This descriptive study investigated two groups of low-income, urban children who had whole-language instruction during their kindergarten and first-grade years. These 17 children were studied previously for those 2 years in their separate schools. The current investigation focused on the general academic success of the two groups and on eight, focal learners' interpretations. In one school, a group of children made a transition to a skills-based/traditional second grade (the Transition Group). In a different school, a group of children continued in a whole-language second grade (the Continuing Group). The children were observed in their classrooms throughout the school year. Data collection included field notes, audio- and videotaping, teacher and parent interviews, and pre- and postmeasures. Findings indicated that the Transition Group had the academic skills necessary for success in the skills-based second grade and that the Continuing Group also succeeded in the whole-language second grade. Differences between the two groups showed that the focal children in the Transition Group experienced a change in their interpretations or sense making patterns and a loss of literate behaviors. Differences in writing favored the focal children in the Continuing Group. Generally, there were no between-group differences in reading growth and no statistical differences on pre- and posttests.
AttwellA. A.OrpetR. E.MeyersC. E. (1967). Kindergarten behavior ratings as predictors of academic achievement. Journal of School Psychology, 6, 43–46.
4.
AndersonL. W.ScottC. C. (1978). The relationship among teaching methods, student characteristics, and student involvement in learning. Journal of Teacher Education, 29, 52–57.
5.
An imperiled generation—saving urban schools. (1988). Princeton, NJ: Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching.
6.
AuK. (1991, December). Cultural responsiveness and the literacy development of minority students. Paper presented at the meeting of the National Reading Conference, Palm Springs, CA.
7.
BarrR. (1972). The influence of instructional conditions on word recognition errors. Reading Research Quarterly, 7, 509–529.
8.
BarrR. (1975). The effect of instruction on pupil reading strategies. Reading Research Quarterly, 10, 555–582.
9.
BloomeD.GreenJ. (1984). Directions in the sociolinguistic study of reading. In PearsonP. D. (Ed.), Handbook of reading research (Vol. 1, pp. 395–422). New York: Longman.
10.
BiemillerA. (1970). The development of the use of graphic and contextual information as children learn to read. Reading Research Quarterly, 6, 75–96.
11.
BondL. G.DykstraR. (1967). The cooperative research program in first-grade reading instruction. Reading Research Quarterly, 20, 5–142.
12.
BurkeC. L. (1980). The reading interview. In FarrB.StricklerD. (Eds.), Reading Comprehension Handbook.Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
13.
BussisA. M.ChittendenE. A.AmarelM.KlausnerE. (1985). Inquiry into meaning.Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
14.
ClayM. M. (1979). The early detection of reading difficulties.Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
15.
CobbJ. A. (1972). Relationship of discrete classroom behaviors to fourth-grade academic achievement. Journal of Educational Psychological, 63, 74–80.
16.
DahlK. L. (1992). Ellen, a deferring learner. In DonmoyerR.KosR. (Eds.), At-risk learners: Policies, programs, and practices (pp. 89–102). Albany: State University of New York Press.
17.
DahlK. L.FrepponP. A. (1991). Literacy learning in whole language classrooms: An analysis of low socioeconomic urban children learning to read and write in kindergarten. In ZutellJ.McCormickS. (Eds.), Learner factors/teacher factors: Issues in literacy research and instruction. Fortieth yearbook of the National Reading Conference (pp. 149–158). Chicago: National Reading Conference.
18.
DahlK. L.FrepponP. A. (1995). A comparison of inner-city children's interpretations of reading and writing instruction in skills-based and whole language classrooms. Reading Research Quarterly, 30, 50–74.
19.
DeFordD. E. (1984). Classroom contexts for literacy learning. In RaphaelT. (Ed.), The contexts of school-based literacy (pp. 163–180). New York: Random House.
20.
DeFordD. E. (1985). Validating the construct of the theoretical orientation in reading instruction. Reading Research Quarterly, 20, 351–367.
21.
DeFordD.LyonsC.PinneelG. (1991). Bridges to literacy.Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
22.
DeLawterJ. A. (1970). Oral reading errors of second grade children exposed to two different reading approaches. Unpublished dissertation. Columbia University, New York.
23.
DurkinD. (1978–1979). What classroom observations reveal about reading comprehension instruction. Reading Research Quarterly, 14, 481–553.
24.
DysonA. H. (1984). Learning to write/learning to do school: Emergent writers' interpretations of school literacy tasks. Research in the Teaching of English, 18, 233–264.
25.
DysonA. H. (1991). Viewpoints: The word and the world—reconceptualizing written language development or do rainbows mean a lot to little girls?Research in the Teaching of English, 25, 97–123.
