Gin and Tonic or Oil and Water: The Entrepreneurial City and Sustainable Managerial Regeneration in Manchester

Abstract

This paper explores the notion of local urban policy hybridity in Manchester, England. It presents the findings of qualitative research set in the context of the parallel entrepreneurial city and sustainable regeneration debates. The research objective was to examine the extent of Manchester's conversion to the politics of the entrepreneurial city on the assumption that this signals a departure from efforts towards the city's achievement of sustainable regeneration and social equity goals. Manchester was selected because it has been held up as an iconic entrepreneurial city. The continuing entrepreneurial city debate, instigated by David Harvey in the 1980s, runs alongside that of sustainable regeneration in ways that are seen as sometimes complementary but usually contradictory. The software package NVivo 7 was used to assist with data analysis. The methodological approach was based loosely on the grounded theory approach of Strauss and Corbin: the approach of the analysis mainly followed the qualitative interpretive approach of discourse analysis. Key community strategy documents are found to interweave elements of the entrepreneurial and managerial governance discourses and also incorporate conceptual elements that have emerged recently such as a concern with crime, sustainability and community involvement. The paper provides valuable insights into the hybrid nature of Manchester's actually existing local community strategies which feature a robust adherence to the managerial mode of local urban policy.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkinson

Coffey

(2004) Analysing documentary realities in: Qualitative Research: theory, method and practice (London: Sage).

Atkinson

(2003) Domestication by cappuccino or a revenge on urban space? Control and empowerment in the management of public spaces, Urban Studies, 40(9), pp. 1211–1245.

Atkinson

Helms

(Eds) (2007) Securing an Urban Renaissance: Crime, Community, and British Urban Policy (Bristol: The Policy Press).

Bennett

Patel

(1995) Sustainable regeneration strategies, Local Economy, 10(2), pp. 133–148.

Bryman

Burgess

(1994) Reflections on qualitative data analysis, in: Bryman

Burgess

(Eds) Analysing Qualitative Data (London: Routledge).

Cellabos

(2003) The role of the Guggenheim Museum in the development of urban entrepreneurial practices in Bilbao, International Journal of Iberian Studies, 16(3), pp. 177–186.

Cochrane

Peck

Tickell

(1996) Manchester plays games: Exploring politics of globalisation, Urban Studies, 33(8), pp. 1319–1336.

Coffey

Holbrook

Atkinson

(1996) Qualitative data analysis: Technologies and representations, Sociological Research Online, 1(1).

Cronin

A.M.

Hetherington

(Eds) (2008) Consulting the Entrepreneurial City: Image, Memory, Spectacles (London: Routledge).

10.

Evans

(2007) The Politics of Partnership Urban Regeneration in New East Manchester, Public Policy and Administration, 22(2), pp. 201.

11.

Gibbs

(2002) Qualitative Data Analysis: Explorations with NVivo (Buckingham: Open University Press).

12.

Greater Manchester Forum (GMF) (2004) Greater Manchester Economic Development Plan 04/05-06/07 (Manchester: GMF).

13.

Hall

Hubbard

(Eds) (1998) The Entrepreneurial City: Geographies of Politics, Regime and Representation (London: Wiley-Academy).

14.

Hall

Hubbard

(1996) The entrepreneurial city: New urban politics, new urban geographies? Progress in Human Geography, 20(2), pp. 153–174.

15.

Harrison

Karyn Miller

(2006) A tale of two cities, Daily Telegraph, 30 September.

16.

Harvey

(1989) From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: The transformation in urban governance in late capitalism, Geografiska Annaler, 71B, pp. 3–17.

17.

Hetherington

(2007) Manchester's urbis: Urban regeneration, museums and symbolic economies, Cultural Studies, 21(4/5), pp. 636–649.

18.

Jackson

(2007) Mainstreaming Sustainability in Local Economic Development Practice, Local Economy, 22(1), pp. 12–26.

19.

