The transition from plan to market in socialist economies dominates the economic agenda of this decade. This two-part paper on the Russian housing reforms addresses four questions. First, what is the legacy of the administrative-command system and why were demands for major reforms so widespread in the housing sector? Secondly, in what manner does the severe contraction of the Russian economy complicate the reformers' task? Thirdly, how has the Russian government responded so far to the reform challenge? Fourthly, why are the privatisation of housing and rent reforms at the core of the transition to market? The first part of the paper deals with the first two questions. The second part addresses the last two questions. Priority goes to an integrated perspective on the early stages of Russian reforms over an in-depth analysis of individual issues. The modern analysis of the real estate economy distinguishes two markets: the 'property market' for the allocation of space, and the 'asset market' where investment decisions are made. This theoretical insight provides a much needed framework to understand how the key components of Russian reform interact during the housing transition to market.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alexeev, M.V. (1987) Soviet residential housing: will the "acute problem" be solved?, in: Joint Economic Committee of the 100th US Congress, Gorbachev's Economic Plans, Vol. II, November.
2.
Alexeev, M.V. (1988) Market vs. rationing: the case of Soviet housing , Review of Economics and Statistics, 70(3), pp. 414-420.
3.
Alexeev, M.V. (1990) Distribution of housing subsidies in the USSR with some Soviet-Hungarian comparisons, Comparative Economic Studies , Vol. 32.
4.
Andrusz, G.D. (1984) Housing and Urban Development in the USSR. London: Macmillan.
5.
Andrusz, G.D. (1990) A note on the financing of housing in the Soviet Union, Soviet Studies, 42, pp. 555-570.
6.
Åslund, A. (1991) Gorbachev's Struggle for Economic Reform. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
7.
Baross, P. and Struyck, R. (Eds) (1993) Special Issue on Housing Reform in Eastern Europe, Cities, 10(3), August.
8.
Basin, E.V. (1994) Legal and regulatory issues in housing and land reforms. Opening presentation by the Chairman, Gosstroy—World Bank Seminar on Housing Reforms, Moscow , February.
9.
Bertaud, A. and Renaud, B. (1994) Cities without land markets, lessons of the failed socialist experiment. World Bank Discussion Papers Series No. 227, March.
10.
Bessonova, O.E. (1988) The phenomenon of free housing: the financing of housing in the USSR, Journal of the Academy of Sciences, Economic Series (Novossibirsk), 3.
11.
Bessonova, O.E. (1990a) Reform of the Soviet Union model: search for a concept. Working Paper, Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Novossibirsk, October. (Mimeo in English).
12.
Bessonova, O.E. (1990b) Towards the essence of the housing system in the USSR. Working Paper, Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Novossibirsk, October. (Mimeo in English).
13.
Bessonova, O.E. (1990c) Housing system and housing policy: methodology and practice in the case of the USSR. Working Paper, Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences, Novossibirsk , December. (Mimeo in English).
14.
Board Of Governors Of The Federal Reserve System (1991) Balance Sheets of the U.S. Economy: 1945-1990. September.
15.
Butler, S.B. and O'Leary, S. (1994) Laws Relating to Housing and Urban Development in theRussian Federation. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute, March.
16.
Council Of Ministers Of The Russian Federation ( 1993) Special Government Housing Programme. Moscow, 18 March.
17.
Daniel, Z. and Partos, G. (1989) The history of the Hungarian housing reform: current issues and lessons learned. Paper presented at the International Conference on Housing Reforms, State Council's Leading Group on Housing Reforms, Beijing, China, October.
18.
Di Pasquale, D. and Wheaton, W.C. (1992) The markets for real estate assets and space: a conceptual framework, Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association, 20, pp. 181-198.
19.
Faltsman, V. (1989) The statistics of perestroika and the perestroika of statistics, Izvestiia akademiinauk SSSR: Seriia ekonomicheskaia (Moscow), 4.
20.
Fisher, J.D. (1992) Integrating research on markets for space and capital. Presidential Address to the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association, 28 December 1990. Journal of the AREUEA, 20, pp. 161-180.
21.
Gao, S. ( 1988) The need for urban housing reforms, China City Planning Review (Beijing), March.
22.
Goldsmith, R. (1985) Comparative National Balance-Sheets: A Study of 20 Countries, 1688-1978. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
23.
Imf, World Bank, Oecd and Ebrd (1991) A Study of the Soviet Economy, 3 vols., OECD, Paris, February.
24.
Institut Ekonomiki I Prognozirovaniia Nauchno-Tekhnicheskogo Progressa (1990) O strategii prestroiki ekonomiki strany [About the strategy of reconstruction of the country's economy], Problemy prognozirovaniia, 2.
25.
Irem Foundation and Anderson, A. (1991) Managing the Future: Real Estate in the 1990s.
26.
Kagalovsky, K. (1989) The pressing problems of state finances in the USSR, Communist Economies, April.
27.
