Over the past 25 years a large literature has developed that attempts to measure the impact of zoning regulations on real estate markets. This vast zoning literature is also quite diverse; studies differ significantly in methodology, data and the results obtained. In this paper we systematically survey each of the four general types of zoning studies: externality studies, exogenous land-use zoning studies, studies of characteristics zoning and endogenous zoning studies. Our review is designed to achieve the following objectives: (1) to summarise existing studies and point out methodological problems; (2) to compare different studies to determine what may be causing the differences in results that are obtained; (3) to determine what conclusions can be drawn from the existing body of research; and (4) to suggest how the shortcomings of previous research can be avoided and thereby provide a guide for future research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adams, F.G., Milgram, G., Green, E.W. and Mansfield, C. (1968) Undeveloped land prices during urbanization: a micro-empirical study over time, Review of Economics and Statistics , 50, pp. 248-258.
2.
Asabere, P.K. and Harvey, B. (1985) Factors influencing the value of urban land: evidence from Halifax-Dartmouth, Canada, AREUEA Journal, 13, pp. 361-377.
3.
Avrin, M.E. (1977) Some economic effects of residential zoning in San Francisco, in: G. K. Ingram (Ed.) Residential Location and Urban Housing Markets. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
4.
Blomquist, G. (1974) The effect of electric utility power plant location on area property value, Land Economics, 50, pp. 97-100.
5.
Burnell, J.D. (1985) Industrial land use, externalities, and residential location, UrbanStudies, 22, pp. 399-408.
6.
Crecine, J.P., Davis, O.A. and Jackson, J.E. (1967) Urban property markets: some empirical results and their implications for municipal zoning, Journal of Law and Economics, 10, pp. 79-99.
7.
Crone, T.M. (1983) Elements of an economic justification for municipal zoning, Journal of Urban Economics, 14, pp. 168-183.
8.
Dowall, D.E. and Landis, J.D. (1982) Land-use controls and housing costs: an examination of San Francisco Bay Area communities, AREUEA Journal, 10, pp. 67-93.
9.
Downing, P.B. (1973) Factors affecting commercial land values: an empirical study of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, Land Economics, 49, pp. 44-56.
10.
Erickson, R.A. and Wollover, D.R. (1987) Local tax burdens and the supply of business sites in suburban municipalities, Journal of Regional Science, 27, pp. 25-37.
11.
Fischel, W.A. (1985) The Economics of Zoning Laws: A Property Rights Approach to American Land Use Controls. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
12.
Fischel, W.A. (1988) Do growth controls matter?: a review of empirical evidence on the effectiveness and efficiency of local government land use regulation. Unpublished manuscript, Department of Economics, Dartmouth College, 20 December.
13.
Grether, D.M. and Mieszkowski, P. (1980) The effects of nonresidential land uses on the prices of adjacent housing: some estimates of proximity effects, Journal of Urban Economics, 8, pp. 1-15.
14.
Giueson, R.E. and White, J.R. (1989) The existence and capitalization of neighbourhood externalities: a reassessment, Journal of Urban Economics , 25, pp. 68-76.
15.
Hushak, L.J. (1975) The urban demand for urban-rural fringe land, Land Economics, 51, pp. 112-123.
16.
Ihlanfeldt, K. and Boehm, T.P. (1987) Government intervention in the housing market: an empirical test of the externalities rationale, Journal of Urban Economics, 22, pp. 276-290.
17.
Ihlanfeldt, K. and Martinez-Vasquez, J. (1986) Alternative value estimates of owner-occupied housing: evidence on sample-selection bias and systematic errors, Journal of Urban Economics, 20, pp. 356-369.
18.
Jud, G.D. (1980) The effects of zoning on single-family residential property values: Charlotte, North Carolina, Land Economics , 56, pp. 142-154.
19.
Kain, J.F. and Quigley, J.M. (1970) Measuring the value of housing quality, Journal of the American Statistical Association,65, pp. 532-548.
20.
Lafferty, R.N. and Frech, H.E., III, (1978) Community environment and the market value of single-family homes: the effect of the dispersion of land uses, Journal of Law and Economics, 21, pp. 381-394.
21.
Li, M.M. and Brown, H.J. (1980) Micro-neighborhood externalities and hedonic housing prices, Land Economics, 56, pp. 125-141.
22.
Mark, J.H. and Goldberg, M.A. (1981) Land use controls: the case of zoning in the Vancouver area, AREUEA Journal, 9, pp. 418-435.
23.
Mark, J.H. and Goldberg, M.A. (1986) A study of the impacts of zoning on housing values over time, Journal of Urban Economics, 20, pp. 257-273.
24.
Martinez-Vasquez, J. and Ihlanfeldt, K.R. (1987) Why property tax capitalization rates differ: a critical analysis, in: J. M. Quigley (Ed.) Perspectives on Local Public Finance and Public Policy, Vol. 3. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
25.
Maser, S.M., Riker, W.H. and Rosett, R.N. (1977) The effects of zoning and externalities on the price of land: an empirical analysis of Monroe County, New York, Journal of Law and Economics, 16, pp. 111-132.
26.
McMillen, D.P. and McDonald, J.F. (1989a) A simultaneous equations model of zoning and land values. Working Paper, Department of Economics, University of Oregon.
27.
McMillen, D.P. and McDonald, J.F. (1989b) Selectivity bias in urban land value functions , Land Economics, 65, pp. 341-351.
28.
McMillen, D.P. and McDonald, J.F. (1991) Urban land value functions with endogenous zoning, Journal of Urban Economics, 29, pp. 14-27.
29.
Orr, L.L. (1975) Income, Employment, and Urban Residential Location . New York: Academic Press.
30.
Peterson, G.E. (1974) The influence of zoning regulations on land and housing prices. Working Paper No. 1207-24, The Urban Institute, Washington, DC.
31.
Pogodzinski, J.M. and Sass, T.R. (1990) The economic theory of zoning: a critical review , Land Economics, 66, pp. 294-314.
32.
Rolleston, B.S. (1987) Determinants of restrictive suburban zoning: an empirical analysis, Journal of Urban Economics, 21, pp. 1-21.
33.
Rueter, F.H. (1973) Externalities in urban property markets: an empirical test of the zoning ordinance of Pittsburgh, Journal of Law and Economics, 16, pp. 313-349.
34.
Sagalyn, L.B. and Sternlieb, G. (1973) Zoning and Housing Costs: The Impact of Land Use Controls on Housing Price. New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University.
35.
Stull, W.J. (1975) Community environment, zoning, and the market value of single-family homes, Journal of Law and Economics, 18, pp. 535-557.
36.
Wallace, N.E. (1988) The market effects of zoning undeveloped land: does zoning follow the market?, Journal of Urban Economics , 23, pp. 307-326.
37.
White, J.R. (1988) Large lot zoning and subdivision costs: a test , Journal of Urban Economics, 23, pp. 370-384.
