Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Acetyl Triethyl Citrate,Acetyl Tributyl Citrate,Acetyl Trihexyl Citrate,and Acetyl Trioctyl Citrate

Abstract

Acetyl Triethyl Citrate, Acetyl Tributyl Citrate, Acetyl Trihexyl Citrate, and Acetyl Trioctyl Citrate all function as plasticizers in cosmetics. Additionally, the Trihexyl and Trioctyl forms are described as skin-conditioning agents—emollients, although there are currently no reported uses of Acetyl Trihexyl Citrate or Acetyl Trioctyl Citrate. Acetyl Triethyl Citrate and Acetyl Tributyl Citrate are used in nail products at concentrations up to 7%. Recognizing that there are no reported uses of Acetyl Trihexyl or Trioctyl Citrate, if they were to be used in the future, their concentration of use is expected to be no higher than that reported for Acetyl Triethyl and Tributyl Citrate. These ingredients were sufficiently similar in structure that safety test data on one were considered applicable to all. Approximately 99% of orally administered Acetyl Tributyl Citrate is excreted—intermediate metabolites include acetyl citrate, monobutyl citrate, acetyl monobutyl citrate, dibutyl citrate, and acetyl dibutyl citrate. In acute, short-term, subchronic, and chronic feeding studies, these ingredients were relatively nontoxic. Differences from controls were either not statistically significant or not related to any organ toxicity. Ocular exposures produced moderate reactions that cleared by 48 hours after instillation. Dermal application was not toxic in rabbits. In a guinea pig maximization test, Acetyl Triethyl Citrate was a sensitizer whereas Acetyl Tributyl Citrate was not. Limited clinical testing of Acetyl Triethyl Citrate and Acetyl Tributyl Citrate was negative for both skin irritation and sensitization. These clinical data were considered more relevant than the guinea pig maximization data, suggesting to the Cosmetic Ingredient Review Expert Panel that none of these ingredients would be a sensitizer. Physiologic effects noted with intravenous delivery of Acetyl Triethyl Citrate or Acetyl Tributyl Citrate include dose-related decreases in blood pressure and intestinal muscular spasms. These ingredients were not genotoxic in bacterial or mammalian test systems. No significant differences in tumor induction (lymphomas) were noted in rats fed Acetyl Tributyl Citrate for 2 year. Acetyl Tributyl Citrate was not a developmental or reproductive toxicant in studies in mice and rats. Based on all the available data, these ingredients were considered safe as used in cosmetics.

References

Ames, B. N.

J. McCann

, and

E. Yamasaki

1975. Methods for detecting carcinogens and mutagens with the Salmonella/mammalian-microsome mutagenicity test. Mutat. Res.31:347–364.2

Beilstein File of Organic Compounds (Beilstein)

. 1998. Acetyl Triethyl Citrate and Acetyl Tributyl Citrate Entries. Beilstein database. Columbus, OH: Scientific and Technical Information Network (STN) International.

Bodmeier, R.

, and

O. Paeratakul

. 1997. Plasticizer uptake by aqueous colloidal polymer dispersions used for the coating of solid dosage forms. Int. J. Pharm.152:17–26.

Castle, L.

J. Gilbert

S. M. Jickells

, and

J. W. Gramshaw

1988. Analysis of the plasticiser acetyltributyl citrate in foods by stable isotope dilution gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. J. Chromatogr.437:281–286.

Chemical Carcinogenesis Research Information System (CCRIS).

1998. Acetyl Tributyl Citrate Entry. CCRIS database. Bethesda, MD: National Library of Medicine.

Chemical Identification (ChemID®).

1998. Acetyl Trioctyl Citrate entry. ChemID® database. Bethesda, MD: National Library of Medicine.

CRC handbook of data on organic compounds (HODOC)

. 1998. Acetyl Triethyl Citrate and Acetyl Tributyl Citrate Entries. HODOC database. Columbus, OH: STN International.

Cosmetic, Toiletry, and Fragrance Association (CTFA). 1982a. CP-61,838 (Citroflex A-6). Acute dermal toxicity and dermal and ocular irritation studies in rabbits. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (6 pages.)2

CTFA. 1982b. Genetic toxicology report. CP-61,838 (Citroflex A-6)—Citrate ester plasticizer. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (17 pages.)2

10.

CTFA. 1998a. Acetyl tributyl citrate dossier for evaluation. (Prepared for the ATBC Industry Group by Toxicology International—date not given.) Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (23 pages.)2

11.

CTFA. 1998b. Eye and dermal irritation of Citroflex A-2 and Citroflex A-4. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4 1998. (2 pages.)2

12.

CTFA. 1999a. Concentration of use data on acetyl triethyl citrate and acetyl tributyl citrate from industry survey. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, April 29, 1999. (1 page.)2

13.

CTFA. 1999b. Acetyl tributyl Citrate: Purity requirements, information on toxicology, human experience and information on environmental aspects—no date given. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, June 2, 1999. (2 pages.)2

14.

Ekwall, B.

1980. Toxicity to HeLa cells of 205 drugs as determined by the metabolic inhibition test supplemented by microscopy. Toxicology17:279–295.

15.

Ekwall, B.

