This article examines the question of whether German companies flee or export the German model. On the basis of data from the Deutsche Bundesbank and mergers and acquisitions data, the article argues that job exports from Germany in the last fifteen years have been rather marginal. Thus, German multinational corporations (MNCs) do not flee the German model to the extent suggested by many critics of Germany as a production location. In addition, the paper draws on 13 case studies of German investments in Hungary to help understand the extent to which German MNCs export the German model. This case study evidence indicates that German MNCs do not attempt to completely transfer all aspects of the German production model, as some proponents of institutionalist political economy approaches maintain. The German labour relations model, in particular, is only selectively transferred.
AbelJ.BraczykH.-J.RenzC.TöpschK. (1998) Wandel der Arbeitsregulation. Arbeitsbericht der Akademie für Technikfolgenabschätzung in Baden-Württemberg, 118 (Stuttgart).
2.
AlbertM. (1992) Kapitalismus Contra Kapitalismus (Frankfurt am Main: Campus).
3.
BeckerC.VitolsS. (1997) Innovationskrise der Deutschen Industrie. Das deutsche Innovationssystem der neunziger Jahre, in: NascholdF.SoskiceD.HanckéB.JürgensU. (Eds.) Ökonomische Leistungsfähigkeit und institutionelle Innovation. Das deutsche Produktions- und Politikregime im globalen Wettbewerb, pp. 251–68 (Berlin: Edition Sigma).
4.
BeyfußJ.EggertJ. (2000) Auslandsinvestitionen der deutschen Wirtschaft und ihre Arbeitsplatzeffekte Aktuelle Trends, Ergebnisse einer Unternehmensbefragung und die Bedeutung der staatlichen Fötrderung (Köln: Deutscher Instituts-Verlag).
5.
BeyfußJ.KittererB. (1990) Deutsche Direktinvestitionen im Ausland (Köln: Deutscher Instituts-Verlag).
6.
BispinckR. (2001) Betriebliche Interessenvertretung, Entgelt und Tarifpolitik, WSI-Mitteilungen, 2, pp. 124–32.
7.
BluhmK. (2001) Exporting or abandoning the ‘German model’? labourpolicies of German manufacturing firms in Central Europe, European Journal of Industrial Relations, 7(2), pp. 153–74.
8.
CasperS.VitolsS. (1997). The German model in the 1990s: Problems and prospects, Industry and Innovation, 4(1), pp. 1–13.
9.
CrossA.TüselmannH.-J. (2000) German foreign direct investment in Central and Eastern Europe: Patterns, motives and effects on German domestic investment and jobs, Quarterly Journal of the University of Economics Bratislava, 29, pp. 268–81.
10.
DietzB.ProtsenkoA.VincentzV. (2000) Direktinvestitionen in Osteuropa, Osteuropa Institut Working papers, 229 (München: Osteuropa Institut).
11.
DIHK (1997) Investitionen im Ausland, Mimeo (Berlin: DIHK).
12.
DIHK (2000) Investitionen im Ausland, Mimeo (Berlin: DIHK).
13.
DIHK (2003) Produktionsverlagerung als Element der Globalisierungsstrategie von Unternehmen, Mimeo (Berlin: DIHK).
14.
DörrenbächerC. (2000) Between Global Market Constraints and National Dependencies. The Internationalisation of the World Leading Telecommunication Equipment Manufacturers 1980–1995, Transnational Corporations, 9(3), pp. 1–3.
15.
DörrenbächerC.ScheikeI.SchmittA.WortmannM. (1995) Internationaler Investitionsmonitor '95. Übernahmen, Beteiligungen, Neugründungen, Investitionen, Verkäufe und Liquidationen durch bundesdeutsche Unternehmen in der verarbeitenden Industrie im Ausland 1985–1994 (Berlin: FAST e.V.).
16.
DörrenbächerC.DohleM.HeidemannB. (1999) Datenband: Beteiligungen, Übernahmen und Verkäufe deutscher Industrieunternehmen im Ausland 1990 bis 1996 (Berlin: FAST e.V).
17.
DörrenbächerC.FichterM.NeumannL.TóthA.WortmannM. (2000a) Transformation and foreign direct investment: Observations on path dependency, hybridization and model transfer at the enterprise level, TRANSFER, 6(3), pp. 434–49.
18.
DórrenbácherC.DohleM.WortmannM. (2000b) Database: German Manufacturing FDI in Hungary, Preliminary results (August 2000), mimeo (Berlin: FU Berlin/FAST).
19.
Dorsch-SchweitzerM.SchultenT. (2001) Betriebs- und Personalräte zwischen Belegschaft, Arbeitgeber und Gewerkschaft, WSI-Mitteilungen, 2, pp. 113–23.
20.
EstrinS.HughesK.ToddS. (1997) Foreign Direct Investment in Central and Eastern Europe. Multinationals in Transition (London: ME Sharp).
21.
FernerA. (1997) Country of origin effect and HRM in multinational companies, Human Resource Management Journal, 7(1), pp. 19–37.
22.
FernerA.QuintanillaJ.VarulM. Z. (2001) Country-of-origin effects, host-country management of HR in multinationals: German Companies in Britain and Spain, Journal of World Business, 36(2), pp. 107–27.
23.
FichterM. (2003) Internationalization of Production: Options and Responses. Evidence from German Enterprises in Hungray. AICGS/DaimlerChrysler Working Paper Series, American Institute of Contemporary German studies (Washington DC: The John Hopkins University).
24.
FlassbeckH. (1995) Deutschland – kein Standort für Investitionen, WSI Mitteilungen, 11, pp. 699–704.
