Review: HM Treasury and Productivity in the UK

Abstract

A central theme of international political economy is the comparative performance of national economies and the determinants thereof. In the debate over such performance ‘productivity’ has emerged a key term, and this paper is concerned with the way in which that term has been deployed in public policy debate in the UK. Its focus is on the ‘New Labour’ period (since 1997), in which the term has been central to the economic agenda of government. However, it is a term which has long been important in the lexicon of British social democracy, and this historical background is discussed here as a preliminary to treatment of the more contemporary material. The core argument of the paper is that the formulation of the productivity issue, and related terms like the ‘productivity gap,’ is both conceptually and statistically highly problematic, and forms an extremely insecure basis for the pursuit of public policy on the economy.

Keywords

Productivity Economic performance Economic policy UK government New labour

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Artis

Cobham

(1991). Labour's Economic Policies 1974–79. Manchester University Press, Manchester.

Benn

(1989). Against the Tide: Diaries 1973–76. Hutchinson, London.

Britton

(1991). Macroeconomic Policy in Britain 1974–1987. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Broadberry

(1997). The Productivity Race: British Manufacturing in International Perspective, 1850–1990. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Brown

(1999). Hansard (Commons), Vol. 327, 9 March. col. 173.

Cannadine

(1997). Apocalypse when? British politicians and British ‘decline’ in the twentieth century. In: Clarke

Trebilcock

(Eds.), Understanding Decline. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 275–281.

CM. 2563. (1994). Competitiveness: Helping Britain Win. HMSO, London.

Crafts

(1995). The golden age of economic growth in Western Europe, 1950–1973. Economic History Review, 85, 429–447.

Crafts

O'Mahony

(2001). A perspective on UK productivity performance. Fiscal Studies, 22, 271–306.

10.

Cutler

(1992). Vocational training and British economic performance: A further instalment of the ‘British labour problem’. Work, Employment and Society, 6, 161–183.

11.

DTI (2002). Hewitt announces study into UK management skills gap www.dti.gov.uk 15th October.

12.

Edgerton

(1996). The ‘White Heat’ revisited: The British Government and technology in the 1960s. Twentieth Century British History, 7, 53–82.

13.

Fallick

J.L.

Elliott

R.F.

, (Eds.) (1981). Incomes Policies, Inflation and Relative Pay. George Allen and Unwin, London.

14.

Godley

Izurieta

(2002). The case for a severe recession. Challenge, 45, 27–51.

15.

Labour Party. (1974). Britain Will Win with Labour: Labour Manifesto October 1974. Labour Party, London.

16.

Labour Party. (1997). New Labour because Britain Deserves Better: General Election Manifesto. Labour Party, London.

17.

Matthews

R.C.O.

(1988). Research on productivity and the productivity gap. National Institute Economic Review, 88, 66–72.

18.

McKinsey. (1998). Driving Productivity Growth in the UK Economy. McKinsey Global Institute, London.

19.

Nichols

(1986). The British Worker Question: A New Look at Workers and Productivity in Manufacturing. Routledge and Kegan Paul, London.

20.

Robinson

(1998). Letter to Financial Times, 15 December.

21.

Robinson

(2000). It's the economy, stupid! New Economy, 7, 8–13.

22.

Robinson

(2001). Policy objectives and tools. New Economy, 8, pp. 148–150.

23.

Rostas

(1948). Comparative Productivity in British and American Industry. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

24.

Shanks

(1961). The Stagnant Society. Penguin, Harmondsworth.

25.

Shonfield

(1958). British Economic Policy Since the War. Harmondsworth, Penguin.

26.

Tiratsoo

Tomlinson

(1993). Industrial Efficiency and State Intervention: Labour 1939–51. Routledge/LSE, London.

27.

Tomlinson

(2001). The Politics of Decline: Understanding Post-war Britain. Pearson, Harlow.

28.

Tomlinson

(2002). The British ‘productivity problem’ in the 1960s. Past and Present, 175, 174–211.

29.

Tomlinson

(2003). Modernising Britain? The Economic Policies of the Wilson Government, 1964–70. Manchester University Press, Manchester.

30.

Treasury. (1998). Pre-Budget Report, Cm.4076. HMSO, London.

31.

Zeitlin

Herrigel

, (Eds.), (2001). Americanization and Its Limits: Reworking US Technology and Management in Post-War Europe and Japan. Oxford University Press, Oxford.