C. Nordenstein

, and

L. Albanus

1982. Toxicity of 29 plasticizers to HeLa cells in the MIT-24 system. Toxicology24:199–210.

16.

European Commission. 2002. The rules governing cosmetic products in the European Union. Volume 1. Cosmetics legislation—cosmetic products. Accessed January 9, 2002. http://dg3.eudra.org./F3/home.html.

17.

Finklestein, M.

, and

H. Gold

. 1959. Toxicology of the citric acid esters: Tributyl citrate, acetyl tributyl citrate, triethyl citrate, and acetyl triethyl citrate. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol.1:283–298.

18.

Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

1992. Modification in voluntary filing of cosmetic product ingredient and cosmetic raw material composition statements. Federal Register57:3128–3130.

19.

FDA.

1998. Frequency of use of cosmetic ingredients. FDA database. Washington, DC: FDA.

20.

Fouda, H. G. 1982. Safety assessment of citroflex plasticizers—In vitro hydrolysis by serum, liver and intestinal enzymes. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (31 pages.)2

21.

Gold, H., W. Modell, and M. Finklestein. 1998. Report to Charles Pfizer and Company on the pharmacology of triethyl, acetyl triethyl, tributyl, and acetyl tributyl citrate by oral administration in rats and cats—no date given. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (31 pages.)2

22.

Gutierrez-Rocca, J. C.

, and

J. W. McGinity

. 1994. Influence of water soluble and insoluble plasticizers on the physical and mechanical properties of acrylic resin copolymers. Int. J. Pharm.103:293–301.

23.

Hazardous Substances Databank (HSDB).

1998. Acetyl Tributyl Citrate entry. HSDB database. Bethesda, MD: National Library of Medicine.

24.

Heath, J. L.

, and

M. Reilly

. 1981. Mutagenesis testing of acetyl-tributylcitrate and epoxidized soybean oil. Poult. Sci.61:2517–2519.

25.

Hill Top Research, Inc. 1978. Repeated insult patch test on Citroflex 2 liquid, Citroflex A-2 liquid, and Citroflex A-4 liquid. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (3 pages.)2

26.

Hollingsworth, M.

1975. Pharmacological properties of the plasticizer, acetyl n-tributyl citrate, and its extraction from poly(vinyl chloride) tubing. J. Biomed. Mater. Res.9:687–697.

27.

Japan Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare (MHLW). 2000. Notification No. 990. MHLW, Parmaceutical and Medical Safety Bureau, Inspection and Guidance Division, Tokyo: Japan.

28.

Larionov, A. G., and T. E. Cherkasova. 1998. Safety evaluation of acetyl tributyl citrate—no date given. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (5 pages.)2

29.

Lewis, R. J., Sr.

, ed. 1993. Hawley's condensed chemical dictionary, 12th ed., 14–15, 286. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.

30.

MSDS-OHS.

1998. Acetyl Tributyl Citrate entry. MSDS-OHS database. Columbus, OH: STN International.

31.

Meyers, D. B.

J. Autian

, and

W. L. Guess

1964. Toxicity of plastics used in medical practice II. Toxicity of citric acid esters used as plasticizers. J. Pharm. Sci.53:774–777.

32.

Mochida, K.

M. Gomyoda

, and

T. Fujita

1996. Acetyl tributyl citrate and dibutyl sebacate inhibit the growth of cultured mammalian cells. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol.56:635–637.

33.

Morflex, Inc. 1998. Citroflex® citric acid esters. Technical bulletin 101. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (15 pages.)2

34.

Nikitakis, J. M.

, and

G. N. McEwen, Jr.

, eds. 1990. CTFA compendium of cosmetic ingredient composition—descriptions I.Washington, DC: CTFA.

35.

Pfannhauser, W.

R. Eberhardt

, and

H. Woidich

1982. Some examples for the identification of artificial flavors in food. Recent Dev. Food Anal. Proc. Eur. Conf. Food Chem.1:168–173.

36.

Registry of Toxic Effects of Chemical Substances (RTECS).

1998. Acetyl Triethyl Citrate and Acetyl Tributyl Citrate entries. RTECS database. Bethesda, MD: National Library of Medicine.

37.

Soeler, O., M. Clinton, J. Boggs, and P. Drinker. 1998. Chemical characterization data from Charles Pfizer and Co, Inc. Experiments on the chronic toxicity of acetyl tributyl citrate—no date given. Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, December 4, 1998. (17 pages.)2

38.

Thoma, K.

, and

H. Heckenmueller

. 1986. Thin-layer chromatographic detection of plasticizers in enteric coating materials. Part 2: Pharmaceutical and analytical studies of enteric coated dosage forms. Pharmazie41:328–332.

39.

Uniliver Limited. 1976. Sensitization potential of citroflex A2 (acetyl triethyl citrate), citroflex A4 (acetyl tributyl citrate), and citroflex 2 (triethyl citrate). Unpublished data submitted by CTFA, May 12, 1999.2

40.

Wenninger, J. A.

R. C. Canterbery

, and

G. N. McEwen, Jr

. 2000. International cosmetic ingredient dictionary and handbook, 8th ed.Washington, DC: Cosmetic, Toiletry, and Fragrance Association.