El objetivo de esta investigación es la comprobación de la capacidad predictiva de los distintos modelos existentes sobre razonamiento y representación en silogismos lineales: modelo de la imagen, lingüístico-proposicional, mixto y de niveles de representación. Se utilizaron 64 tipos de silogismos lineales con el fin de cumplir los requisitos mínimos necesarios para utilizar la metodología empleada. Aunque los resultados obtenidos no presentan diferencias estadísticamente significativas entre los dos modelos con mayor capacidad predictiva, el modelo de niveles de representación supera al modelo mixto.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonJ.R. (1978). Arguments concerning representations for mental imagery.Psycological Review, 83, 249–277. Trad. cast, en M.V. Sebastian (Comp.): Lecturas de Psicología de la Memoria.Madrid: Alianza Editorial, 1983.
2.
AndersonJ.R.BowerG.H. (1973). Human associative memory.Washington D.C.: Winston.
3.
CaramazzaA.GordonJ.ZuriffE.B.DelucaD. (1976). Right hemispheriffa damage and verbal problem solving behavior.Brain and Language, 3, 41–46.
4.
CasadoP.F. (1986). Estrategias de solución de silogismos lineales, Representación y Memoria. Memoria de Licenciatura. U.A.M. Sin publicar.
5.
CasadoP.F.RiviereA.AdarragaP. (en preparación), Reconocimiento y Niveles de Procesamiento en procesos de razonamiento sobre silogismos lineales.
6.
ChaseW.G.ClarkH.H. (1972). Mental operations in the comparision of sentences and pictures. EnGreggL. (comp.): Cognition in Learning and Memory.Nueva York: Wiley.
7.
ClarkH.H. (1969a). Linguistic processes in Deductive Reasoning.Psychological Review, 76, (4), 387–404.
8.
ClarkH.H. (1969b). The influence of language in solving three-term series problems.Journal of Experimental Psychology, 82, 205–215.
9.
ClarkH.H. (1971). More about adjetives, comparatives, and syllogism: a reply to Huttenlocher and Higgins.Psychological Review, 78, (6), 505–514.
10.
ClarkH.H. (1972). On the evidence concerning J. Huttenlocher and E.T. Higgins' Theory of Reasoning.Psychological Review, 79, (5), 428–432.
11.
CooperL.A.ShepardR.N. (1973). Chronometric studies of the rotation of mental images. En: W.G. Chase (Comp.)Visual information Processing.N.Y.: Academic Press.
12.
De SotoC.B.LondonM.HandelS. (1965). Social reasoning and spatial paralogic.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2, 513–521.
13.
HandelS.De SotoC.B.LondonM. (1968). Reasoning and Spatial Representation.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 7, 351–357.
14.
HunterI.M.L. (1957). The solving of three-term series problems.British Journal of Psychology, 48, 286–298.
15.
HuttenlocherJ. (1968). Constructing spatial images: a strategy in reasoning.Psychological Review, 75, 550–560.
16.
HuttenlocherJ.EisenbergK.StraussS. (1968). Comprehension: relation between perceived actor and logical subject.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 7, 527–530.
17.
HuttenlocherJ.HigginsE.T. (1971). Adjetives, Comparatives and Syllogisms.Psychological Review, 78, (6), 487–502.
18.
HuttenlocherJ.HigginsE.T. (1972). On reasoning, congruence and other matters.Psychological Review, 79, 420–427.
19.
HuttenlocherJ.StraussS. (1968). Comprehension and statement's relation to the situation it describes.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 7, 300–304.
20.
HuttenlocherJ.HigginsE.T.MiluganC.KauffmanB. (1970). The Mystery of the ‘Negative Equative’ Construction, Journal Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 9, (3), 334–341.
21.
Johnson-LairdP.N. (1972). The three-term series problem.Cognition, 1, 57–82. Trad. cast, en J. Delval (Comp.): Investigaciones sobre lógica y Psicología.Madrid: Alianza, 1977.
22.
JonesS. (1970). Visual and Verbal Processes in problem-solving.Cognitive Psychology, 1, 201–214.
23.
KeeneyT.J.GaudinoD.L. (1973). Solution of comparative and negative-equatrie three-term series problems.Journal of Experimental Psychology, 101, 193–196.
24.
