women in Washington, DC. AIDS Patient Care STDs, 2021; 35:75–83.
87.
BudhwaniH, YigitI, OfotokunI, et al.Examining the relationships between experienced and anticipated stigma in health care settings, patient–provider race concordance, and trust in providers among women living with HIV. AIDS Patient Care STDs, 2021; 35:441–448.
88.
MuzeRH. Parenting and Child Outcomes of HIV-Infected African American Mothers: A literature review. J Commun Health Nurs, 2013; 30:164–171.
