Objectives: In 1967, despite escalating international hostility towards psychosurgery, a program of amygdaloid neurosurgery for the reduction of aggressive and self-harming behaviour commenced in Sydney. In this paper, the second of two articles on the Amygdaloid Neurosurgery Project (ANP), we analyse the relative contributions of seven nominated societal, ethical and other factors to the genesis and demise of the ANP, and consider implications of the history of the ANP for the future of neurosurgery for psychiatric disorders (NPD) in New South Wales (NSW) and elsewhere.
Conclusions: Leadership and the availability of resources were crucial factors in the genesis of the project. Its scientific foundations were doubtful in 1967, and remain so in 2009. Ethical issues became the focus of hostile media and Government attention in 1977 and precipitated the project's demise. Lessons derived from an historical analysis of the ANP should assist the medical profession develop appropriate approaches to recent advances in NPD, including deep brain stimulation, new ablative procedures and stem cell implantation.
PressmanJD. Last Resort: Psychosurgery and the Limits of Medicine. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge1998.
3.
ValensteinES. Great and Desperate Cures: the Rise and Decline of Psychosurgery and Other Radical Treatments for Mental Illness. Basic Books, New York1986.
4.
ShorterEA. History of Psychiatry: From the Era of the Asylum to the Age of Prozac. John Wiley and Sons Inc, New York1997.
5.
DiefenbachGJDiefenbachDBaumeisterAWestM. Portrayal of lobotomy in the popular press: 1935-1960. Journal of the History of the Neurosciences1999; 8: 60–69.
6.
LaingRD. The Divided Self: An Existential Study in Sanity and Madness. Penguin, Harmondsworth1960.
7.
SzaszTS. The Myth of Mental Illness: Foundations of a Theory of Personal Conduct. Paul B Hoeber, Inc, New York1961.
8.
WilliamsT. Suddenly, Last Summer. Dramatists Play Service Inc, New York1958.
9.
KeseyK. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. Viking, New York1973.
10.
CrichtonM. The Terminal Man. Random House, New York1972.
11.
CrowH. The treatment of anxiety and obsessionality with chronically implanted electrodes, In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 116.
12.
This Week: Anti-Psychiatry. Tharunka (Student Newspaper). Sydney: University of NSW Student's Union. 1971: 30 May, 6 [17].
13.
WinklerRC. Research into mental health practice using pseudopatients. Medical Journal of Australia1974; 2: 399–403.
14.
RubinsteinWDRubinsteinHL. Menders of the Mind. A History of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists, 1946-1996. Oxford University Press Australia, Melbourne1996; 168–171.
15.
Australian Financial Review26 June, 1973, 2–3.
16.
DeileyR. Surgeons who dig into the brain. Daily Telegraph Sydney. 21 June, 1973, 22.
17.
Editorial comment. Stereotactic neurosurgery for aggressive behaviour. Medical Journal of Australia1973; 1: 779–780.
18.
BaileyHRDowlingJLDaviesE. Studies in depression. 3. The control of affective illness by cingulotractotomy: a review of 150 cases. Medical Journal of Australia1973; 2: 366–371.
19.
BrombergerB, Fife-YeomansJ. See no evil. In. Deep Sleep: Harry Bailey and the Scandal of Chelmsford. Sydney: Simon and Schuster,. 1991; 88–90.
20.
BickG. The media and brain surgery. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 99–102.
21.
KilohLGGyeRGRushworthRGBellDSWhiteRT. Stereotactic amygdaloidotomy for aggressive behaviour. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry1974; 4: 437–444.
22.
SmithJS, KilohLG. Introduction. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 1–3.
23.
McIlraithS. Sydney Morning Herald. 8 June, 1974.
24.
SmithJS, KilohLG. Epilogue. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 167–169.
25.
BrombergerBFife-YeomansJ. The Royal Commission. Deep Sleep: Harry Bailey and the Scandal of Chelmsford. Sydney: Simon and Schuster. 1991; 162.
26.
FinsJJ. From psychosurgery to neuromodulation: history's lessons for the ethical conduct and regulation of neuropsychiatric research. Neurosurgical Clinics of North America2003; 14: 303–319.
27.
GreenbergBDCosgroveGR. Neurosurgical treatments and deep brain stimulation. Kaplan & Sadock's Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry8th edn, SadockBJSadockVA. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia2005; 2983–2990.
28.
Position Statement No 29. Psychosurgery. Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists. Revised. October. 1993.
BregginP. Lobotomies: an alert. American Journal of Psychiatry1972; 129: 97–98.
32.
MarkVHSweetWHErvinFR. Role of brain disease in riots and urban violence. Journal of the American Medical Association1967; 201: 895, (letter).