KosslynS.M. (1975). Information Representation in visual images.Cognitive Psychology, 7, 341–370.
25.
KossiynS.M. (1981). The Medium and the Message in Mental imagery: a theory.Psychological Review, 88, 46–65.
26.
KosslynS.M.PomerantzJ.R. (1977). Imagery, propositions and the form of internal representations.Cognitive Psychology, 9, 52–76. Trad. cast. En García-AlbeaJ.E.Percepción y computación.Madrid: Pirámide, 1986.
27.
KossiynS.M.SchwartzS.P. (1978). Visual Images as Spatial representations in Active Memory. EnRisemanE.M.HansonA.R. (Eds.): Machine Vision.N.Y.: Academic Press.
28.
PaivioA. (1971). Imagery and verbal process.N.Y.: Holt, Rinehart and Winston Inc.
29.
PaivioA. (1977). Images, propositions and Knowledge. EnNicholasJ.M. (Ed.): Images, perception and Knowledge. Reidel Publishing Company.
30.
PottsG.R.ScholzK.W. (1975). The internal representation of a three-term series problems.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 14, 439–452.
31.
PylyshynZ.W. (1973). What the mind's eye tells the mind's brain: A critique of mental imagery.Psychological Bulletin, 80, 1–24.
32.
PylyshynZ.W. (1978). La naturaleza simbólica de las representaciones mentales. En: M.V. Sebastian (Comp.):Lecturas de Psicología de la Memoria.Madrid: Alianza Editorial, 1981.
33.
PylyshynZ.W. (1979). Validating computational Models: A Critique of Anderson's Indeterminacy of Representation Claim.Psychological Review, 86, (4), 384–394.
34.
PylyshynZ.W. (1981). The imagery debate: Analogue media versus tacit Knowledge.Psychological Review, 88, 16–45.
35.
RiviereA. (1984). Modelos de la representación en el razonamiento sobre series. EnCarreteroM.García MadrugaJ.A. (comp.): Lectura de Psicología del Pensamiento.Madrid: Alianza Psicología.
36.
RiviereA. (1985a). Sobre la multiplicidad de las representaciones. Un viaje por los vericuetos de los lenguajes del pensamiento. EnMayorJ. (Ed.): Actividad Humana y Procesos Cognitivos.Madrid: Alhambra.
37.
RiviereA. (1985b). Hacia una nueva concepción de la función de las representaciones en el razonamiento: el modelo de los niveles de representación.Revista de Psicología General y Aplicada, 40, (4), 667–703.
38.
RiviereA. (1986). Razonamiento y Representación.Madrid: Siglo XXI.
39.
RumelhartD.E.LindsayNormanD.A. (1972). A process model for long-term memory. EnTulvingE.DonalsonW.Organization and Memory.Nueva York: Academic Press.
40.
San MartínR.EspinosaL. (1985). Psicometría: 2.a parte. Técnicas multivariadas. U.A.M.
41.
ShaverP.PiersonL.LangS. (1973). Converging evidence for the functional significance of imagery in problem solving.Cognition, 3, 359–375.
42.
ShepardR.N.MetzlerJ. (1971). Mental rotation of three-dimensional objects.Science, 171, 701–703.
43.
ShermanM.A. (1976). Adjetival negation and the comprenhension of multiply negated sentences.Journal of Verbal Learning and Vergal Behavior, 15, 143–157.
44.
SternbergR.J. (1977). The componential Approach to Human Intelligence, Intelligence Information Processing, and Analogical Reasoning: The Componential analysis of Human Abilities, L.E.A.
45.
SternbergR.J. (1980a). Representation and Process in Linear Syllogistic Reasoning.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 109, (2), 119–159.
46.
SternbergR.J. (1980b). A proposed resolution of curious conflicts in the literatura on linear syllogisms. EnNickersonR. (Ed.): Attention and Performance VIII.Hillsdale, N.J.: Erlbaum.
47.
SternbergR.J. (1980c). The development of linear sylogistic reasoning.Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 29, 342–356.
48.
WasonP.C.Johnson-LairdP.N. (1972). Psychology of reasoning: structure and content.London: B.T. Bratsford. Trad. cast. Debate,. 1980
49.
WilliamsR.L. (1979). Imagery and linguistic factores affecting the solution of linear syllogism.Journal of Psycholinguistics Research, 8, 123–140.
