This paper seeks to evaluate critically the extent to which there is community involvement in the construction and delivery of urban policy under New Labour, through a case study of the Greater Pollok Social Inclusion Partnership. The paper concentrates on the Scottish experience, but its lessons resonate more widely. Its key finding is that, for all the rhetoric of New Labour and community involvement, the degree to which it has occurred in practice is little different to the level of involvement under Conservative urban policy initiatives. The paper argues that the processes of community consultation and participation during the early stages of the Greater Pollok Social Inclusion Partnership were woefully inadequate. At best it was tokenistic, and at worst, local people were being ‘exploited’ to legitimise the policy process.
ArnsteinS. (1969) A ladder of citizen participation, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35, pp. 216–224.
2.
AtkinsonR. (2000) Narratives of policy: the construction of urban problems and urban policy in the official discourse of British government, Critical Social Policy, 20(2), pp. 211–232.
3.
BeresfordP.GreenD. (1996) Income and wealth — an opportunity to reassess the UK poverty debate, Critical Social Policy, 16(1), pp. 95–109.
4.
ByrneD. (1999) Social exclusion (Buckingham: Open University Press).
5.
Cambridge Economic Consultants (1999) An evaluation of the new life for urban scotland initiative (Edinburgh: Scottish Executive Central Research Unit).
6.
ColenuttB.CuttenA. (1994) Community empowerment in vogue or vain?Local Economy, 9, pp. 236–250.
7.
CollinsC. (1999) Applying Bakhtin in urban studies: the failure of community participation in the Ferguslie Park partnership, Urban Studies, 36(1), pp. 73–90.
8.
DuffyK.HutchinsonJ. (1997) Urban policy and the turn to community, Town Planning Review, 68(3), pp. 347–362.
9.
FurbeyR. (1999) Urban ‘regeneration’: reflections on a metaphor, Critical Social Policy, 19, pp. 419–445.
10.
GinsburgN. (1999) Putting the social into urban regeneration policy, Local Economy, 14(May), pp. 55–70.
11.
Glasgow Regeneration Alliance (1993) Shaping the future: a commitment to area regeneration (Glasgow Regeneration Alliance, Sovereign ECF).
12.
Greater Pollok Social Inclusion Partnership Board (1999) Greater Pollok social inclusion partnership strategy. Greater Pollok Social Inclusion Partnership Board.
13.
HastingsA. (1996) Unravelling the process of ‘partnership’ in urban regeneration policy, Urban Studies, 33(2), pp. 253–268.
14.
McCarthyJ. (1997) Empowerment or exclusion?Town and Country Planning, 66(1), pp. 20–21.
15.
McGregorA. (1992) The economics of peripheral estates. TERU Research paper No. 2, University of Glasgow, Glasgow.
16.
McWilliamsC. (2002) An analysis of the contemporary governance of Glasgow, 1975–2000. Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Glasgow.
17.
McWilliamsC.MooneyG.JohnstoneC. (2003) Urban social policy in the new Scotland: a new beginning or ‘old hat’? Paper given to the Regional Studies Association International Conference: Reinventing Regions in the Global Economy. Pisa, Italy, 12–15 April, 2003.
18.
NevinB.ShinerP. (1995) The left, urban policy and community empowerment: the first steps towards a new framework for urban regeneration, Local Economy, 10, pp. 204–217.
19.
NobleM.WrightG.MyfanwyL.DibbenC.SmithG.RatcliffeA.McLennanD.SigalaM.AntillaC. (2003) Scottish indices of deprivation 2003. Department of Social Policy and Social Work (Oxford: University of Oxford).
20.
PacioneM. (1988) Public participation in neighbourhood change, Applied Geography, 8, pp. 229–247.
21.
RacoM. (2000) Assessing community participation in local economic development — lessons for the new urban policy, Political Geography, 19, pp. 573–599.
22.
RacoM.ImrieR. (2003) Towards an urban renaissance? sustainable communities, new Labour and urban policy, in: ImrieR.RacoM.(Eds) (2003) Urban Renaissance: New Labour, Community and Urban Policy, pp. 1–29 (Bristol: Policy Press).
23.
RobinsonF.ShawK. (1995) Urban regeneration and community involvement, Local Economy, 9, pp. 61–73.
24.
Scottish Office (1988) New life for urban Scotland (Edinburgh: Scottish Office).
25.
Scottish Office (1998) Social inclusion partnerships: invitation to submit expressions of interest (Edinburgh: The Scottish Office Development).
26.
Scottish Office (1999) Social inclusion strategy: opening the door to a better Scotland (Scottish Office Publications).
27.
SimD. (1984) Urban deprivation: not just the inner city, Area, 16(3), pp. 299–306.
28.
StepneyP.LynchR.JordanB. (1999) Poverty and exclusion and new Labour, Critical Social Policy, 19(1), pp. 109–125.
29.
StewartM. (1996) Competition and competitiveness in urban policy, Public Management, July–September, pp. 21–26.
30.
Sunday Herald (1999) Why the WTO is making life miles worse for Glasgow's poor, 5 December 1999, p. 7.
