Differences in the Human and Mouse Amino-Terminal Leader Peptides of Ornithine Transcarbamylase Affect Mitochondrial Import and Efficacy of Adenoviral Vectors

Abstract

Mouse models of ornithine transcarbamylase (OTC) deficiency are being used to test the efficacy of viral vectors as possible vehicles for gene therapy. However, it has been demonstrated that virus containing the human OTC cDNA failed to express functional OTC enzyme in the recipient animals. Because functional OTC is assembled as a homotrimer in the mitochondria, there are at least two possible explanations for these results. Either endogenous mutant protein coassembles with the human OTC and has a "dominant-negative effect," or the human version of the protein is not appropriately imported or processed in the mouse mitochondria. To test the importance of processing, which in rodents is thought to depend on the leader peptide, adenoviral vectors containing chimeric OTC cDNAs were prepared. These vectors were evaluated in the OTC-deficient sparse fur mouse models. Although comparable levels of transgene expression were observed in all groups of mice, the only mice that had high levels of OTC activity and mitochondrial OTC immunoreactivity were those mice injected with the vectors containing the mouse leader peptide (mouse OTC and a mouse-human chimera of OTC). To address possible dominant-negative effects, adenoviruses containing mutant human or mouse OTC cDNAs were prepared and evaluated in cell lines or normal C3H mice, respectively. No inhibition of normal OTC activity was observed in either model system. Together, these studies provide no evidence of a dominant-negative effect and suggest that the human and rodent enzymes responsible for transporting of OTC and possibly other mitochondrial proteins have different specificity.