This article explores the nature of the relationship between Health as a Bridge for Peace (HBP) projects and the political contexts in which they are implemented. HBP projects derive from the intersections of the health and conflict fields, which may be formulated in one of two ways: the effect of the conflict on the practice of health care; and/or the use of the health field in the transformation of conflict. Projects carried out under the ‘health as a bridge for peace’ banner encompass a wide range of goals, target populations and project components, which vary based on factors such as local conditions and the initiating party. This paper offers two typologies for understanding HBP projects. It shows that while HBP projects are not a substitute for political processes, the relationships and the values they generate can serve as an important bridge during periods of conflict when the political processes are at their weakest point.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BarneaT.AbdeenZ.GarberR.BarghuthyF.QleiboM.HabibJ.DkeidekS.YuvalD.AboulafiaM. (2000). Israeli-Palestinian Cooperation in the Health Field, 1994–1998. Study ReportJDC-Brookdale Institute, JDC-Israel, AJJDC & Al Quds University Also available www.jdc.org.il/jdcisr.
2.
Separate and Cooperate, Cooperate and Separate: The Disengagement of the Palestine Health Care System from Israel and its Emergence as an Independent SystemBarneaT.HusseiniR.Stanford, Conn: Greenwood/Praeger Publishing House2002.
3.
Economic Cooperation Foundation (ECF)Palestine Council of Health (PCH)Building Bridges Through Health: PCH-ECF Health, Medicine and Social Welfare Cooperation 1998 ReportTel-Aviv: ECF-PCH1999.
4.
GarberR.MashalJ.SugarmanK. (2002). Serving Palestinian Children with Disabilities: Child Development Program (CDP) Idna Village, 1999–2001, Final Project ReportAJJDC (JDC-Israel, JDC-Brookdale Institute), Union of Palestinian Medical Relief Committees, Palestinian-Israeli Health Care Group.
5.
GarberR., MannorH., BarneaT. (2000)., 1998, The Role of Health Professionals in Promoting Cooperation in Conflict Areas — Literature Reviews for Study of Israeli-Palestinian Cooperation in the Health Field, 1994–1998, JDC-Brookdale Institute, JDC-Israel, AJJDC and Al Quds University [Internal Document].
6.
GreenawayS. (1999)., ‘Post-modern conflict and humanitarian action: Questioning the paradigm.’, The Journal of Humanitarian Assistance. [Online], Available: http://www.jha.ac/articles/a053.htm Accessed 31 Dec 1997.
7.
GutloveP. (1999). Health bridges for peace: Integrating health care with conflict prevention and community reconciliation. Training to Promote Conflict Management: USIPAssisted Training ProjectsSmockD.Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace11–16.
8.
Institute for Multi-Track Diplomacy (IMTD) (2000)., Washington, DC. [Online], http://www.imtd.org.
9.
International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)Press ReleaseGeneva21 December20002000.
10.
MachelG. (1996)., Impact of Armed Conflict on Children, UNICEF. [Online], Available: http://www.unicef.org/graca Accessed 31 Dec 2000.
11.
MacraeJ. (1998)., ‘Purity or political engagement?: Issues in food and health security interventions in complex political emergencies.’, The Journal of Humanitarian Assistance. [Online]. Available: http://www.jha.ac/articles/a037.htm Accessed 31 Dec 2000.
12.
MannJ., DrukerE., TaratolaD., McCabeM. P (1994)., ‘Bosnia: The war against public health.’, Medicine and Global Survival. [Online], Available: http://www.ippnw.org/MGS/V1N3Mann.html Accessed 15 Jan 2001.
13.
Medicins du MondeA Case by Case Analysis of Recent Crises Assessing 20 Years of Humanitarian ActionParis1999[Working Paper].
14.
Pan-American Health Organization (1991). Health and Peace For Development and Democracy. Report on Central American Health InitiativeMadrid: Third Madrid Conference, PAHO/PPSCAP.
15.
PughM. (1998)., ‘Post-conflict rehabilitation: Social and civil dimensions.’, The Journal of Humanitarian Assistance. [Online] Available: http://www.jha.ac/articles/a034.htm, 23 November 2000.
16.
SaltmanR. B. (2002). The transition of the Palestinian health care system: An international perspective. Separate and Cooperate, Cooperate and Separate: The Disengagement of the Palestine Health Care System from Israel and its Emergence as an Independent SystemBarneaT.Husseini edsR.Stanford, Conn: Greenwood/Praeger Publishing House.
17.
SaricM., RodwinV. G. (1993)., The Once and Future Health System in the Former Yugoslavia: Myths and Realities. [Online] Available: http://www.nyu.edu/projects/rodwin/future.html Accessed 28 Jan 2001.
18.
TardifF. (1998)., ‘Building a bridge for peace or servicing complex political emergencies: A study of the case of the health humanitarian programs in Haiti, 1991–1994.’, in Research and Development — Health as a Bridge for Peace, WHO. [Online] Available: http://www.who.int/eha/ Accessed 27 Dec 1999.
19.
van der HeijdenT. (1997)., ‘Health care between war and peace: An exploration of issues and strategies.’, in Research and Development — Health as a Bridge for Peace. [Online] Available: http://www.who.int/eha/trares/hbp/hnet/index.htm Accessed 27 Nov 2000.
20.
World Health Organization (WHO) (2000)., ‘Annex 1 — Guiding principles: Health in relief and development.’ in Health Strategic Response: Relief, Rehabilitation and Development. [Online] Available: http://who.int/eha/trates/hsr/annex1.htm Accessed 2 Oct 2000.
21.
WHOHealth Coordination in Emergencies: Options For The Role of WHOGeneva: WHO1998aConcept Paper on Health Coordination in Emergencies.
22.
WHOMeeting on Strategic Response in Health, Relief and Development. Report on Strategic Responses in HealthGeneva: WHO/HQ1998b.
23.
WHO (1997a)., ‘Report on the First World Health Organization Consultative Meeting on Health as a Bridge for Peace.’, Les Pensierses, Annecy, 30–31 October 1997 in Research and Development — Health as a Bridge for Peace. [Online] Available: Http://www.who.int/eha/trares/hbp/annecy.htm. Accessed: 27 Dec 1999.
24.
WHO (1997b). Consultation on Applied Health Research Priorities in Complex Emergencies. Report on Complex Health EmergenciesGeneva: WHO/EHA.
25.
WHOSummary Record on EHA Consultation With Donors and Collaborating Agencies on the Role of WHO in Complex EmergenciesGeneva: WHO/EHA1997c.
