The present article reports evidence from human subjects that high payoff for instrumental performance may cause reduced vigour of response compared to the vigour observed for lower payoffs. Vigour of response, as measured by force of pressing (Experiment 1) and number of fortune wheel turns (Experiment 2), was inversely related to payoffs, with higher vigour in the low payoff conditions. Experiment 2 further demonstrated this effect, regardless of whether or not payoff depended on performance. These findings are related to parallel animal data, and an analysis in terms of a learned incentive-effort hypothesis is offered. Experiment 3 presented support for this hypothesis. The results are argued to be of importance to the understanding of how reinforcers affect human instrumental performance.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmselA. (1958). The role of frustrative nonreward in noncontinuous reward situations.Psychological Bulletin55, 102–118.
2.
AmselA.SurridgeC. T.HugJ. J. (1969). Number of food pellets and the partial reinforcement extinction effect after extended acquisition.Journal of Experimental Psychology82, 578–580.
3.
BanduraA. (1977). Social learning theoryEnglewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
4.
BemD. J. (1972). Self-perception theory. In BerkowitzL. (Ed.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 6New York: Academic Press.
5.
BittermanM. E.SchoelW. M. (1970). Instrumental learning in animals: Parameters of reinforcement.Annual Review of Psychology21, 367–436.
6.
BlackR. W. (1969). Incentive motivation and the parameters of reward in instrumental conditioning. In ArnoldW. J.LevineD. (Eds), Nebraska Symposium on MotivationLincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.
7.
BlackR. W.ElstadP. (1964). Instrumental and consummatory behavior as a function of length of reward period.Psychonomic Science1, 301–302.
8.
BoyagianL. G.NationJ. R. (1981). The effect of force training and reinforcement schedules on human performance.American Journal of Psychology94, 619–632.
9.
BrehmJ. W.CohenA. R. (1962). Explorations in cognitive dissonanceNew York: Wiley.
10.
BrenerJ.MitchellS. (1989). Changes in energy expenditure and work during response acquisition in rats.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes15, 166–175.
11.
ClitesM. S. (1936). Certain somatic activities in relation to successful and unsuccessful problem solving: III.Journal of Experimental Psychology19, 172–192.
12.
CrespiL. P. (1942). Quantitative variation of incentive and performance in the white rat.American Journal of Psychology55, 467–517.
13.
DavisR. C. (1938). The relation of muscle action potentials to difficulty and frustration.Journal of Experimental Psychology23, 141–158.
14.
DiggoryJ. C.KleinS. J.CohenM. (1964). Muscle action potentials and estimated probability of success.Journal of Experimental Psychology68, 449–455.
15.
Di LolloV.EnsmingerW. D.NottermanJ. M. (1965). Response force as a function of amount of reinforcement.Journal of Experimental Psychology70, 27–31.
16.
DitkoffG.LeyR. (1974). Effects of positive and negative force-contingent reinforcement on the frustration effect.Journal of Experimental Psychology102, 818–823.
17.
EisenbergerR. (1989). Can response force be shaped by reinforcement?Perceptual and Motor Skills68, 725–726.
EisenbergerR.AdornettoM. (1986). Generalized self-control of delay and effort.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology51, 1020–1031.
20.
EisenbergerR.HeerdtW. A.HamdiM.ZimetS.BruckmeirG. (1979). Transfer of persistence across behaviors.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory5, 522–530.
21.
EstesW. K. (1988). Human learning and memory. In AtkinsonR. C.HerrnsteinR. J.LindzeyG.Duncan LuceR. (Eds), Steven's handbook of experimental psychology, second ed. New York: Wiley.
22.
FestingerL. (1954). A theory of social comparison processes.Human Relations7, 117–140.
23.
FestingerL.CarlsmithJ. M. (1959). Cognitive consequences of forced compliance.Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology58, 203–210.
24.
FreedmanJ. L.CunninghamJ. A.KrismerK. (1992). Inferred values and the reverse-incentive effect in induced compliance.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology62, 357–368.
25.
GoodrichK. P. (1959). Performance in different segments of an instrumental chain as a function of reinforcement schedule.Journal of Experimental Psychology57, 57–63.
26.
HearstE. (1988). Fundamentals of learning and conditioning. In AtkinsonR. C.HerrnsteinR. J.LindzeyG.Duncan LuceR. (Eds), Steven's handbook of experimental psychology, second ed. New York: Wiley.
27.
