This paper examines changes over time in Arab-Jewish power relations in the land use planning of Israel's Galilee region. A theoretical framework is developed, linking power disparities to levels of social and political strife. Following the findings of recent research on policies towards the Arabs in Israel, it is hypothesised that Arab-Jewish power disparities have narrowed since the mid 1970s. This hypothesis is tested against the case of land use planning in the Galilee between 1975 and 1988. Three principal aspects of the issue are examined: the power structure of the planning system; participation in the formulation of land use plans; and Arab and Jewish efficacy in the planning process. The findings do not support the hypothesis. Power relations have narrowed in some areas of the planning system during the research period, but in other areas disparities have widened with the introduction of new inequalities. Overall, a status-quo has been maintained, leaving the Arabs largely outside the policy-making process in a region where they form a clear majority.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Al Haj, M. and Rosenfeld, H. (1990) Arab Local Government in Israel. Boulder, CO: Westview.
2.
Alterman, R. (1988) Implementing decentralisation for neighborhood regeneration, Journal of american Planning Association, 54, pp. 454-469.
3.
Carmon, N., Law Yone, H., Lifshitz, G., Czamanski, D., Amir, S. and Kipnis, B. (1989) The New Settlement in the Galilee-an Evaluation . Haifa: Center for Urban and Regional Research, The Technion. (In Hebrew).
4.
Central BuReau Of Statistics (1949-89) Special Publications on the 1972 and 1983 Population and Housing Censuses. Statistical Abstracts Nos 27-39 and Israel's Year Books 1949-90. Jerusalem: Government Printers. (In Hebrew).
5.
Churchman, A. (1987) Issues in residents' participation: lessons from the Israel experience, Policy Study Journal, 16, pp. 290-299.
6.
Coakley, J. (1990) National minorities and the government of divided societies: a comparative analysis of some European evidence, European Journal of Political Research, 18, pp. 437-456.
7.
Czamanski, D. and Taylor, T. (1986) Dynamic aspects of entrepreneurship in Arab settlements in Israel, Ofakim Begeographia, 17-18, pp. 125-144.
8.
Druze Committee (The National Committee Of Druze Local CouNcIls). (1983) Strategy for the Development of Druze Villages. Druze Committee. (In Hebrew).
9.
Esman, M.J. (1987) Ethnic politics and economic power, Comparative Politics, 19, pp. 395-418.
10.
Falah, G. (1989) Israeli Judaisation policy in Galilee and its impact on local arab urbanisation, Political Geography Quarterly , 8, pp. 229-253.
11.
Falah, G. (1990) Arabs versus Jews in Galilee: competition over regional resources, Geo-journal, 21, pp. 325-337.
12.
Faludi, A. (1987) A Decision-centred View of Environmental Planning . Oxford: Pergamon.
13.
Freidmann, J. (1987) Planning in the Public Domain: From Knowledge to Action. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
14.
Gurr, T. and Lichbach, M. (1986) Forecasting internal conflict, Comparative Political Studies, 9, pp. 3-38.
15.
Hameissi, R. (1987) Performance of outline plans in the Arab villages , Ofakim Begeographia, 17-18, pp. 161-173. (In Hebrew).
16.
Hameissi, R. (1990) Planning and Housing among Arabs in Israel. Tel Aviv: International Centre for Peace in the Middle East.
17.
Harvey, D. (1973) Social Justice and the City. London: Arnold.
18.
Hewett, C. (1977) Majorities and minorities: a comparative survey of ethnic violence, Annals of the American Association of Political andSocial Sciences, 433, pp. 150-160.
19.
HoRvrrz, Y. (1986) Building permit without a plan? A plan without specifications?, Mishpatim, 16, pp. 234-248. (In Hebrew).
20.
Israel Land AuTHoRity (1976) Framework Proposal for the Galilee. Nazareth: ILA, (In Hebrew).
21.
Jewish Agency (1978) Protecting the Lands of Galilee-Proposal for Implementation (the Weitz Document). Settlement Department of the Jewish Agency, Zefad. (Unpublished, in Hebrew).