25.
FleckerJ.SchultenT. (1999) The end of institutional stability; what future for the German model, Economic and industrial democracy, 20, pp. 81–115.
26.
HallP. A.SoskiceD., (Eds) (2001) Varieties of Capitalism. The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Average (Oxford/New York Oxford University Press).
27.
HarzingA.-W.SorgeA. (2003) The relative impact of country of origin and universal contingencies on internationalization strategies and corporate control in multinational enterprises: Worldwide and European perspectives, Organizational Studies, 24(2), pp. 187–214.
28.
HenkelH.-O. (1995) Interview in der Neuen Osnabrücker Zeitung, 21 October.
29.
HuY.-S. (1992) Global or stateless corporations are national firms with international operations, California Management Review, 34(2), pp. 107–26.
30.
JürgensU.NaumannK.KuppJ. (2000) Shareholder value in an adverse environment: The German case, Economy and Society, 29(1), pp. 54–79.
31.
KatzensteinP. J. (1980) Problem or Model? West Germany in the 1980s, World Politics, 32, pp. 577–98.
LallementR. (2001) Foreign direct investment and the diversity of socio-economic systems in Europe: France, Germany and Britain compared, in: MacleanM.TrouilleJ.-M. (Eds.) France, Germany and Britain. Partners in a Changing World, pp. 85–99 (Basingstoke/New York: Palgrave).
34.
MarkovitsA. S. (1982) The Political Economy of West Germany (New York: Modell Deutschland).
35.
MauriceM.SorgeA.WarnerM. (1980) Societal differences in organizing manufacturing units, Organization Studies, 1(1), pp. 63–91.
36.
MorganG.KellyB.SharpeD.WhitleyR. (2000) Multinationals as Organizations, Paper presented at the II ESRI Workshop: Forms of Transnational Governance and Paths of economic Development, Lisbon, Portugal, 20 September 2000.
37.
MüllerF. (1994) Societal effect, organizational effect and globalization, Organization Studies, 15(3), pp. 407–28.
38.
NascholdF. (1997) Ökonomische Leistungsfähigkeit und institutionelle Innovation. Das deutsche Produktions- und Politikregime im globalen Wettbewerb, in: NascholdF.SoskiceD.HanckéB.JürgensU. (Eds.) Ökonomische Leistungsfähigkeit und institutionelle Innovation. Das deutsche Produktions- und Politikregime im globalen Wettbewerb, pp. 19–62 (Berlin: Edition Sigma).
39.
Nordhause-JanzJ.PrekuhlU. (2000) Managementmethoden oder Zukunftskonzepte? Zur Entwicklung von Arbeitsstrukturen und Gruppenarbeit in Deutschland, in: Nordhause-JanzJ.PrekuhlU. (Eds.) Arbeiten in neuen Strukturen? Partizipation, Kooperation, Autonomie und Gruppenarbeit in Deutschland, pp. 13–68 (München: Hampp).
40.
PaulyL. W.ReichS. (1997) National structures and multinational corporate behaviour: Enduring differences in the age of globalization, International Organization, 1, pp. 1–30.
41.
RuigrokW.van TulderR. (1995) The Logic of International Restructuring (London/New York: Routledge).
42.
SallyR. (1995). States and Firms. Multinational Enterprises in Institutional Competition (London: Routledge).
43.
SchroederW.WeinertR. (1999) Managing decentralization. The strategy of institutional differentiation in German industrial relations, German Politics and Society, 53(4), pp. 52–73.
44.
SpringerR. (1999) Rückkehr zum Taylorismus? Arbeitspolitik in der Automobilindustrie am Scheideweg (Frankfurt am Main: Campus Verlag).
45.
StreeckW. (1987) The uncertainties of management in the management of uncertainty: Employers, labor relations and industrial adjustment in the 1980s', Work, Employment and Society, 1(3), pp. 281–308.
46.
ThurowL. C. (1999) Building Wealth. The New Rules for Individuals, Companies, and Nations in a Knowledge-Based Economy (New York: Harper Collins).
47.
UpchurchM. (2000) The crisis of Labour relations in Germany, Capital & Class, 70, pp. 65–93.
48.
WestneyD.E. (1993) Institutionalization theory and the multinational corporation, in: GhoshalS.WestneyD. E. (Eds.) Organization Theory and the Multinational Corporation, pp. 53–76 (New York: St. Martins Press).
49.
WhitleyR. (1992) Societies, firms and markets: The social structuring of business systems, in: WhitleyR. (Ed.) European Business Systems. Firms and Markets in their National Contexts, pp. 5–45 (London: Sage Publications).
50.
WhitleyR. (2001) How and why are international firms different? The consequences of cross-border managerial coordination for firm characteristics and behaviour, in: MorganG.KristensenP. H.WhitleyR. (Eds.) The Multinational Firm. Organizing across Institutional and National Divides, pp. 27–68 (New York: Oxford University Press).
51.
WortmannM. (2002) (unter von BotzemS. MitarbeitDohleM.NoltingU.) Ausländische Direktinvestitionen und Arbeitsplatzexport? Eine Untersuchung des externen und internen Auslandswachstums deutscher Unternehmen. Studie erstellt im Auftrag des Bundesministeriums für Wirtschaft und Technologie, 47/01 (Berlin: FAST e.V.).
52.
WortmannM.DörrenbächerC. (1997) Multinationale Konzerne und der Standort Deutschland, in: FrickeW. (Ed.) Jahrbuch für Arbeit und Technik 1997, pp. 28–42 (Bonn: Dietz-Verlag).
