The catastrophic earthquake of January 2010 deepened the socio-cultural fault lines and disparities that define Haitian society. Even before, the needs of the population and the prioritisation of intervention were managed by international actors. As a result of societal fragilities and the ineffectiveness of the Haitian state in shoring up community relations and basic services, a proliferation of NGOs has arisen in shanties to organise local groups around short-term programmes. Building on surveys and ethnographic research, this article analyses residents' perceptions of such initiatives to foster peace, reconstruction and development in one of Port-au-Prince's poorest and most violent neighbourhoods. Findings suggest that residents remain sceptical about the peace and development impacts of the proliferation of scattered, foreign-driven and unsustainable interventions in Cité Soleil.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BaranyiS. (2011). Cooperation for Reconstruction, Peace and Transformation in Haiti?. Journal of Peacebuilding and Development6, 3this issue.
2.
BeckerD. (2011). Gangs, Netwar, and “Community Counterinsurgency” Haiti?. PRISM2, 3Special Issue: Cooperation for Reconstruction, Peace and Transformation in Haiti137–154.
3.
BeckerD.Grossman-VermaasR. (2010). Metrics for the Haiti Stabilisation Initiative. PRISM2, 2145–158.
4.
BercovichD. (2007)., ‘Less Guns, More Peace in Haiti.’, interview with Alix Fils-Aimé, Director, CNDDR, Communidade Segura, 31 August: www.comunidadesegura.org.br/?q=en/node/36020, accessed 21 October 2011.
5.
BurkleF. (2010). Future of Humanitarian Crises: Challenges for Practice, Policy, and Public Health. Prehospital and Disaster Medicine25, 3Special Issue: Cooperation for Reconstruction, Peace and Transformation in Haiti191–199.
6.
ChandlerD.HynekN. (2011). Introduction. Critical Perspectives on Human Security: Rethinking Emancipation and Power in International RelationsChandlerD.HynekN.New York: Routledge1–11.
7.
CNDDR (Commission Nationale de Désarmement, de Démantèlement et de Réinsertion)Evaluation ReportPort-au-Prince September 2011.
8.
DupuyA. (2007). The Prophet and Power: Jean-Bertrand Aristide, The International Community, and HaitiLanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
9.
ForstM. (2009). Report of the Independent Expert on the Situation of Human Rights in Haiti UN Doc. A/HRC/11/5 26 March.
10.
INURED (Interuniversity Institute for Research and Development) (2010a). Voices from the Shanties: A Post-Earthquake Assessment of Cité Soleil, Port-au-Prince, Haiti., research report, March, Portau-Prince: http://inured.org/docs/Voices%20from%20the%20Shanties_INURED2010.pdf; 2010b. Violence and Stabilization Process in Port-au-Prince, Haiti: An Evaluation of the International Effort to Stabilize Haiti, Phase III (Cité Soleil)., research report, May, Port-au-Prince.
11.
Logos TechnologiesINURED (2010). Haiti Stabilization Initiative Monitoring & Evaluation Final Report Phase 3 Assessment of Progress in Cité SoleilWashington, DC: Logos Technologies June research report.
12.
MaguireR. (2011). Goodbye to “Pixie Dust”? A New U.S. Development Strategy in Haiti. Journal of Peacebuilding and Development6, 3this issue.
13.
MarcelinL.PageB.SingerM.LauroreR.ShethA. (2008a). The Impact of International Aid in the Life of Cité Soleil InhabitantsPort-au-Prince: INURED research report.
14.
MarcelinL.GardellaA.LauroreR.VivianJ. (2008b). Violence and Stabilization Process in Cité SoleilPort-au-Prince: INURED research report.
15.
MarcelinL.LauroreR.Nang-YadR.HermantinC.PeterlyR.Petit-HommeS.LouisJ.LouisS. (2009). Urban Crime and Violence in Port-au-Prince, Haiti: A Study of Two Neighborhoods in Cité SoleilPort-au-Prince: INURED research report.
16.
MuggahR. (2010). The Effects of Stabilization on Humanitarian Action in Haiti. Disasters34, s3S444–S463.
17.
MunckR. (2010). Critical Development Theory: Results and Prospects. Migración y Desarrollo14, 33–52.
18.
ShamsieY. (2011). Pro-poor Economic Development Aid to Haiti: Unintended Effects Arising from the Conflict-Development Nexus. Journal of Peacebuilding and Development6, 3this issue.
19.
SmuckerG.PierreY.TardieuJ. (2009). Human Rights Violation in Haitian Cities: A Household Prevalence SurveyPort-au-Prince: Pan American Development Foundation43–44.
20.
Thomas-LakeH.BergF.CalpasE. (2010). Strategies Haiti Conflict Vulnerability Assessment. USAID reportWashington, DC.
21.
WillmanA.MarcelinL. (2010). If They Could Make Us Disappear, They Would! Youth and Violence in Cité Soleil, Haiti. Journal of Community Psychology38, 4515–531.
22.
ZanottiL. (2010). Cacophonies of Aid, Failed State Building and NGOs in Haiti: Setting the Stage for Disaster, Envisioning the Future. Third World Quarterly31, 5755–771.