26.
EdelskyC.AltwergerB.FloresB. (1991). Whole language: What's new? In EdelskyC. (Ed.), With Literacy and justice for all: Rethinking the social in language and education (pp. 96–111). New York: Falmer Press.
27.
EdwardsE.MercerN. (1987). Common knowledge.New York: Methuen.
28.
EricksonF.ShultzJ. (1992). Students' experience of the curriculum. In JacksonP. W. (Ed.), Handbook of research on curriculum (pp. 465–485). New York: Macmillan.
29.
FinchmanF. D.HokodaA.SandersR. (1989). Learned helplessness, test anxiety, and academic achievement: A longitudinal analysis. Child Development, 60, 138–145.
30.
FrepponP. A. (1991). An investigation of children's concepts of the purpose and nature of reading in different instructional settings. Journal of Reading Behavior, 23, 139–163.
31.
FrepponP. A. (1994). Understanding the nature of reading and writing Difficulties: An alternative view. Reading and Writing Quarterly, 10, 227–238.
32.
FinnJ. D. (1989). Withdrawing from school. Review of Educational Research, 59, 117–142.
33.
FinnJ. D.CoxD. (1992). Participation and withdrawal among fourth-grade pupils. American Educational Research Journal, 29, 141–162.
34.
GlaserB. G. (1978). Theoretical Sensitivity.Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press.
35.
GoodmanK. (1986). What's whole in whole language?Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
36.
GoodmanY. M.WatsonD. J.BurkeC. L. (1987). Reading miscue inventory.New York: Richard C. Owen.
37.
GoetzJ. P.LeCompteM. D. (1984). Ethnography and qualitative design in educational research.New York: Academic Press.
38.
GriffinP.ColeM.NewmanD. (1982). Locating tasks in psychology and education. Discourse Processes, 5, 111–125.
39.
HaggertyP. J.HiebertE. H.OwensM. K. (1989). Students' comprehension, writing, and perceptions in two approaches to literacy instruction. In McCormickS.ZutellJ. (Eds.), Cognitive and social perspective for literacy research and instruction. Thirty-eighth yearbook of the National Reading Conference (pp. 453–459). Chicago: National Reading Conference.
40.
HeathS. B. (1983). Ways with words: Language, life, and work in communities and classrooms.New York: Cambridge University Press.
41.
HeathS. B. (1986). Inside learners: Interactive reading in the elementary classroom. (video tape). Palo Alto, CA: Stanford University.
42.
HeathS. B. (1991). The sense of being literate: Historical and cross-cultural features. In BarrR.KamilM. L.MosenthalP.PearsonP. D. (Eds.), Handbook of Reading Research (Vol. 2, pp. 3–25). White Plains, NY: Longman.
43.
HiebertE. H.FisherC. W. (1990). Whole Language: Three themes for the future. Educational Leadership, 47, 62–66.
44.
KnappM. S.ShieldsP. M. (1990). Reconceiving academic instruction for children of poverty. Phi Delta Kappan, 71, 752–758.
45.
Knapp, M. S. & Associates. (1995). Teaching for meaning in high poverty classrooms.New York: Teachers College Press.
46.
MacKinnonA. R. (1959). How do children learn to read?Toronto: Copp Clark.
47.
MartinezM. G.CheyneyM.McBrownC.HemmeterA.TealeW. H. (1989). No risk kindergarten literacy environments for at-risk children. In AllenJ.MasonJ. (Eds.), Risk makers, risk takers, risk breakers (pp. 93–124). Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
48.
McGill-FranzenA.AllingtonR. L. (1991 May/June). The gridlock of low reading achievement: Perspectives on practice and policy. Remedial and Special Education, 12, 20–30.
49.
McIntyreE. (1992a). Young children's reading behaviors in various classroom contexts. Journal of Reading Behavior, 24, 339–371.
50.
McIntyreE. (1992b). Individual literacy instruction for young low-SES learners in traditional urban classrooms. Reading Research and Instruction, 31, 53–63.
51.
McIntyreE.FrepponP.A. (1994) Children's development of alphabetic knowledge in a skills-based classroom and a whole language classrooms. Research in the Teaching of English, 28, 391–417.
52.
MilesM. B.HubermanM. A. (1984). Qualitative data analysis.Beverly Hills, London, New Delhi: Sage Publications.
53.
MorrowL. M. (1992). The impact of a literature-based program on literacy achievement, use of literature, and attitudes of children from minority backgrounds. Reading Research Quarterly, 27, 250–275.
