Studies on Sensory Feedback: III the Effects of Display Gain on Tracking Performance

Abstract

Instrumentation is described which permits study of the effects of different forms of visual feedback display on the patterns of fine movement obtained from the extended human index finger when the subject is attempting to keep his finger at a fixed point in space. The task is a compensatory tracking task in which the only source of input to the system is the subject's own finger movement. The effects of increasing the gain (or amplification) of a proportional error signal on the pattern of finger movement was studied. Gains of 1, 2, 4, 10, 20 and 40 were studied with a group of 24 subjects. Increasing the gain of a proportional error signal resulted in a marked improvement in the ability of subjects to maintain their extended finger at a fixed point in space. As the gain of the error signal was increased, the subject's high-amplitude, low frequency errors were reduced, and there was a progressive appearance of high-frequency activity of low-amplitude, more accurately centred about the reference position in space. A total off-target area measure (integrated absolute error) showed marked decrease in scores as the amplification of the error signal was increased from 1 through 10. Beyond this gain there was no appreciable additional improvement in motor control, however no degradation of control was noted to characterize the group performance.

Exploratory studies were undertaken to permit comparison of the effects of increasing the gain of a proportional visual display with the effects of increasing the gain of non-proportional visual and auditory displays. An increase in the dominant-energy frequency was noted as the error signal gain was increased, independent of whether a proportional visual, or non-proportional visual or auditory display was used. This observation suggests that common mechanisms mediate the processing of the gain parameters of feedback displays, in some measure independent of the display form or the sensory modality used for presentation.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andreas

B. G.

Gerall

A. A.

Green

R. F.

Murphy

D. P.

(1957). Performance in following tracking as a function of the sensitivity of the airplane-type control stick. J. Psychol. 43, 169–79.

Andreas

B. G.

Weiss

(1954). Review of research on perceptual-motor performance under varied display-control relationships. Univ. Rochester: N.Y. Scientific Rep. No. 2, (Astia AD 61113).

Symposium on Muscle Receptors Barker

Hong Kong

1962.

Bell

(1811). Idea of a new anatomy of the brain. Readings in the History of Psychology Dennis

New York (1948).

Bell

(1826). On the nervous circle which connects the voluntary muscles with the brain. Phil. Trans. 2, 163–75pt.

Bennett

C. A.

(1956). Sampled-data tracking: Sampling of the operator's output. J. exp. Psychol. 51, 429–38.

Bernard

(1858). Leçons sur la Physiologie et la Pathologie du Système Nerveaux. Paris 1, 246–66.

Binet

(1920). The laws of tremor. Lancet 1, 265–6.

Boneau

C. A.

(1960). The effects of violations of assumptions underlying the t test. Psychol. Bull. 57, 49–64.

10.

Boneau

C. A.

(1962). A comparison of the power of the U and t tests. Psychol. Rev. 69, 246–56.

11.

Bowen

J. H.

Chernikoff

(1957). Time relationships between magnification and course frequency in compensatory aided tracking. Naval Res. Lab.: Washington, D.C. (Astia AD 129691).

12.

Briggs

G. E.

Fitts

P. M.

Bahrick

H. P.

(1957). Effects of force and amplitude cues on learning and performance in a complex tracking task. J. exp. Psychol. 54, 262–8.

13.

Brumlik

(1962). On the nature of normal tremor. Neurology 12, 159–79.

14.

Chase

R. A.

(1963). Information system analysis of the organization of motor activity. Disorders of Perception Hoch

P. H.

Zubin

New York (1965).

15.

Chase

R. A.

Harvey

Standfast

Rapin

Sutton

(1961). Studies on sensory feedback I: Effect of delayed auditory feedback on speech and keytapping. Quart. J. exp. Psychol. 13, 141–52.

16.

Chase

R. A.

Rapin

Gilden

Sutton

Guilfoyle

(1961). Studies on sensory feedback II: Sensory feedback influences on keytapping motor tasks. Quart. J. exp. Psychol. 13, 153–67.

17.

Chase

R. A.

Sutton

Rapin

(1961). Sensory feedback influences on motor performance. J. Aud. Res. 3, 212–23.

18.

Cooper

J. D.

Halliday

A. M.

Redfearn

J. W.

(1957). Apparatus for the study of human tremor and stretch reflexes. Electroenceph Clin. Neurophysiol. 9, 546–50.

19.

Craik

K. J. W.

Vince

M. A.

(1945). A note on the design and manipulation of instrument-knobs. Med. Res. Council, Cambridge. (MRC. 46/272, A.P.U. 14).

20.

Craik

K. J. W.

Vince

M. A.

(1963). Psychological and physiological aspects of control mechanisms with special reference to tank gunnery. Ergonomics 6, 1–33.

21.

Fitts

P. M.

Marlowe

Noble

M. E.

(1953). The interrelations of task variables in continuous pursuit tasks: I. Visual-display scale, arm-control scale, and target frequency in pursuit tracking. Hum. Resources Res. Cen. Res. Bull. 1–66.

22.

Garvey

W. D.

Henson

J. B.

(1958). Interactions between display gain and taskinduced stress in manual tracking systems. U.S. Naval Res. Lab.: Washington, D.C. (NRL Report 5204).

23.

Gibbs

C. B.

(1963). Methodology of gain studies in man-machine systems. Psychol. Bull. 60, 147–51.

24.

