The extent to which underlining as an adjunct study aid influenced recall was investigated. Subjects were 64 tenth, eleventh, and twelfth grade students and 61 college sophomores assigned to one of 5 conditions. The 5 conditions varied on amount of underlining and difficulty of material underlined. For each condition, exposure time was held constant. No significant differences among groups were found. The data indicate that, with time held constant, underlining is of limited value and may only manipulate which parts of a passage may be learned at the expense of other parts.
References
1.
BrunningR.Effects of review and test-like events within the learning of prose materials. Journal of Educational Psychology1968, 59, 16–19.
2.
CashenV.M.LeichtK.L.Role of the isolation effect in a formal educational setting. Experimental Publication System1970, 7, 240–244.
3.
CrouseJ.H.Id SteinP.Effects of encoding cues on prose learning. Journal of Educational Psychology1972, 63, 309–313.
4.
FraseL.T.Effect of question location, pacing, and mode upon retention of prose material. Journal of Educational Psychology1968, 59, 244–249.
5.
JenkinsJ.R.NeisworthJ.T.The facilitative influence of instructional objectives. Journal of Educational Research1973, 66, 254–256.
6.
KaplanR.RothkopfE.Z.Instructional objectives as directions to learners: Effect of passage length and amount of objective-relevant content. Journal of Educational Psychology1974, 66, 448, 456.
7.
KaplanR.SimmonsF.G.Effects of instructional objectives used as orienting stimuli or as summary/review upon prose learning. Paper presented at American Educational Research Association Convention, Chicago, 1974.
8.
RothkopfE.Z.Learning from written instructive materials: Exploration of the control of inspection behavior by test-like events. American Educational Research Journal1966, 3, 241–248.
9.
RothkopfE.Z.Textual constraint as a function of repeated inspection. Journal of Educational Psychology1968, 59, 20–25.
10.
RothkopfE.Z.BisbicosE.E.Selective facilitative effects of interspersed questions on learning from written materials. Journal of Educational Psychology1967, 58, 56–61.