Marginalised Voices: Resisting the Privatisation of Council Housing in Glasgow

Abstract

This paper explores the opposition to housing stock transfer in Glasgow in the early 1990s. Taking the position of anti-transfer campaigners, it argues that transfer can be interpreted as a form of ‘privatisation’ involving a profound restructuring in the role of the state in a key heartland area of welfare provision. Using interviews from housing campaigners in Glasgow, the paper argues that the much-heralded rhetoric about housing stock transfer as promoting tenant choice is highly contentious and misleading. The paper includes by highlighting that dispite the move to transfer in Glasgow, there remains a significant campaign against transfer in other parts of the UK.

Keywords

Housing stock transfer Scotland Glasgow community participation privatisation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baldock

(2003) On being a welfare consumer in a consumer society, Social Policy and Society, 2(1), pp. 65–71.

BBC Scotland (2003) Frontline Scotland: Slumming It (Glasgow: BBC Scotland, Broadcast on BBC1 Scotland, 21 October 21).

Centre for Public Services (2004) The Case for the 4th Option for Council Housing (Sheffield: Centre for Public Services).

Danson

Fleming

Gilmore

Sternberg

Whittam

(2000) Glasgow City Council—Proposed Housing Stock Transfer: Final Report for Unison Scotland (Paisley: University of Paisley Faculty of Business).

Defend Council Housing (2003) The Case for Council Housing, 2nd edn (London: DCH).

Donaldson

Forster

(1992) Sell and be dammed (Glasgow: Clydeside Press).

Durden

(2001) Housing policy, in: Savage

S.P.

Atkinson

(Eds) Public Policy Under Blair (London: Palgrave).

Evans

(2003) Best-laid schemes, Inside Housing, 6 June(www.insidehousing.co.uk) (accessed 20 October 2003).

Gibb

(2003) Transferring Glasgow's council housing: financial, urban and housing policy implications, European Journal of Housing Policy, 3(1), pp. 89–114.

10.

Glasgow City Council (2001) Housing Plan 2001: Preparing Together for Glasgow's Future in Housing (Glasgow: GCC Housing Department).

11.

Glasgow City Council (2002) Glasgow Housing Transfer Video (Glasgow: Glasgow City Council).

12.

House of Commons Council Housing Group (2004) The Case for the ‘Fourth Option’ for Council Housing (London: HOCCHG).

13.

Johnstone

(2000) Housing and class struggles in post-war Glasgow, in: Lavalette

Mooney

(Eds) Class Struggle and Social Welfare (London: Routledge).

14.

Malpass

Murie

(1999) Housing Policy and Practice, 5th edn (London: Macmillan).

15.

North

(2003) Communities at the heart? Community action and urban policy in the UK, in: Imrie

Raco

(Eds) Urban Renaissance? New Labour, Community and Urban Policy (Bristol: The Policy Press).

16.

Paris

Muir

(2002) After housing policy: housing and the UK General Election 2001, Housing Studies, 17(1), pp. 151–64.

17.

Robbins

(2002) Taking stock—regeneration programmes and social housing, Local Economy, 17(4), pp. 266–72.

18.

Scottish Executive (2003) A Partnership for a Better Scotland (Edinburgh: The Scottish Executive).

19.

Scottish Television (2002) Platform (Glasgow: Scottish Television, broadcast on Scottish Television, 2 February).