Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The blank trials technique introduced by Levine (1966) has been of considerable importance in the study of concept identification and human discrimination learning, as it provides a means of identifying the hypotheses generating choice responses. However, this technique involves the interpolation between normal feedback trials of several trials during which no feedback concerning the correctness of a subject's responses is given.

An experiment was conducted to study the comparability of concept identification with and without blank trials. No differences in trials to criterion, number of errors, or in presolution latencies were observed. These results tend to justify inferences about normal concept identification from blank trial data, and they also have some implications concerning the role of memory in concept identification.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bower

Trabasso

(1964). Concept identification. In Atkinson

R. C.

(Ed.), Studies in Mathematical Psychology, pp. 32–94. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Coltheart

(1972). The effects of acoustic and semantic similarity on concept identification. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 24, 55–65.

Edwards

A. L.

(1968). Experimental Design in Psychological Research New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

Erickson

J. R.

(1968). Hypothesis sampling in concept identification. Journal of Experimental Psychology 76, 12–8.

Erickson

J. R.

Zajowski

M. M.

Ehmann

E. D.

(1966). All-or-none assumptions in concept identification: Analysis of latency data. Journal of Experimental Psychology 72, 690–7.

Levine

(1966). Hypothesis behaviour by humans during discrimination learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology 71, 331–8.

Levine

(1969). Neo-noncontinuity theory. The Psychology of Learning and Motivation Bower

G. H.

Spence

J. T.

New York: Academic Press Volume 3, 101–134.

Levine

Leitenberg

Richter

(1964). The blank trials law: The equivalence of positive reinforcement and nonreinforcement. Psychological Review 71, 94–103.

Levine

Miller

Steinmeyer

C. H.

(1967). The none-to-all theorem of human discrimination learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology 73, 568–73.

10.

Restle

(1962). The selection of strategies in cue learning. Psychological Review 69, 329–43.

11.

Smoke

K. L.

(1932). An objective study of concept formation. Psychological Monographs 42, No. 4.

12.

Trabasso

Bower

(1964). Presolution reversal and dimensional shifts in concept identification. Journal of Experimental Psychology 67, 398–9.

13.

Trabasso

Bower

(1966). Presolution dimensional shifts in concept identification: a test of the sampling with replacement axiom in all-or-none models. Journal of Mathematical Psychology 3, 163–73.

14.

Trabasso

Bower

(1968). Attention in Learning New York: Wiley.

Concept Identification with and without Blank Trials †

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References