Kalinina, N.V. (1986) On the question of social guarantees in the provision of housing, in: S. S. Shatalin (Ed.) Sistemnoe modelrovanie protsessov intensificatsii obshchestvennogo proizvodstva. Moscow: Institute of Economic Forecasting, USSR Academy of Sciences.
28.
Kalinina, N.V. (1990) Guaranteeing housing in the USSR: a few suggestions for reforming the housing provision system. Working Paper, Institute of Economic Forecasting, USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow (in Russian).
29.
Kalinina, N.V. (1991) Housing and housing policy in the USSR: a brief description of the system and its current changes, in: I. Tosics, J. Hegedus and B. Turner (Eds) Housing Reform in Eastern Europe. London: Routledge .
30.
Kornai, J. (1990) The affinity between ownership forms and coordination mechanisms, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 4(3).
31.
Kornai, J. (1993) The Socialist Economy: The Political Economy of Communism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
32.
Kosareva, N.B., Pchelinchev, O.S. and Ronkin, G.S. (1990) Toward a housing reform: analysis and forecast. Voprosy ekonomiki [Economic Problems], No. 8, Moscow.
33.
Kosareva, N.B. and Struyck, R. (1993) Housing privatisation in the Russian Federation . Housing Policy Debate (Washington, DC ), pp. 81-100.
34.
Matras, H. (1989) Structure and performance of the housing sector of the centrally planned economies Report 53, World Bank , Washington DC, October.
35.
Matras, H. and Renaud, B. (1992) Housing reform in transition economies: a survey report for Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union. ECA Office, World Bank, August. (Mimeo).
36.
Miles, M.E. (1991) What is the value of all US real estate?, Real Estate Review, 2 (2), pp. 69-77.
37.
Ministere Du Logement, France (1994) Le Compte du Logement. Paris: Economica .
38.
Renaud, B. (1990) China's 1988 urban housing reforms: origins, scope, and major obstacles, in G. C. Lim and W. Chang (Eds) Dynamic Transformation: Korea, NICs, and Beyond. Seoul, Korea: Myung Bo Publishing Co.
39.
Renaud, B. (1991a) Housing, in: Imf, World Bank, Oecd and Ebrd (eds) A Study of the Soviet Economy (3 vols), vol. 3, ch. 9. OECD, Paris, February.
40.
Renaud, B. (1991b) Housing reform in socialist economies. World Bank Discussion Papers Series No. 125, June.
41.
Renaud, B. (1992) The housing system of the former Soviet Union: why do the Soviets need housing markets?Housing Policy Debate (Washington, DC), 3(3), November.
42.
Renaud, B. and Czerny, M. (Eds) (1992) The Building Industry in Transition Economies, Proceedings of the WIFO-World Bank Seminar on the Building Industry in Transition Economies, Vol. 1: Current Industry Conditions; Vol. 2: Technical Papers and Western Experiences in Eastern Europe . Vienna, Austria, November.
43.
Shironin, V. (1990) Product prices in the USSR. Paper presented at the HASA Conference on Economic Reform and Integration, Sopron, Hungary, July-August.
44.
Shmelev, N. and Popov, V. (1989) The Turning Point: Revitalizing the Soviet Economy . New York: Doubleday. (Translated from the Russian).
45.
Treml, V.G. (1988) Perestroika and Soviet statistics, Soviet Economy, 4(1).
46.
Tsentral'Noe Statisticheskoe Upravleniye Sssr [TsSu now GosKomstat] (1987) Narodnoe Khoziaistvo SSSR za 70 let [The Economy of the USSR over 70 Years]. Moscow.
47.
Tsentral'Noe Statisticheskoe Upravleniye Sssr [Tssu now GosKomstat] (1989) Soviet Union Survey of 310 000 Households. Moscow, March (Mimeo).
48.
Tsentral'Noe Statisticheskoe Upravleniye Sssr [Tssu now GosKomstat] (annual) Narodnoe Khoziaistvo SSSR v 19.. godu Statisticheskiy Yezhegodnik [The Economy of the USSR in 19..: Annual Statistical Yearbook] . Moscow: Goskom stat.
49.
Vavilov, A. (1990) Housing, in: S. S. Shatalin and G. Y. Yavlinski (Eds) Transition to the Market: The Concept and the Program, Part III , ch. 6. Moscow, September. [Translated and published as 500 Days: Transition to the Market. New York: Saint Martin's Press, 1991.]
50.
Wang, Y. (1991) The size of housing subsidies in China, Review of Urban and Regional Development Studies ( Tokyo ), 3(2).
51.
World Bank (1993) Housing: Enabling Markets to Work. World Bank Policy Paper.
52.
World Bank (1994) Russia: Housing Reform and Privatization: Strategy and Transition Issues, (2 vols). World Bank.
53.
Yasin, Y.G. (1989) Perestroika and statistics, Ekonomika I matematicheskie metody [Economics and Mathematical Methods] ( Moscow), 5.
54.
Yunina, O.N. (1988) Local Government and the Right of Citizens to Housing. Institut Gosudarstva y Prava [State and Law Institute], USSR Academy of Sciences, Moscow. (in Russian).