22.
Jewish Agency (1979) Outline Plan 3438-the Mitzporim. Settlement Departments, Northern and Galilee Regions, Haifa and Zefad. (Unpublished, in Hebrew).
23.
Jewish National Fund (In Co-Operation With The Jewish Agency) (1979) Plan for Land Uses in the Galilee . (Unpublished, Zefad, in Hebrew).
24.
Kimmerling, B. (1983) Zionism and Territory. Berkeley, CA: Institute of International Studies, University of California.
25.
Kipnis, B. (1987) Geopolitical ideologies and regional strategies in Israel, Tijdchrift voor Economische en SocialeGeografie , 78, pp. 125-138.
26.
Knesset Archives (1949-88) Protocols of the Israeli Knesset. ( Jerusalem: Government Printers. (In Hebrew).
27.
Krumbholtz, N. (1982) A retrospective view of equity planning: Cleveland, 1968-1978, Journal of American Planning Association, 48, pp. 163-183.
28.
The Lands Committee (The Executive Committee For The Defence Of Arab Lands) (1975-88) Minutes, Protocols, Correspondence, Leaflets and Press Releases, the Committee's Office (Nazereth) and private archives of past and present members. (Unpublished, in Arabic and Hebrew).
29.
Lane, J.E. and Ersson, S.O. (1987) Politics and Society in Western Europe, London: Sage.
30.
Luphart, A. (1977) Democracy in Plural Societies: A Comparative Exploration . New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
31.
Lustick, I. (1979) Stability in deeply divided societies: consociationalisation vs Control, World Politics, 31: 325-344.
32.
Lustick, I. (1980) Arabs on the Jewish States: Israel's Control over a National Minority. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
33.
Lustick, I. (1980) Arabs in the Jewish States: Israel's Control over a National Minority. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
34.
Lustick, I. (1988) Creeping bi-nationalism within the Green Line. New Outlook, 31(7), pp. 14-19.
35.
Mar'I, S. (1988) Sources of conflict in Arab-Jewish relations in Israel, in: J. Hofman et al. (Eds) Arab-Jewish Relations in Israel-A Quest in Human Understanding, pp. 1-21. Bristol, IN: Wyndham Press.
36.
Markovitz, Y. (1987) Report of the Interministerial Committee on Illegal Construction in the Arab Sector. Jerusalem: Ministry of the Interior. (Unpublished, in Hebrew).
37.
Meyer Brodnitz, M. (1986) The suburbanisation of Arab villages in Israel , Ofakim Begeographia, 16, pp. 23-36. (In Hebrew).
38.
Ministry Of Housing And Construction (1976 ) Accelerated Urban Development in the Galilee (PAAM Begalil) . Jerusalem: The Programme Branch . (In Hebrew).
39.
Ministry Of Industry (And H. Brand) (1976) Plan for the Distribution of Industry in the Galilee. Tel Aviv: Mivne Taasia. (In Hebrew).
40.
Ministry Of The Interior (In Co-Ordination With The Ministry Of Finance (1972) Geographical Distribution Plan of Israel's Population of 5 Million, Vol. 1 and 2. Jerusalem. (In Hebrew).
41.
National Committee Of Arab Heads Of Local CouNcILs (1974-88) Minutes, Protocols, Correspondence, Leaflets and Press Releases, the Committee's Office (Shfaamer), the Committee's Secretary's Office (Kfar Yasif) and private archives of past and present Committee's members . (Unpublished, in Arabic and Hebrew).
42.
Nordlinger, E.A. (1972) Conflict Regulation in Divided Societies. Cambridge: Centre for International Affairs , Harvard University Press.
43.
Northern District Planning And Building Commitee (1946) Regional Plan: Outline Scheme RP/50/42, The Palestine Gazette, 1533, Supplement No. 2, pp. 1530-1560.
44.
Northern District Planning And Building Committee (1973) Plan No. 852/C—Outline Plan for the Northern District, Vol. 1 and 2. Nazereth. (In Hebrew).
45.
