Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2015-03
A Synthesis of the Theory of Silencing the Self and the Social Ecological Model: Understanding Gender,Race,and Depression in African American Women Living with HIV Infection
The challenges that face African American women living with HIV are immense. African American women continue to be disproportionately infected and affected by this chronic and life-threatening infection in a complex context of individual experience, interactions with the environment, formal and informal support systems, and cultural belief systems. This article identifies the Theory of Silencing the Self (STS) and a widely known model, the Social Ecological Model (SEM), as a synthesized explanatory framework in helping nurses understand how to address research questions and clinical care that is congruent with the experience of African American women living with HIV infection. In synthesizing the components of these two frameworks, an explanation of the relationship between disempowerment and depression in this population will be uncovered as a key component to making relationships at the individual, family, and community level better. Helping African American women living with HIV infection to explore and address how choosing to be silent across their life systems will advance healthcare adherence as we currently know it to improved self-management of a chronic, gender-specific, culturally-bound experience of depression.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. HIV Surveillance Report. Diagnosis of HIV Infection and AIDS in the United States and Dependent Areas, 2008; 20:1–143.
2.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report 2007. Atlanta: U.S.Department of Health and Human Services. 2007; 19:1–63.
3.
ClarkA, MaybenJK, HartmanC, et al.Conspiracy beliefs about HIV infection are common but not associated with delayed diagnosis or adherence to care. AIDS Patient Care STDs, 2008; 22:753–759.
4.
WyattGE. Enhancing cultural and contextual intervention strategies to reduce HIV/AIDS among African Americans. Am J Public Health, 2009; 99:1941–1945.
5.
WyattGE, AxelrodJ, ChinD, et al.Examining the patterns of vulnerability to domestic violence among African American women. Violence Against Women, 2000; 6:495–514.
6.
CieslaJA, RobertsJE. Meta-analysis of the relationship between HIV infection and risk for depressive disorders. Am J Psychiatry, 2001; 158:725–730.
7.
MilesMS, Holditch-DavisD, PedersonC, et al.Emotional distress in African American women with HIV. J Prevent Intervent Commun, 2007; 33:35–50.
8.
MoneyhamL, SowellR, SealsB, DemiA. Depressive symptoms among African American women with HIV disease. Schol Inquir Nursing Practice, 2000; 14:9–39.
9.
WingoodGM, HardinJW, DiClementeRJ, et al.HIV discrimination and the health of women living with HIV. Women Health, 2007; 46:99–112.
10.
JackD. Silencing the Self: Women and Depression. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA, 1991.
11.
JackD. Behind the Mask: Destruction and Creativity in Women's Aggression. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, MA, 1999.
12.
JackD, AliA. Silencing the Self across Cultures: Depression and Gender in the Social World. Oxford University Press: New York, New York, 2010.
13.
DeMarcoR, JohnsenC, FukudaD, DeffenbaughO. Content validity of a scale to measure silencing and affectivity among women living with HIV/AIDs. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care, 2001; 12:77–88.
14.
DeMarcoR, JohnsenC. Vulnerable Populations: Women Living with HIV/AIDS. In: MahoneyEA, ShawJK. (Eds.) HIV/AIDS Nursing Secrets. Philadelphia, PA: Hanely & Belfus, Inc, 2002.
15.
DeMarcoRF, LanierLR. The Concept of “Silencing the Self” in low income, aging, HIV-infected Black women: A ten-year community-based participatory program of research with results. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care, 2014; 25:112–122.
16.
DeMarcoRF, NorrisAE. Women's Voices Women's Lives: A Web-Based HIV Prevention Film Project. WelieJVM, JLee (Eds.). Jesuit health sciences and the promotion of justice: An invitation to a discussion. Milwaukee, WI: Marquette University Press, 2004a.
17.
DeMarcoRF, KendricksM, DolmoY, et al.The effect of prevention messages and self-efficacy skill building with inner city women at risk for HIV infection. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care, 2009; 20:283–292.