33.
USA Congressional Records. 1972. E3380 30-3-1972.
34.
Editorial Comment. Stereotactic surgery for aggressive behaviour. Medical Journal of Australia1973; 1: 779–780.
35.
OlderJ. Psychosurgery reconsidered. Medical Journal of Australia1974; 1: 68–70, and Editorial comments. White RT Comment 1; 1: 70; Whitlock FA Comment 2; 1: 71-72.
36.
Session III. Panel discussion and questions. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia, Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 120–121.
37.
BrombergerBFife-YeomansJ. See no evil. Deep Sleep: Harry Bailey and the Scandal of Chelmsford. Simon and Schuster, Sydney1991; 90–91.
38.
EdwardsG. Mental health legislation and psychosurgery in NSW – a proposed amendment. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 153.
39.
KilohLG. Overview of symposium: psychosurgery and society. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 165.
40.
Parliament of New South Wales: Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Psychosurgery (The Foster Report). Sydney: NSW Government Printer, 1977.
41.
Debate on Mental Health Bills. Proceedings of the Legislative Assembly of NSW. (Hansard). 29 November. 1983, 3888–3892.
42.
CoultanM, GarciaLM. Backbenchers stop ban on psychosurgery. Sydney Morning Herald19 April, 1989; 4.
43.
WhitlockF. The ethics of psychosurgery. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1977; 129–135.
44.
KilohLG. Unpublished manuscript in possession of the first author, Psychiatric Research Unit, Rozelle, 1968.
45.
MesulamM. Behavioral neuroanatomy. Principles of Behavioral and Cognitive Neurology2nd edn, MesulamM. Oxford University Press, Oxford2000; 56–59.
46.
KilohLG. The treatment of anger and aggression and the modification of sexual deviation. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia, SmithJSKilohLG. Pergamon Press, Oxford1977; 45.
47.
NarabayashiHNagaoTSaitoYYoshidaMNagahataM. Stereotaxic amygdalotomy for behavior disorders. Archives of Neurology1963; 9: 1–6.
48.
HeimburgerRFWhitlockCCKalsbeckJE. Stereotactic amygdalotomy for epilepsy with aggressive behaviour. Journal of the American Medical Association.1966; 198: 741–745.
49.
KilohLG. The treatment of anger and aggression and the modification of sexual deviation. In. SmithJS, KilohLG. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Oxford: Pergamon Press. 1977; 38–39.
50.
KilohLGSmithJS. The neural basis of aggression and its treatment by neurosurgery. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry1978; 12: 21–28.
51.
ErvinR. The treatment of rage: implications for the future. In. SmithJS, KilohLG, Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute, Sydney, Australia. Pergamon Press, 1977; 77.
52.
GoldsteinM. Brain research and violent behavior. A summary and evaluation of the status of biomedical research on brain and aggressive violent behavior. Archives of Neurology1974; 30: 1–8.
53.
SmithJS. Episodic rage. Festschrift in Honour of Leslie Gordon Kiloh, AndrewsG. Publications Section, Department of the Registrar. University of New South Wales, Sydney1986; 165–171.
54.
WinklerR. Current psychosurgery in Australia: local concerns. Psychosurgery and Society: A Symposium Organized by the Neuropsychiatric Institute. Sydney, Australia, SmithJSKilohLG. Pergamon Press, Oxford1977; 91–98.
55.
NuttinBCosynsPDemeulemeesterHGybelsHMeyersonB. Electrical stimulation in anterior limbs of internal capsules in patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder. Lancet1999; 354: 1526.
56.
SchlaepferTELiebK. Deep brain stimulation for treatment of refractory depression. Lancet2005; 366: 1420–1422.
57.
ZamiskaN. In China, brain surgery is pushed on the mentally ill. Wall Street Journal. 2 November, 2007; 250(195): 1.
58.
SachdevPSSachdevJ. Long-term outcome of neurosurgery for the treatment of resistant depression. Journal of Neurosurgery and Clinical Neurosciences2005; 17: 478–485.
59.
SachdevP. Is deep brain stimulation a form of psychosurgery?. Australasian Psychiatry2007; 15: 97–99.
60.
FinsJJ. A proposed ethical framework for interventional cognitive neuroscience: A consideration of deep brain stimulation in impaired consciousness. Neurological Research.2000; 22: 272–278.
61.
HabermasJ. Discourse ethics: notes on a program of philosophical justification, and Apel K-O. Is the ethics of the ideal communication community a utopia? On the relationship between ethics, utopia, and the critique of utopia. The Communicative Ethics Controversy, BenhabibSDallmayrF. MIT Press, Cambridge1990.