Jessop

Sum

(2000) An entrepreneurial city in action: Hong Kong's strategies in and for (inter)urban competition, Urban Studies, 37(12), pp. 2287–2313.

20.

Jones

Wilks-Heeg

(2004) Capitalising culture: Liverpool 2008, Local Economy, 19(4), pp. 341–360.

21.

Kidd

A.J.

(2006) Manchester: A History, 4th edn (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press).

22.

Krueger

Gibbs

(Eds) (2007) The Sustainable Development Paradox (New York: Guilford Press).

23.

MacLeod

Raco

Ward

(2003) Negotiating the contemporary city: Introduction, Urban Studies, 40(9), pp. 1655–1671.

24.

Manchester City Council (MCC) (2002) Manchester Community Strategy 2002–2012 (Manchester: Manchester City Council).

25.

Manchester City Council (MCC) (2003) 2001 Census Key Population Statistics for Manchester (Manchester: MCC).

26.

Manchester City Council (MCC) (2004) Reshaping Manchester (Manchester: RIBA/Manchester City Council).

27.

Manchester City Council (MCC) (2006) Manchester Sustainable Community Strategy 2006–2015 (Manchester: Manchester City Council).

28.

Manchester City Council (MCC) (2007) Mid Year Estimate 2006: Summary Note (Manchester: MCC).

29.

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (ODPM) (2003) Sustainable Communities: Building for the Future (London: ODPM).

30.

Peck

Tickell

(1995) Business goes local: dissecting the ‘business agenda’ in Manchester, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research (19), pp. 55–78.

31.

Peck

Ward

(Eds) (2002) City of Revolution (Manchester: Manchester University Press).

32.

Porter

Hunt

(2005) Birmingham's Eastside story: Making steps towards sustainability? Local Environment, 10(5), pp. 525–542.

33.

Prescott

(2006) Three years on from the Sustainable Communities Plan, Statement by the Deputy Prime Minister. Available online at: www.communities.gov.uk/communities/sustainablecommunities/sustainablecommunities (accessed 11 February 2008).

34.

Prior

(2004) Documents, in: Seale

Gobo

Gubrium

Silverman

(Eds) Qualitative Research Practice (London: Sage).

35.

Quilley

(1996) Economic Transformations and Local Strategy in Manchester, PhD Thesis, Manchester University.

36.

Quilley

(2002) Entrepreneurial turns: municipal socialism and after, in: Peck

Ward

(Eds) City of Revolution: Restructuring Manchester (Manchester: Manchester University Press).

37.

Raco

(2005) Sustainable development, rolled-out neoliberalism and sustainable communities, Antipode, 37(2), pp. 324–347.

38.

Raco

(2007) Building Sustainable Communities: Spatial Policy and Labour Mobility in Post-war (Bristol: The Policy Press).

39.

Scott

J.P.

(Ed) (2006) Documentary Research (London: Sage).

40.

Shapely

Tanner

Walling

(2004) Civic culture and housing policy in Manchester, 1945–79, Twentieth Century British History, 15(4), pp. 410–434.

41.

Silverman

(Ed) (2004) Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analysing Talk, Text and Interaction (London: Sage).

42.

Silverman

(2005) Doing Qualitative Research, 2nd edn (London: Sage).

43.

Strauss

A.L.

Corbin

J.M.

(1997) Grounded Theory in Practice (London: Sage).

44.

Tonkiss

(2004) Analysing text and speech: content and discourse analysis, in: Seale

(Ed.), Researching Society and Culture, 2nd edn. (London: Sage).

45.

While

Jonas

A.E.G.

Gibbs

(2004) The environment and the entrepreneurial city: searching for the urban ‘sustainability fix’ in Manchester and Leeds, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 28(3), pp. 549–569.

46.

Wilks-Heeg

North

(2004) Cultural policy and urban regeneration: a special edition of Local Economy, Local Economy, 19(4), pp. 305–311.

47.

Williams

(2003) The Enterprising City Centre: Manchester's Development Challenge (London: Taylor & Francis Ltd).