Metaphor is indispensable to science. Evelyn Fox Keller has argued argue that there is a commonality between the metaphors of gene action, and that of a genetic program. I suggest that the common thread is that of executive control or agency. The genetic program metaphor has progressively undergone a process that William James called ‘vicious abstractionism’, in which an abstract concept is erroneously made concrete; the metaphorical conceit has become metaphysical commitment. I use a natural meaning approach to illocutionary force to ask whether genes really are programs, whether they issue commands to the developmental systems. I argue that it is more plausible to suppose that developmental systems issue commands to genes. Agency or executive control more properly lies with the organism.
DanchinÉ., PochevilleA., and HunemanP.. 2019. “Early in Life Effects and Heredity: Reconciling Neo-Darwinism with Neo-Lamarckism under the Banner of the Inclusive Evolutionary Synthesis. ” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B . https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rstb.2018.0113.
2.
DawkinsR.1986. The Blind Watchmaker . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
DawkinsR.1998. “Universal Darwinism. Reprinted. ” In Oxford Readings in Philosophy of Biology , edited by HullD. and RuseM., 15–37. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
DennettD.1995. Darwin's Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meanings of Life . New York: Simon and Schuster.
5.
DraaismaD.2000. Metaphors of Memory: A History of Ideas about the Mind . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
DupréJ.2012. Processes of Life: Essays in the Philosophy of Biology . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
7.
Godfrey SmithP.2007. “Information in Biology. ” In The Cambridge Companion to the Philosophy of Biology , edited by HullD. and RuseM., 103–119. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
GriceP.1981. “Presupposition and Conversational Implicature. ” In Radical Pragmatics , edited by ColeP., 183–198. New York: Academic Press.
10.
GriffithsP. E., and StotzK.. 2013. Genetics and Philosophy: An Introduction . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
11.
HermanJ. J., SultanS., Horgan-KybelskiT., and RiggsC.. 2016. “Adaptive Transgenerational Plasticity in an Annual Plant: Grandparental and Parental Drought Stress Enhance Performance of Seedlings in Dry Soil. ” Integrative and Comparative Biology 52: 77–88. doi: 10.1093/icb/ics041
12.
HesseM.1988. “The Cognitive Claims of Metaphor. ” The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, New Series 2 (1): 1–16.
13.
HesseM.1993. “Models, Metaphors and Truth. ” In Knowledge and Language, vol. 3, edited by AnkersmitF. R. and MooijJ. J. A., 49–66. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic.
HuY., LinzD. M., ParkerE. S., SchwabD. B., CasasaS., MacagnoA. L., and MoczekA. P.. 2019. “Developmental Bias in Horned Dung Beetles and its Contributions to Innovation, Adaptation, and Resilience. ” Evolution & Development 22: 1–16.
16.
JacobF.1973. The Logic of Life: A History of Heredity . Translated by SpillmanB. R.. New York: Pantheon.
17.
JacobF., and MonodJ.. 1961. “Genetic Regulatory Mechanisms in the Synthesis of Proteins. ” Journal of Molecular Biology 3: 318–356. doi: 10.1016/S0022-2836(61)80072-7
18.
KayL.2000. Who Wrote the Book of Life? Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
19.
KellerE. F.2000. The Century of the Gene . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
20.
KellerE. F.2003. Making Sense of Life: Explaining Biological Development with Models, Metaphors, and Machines . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
21.
KellerE. F.2011. The Mirage of a Space between Nature and Nurture . Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
22.
KellerE. F.2013. “Genes as Difference Makers. ” In Genetic Explanations: Sense and Nonsense , edited by KrimskyS. and GruberJ., 329–345. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
23.
KellerE. F.2015. “Cognitive Functions of Metaphor in the Natural Sciences. ” Philosophical Inquiry III (1): 113–132.
24.
LindM., and SpagopoulouF.. 2018. “Evolutionary Consequences of Epigenetic Inheritance. ” Heredity 121: 205–209. doi: 10.1038/s41437-018-0113-y
25.
MameliM.2005. “The Inheritance of Features. ” Biology and Philosophy 20: 365–399. doi: 10.1007/s10539-004-0560-0
26.
Maynard SmithJ.1969. “The Status of Neo-Darwinism. ” In Toward a Theoretical Biology , edited by WaddingtonC. H., 82–89. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
27.
Maynard SmithJ.2000. “The Concept of Information in Biology. ” Philosophy of Science 67: 177–194. doi: 10.1086/392768
28.
MayrE.1961. “Cause and Effect in Biology. ” Science 134: 1501–1506. doi: 10.1126/science.134.3489.1501
29.
MayrE.1991. Letter to François Jacob, July 3, 1991, JAC D29, Fonds Jacob, Archives de l'Institut Pasteur, Paris.
30.
MonodJ.1971. Chance and Necessity . Translated by WainhouseA.. New York, NY: Schopf.
31.
PeluffoA. E.2015. “The ‘Genetic Program’: Behind the Genesis of an Influential Metaphor. ” Genetics 200 (3): 685–696. doi: 10.1534/genetics.115.178418
32.
RiskinJ.2016. The Restless Clock A History of the Centuries-Long Argument over What Make Living Things Tick . Chicago: Chicago University Press.
33.
SchrödingerE.1944. What Is Life? New York: Dover.
34.
SheaN.2007. “Representation in the Genome and in Other Inheritance Systems. ” Biology and Philosophy 22: 313–331. doi: 10.1007/s10539-006-9046-6
35.
SinclairR.2019. “Reification. ” In Bad Arguments:100 of the Most Important Fallacies in Western Philosophy, First Edition , edited by ArpR., BarboneS., and BruceM., 378–381. Wiley.
36.
StotzK., and GriffithsP.. 2017. “Biological Information, Causality, Specificity—An Intimate Relationship. ” In Information and Causality: From Matter to Life , edited by WalkerP. C., DaviesP. C. W., and EllisG. F. R., 366–390. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
ThibodeauP., and BoroditskyL.. 2011. “Metaphors we Think with: The Role of Metaphor in Reasoning. ” PloS one 6 (2), doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0016782.
39.
Von BertalanffyL.1969. General Systems Theory . New York: George Braziller.
40.
WagnerA.2011. The Origin of Evolutionary Innovations: A Theory of Transformative Change in Living Systems . Oxford: Oxford University Press.
41.
WagnerA.2012. “The Role of Robustness in Phenotypic Adaptation and Innovation. ” Proceedings of the Royal Society B 279: 1249–1258. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2011.2293
42.
WalshD. M.2015. Organism, Agency and Evolution . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
43.
WangE. T., SandbergR., LuoS., KhrebtukovaI., ZhangL., MayrC., KingsmoreS. F., SchrothG. P., and BurgeC. B.. 2008. “Alternative Isoform Regulation in Human Tissue Transcriptomes. ” Nature 456 (7221): 470–476. doi: 10.1038/nature07509.
44.
WatersC. K.2007. “Causes That Make a Difference. ” Journal of Philosophy 104: 551–579. doi: 10.5840/jphil2007104111
45.
WintherR.2014. “James and Dewey on Abstraction. ” The Pluralist 9: 1–28. doi: 10.5406/pluralist.9.2.0001
46.
ZollmanK. J.2011. “Separating Directives and Assertions in Signaling Games. ” Journal of Philosophy 108: 158–169. doi: 10.5840/jphil201110839