Northern District Planning And Building Committee (1975-88) Outline Plan Files (including Correspondence) and Protocols. Nazereth. (In Hebrew).
46.
Pinkerfeld, U. (Ed.) (1987) The Markovitz Report: Confrontation of Problem Resolution ?, Givaat Haviva: The Institute of Arab Studies. (In Hebrew).
47.
Plotkin, S. (1987) Keep Out: The Struggle for Land Use Control. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
48.
Prime Minister'S Office (1975) The New Development Plan for the Galilee. Jerusalem: Information Centre.
49.
Rekhes, E. (1986) The Arab village in Israel: a renewing national political centre, Ofakim Begeographia, 17-18, pp. 145-160. (In Hebrew).
50.
Rekhes, E. (1989) Israeli Arabs and the Arabs of the West Bank and Gaza Strip: political ties and national identification, Hamizrach Hachadash, 32, pp. 165-191.
51.
Rouhana, N. (1990) The intifada and the Palestinians of Israel: resurrecting the Green Line, Journal of Palestine Studies, 19, pp. 58-75.
52.
Rumley, D. (1991) The political organisation of space: a reformist conception, Australian Geographical Studies, 26, pp. 329-336.
53.
Simmie, J. (1987) Planning theory and planning practice: an analysis of the San Francisco down town plan, Cities, 5, pp. 304-324.
54.
Smooha, S. (1980) Control of minorities in Israel and Northern Ireland , Comparative Studies in Society and History, 22, pp. 256-280.
55.
Smooha, S. (1982) Existing and Alternative policy towards the Arabs in Israel, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 5, pp. 71-98.
56.
Smooha, S. (1989) Arabs and Jews in Israel: Conflicting and Shared Attitudes in a Divided Society, Vol. 1. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
57.
Soffer, A. (1988) The Demographic and Geographic Situation in the Land of Israel: Is it the End of the ZionistVision? Haifa: privately published. (In Hebrew).
58.
Soffer, A. (1989) The Arabs of Israel-from village to metropolis , Hamizrach Hachadash, 32, pp. 97-105.
59.
Soffer, A. and Finkel, R. (1989) The Mitzpim Project-Interim Evaluation. Rehovot: Centre of Settlement Research . (In Hebrew).
60.
State Of Israel (1960) Basic Law-the Lands of Israel (1960), Laws of the State of Israel. Jerusalem: Government Printers. (In Hebrew).
61.
State Of Israel (1965) Planning and Building Law (PBL) (1990— as Amended), Laws of the State of Israel , Jerusalem: Government Printers . (In Hebrew).
62.
Van Den Berghe, P.L. ( 1981 ) The Ethnic Phenomenon. New York: Elsevier.
63.
Williams, C.H. (1985) Minority groups in the modern state, in: M. Pacione (Ed.) Progress in Political Geography , pp. 111-157. London: Croom Helm.
64.
Yiftachel, O. (1988) Geopolitical aspects of stability in a bi-ethnic democracy: the case of Israel's policy towards its Arab minority, Politics, 23(2), pp. 48-56.
65.
Yiftachel, O. (1989) Towards a new typology of urban planning theories , Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 16, pp. 23-39.
66.
Yiftachel, O. (1990) State policies and political stability in a bi-ethnic democracy: the influence of Israel's land use planning policies on Arab-Jewish relations in the Galilee. PhD thesis, University of Western Australia and the Technion, Israel Institute of Technology.
67.
Yiftachel, O. (1991 a) Industrial development and Arabs-Jewish economic gaps in the Galilee, Professional Geographer, 41, pp. 161-177.
68.
Yiftachel, O. (1991b) State policies, land control and an ethnic minority: the Arabs in the Galilee, Israel, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 9, pp. 329-352.
69.
Yiftachel, O. (1992) Planning a Mixed Region in Israel: the Political Geography of Arab-Jewish Relations in the Galilee. Aldershot : Avebury (In press).
70.
Yom Tov, S. (1984) Cultural inhibitions for physical planning progress in Arab villages in the Galilee. PhD thesis, Hebrew University , Jerusalem. (In Hebrew).