KilleenP. R. (1979). Arousal: Its genesis, modulation, and extinction. In ZeilerM. D.HarzemP. (Eds), Advances in analysis of behaviour: Volume 1, Reinforcement and the organization of behaviourChichester: Wiley.
28.
KilleenP. R.AmselA. (1987). The kinematics of locomotion towards a goal.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes13, 92–101.
29.
KirkpatrickM. A.FowlerS. C. (1989). Operant force-band differentiation by rats using two different response topographies.Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society27, 52–54.
30.
LangerE. (1975). The illusion of control.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology32, 311–328.
31.
LepperM. R.GreeneD. (1978). The hidden cost of reward: New perspectives on the psychology of human motivationHillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
32.
LepperM. R.GreeneD.NisbettR. E. (1973). Undermining children's intrinsic interest with extrinsic rewards: A test of the overjustification hypothesis.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology23, 129–137.
33.
LoganF. A. (1960). IncentiveNew Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
34.
LoweC. F. (1979). Determinants of human operant behaviour. In ZeilerM. D.HarzemP. (Eds), Advances in analysis of behaviour, Vol. 1: Reinforcement and the organization of behaviourChichester: Wiley.
35.
McCainG. (1969). Different levels of performance with equivalent weights of reward.Psychonomic Science14, 2–3.
36.
McCainG. (1970). Reward magnitude and instrumental responses: Consistent and partial reward.Psychonomic Science19, 139–141.
37.
MackintoshN. J. (1974). The psychology of animal learningLondon: Academic Press.
38.
MeltzerD.BrahlekJ. A. (1968). Quantity of reinforcement and fixed-interval performance.Psychonomic Science12, 207–208.
39.
NavonD.GopherD. (1979). On the economy of the human-processing system.Psychological Review86, 214–255.
40.
NottermanJ. M.MintzD. E. (1965). Dynamics of responseNew York: Wiley.
41.
PishkinV. (1973). Electromyography in cognitive performance by schizophrenics and normals.Perceptual and Motor Skills37, 382.
42.
PishkinV.ShurleyJ. T. (1968). Electrodermal and electromyographic parameters in concept identification.Psychophysiology5, 112–118.
43.
PubolsB. H.Jr. (1960). Incentive magnitude, learning and performance in animals.Psychological Bulletin57, 89–115.
44.
RescherN. (1970). On the characterization of actions. In BrandM. (Ed.), The nature of human actionGlenview, IL: Scott, Foresman & Co.
45.
RosenfeldH. M. (1982). Measurement of body motion and orientation. In SchererK. R.EkmanP. (Eds), Handbook of methods in nonverbal behavior resarchCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
46.
SchachterS. (1959). The psychology of affiliationStanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
47.
SchererK. R. (1982). Methods of research on vocal communication: Paradigms and parameters. In SchererK. R.EkmanP. (Eds), Handbook of methods in nonverbal behavior researchCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
48.
SchererK. R.EkmanP. (Eds), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press1982.
49.
ShanksD.DickinsonA. (1991). Instrumental judgement and performance under variations in action-outcome contingency and contiguity.Memory and Cognition19, 353–360.
50.
StaddonJ. E. R. (1977). Schedule-induced behavior. In HonigW. K.StaddonJ. E. R. (Eds), Handbook of operant behaviorEnglewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
51.
SvartdalF. (1989). Shaping of rule-governed behaviour.Scandinavian Journal of Psychology30, 304–314.
52.
SvartdalF. (1991). Operant modulation of rule-governed behavior by nonverbal contingencies.Learning and Motivation22, 406–420.
53.
SvartdalF. (in press). Sensitivity to nonverbal operant contingencies: Do limited processing resources affect operant conditioning in humans?Learning and Motivation..
54.
SvartdalF.MortensenT. (submitted). Effect of reinforcer value on sensitivity to nonverbal operant contingencies in humans.
55.
VallacherR. R.WegnerD. M. (1987). What do people think they are doing? Action identification and human behavior.Psychological Review94, 3–15.
56.
WagnerA. R. (1961). Effects of amount and percentage of reinforcement and number of acquisition trials on conditioning and extinction.Journal of Experimental Psychology62, 234–242.
57.
WassermanE. A.NeunaberD. J. (1986). College students’ responding to and rating of contigency relations: The role of temporal contiguity.Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior46, 15–35.
58.
WeardenJ. H. (1988). Some neglected problems in the analysis of human operant behavior. In DaveyG. C. L. (Ed.), Human operant conditioning and behavior modificationChichester: Wiley197–224.