18.
DeMarcoRF, StokesC. Midlife Black women living with HIV/AIDS in the United States: A treatment strategy using peer-led, structured writing in a group with global possibilities. Treatment Strategies-AIDS. Available at: http://viewer.zmags.com/publication/d4b7caf8#/d4b7caf8/1 (2010) (Last accessed March12, 2014).
19.
DeMarcoRF. Supporting voice in women living with HIV/AIDS. In: JackD, AliA. (eds.), Cultural Perspectives on Womens' Depression: Self-Silencing, Psychological Distress and Recovery. NY: Oxford University Press, 2010.
20.
JackD, DillD. The silencing the self scale: Schemas of intimacy associated with depression in women. Psychol Women Quart, 1992; 16:97–106.
21.
BronfenbrennerU. The Ecology of Human Development: Experiments by Nature and Design. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University, 1979.
22.
BronfenbrennerU. Making Human Beings Human. Bioecological Perspectives on Human Development. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 2004.
23.
El-BasselN, WitteSS, GilbertL, et al.The efficacy of a relationship-based HIV/STD prevention program for heterosexual couples. Am J Public Health, 2003; 93:963–969.
24.
El-BasselN, CaldeiraNA, RuglassLM, GilbertL. Addressing the unique needs of African American women in HIV prevention. Am J Public Health, 2009; 99:996–1001.
25.
EddyJM, DonahueRE, WebsterRD, BjournstadED. Application of an ecological perspective in worksite health promotion: A review. Am J Health Studies, 2002; 17:197–202.
26.
SchaalmaHP, AbrahamC, GillmoreMR, KokG. Sex education as health promotion: What does it take?. Arch Sexual Behav, 2004;2003;33:259–269.
27.
BurkeJG. Intimate partner violence among low income women: Associated individual and contextual risk factors. Violence Against Wom, 2005; 11:1140–1161.
28.
BhattacharyaG. Health care seeking for HIV/AIDS among South Asians in the United States. Health Social Work, 2004; 29:106–116.
29.
CrosbyRA, YarberWL, MyersonBM. Prevention strategies other than male condoms employed by low-income women to prevent HIV infection. Public Health Nursing, 2000; 17:53–60.
30.
PulerwitzJ, AmaroH, DeJongW, et al.Relationship power, condom use and HIV risk among women in the USA. AIDS Care, 2002; 14:789–800.
31.
YatesME, StellatoRK, JoannesCB, AvisNE. The importance of AIDS-related knowledge for mid-life and older women. AIDS Edu Prevent, 1999; 11:224–231.
32.
Berger-GreensteinJA, CuevasCA, BradySM, et al.Major depression in patients with HIV/AIDS and substance abuse. AIDS Patient Care STDs, 2007; 21:942–955.
33.
WhettenK, ReifS, WhettenR, Murphy-McMillanLK. Trauma, mental health, distrust, and stigma among HIV-positive persons: Implications for effective care. Psychosom Med, 2008; 70:531–538.
34.
NewmanPA, WilliamsCC, MassaquoiN, et al.HIV prevention for Black women: Structural barriers and opportunities. J Health Care Poor Underserved, 2008; 19:829–844.
35.
MyersHF, SumnerLA, UllmanJB, et al.Trauma and psychosocial predictors of substance abuse in women impacted by HIV/AIDS. J Behav Health Services Res, 2009; 36:233–246.
36.
MyersHF, WyattGE, LoebTB, et al.Severity of child sexual abuse, post- traumatic stress and risky sexual behaviors among HIV-positive women. AIDS Behav, 2006; 10:191–199.
37.
WyattGE, CarmonaJV, LoebTB, WilliamsJK. HIV-positive black women with histories of childhood sexual abuse: Patterns of substance use and barriers to health care. J Health Care Poor Underserved, 2005; 16:9–23.
