Objective: The aim of this paper is to describe the current status of psychiatric ethics as a form of professional ethics and apply this approach to a common clinical situation.
Conclusion: Psychiatry is a profession and, like all professions, comprises a set of specific skills and knowledge that are applied for the ‘common good’ of society. Such a proposition places the psychiatrist in a position of tension between contractarian and Hippocratic ideals of ethical conduct, in that there is an assumption of moral equivalence between the law and ethics. The supposition that legally defensible behaviours are the same as ethically defensible behaviours is integral to the definition of professional ethics. This frequently places psychiatrists at odds with the ‘do no harm’ principle.
FulfordK. Psychiatric ethics: a bioethical ugly duckling. Principles of Health Care Ethics, GillonRLloydA. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester1994; 681–695.
2.
ClouserK.What is medical ethics?Annals of Internal Medicine1970; 80.
3.
PellegrinoE. Humanism and the Physician. University of Tennessee Press, Knoxville1979.
4.
DyerA. Ethics and Psychiatry: Toward a Professional Definition. American Psychiatric Press, New York1988.
5.
ABIM Foundation, ACP-ASIM Foundation, EFIM. Medical Professionalism in the New Millennium: A Physician Charter. Annals of Internal Medicine2002; 136: 243–246.
6.
GreenSBlochS. Special clinical populations. An Anthology of Psychiatric Ethics, GreenSBlochS. Oxford University Press, Oxford2006; 282–289.
7.
BlochSPargiterR. A history of psychiatric ethics. Psychiatric Clinics of North America2002; 25: 509–524.
8.
LiftonR. The Nazi Doctors. Basic Books, New York1986.
9.
DudleyMGaleF. Psychiatrists as a moral community? Psychiatry under the Nazis and its contemporary relevance. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry2002; 36: 585–594.
10.
StrousR. Psychiatry during the Nazi era: ethical lessons for the modern professional. Annals of General Psychiatry2007; 6: 8.
BlochS. Abuses in psychiatry. Encyclopaedia of Bioethics, ReichW. Macmillan, New York1995; 2126–2132.
13.
MurnoR. Political psychiatry in post-Mao China and its origins in the Cultural Revolution. Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law2002; 30: 97–106.
14.
AppelbaumP. Law and psychiatry: abuses of law and psychiatry in China Psychiatric Services2001; 52: 1297–1298.
15.
RubensteinL, ProssC, DavidoffF, IancopinoV. Coercive US Interrogation Policies – A challenge to medical ethics. Journal of the American Medical Association2005; 294: 1544–1549.
16.
BlocheMMarksJ. Doctors and interrogators at Guantanamo Bay. New England Journal of Medicine2005; 353: 6–8.
ChadwickRAindowG. Treatment and research ethics. The Philosophy of Psychiatry, RaddenJ. Oxford University Press, New York2004; 282–295.
26.
CrowdenA. Ethically sensitive mental health care: is there a need for a unique ethics for psychiatry?. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry2002; 36: 52–59.
27.
PellegrinoEThomasmaD. A Philosophical Basis of Medical Practice. Oxford University Press, New York1981.
28.
PolyaniM. Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy. Harper and Row, New York1964.
29.
MunsonR. Why medicine cannot be a science. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy1981; 6: 183–208.
30.
SchwartzMWigginsO. Phenomenological and hermeneutical models: understanding and interpretation in psychiatry. The Philosophy of Psychiatry, RaddenJ. Oxford University Press, New York2004; 351–363.
31.
AlexanderJ. On the social construction of moral universals. Cultural Trauma and Collective Identity, AlexanderJEyermanRGiesenBSmelserNSztompkaP. University of California Press, Berkely2004; 196–263.
32.
BaumanZ. Modernity and the Holocaust. Cornell University Press, Ithica1989.
33.
MacIntyreA. A Short History of Ethics. Routledge, Milton Park1998.
34.
HughesJFulfordK. Hurly-burly of psychiatric ethics. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry2005; 39: 1001–1007.
TaylorC.Philosophy and the Human Sciences. Philosophical Papers 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985.
37.
FulfordK. Analytic philosophy, brain science, and the concept of disorder. Psychiatric Ethics, BlochSGreenSChodoffP. Oxford University Press, New York1999; 161–191.
38.
Oxford English Dictionary, 2nd edn. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993.
39.
CruessS, JohnstonS, CruessR. Professionalism for medicine: opportunities and obligations. Medical Journal of Australia2002; 177: 208–211.
40.
FullinwiderR. Professional codes and moral understanding. Codes of Ethics and the Professions, CoadyMBlochS. Melbourne University Press, Melbourne1996; 72–87.
41.
CruessRCruessS. Teaching medicine as a profession in the service of healing. Academic Medicine1997; 72: 941–952.
