Thresholds in Chemical Carcinogenesis: What Are Animal Experiments Telling Us?

Abstract

It appears that the controversy over whether animal experiments demonstrate a threshold for carcinogenicity from chemicals was due to an error in plotting dose response. A linear (arithmetic) scale for the dose of chemicals obscures effects at doses below those used in the experiment and distorts the effect seen over the range of doses used. Gaddum (Nature 156: 463, 1946) pointed out that, empirically, dose should be on a logarithmic scale to effect a linear quantal response. It now is proposed that this logarithmic relationship of dose to effect has a sound basis in chemical thermodynamics (Waddell, Toxicol Sci 68: 275—279, 2002). When the results of major studies (e.g., ED01, etc.) done in the past were reanalyzed with this in mind using the Rozman et al scale (Drug Metab Rev 28: 29—52, 1996), which has a logarithmic scale down to one molecule (100), unequivocal thresholds were demonstrated. Many animal studies now have been reanalyzed by this procedure (e.g., Waddell, Toxicol Sci 72: 158—163, 2003; Waddell, Food Chem Toxicol, in press; Waddell, Hum Exp Toxicol, in press); these studies show thresholds for carcinogenicity at doses ranging from 1017.1 to 1021.92 molecules/kg/day. These results require a complete reevaluation of human risk assessment for carcinogenesis from chemicals and a redirection of basic research to discover the system, or systems, that are overwhelmed at these thresholds.

Keywords

Carcinogenesis thresholds ED01 2-acetylaminofluorene N-nitrosodiethylamine methyleugenol safety factor risk assessment extrapolation.

References

Farmer JH , Kodell RL , Greenman DL , Shaw GW ( 1980). Dose and time response models for the incidence of bladder and liver neoplasms in mice fed 2-acetylaminoflourene continuously. J Environ Path Toxicol 3: 55— 68.

Gaddum JH (1945). Lognormal Distributions. Nature 156: 463.

Littlefield NA , Farmer JH , Gaylor DW , Sheldon WG (1980). Effects of dose and time in a long term low dose carcinogenic study. J Environ Path Toxicol 3: 17—34.

Peto R. , Gray R. , Brantom P. , Grasso P. (1991). Effects on 4080 rats of chronic ingestion of N- nitrosodiethylamine or N-nitrosodimethylamine: A detailed dose-response study . Cancer Res 51: 6415—6451.

Rozman KK , Kerecsen L. , Viluksela MK , Österle D. , Deml E. , Viluksela M. , Stahl BU , Greim H. , Doull J. (1996). A toxicologist's view of cancer risk assessment . Drug Metab Rev 28: 29—52.

Waddell, WJ (2002). Thresholds of carcinogenicity of flavors. Toxicol Sci 68: 275—279.

Waddell, WJ (2003). Thresholds of carcinogenicity in the ED01 study . Toxicol Sci 72: 158—163.

Waddell, WJ (2003). Threshold of carcinogenicity of nitrosodiethylamine for esophageal tumors in rats. Food Chem Toxicol (in press).

Waddell, WJ (2003). Comparison of human exposures to selected chemicals with thresholds from NTP carcinogenicity studies in rodents. Hum Exp Toxicol (in press).

10.

Waddell WJ , Bates RG (1969). Intracellular pH. Physiol Rev 49: 285—329.