38.
LaughonK, GielenAC, CampbellJC, et al.The relationships among sexually transmitted infection, depression, and lifetime violence in a sample of predominantly African American women. Res Nursing Health, 2007; 30:413–428.
39.
LiuH, LongshoreD, WilliamsJK, et al.Substance abuse and medication adherence among HIV-positive women with histories of child sexual abuse. AIDS Behav, 2006; 10:279–286.
40.
Warren-FindlowJ, ProhaskaTR. Families, social support, and self-care among older African-American women with chronic illness. Am J Health Promot, 2008; 22:342.
41.
TrzynkaSL, ErlenJA. HIV disease susceptibility in women and the barriers to adherence. Med Surg Nursing, 2004; 13:97–104.
42.
HerekGM, CapitanioJP, WidamanKF. HIV-related stigma and knowledge in the United States: Prevalence, and trends, 1991–1999. Res Pract, 2002; 92:371–377.
43.
GoffmanE. Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Prentice Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1963.
44.
ColbertK, SereilcaE. An examination of the relationships among gender, health status, social support, and HIV-related stigma. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care, 2010; 21:302–313.
45.
Neely-SmithSL, PatsdaughterCA. The influence of self-esteem and self-silencing on self-efficacy for negotiating safer sex behaviors in urban Bahamian women. J Multicult Nursing Health, 2004; 10:15–27.
46.
NorrisAE, DeMarcoRF. The experience of African American women living with HIV creating a prevention film for teens. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care, 2005; 16:32–39.
47.
SanzeroL, CorlessIB, BunchEH, et al.Self-care strategies for depressive symptoms in people with HIV disease. J Adv Nursing, 2005; 51:119–130.
48.
IronsonG, O'CleirighC, FletcherMA, et al.Psychosocial factors predict CD4 and viral load change in men and women with human immunodeficiency virus in the era of highly active antiretroviral treatment. Psychosom Med, 2005; 67:1013–1021.
49.
LiebschutzJM, GeierJL, HortonNJ, et al.Physical and sexual violence and health care utilization in HIV-infected persons with alcohol problems. AIDS Care, 2005; 17:566–578.
50.
WolitskiRJ, JanssenRS, OnoratoIM. An overview of prevention with people living with HIV. In: KalichmanSC (Ed.). Positive Prevention: Reducing HIV Transmission among People Living with HIV/AIDS. New York: Kluwer, 2005.
51.
HaynesRB, AcklooE, SahotaN, McDonaldHP, YaoX. Interventions for enhancing medication adherence. [Review] [455 refs][Update of Cochrane Database Syst Rev., 2005; 4:CD000011.
52.
HunnVL, CraigCD. Depression, sociocultural factors, and African American women. J Multicult Counsel Devel, 2009; 37:83–93.
53.
JonesLV, FordB. Depression in African American women. J Women Social Work, 2008; 23:134–143.
54.
VyavaharkerM, MoneyhamL, CorwinS, et al.HIV-disclosure, social support, and depression among HIV-infected African American women living in the rural southeastern United States. AIDS Edu Prevent, 2011; 23:78–90.
55.
ParanjapeA, BersnteinL, St. GeorgeDM, et al.Effect of relationship factors on safer sex decisions in older inner city women. J Women's Health, 2006; 15:90–97.
56.
DeMarcoRF, MillerK, PatsdaughterC, et al.From silencing the self to action: Experiences of women living with HIV/AIDS. Women's Health Care Intl, 1998; 19:539–552.
57.
DeMarcoR, JohnsenC. Taking action in communities: Women living with HIV lead the way. J Commun Health Nursing, 2003; 20:51–62.
58.
DeMarcoRF, LynchMM, BoardR. Mothers who silence themselves: Clinical implications for women living with HIV/AIDS and their children. J Pediatr Nursing, 2002; 17; 89–95.
