Attitudes towards creationism and evolutionary theory: the debate among secondary pupils attending Catholic and Protestant schools in Northern Ireland

Abstract

A sample of 2129 pupils in the third through sixth years of Protestant and Catholic grammar schools in Northern Ireland completed an index concerned with attitudes towards creationism and evolutionary theory. The data demonstrate that among this age group in Northern Ireland, 48 percent accept the view that “God created the world as described in the Bible,” while 33 percent accept the view that “Science disproves the biblical account of creation.” Support for creationism is stronger among girls than boys, among Protestants than Catholics, and among third and fourth year students than fifth and sixth year students. The results have implications for understanding the conflict between science and religion and for both science educators and religious educators.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

K. H. Reich , “Between religion and science: complementarity in the religious thinking of young people,” British Journal of Religious Education 11 (1989): 62-69.

P. Fulljames , H. M. Gibson , and L. J. Francis , “Creationism, scientism, Christianity and science: a study in adolescent attitudes,” British Educational Research Journal 17 (1991): 171-190.

W.-M. Roth and T. Alexander , “The interaction of students' scientific and religious discourses: two case studies,” International Journal of Science Education 19 (1997): 125-146.

L. J. Francis , “Christianity today: the teenage experience,” in The Contours of Christian Education, edited by J. Astley and D. V. Day (Great Wakering, U.K.: McCrimmons, 1992), pp. 340-368.

L. Burton and L. J. Francis , “Growing up Catholic today: the teenage experience,” in Research in Religious Education, edited by L. J. Francis , W. K. Kay and W. S. Campbell (Leominster, U.K.: Gracewing, 1996), pp. 359-381.

L. J. Francis and W. K. Kay , Teenage Religion and Values (Leominster, U.K.: Gracewing, 1995).

L. J. Francis , “The pews talk back: the church congregation survey,” in Learning in the Way: research and reflection on adult Christian education, edited by J. Astley (Leominster, U.K.: Gracewing, 1998).

P. Kaldor , R. Powell , J. Bellamy , K. Castle , M. Correy , and S. Moore , Views from the Pews: Australian church attenders speak out (Adelaide, South Australia: Openbook Publishers, 1995).

R. A. Eve and F. B. Harrold , “Creationism, cult archaeology, and other pseudoscientific beliefs: a study of college students,” Youth and Society 17 (1986): 396-421.

10.

A. E. Lawson and W. A. Worsnop , “Learning about evolution and rejecting a belief in special creation: effects of reflective reasoning skill, prior knowledge, prior belief and religious commitment,” Journal of Research in Science Teaching 29 (1992): 143-166.

11.

A. Sinclair , M. P. Pendarvis , and B. Baldwin , “The relationship between college zoology students' beliefs about evolutionary theory and religion,” Journal of Research and Development in Education 30 (1997): 118-125.

12.

D. Murray , Worlds apart: segregated schools in Northern Ireland (Belfast: Appletree Press, 1985).

13.

D. Murray , “Schools and conflict,” in Northern Ireland: the background to the conflict, edited by J. Darby (Belfast: Appletree Press, 1983), pp. 136-150.

14.

Catholic Advisory Council on Education , The Role of Catholic Education (Belfast: Catholic Advisory Council on Education, 1974).

15.

J. E. Greer , “The county school in Northern Ireland,” The Northern Teacher 14, no. 1 (1983): 6-11.

16.

I. Ajzen , Attitudes, Personality and Behaviour (Milton Keynes, U.K.: Open University Press, 1988).

17.

J. Menis , “Attitudes towards school, chemistry students and science among upper secondary chemistry students in the United States,” Research in Science and Technological Education 7 (1989): 183-190.