On Retrieving Analogues When Solving Problems

Abstract

After criticism of the precision of previous experimental procedures for testing analogue retrieval, a new procedure that overcomes the proposed inadequacies is described. This procedure is then employed in two experiments that test aspects of the general hypothesis that base analogues that are semantically remote from a target problem (Duncker's radiation problem) are more difficult to retrieve than those that are semantically closer. Experiment 1 confirmed this hypothesis by finding that remote analogues are seldom retrieved relative to literal analogues. The results of Experiment 2 falsified the hypothesis that analogue retrieval is solely due to the recognition of an “identical element”. Finally, an ad hoc model of analogue retrieval is proposed based on Schank's dynamic memory theory, and its consistency with the evidence and more general implications are considered.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bishop

Y. M. M.

Fienberg

S. E.

Holland

P. W.

(1975). Discrete multivariate analysis Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.

Dreistadt

(1968). An analysis of the use of analogies and metaphors in science. Journal of Psychology 68, 97–116.

Duncker

(1945). On problem solving. Psychological Monographs 58, (Whole No. 270).

Gentner

(1983). Structure-mapping: A theoretical framework for analogy. Cognitive Science 7, 155–170.

Gentner

Landers

(1985). Analogical reminding: A good match is hard to find. Proceedings of the international conference on systems, man and cybernetics Tucson, Arizona (November).

Gick

M. L.

Holyoak

(1980). Analogical problem solving. Cognitive Psychology 12, 306–355.

Gick

M. L.

Holyoak

(1983). Schema induction and analogical transfer. Cognitive Psychology 15, 1–38.

Hays

W. L.

(1973). Statistics for the social sciences. 2nd ed. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.

Holyoak

K. J.

(1984a). Analogical thinking and human intelligence. Sternberg

R. J.

Advances in the psychology of human intelligence. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 2.

10.

Holyoak

K. J.

(1984b). Mental models in problem solving. Anderson

J. R.

Kosslyn

S. M.

Tutorials in learning and memory: Essays in honor of Gordon Bower. San Francisco: Freeman.

11.

Keane

(1985). On drawing analogies when solving problems. British Journal of Psychology 76, 449–458.

12.

Keane

(1985b). Restructuring revised: A theoretical note on Ohlsson's mechanism of restructuring. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 26, 363–365.

13.

Koestler

(1964). The act of creation London: Picador.

14.

Newell

Simon

H. A.

(1972). Human problem solving Englewood-Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.

15.

Ohlsson

(1984). Restructuring revisited: II an information processing theory of restructuring and insight. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 25, 117–129.

16.

Ohlsson

(1985). Retrieval processes in restructuring: Answer to Keane. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 26, 366–368.

17.

Schank

R. C.

(1982). Dynamic memory Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

18.

Thorndyke

P. W.

(1977). Cognitive structures in comprehension and memory. Cognitive Psychology 9, 23–31.

19.

Winston

P. H.

(1980). Learning and reasoning by analogy. Communications of the ACM 23, 689–703.