The theme of this paper is the current practice of vision and visioning in land use planning in Scotland. The recent allocation of £90 million as part of the Building Better Cities Growth Fund required Scotland's six principal cities to prepare a city-vision. This was based on the perceived necessity of shared visions in providing a clear framework to guide development. The paper examines the contested concepts of visions and visioning and asks whether the prescriptive approach to the city-visions provides for inspirational or aspirational visions.
Aberdeen City Council (2003) Energising Aberdeen—Creating the Conditions for Growth (Aberdeen).
2.
AcheP. (2000) Cities in old industrial regions between local innovative milieu and urban governance— reflections on city-region governance, European Urban Studies, 8(6), pp. 693–709.
3.
BurtonP. (1997) Community Visioning: An Evaluation of the ‘Choices for Bristol’ Project (Bristol: The Policy Press).
4.
CookeP.MorganK. (1998) The Associational Economy, Firms, regions & innovation (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
5.
DETR (1999) Towards an Urban Renaissance (London: E & FN Spon).
6.
Dundee City Council (2003) Dundee—A City Vision (Dundee).
7.
EvansA. W. (2003) Shouting very loudly: Economics, planning and politics, Town Planning Review, 74(2), pp. 195–212.
8.
FaludiA. (1973) Planning Theory (Oxford: Pergamon).
9.
GoodwinM. A.DuncanS. S.HalfordS. (1993) Regulation theory, the local state, and the transition of urban politics, Environment & Planning D: Society & Space, 11, pp. 67–88.
KaufmanJ. L. (2003) Looking ahead: major planning challenges moving into the 21st century. Keynote Address, American Planning Association 2003 National Planning Conference, Denver, Colorado, 30 March.
13.
LoganJ.MolotchH. (1987) Urban Fortunes (Berkley: University of California Press).
14.
LloydM. G.PeelD. (2004) April showers? National spatial planning in Scotland, Scottish Planning and Environmental Law, June, 103, pp. 56–8.
15.
McCannE. J. (2001) Collaborative visioning or urban planning as therapy? The politics of publicprivate policy making, Professional-Geographer, 53(2), pp. 207–18.
16.
McEldowneyM.SterrettK. (2001) Shaping a regional vision: the case of Northern Ireland, Local Economy, 16(1), pp. 38–49.
17.
MurtaghB. (2001) City visioning and the turn to community, Planning Practice and Research, 16(1), pp. 9–19.
18.
NadinV. (2000) Reviewing Transnational Spatial Planning, edited by SchindeggerF. (Vienna Austrian Institute for Regional Studies and Spatial Planning) [VISION PLANET was established as an INTERREG IIC project].
19.
Office of the Deputy Prime Minister (2004) The Egan Review: Skills for Sustainable Communities (London: ODPM).
20.
Royal Town Planning Institute (2000) A New Vision for Planning (London: RTPI).
21.
Scottish Executive (2002a) Better Cities, New Challenges A Review of Scotland's Cities (Edinburgh: The Stationery Office).
22.
Scottish Executive (2002b) Building Better Cities Guidance and Next Steps (Edinburgh).
Scottish Executive (2003b) Building Better Cities—A Policy Statement (Edinburgh).
25.
ShipleyR. (2000) The origin and development of vision and visioning in planning, International Planning Studies, 5(2), pp. 225–236.
26.
ShipleyR.NewkirkR. (1999) Vision and visioning in planning: what do these terms really mean?Environment and Planning B—Planning and Design, 26(4), pp. 573–91.
27.
TempleM. (2000) New Labour's third way: pragmatism and governance, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 2(3), pp. 302–25.