NicolaidisC, TimmonsV, ThomasMJ, et al.“You don't go tell white people nothing”: African American women's perspectives on the influence of violence and race on depression and depression care. Am J Public Health, 2010; 100:1470–1476.
61.
CarringtonCH. Clinical depression in African American women: Diagnosis, treatment, and research. J Clin Psychol, 2006; 62:779–791.
62.
WaiteR, KilliianP. Health beliefs about depression among African American women. Persp Psychiat Care, 2008; 44:185–195.
63.
WaiteR. Perceptions of treatment for depression among underserved African American women. J Chi Eta Phi Sorority, 2008; 53:14–19.
64.
DaleSK, CohenMH, CruiseRC, BrodyLR. Resilience moderates the association between childhood sexual abuse and depressive symptoms among women with and at-risk for HIV. AIDS Behav 2014.
65.
Abu-BaderSH, CreweSE. Predictors of depression among African American women who were former welfare recipients: A path diagram. Best Pract Mental Health, 2006; 2:1–22.
66.
GroteNK, BledsoeSE, WellmanJ, BrownC. Depression in African American and white women with low incomes: The role of chronic stress. Soc Work Public Health, 2007; 23:59–88.
67.
O'MalleyAS, ForrestCB, MirandaJ. Primary care attributes and care for depression among low-income African American women. Am J Public Health, 2003; 93:1328.
68.
RamosBM, CarlsonBE, McNuttL. Lifetime abuse, mental health, and African American women. J Family Violence, 2004; 19:153–164.
69.
American Psychiatric Association, Office of HIV Psychiatry. HIV mental health treatment issues—HIV and clinical depression. Available at http://www.psych.org (2002) (Last accessed March23, 2011).
70.
National Alliance on Mental Illness. African American women and depression. Available at: http://www.nami.org/Template.cfm?Section=Women_and_Depression&Template=/ContentManagement/ContentDisplay.cfm&ContentID=88884 (2009) (Last accessed August9, 2013).
71.
BrownD, KeithV, JacksonJ, GaryL. (Dis) Respected and (dis) Regarded: Experiences of Racism and Psychological Distress. In and Out of our Right Minds: The Mental Health of African American Women. New York: Columbia University Press, 2003.
72.
SettlesIH, NaverreteCD, PaganoS, et al.Racial identity and depression among African American women. Cult Diversity Ethnic Minority Psychol, 2010; 16:248–255.
73.
ClumG, ChungS, EllenJM. Mediators of HIV-related stigma and risk behavior in HIV infected young women. AIDS Care, 2009; 21:1455–1462.
74.
VyavaharkerM, MoneyhamL, CorwinS, et al.Relationships between stigma, social support, and depression in HIV-infected African American women living in the rural southeastern United States. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care, 2010; 21:144–152.
75.
SenguptaS, StraussRP, MilesMS, et al.A conceptual model exploring the relationship between HIV stigma and implementing HIV clinical trials in rural communities of North Carolina. N Carolina Med J, 2010; 71:113–122.
76.
PrachakulW, GrantJS, KeltnerNL. Relationships among functional support, HIV-related stigma, social problem solving, and depressive symptoms in people living with HIV: A pilot study. J Assoc Nurses AIDS Care, 2007; 18:67–76.
77.
SherbourneC, ForgeNG, KungF, et al.Personal and psychosocial characteristics associated with psychiatric conditions among women with human immunodeficiency virus. Women's Health Issues, 2003; 13:104–110.
78.
VanceD. The relationship between HIV disclosure and adjustment. Psychol Rep, 2006; 99:659–663.
79.
WyattGE, MyersHF, WilliamsJK, et al.Does a history of trauma contribute to HIV risk for women of color? Implications for prevention and policy. Am J Public Health, 2002; 92:660–665.
80.
WyattGE, MyersHF, LoebTB. Women, trauma, and HIV: An overview. AIDS Behav, 2004; 8:401–403.
