An experiment is reported which attempts to demonstrate the effects of manipulating two linguistic variables on a propositional reasoning task, one relating to the linguistic form of the logical rule, and the other to the presence and absence of negative components. The results are discussed in relation to Evans' (1972a) distinction between interpretational and operational factors in reasoning. Problems arising from the application of this distinction are discussed in detail.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BreeD. S. (1973). The interpretation of implication. In ElithornA.JonesD. (Eds), Artificial and Human ThinkingAmsterdam: Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co.
2.
ClarkH. H.ChaseW. G. (1972). On the process of comparing sentences against pictures. Cognitive Psychology3, 472–517.
3.
EvansJ. St. B. T. (1972a). On the problems of interpreting reasoning data: logical and psychological approaches. Cognition1, 373–84.
4.
EvansJ. St. B. T. (1972b). Interpretation and matching bias in a reasoning task. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology24, 193–99.
5.
EvansJ. St. B. T. (1972c). Reasoning with negatives. British Journal of Psychology63, 213–9.
6.
EvansJ. St. B. T. (1973). TRANSFORM: a program to select a suitable transformation for the analysis of variance. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology26, 124.
7.
EvansJ. St. B. T. (1975). On interpreting reasoning data—a reply to Van Duyne. Cognition3, 387–90.
8.
EvansJ. St. B. T.LynchJ. S. (1973). Matching bias in the selection task. British Journal of Psychology64, 391–7.
9.
EvansJ. St. B. T.WasonP. C. (1976). Rationalization in a reasoning task. British Journal of Psychology (in press).
10.
LegrenziP. (1970). Relations between language and reasoning about deductive rules. In D'ArcaisG. B. F.LeveltW. J. M. (Eds), Advances in PsycholinguisticsAmsterdam, London: North Holland.
11.
RobergeJ. J. (1971). Some effects of negation on adults' conditional reasoning abilities. Psychological Reports29, 839–44.
12.
RobergeJ. J. (1974). Effects of negation of adults' comprehension of fallacious conditional and disjunctive arguments. Journal of General Psychology91, 287–93.
13.
StaudenmayerH. (1975). Understanding conditional reasoning with meaningful propositions. In FalmagneR. J. (Ed.), Reasoning: Representation and ProcessNew York: Wiley.
14.
Van DuyneP. C. (1973). A short note on Evans' criticism of reasoning experiments and his matching bias hypothesis. Cognition2, 239–42.
15.
Van DuyneP. C. (1974). Realism and linguistic complexity. British Journal of Psychology65, 59–67.
16.
WasonP. C.EvansJ. St. B. T. (1975). Dual processes in reasoning?Cognition3, 141–54.
