Improvement,Learning and Retention of Skill at Visual Search

Abstract

Three experiments examined factors responsible for improvement in visual search. In Experiment I three groups of subjects were each trained for 3000 trials to search for a particular set of target letters among a particular set of background letters. After intervals of 2, 4, or 6 weeks without further practice they were re-tested, either with the same displays or on new displays which they searched for the same target items among new background items. Negative transfer suggested that memory for specific cue-systems distinguishing target from background letters is retained for as long as 4 weeks.

Experiment II examined performance of three very highly practised subjects. After 25 days practice, variations in the size of the target set no longer affected search time. This could not be explained by learning of specific cue systems, since after this amount of practice subjects showed perfect transfer to displays which they searched for the same target items among new background items. Experiment III suggested that practised subjects achieve this high level of competence by learning to make two independent successive decisions, first to locate any member of the target set on the display and next to identify which particular member of the target set has been located.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Brand

(1971). Classification without identification in visual search. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 23, 178–86.

Crossman

E. R. F. W.

(1956). The information-capacity of the human operator in symbolic and non-symbolic control processes. In Draper

(Ed.), The Application of Information Theory to Human Operator Problems W.R. (D) Report No. 2/56 Ministry of Supply.

Crossman

E. R. F. W.

(1959). A theory of acquisition of speed-skill. Ergonomics 2, 153–66.

Duncan

(1976). Association and Decision: S-R compatibility in choice reaction tasks Unpublished D. Phil thesis, University of Oxford.

Duncan

(1977). Response selection rules in spatial choice reaction tasks. In Dornic

(Ed.), Attention and Performance VI. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Potomac Md. U.S.A.

Gleitman

Jonides

(1976). The cost of categorisation in visual search; Incomplete processing of target and field items. Perception and Psychophysics 20, 281–8.

Ingling

N. W.

(1971). Categorisation: A mechanism for rapid information processing. Journal of Experimental Psychology 94, 239–43.

Jonides

Gleitman

(1972). A conceptual category effect in visual search: O as a letter or as a digit. Perception and Psychophysics 1, 172–4.

Jonides

Gleitman

(1976). The benefit of categorisation in visual search: Target localisation without identification. Perception and Psychophyiscs 20, 289–98.

10.

Kaplan

I. T.

Carvellas

(1965). Scanning for multiple targets. Perceptual and Motor Skills 21, 239–43.

11.

Kaplan

I. T.

Carvellas

Metlav

(1966). Visual search and immediate memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology 71, 488–93.

12.

Kristofferson

(1977). The effects of practice with one positive set in a memory scanning task can be completely transferred to a new set. Memory and Cognition 5, 177–86.

13.

Mowbray

G. H.

Rhoades

M. V.

(1959). On the reduction of choice reaction time with practice. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 11, 16–23.

14.

Neisser

(1963). Decision time without reaction time: Experiments in visual scanning. American Journal of Psychology 76, 376–85.

15.

Neisser

Novick

Lazar

(1963). Searching for ten targets simultaneously. Perceptual and Motor Skills 17, 955–61.

16.

Nickerson

R. S.

Feehrer

C. E.

(1964). Stimulus categorisation and response time. Perceptual and Motor Skills 18, 785–93.

17.

Pollack

(1963). Speed of classification of words into superordinate categories. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behaviour 2, 159–65.

18.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

(1959). Effects of independent variations in stimulus and response probability. Nature, London 183, 1212.

19.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

(1962). Stimulus discrimination and the choice of responses England: University of Cambridge Unpublished Ph.D. thesis.

20.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

(1964). Ignoring irrelevant information. British Journal of Psychology 55, 403–14.

21.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

(1966). In Vinozdrova

O. S.

Noroselova

V. V.

(Eds), (Proceedings of XVIII International Congress of Psychology Moscow.

22.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

(1967). Ignoring irrelevant information. American Journal of Psychology 80, 1–13.

23.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

Vyas

S. M.

(1970). An elementary preliminary taxonomy for errors in choice reaction time tasks. Acta Psychologia 33, 56–76.

24.

Sperling

Budianski

Spivak

J. E.

Johnson

M. C.

(1971). Extremely rapid visual search: the maximum rate of scanning letters for the presence of a numeral. Science 174, 307–10.

25.

Sternberg

(1975). Memory scanning. New findings and current controversies. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 27, 1–32.

26.

Wattenbarger

B. L.

(1968). Speed and accuracy set in visual search performance. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis University of Michigan.