54.
NewkirkT. (1989). More than stories, the range of children's writing.Portsmouth NH: Heinemann.
55.
OldfatherP. (1993). What students say about motivating experiences in a whole language classroom. Reading Teacher, 46, 672–681.
56.
OldfatherP.DahlK. L. (1994). Toward a social constructivists reconceptulization of intrinsic motivation for literacy learning. Journal of Reading Behavior, 26, 139–158.
57.
OldfatherP.McLaughlinJ. (1993). Gaining and losing voice: A longitudinal study of students' continuing impulse to learn across elementary and middle level contexts. Research in Middle Level Education, 17, 2–25.
58.
PoplinM. S. (1988). Holistic/constructivists principles of the teaching/learning processes: Implications for the field of learning disabilities. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 21, 401–416.
59.
PressleyM.Forrest-PressleyD.Elliott-FaustD. J. (1988). What is strategy instructional enrichment and how to study it: Illustrations from research on children's prose memory and comprehension. In WeinertF.PerlmutterM. (Eds.), Memory development: Universal changes and individual development (pp. 101–130). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
60.
PressleyM.GoodchildF.FleetJ.ZajchowskiR.EvansE. D. (1989). The challenges of classroom strategy instruction. Elementary School Journal, 89, 301–333.
61.
Purcell-GatesV. (1988). Lexical and syntactic knowledge of written narrative held by well-read-to kindergartners and second graders. Research in the Teaching of English, 22, 128–160.
62.
Purcell-GatesV. (1989). Written language knowledge held by low-SES, inner-city children entering kindergarten. In McCormickS.ZutellJ. (Eds.), Cognitive and social perspectives for literacy research and instruction. Thirty-ninth yearbook of the National Reading Conference (pp. 95–105). Chicago: National Reading Conference.
63.
Purcell-GatesV.DahlK. L. (1991). Low-SES children's success and failure at early literacy in skills-based classrooms. Journal of Reading Behavior, 23, 1–34.
64.
Purcell-GatesV.McIntyreE.FrepponP. A. (1995). Learning written storybook language in school: A comparison of low-SES children in skills-based and whole language classrooms. American Educational Research Journal, 32, 659–685.
65.
RosenblattL. M. (1989). Writing and reading: The transactional theory. In MasonJ. (Ed.), Reading and writing connections (pp. 153–176). Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
66.
RoweD. W. (1989). Author/Audience interaction in the preschool: the role of social interaction in literacy learning. Journal of Reading Behavior, 21, 311–351.
67.
ShapiroJ.WhiteW. (1991). Reading attitudes and perceptions in traditional and nontraditional reading programs. Reading Research and Instruction, 30, 52–66.
68.
Smith-BurkeM. T. (1989). Political and economic dimensions of literacy: Challenges for the 1990's. In McCormickS.ZutellJ. (Eds.), Cognitive and social perspectives for literacy research and instruction. Thirty-ninth yearbook of the National Reading Conference (pp. 19–34). Chicago: National Reading Conference.
69.
StricklandD. S. (1994). Educating African American learners at risk: Finding a better way. Language Arts, 71, 328–345.
70.
SulzbyE. (1985). Children's emergent reading of favorite storybooks: A developmental study. Reading Research Quarterly, 20, 458–481.
71.
TurnerJ. (1995). The influence of classroom contexts on young children's motivation for literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 30, 410–441.
72.
TaylorE.Dorsey-GainesC. (1988). Growing up literate: Learning from inner-city families.Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
73.
van KraayenoordC. E.ElkinsJ.AshmanA. F. (1989, December). Reading difficulties, metacognition and affect. Paper presented at the meeting of the National Reading Conference, Austin, TX.
74.
VarbleM. L. (1990). Analysis of writing samples of students taught by teachers using whole language an traditional approaches. Journal of Educational Research, 83, 245–252.
75.
VygotskyL. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
76.
WeaverC. (1988). Reading process and practice.Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
77.
WehlageG. G.RutterR. A.SmithG. A.LeskoN.FernandezR. R. (1989). Reducing the risk. Schools as communities of support.London: Falmer.
78.
WestJ., (1994). Children's perceptions of fun and work in literacy learning (National Reading Research Center Perspective No. 7). Athens: Universities of Georgia and Maryland.
79.
WehlageG. G.RuterR. A.SmithG. A.LeskoN.FernandezR. R. (1989). Reducing the risk. Schools as communities of support.London: Falmer.
80.
WhitemanM. F. (1981). Variation in writing: Functional and linguistic-cultural differences.Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