Gorska

Jankowska

(1959). Instrumental conditioned reflexes of the deafferentated limb in cats and rats. Bulletin de L'Academie Polonaise Des Sciences, CL. VI 7, 161–4.

25.

Gorska

Jankowska

(1960). The effect of deafferentation on the instrumental conditioned reflexes established in dogs by reinforcing passive movements. Bulletin de L'Academie Polonaise Des Sciences, CL. II 8, 527–30.

26.

Halliday

A. M.

Redfearn

J. W. T.

(1956). An analysis of the frequencies of finger tremor in healthy subjects. J. Physiol. 134, 600–11.

27.

Helson

(1949). Design of equipment and optimal human operation. Amer. J. Psychol. 62, 479–81.

28.

Jenkins

W. L.

Karr

A. C.

(1954). The use of a joy-stick in making settings on a simulated scope face. J. appl. Psychol. 6, 457–61.

29.

Jenkins

W. L.

Olson

M. W.

(1952). The use of levers in making settings on a linear scale. J. appl. Psychol. 36, 269–71.

30.

Knapp

H. D.

Taub

Berman

A. J.

(1958). Effect of deafferentation on a conditioned avoidance response. Science 128, 842–3.

31.

Lassek

A. M.

(1953a). Potency of isolated brachial dorsal roots in controlling muscular physiology. Neurology 3, 53–7.

32.

Lassek

A. M.

(1953b). Inactivation of voluntary motor function following rhizotomy. J. Neuropath, exp. Neural. 12, 83–7.

33.

Lassek

A. M.

(1955). Effect of combined afferent lesions on motor functions. Neurology 5, 269–72.

34.

Lassek

A. M.

Moyer

E. K.

(1953). An ontogenetic study of motor deficits following dorsal brachial rhizotomy. J. Neurophysiol. 16, 247–51.

35.

Mackay

D. M.

(1961). The Science of Communication—A Bridge Between Disciplines. Keele.

36.

MacKay

D. M.

(1955). On comparing the brain with machines. Smithsonian Inst.: Washington, D.C. 231–9Rep.

37.

Magendie

(1822). Experiments on the functions of the roots of the spinal nerves. Francois Magendie Olmsted

J. M. D.

New York Reprinted in: (1944).

38.

Marshall

(1961). The effect of ageing upon physiological tremor. J. Neural. Neurosurg. Psychiat. 24, 14–17.

39.

Marshall

Walsh

E. G.

(1956). Physiological tremor. J. Neural. Neurosurg. Psychiat. 19, 260–7.

40.

McRuer

D. T.

Krendel

E. S.

(1957). Dynamic response of human operators. Air Res. Dev. Command, USAF (Astia AD 110693).

41.

Newman

H. W.

Friedlander

W. J.

(1950). A simple device for recording tremors. Stanford Med. Bull. 8, 191–2.

42.

Noble

M. E.

Fitts

P. M.

Marlowe

(1953). The interrelations of task variables in continuous pursuit tasks: II. Visual-display scale, arm-control scale, and target frequency in compensatory tracking. Percept. Motor Skills Res. Lab. (Astia AD 25621).

43.

Obermayer

R. W.

Swartz

W. F.

Muckler

F. A.

(1962). Interaction of information displays with control system dynamics and course frequency in continuous tracking. Percept. Motor Skills 15, 199–215.

44.

Provins

K. A.

(1955). The role of receptors in muscle and tendon in controlling the application of finger pressure in man. J. Physiol. 128, 55–6.

45.

Rockway

M. R.

(1954). The effect of variations in control-display ratio and exponential time delay on tracking performance. Aero Med. Lab. (WADC Tech. Rep. 54–618, Astia AD 62763).

46.

Rockway

M. R.

(1957). Effects of variations in control dead-space and gain on tracking performance. Aero Med. Lab. (WADC Tech. Rep. 57–326, Astia AD 118347).

47.

Rockway

M. R.

(1962). Pursuit and compensatory mode of information display: A review. Aerospace Med. Div. (Astia AD 288888).

48.

Sampson

P. B.

Coleman

P. D.

Elkin

E. H.

(1959). The feasibility of using the eye as a source of control signals in tracking. Inst. appl. exp. Psychol., Tufts University (Astia AD 231516).

49.

Schäfer

E. A.

Canney

H. E. L.

Tunstall

J. O.

(1886). On the rhythm of muscular response to volitional impulses in man. J. Physiol. 7, 111–9.

50.

Senders

J. W.

(1959). Human tracking behavior. Aeronautical Div.: Minneapolis, Minn. (Astia AD 235–174).

51.

Shackel

(1954). The human limbs in control. 2. Optimum control-display ratios at different display distances. Med. Res. Council, Cambridge (APU. 215/54).

52.

Sherrington

C. S.

Mott

S. W.

(1895). Experiments upon the influence of sensory nerves upon movement and nutrition of the limbs. Proc. Roy. Soc. 57, 481–8.

53.

Siegel

(1956). Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences. New York.

54.

Tuttle

W. W.

Janney

C. D.

Wilkerson

Jr. Imig

C. J.

(1951). Effect of exercises of graded intensity on neuro-muscular tremor as measured by a strain gauge technique. J. appl. Physiol. 3, 732–5.

55.

Van Buskirk

Fink

R. A.

(1962). Physiologic tremor: An experimental study. Neurology 12, 361–70.