Objectives: This paper looks at Freud's Jewish identity in the context of the Jewish experience in Eastern and Central Europe after 1800, using his family history and significant figures in his life as illustration. Sigmund Freud's life as a Jew is deeply paradoxical, if not enigmatic. He mixed almost exclusively with Jews while living all his life in an anti-Semitic environment. Yet he eschewed Jewish ritual, referred to himself as a godless Jew and sought to make his movement acceptable to gentiles. At the end of his life, dismayed by the rising forces of nationalism, he accepted that he was in his heart a Jew “in spite of all efforts to be unprejudiced and impartial”. The 18th century Haskalla (Jewish Enlightenment) was a form of rebellion against conformity and a means of escape from shtetl life. In this intense, entirely inward means of intellectual escape and revolt against authority, strongly tinged with sexual morality, we see the same tensions that were to manifest in the publication by a middle-aged Viennese neurologist of a truly revolutionary book to herald the new 20th century: The Interpretation of Dreams. Freud's life and work needs to be understood in the context of fin-de-siécle Vienna. Mitteleuropa, the cultural renaissance of Central Europe, resulted from the emancipation and urbanization of the burgeoning Jewish middle class, who adopted to the cosmopolitan environment more successfully than any other group. In this there is an extreme paradox: the Jewish success in Vienna was a tragedy of success.
Conclusions: Freud, despite a deliberate attempt to play down his Jewish origins to deflect anti-Semitic attacks, is the most representative Jew of his time and his thinking and work represents the finest manifestation of the Litvak mentality.
AbramovitchHPrinceR. The Jewish heritage of Ludwig Wittgenstein: its influence on his life and work. Transcultural Psychiatry2006; 43: 533–553.
28.
BrownEM. Why Wagner-Jauregg won the Nobel Prize for discovering malaria therapy for General Paresis of the Insane. History of Psychiatry2000; 11: 371–382.
29.
MahlerR.Hasidism and the Jewish Enlightenment: Their Confrontation in Galicia and Poland in the First Half of the Nineteenth Century. Philadelphia and New York, 1985.
30.
FeinerSNaorC. The Jewish Enlightenment. University of Pennsylvania Press. 2003.
31.
FeinerS. Seductive science and the emergence of the secular Jewish intellectual. Science in Context2002; 15: 121–135.
32.
DavidoffL. The legacy of the nineteenth-century bourgeois family and the wool merchant's son. Transactions of the Royal Historical Society2004; 14: 25–46.
33.
IgnatieffM.The rise and fall of Vienna's Jews. The New York Review of Books1989; 36: 29 June.
34.
ReinhardR. A success story and its limits: European Jewish social history in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Jewish Social Studies2004; 11: 3–15.
35.
LoewenbergP. Sigmund Freud as a Jew: A study in ambivalence and courage. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences1971; 7: 363–369.
36.
BakanD. Sigmund Freud and the Jewish Mystical Tradition. NJ Publication Year, Princeton1958.
37.
JohnsonP. A History of the Jews. Weidenfeld & Nicolson, London2001.
38.
SlezkineY. The Jewish Century. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ2004.
39.
SteinbergMP. Jewish identity and intellectuality in Fin-de-Siècle Austria: suggestions for a historical discourse. New German Critique1988; 43: 3–33.
40.
RubensteinRL. Freud and Judaism: a review article. The Journal of Religion1967; 47: 39–44.
