The skills mismatch and spatial mismatch perspectives are often presented as competing explanations of the spatial distribution of unemployment within metropolitan areas. This paper argues that the spatial mismatch hypothesis addresses some of the shortcomings of the skills mismatch perspective, while not denying the importance of skills mismatch. The development of the spatial mismatch hypothesis in the US is traced, before considering its relevance in the British context. A framework in which to conceptualise and reconcile skills mismatch and spatial mismatch within metropolitan areas is developed, incorporating the operation of local housing and labour markets as well as the role of commuting. The paper concludes by arguing that skills and spatial mismatches reinforce each other and that the concept of employability offers some potential to help understand how job searchers and employers make decisions in situations of skills and/or spatial mismatch. The implications for future research are highlighted.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alonso, W. (1964) Location and Land Use: Towards a General Theory of Land Rent. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger .
2.
Amuedo-Dorantes, C. (2000) Work transitions into and out of involuntary temporary employment in a segmented market: evidence from Spain, Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 53, pp. 309-325.
3.
Aronsson, T. and Brannas, K. (1996) The importance of locational choice in an empirical labour supply model, Applied Economics, 28, pp. 521-529.
4.
Bagshaw, M. (1997) Employability: creating a contract of mutual investment , Industrial and Commercial Training, 29, pp. 187-189.
5.
Bailey, N. and Turok, I. (2000) Adjustment to job loss in Britain's major cities , Regional Studies, 34(7), pp. 631-653.
6.
Beck, M. (1998) Dualism in the German labour market? A non-parametric analysis with panel data, American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 57, pp. 261-283.
7.
Bohelm, R. and Taylor, M.P. (2001) Job search methods, intensity and success in Britain in the 1990s. Working Paper, Institute for Social and Economic Research, University of Essex, Colchester.
8.
Bruegel, I. and Perrons, D. (1996) Deregulation and women's employment: the diverse experience of women in Britain. Discussion paper, The Gender Institute, London School of Economics and Political Science.
9.
Budd, A., Levine, P. and Smith, P. (1988) Unemployment, vacancies and the long-term unemployed , Economic Journal, 98(393), pp. 1071-1091.
10.
Cabinet Office (1999) Sharing the Nation's Prosperity: Variation in Economic and Social Conditions Across the UK. London: The Cabinet Office.
11.
Cadwallader, M. (1992) Migration and Residential Mobility: Macro and Micro Approaches. Wisconsin, MA: The University of Wisconsin Press.
12.
Cheshire, P.C. (1979) Spatial unemployment and inequality, in: J. K. Bowers (Ed.) Inflation, Development and Integration: Essays in Honour of A.J. Brown, pp. 263-278. Leeds : Leeds University Press.
13.
Clarke, H. (1998) International trade, labour migrations and capital flows: long-term evidence for Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States, International Migration, 36(3), pp. 383-408.
14.
Cohn, S. and Fossett, M. (1996) What spatial mismatch? The proximity of Blacks to employment in Boston and Houston, Social Forces, 75(2), pp. 557-572.
15.
Cooke, T.J. (1996) City-Suburb differences in African American Male labor market achievement, Professional Geographer, 48(4), pp. 458-467.
16.
Cooke, T.J. and Shumway, J.M. (1991) Developing the spatial mismatch hypothesis: problems of accessibility to employment for low-wage central city labour, Urban Geography, 12(4), pp. 310-323.
17.
Crampton, G.R. (1997) Labour market search and urban residential structure , Environment and Planning A, 29(6), pp. 989-1002.
18.
Danziger, S. and Gottschalk, P. (1987) Earnings inequality, the spatial concentration of poverty, and the underclass, American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings, 77(2), pp. 211-215.
19.
Doogan, K. (1996) Labour mobility and the changing housing market , Urban Studies, 33(2), pp. 199-221.
20.
Downs, A. (1999) Contrasting strategies for the economic development of metropolitan areas in the United States and Western Europe, in: A. A. Summers, P. Cheshire and L. Senn (Eds) Urban Change in the United States and Western Europe: Comparative Analysis and Policy , pp. 15-54. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.
21.
Duffy, C. (1992) Disadvantage and exclusion: the case of peripheral estates, in: M. Campbell and C. Duffy (Eds) Local Labour Markets: Problems and Policies, pp. 89-116. Harlow: Longman .
22.
Ellwood, D.T. (1983) The spatial mismatch hypothesis: are there teenage jobs missing in the ghetto? Working Paper No.1188 , NBER.
23.
Fernandez, R.M. and Weinberg, N. (1996) Getting a job: networks and hiring in a retail bank. Graduate Business School Research Paper No. 1382, University of Stanford, March.
24.
Fieldhouse, E. and Tranmer, M. (2001) Concentration effects, spatial mismatch, or neighbourhood selection? Exploring labour market and neighbourhood variations in male unemployment risk using census microdata from Great Britain, Geographical Analysis, 33(4), pp. 353-369.
25.
Fieldhouse, E.A. (1999) Ethnic minority unemployment and spatial mismatch: the case of London, UrbanStudies, 36(9), pp. 1569-1596.
26.
Fine, B. (1998) Labour Market Theory: A Constructive Reassessment . London: Routledge.
27.
Forrest, R. and Murie, A. (1994) The dynamics of the owner-occupied housing-market in southern England in the late 1980s: a study of new building and vacancy chains, Regional Studies, 28(3), pp. 275-289.
28.
Gabriel, S.A. and Rosenthal, S.S. (1996) Commutes, neighbourhood effects and earnings: an analysis of racial discrimination and compensating differentials, Journal of Urban Economics, 40(1), pp. 61-83.
29.
Garner, C., Main, B.G.M. and Raffe, D. (1988) The distribution of school-leaver unemployment within Scottish cities, UrbanStudies, 25, pp. 133-144.
30.
Gordon, I. (1985) The cyclical interaction between regional migration, employment and unemployment: a time series analysis for Scotland, Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 32(2), pp. 135-158.
31.
Gordon, I. (1987) Evaluating the effects of employment changes on local unemployment, Regional Studies, 22, pp. 135-147.
32.
Gordon, I. (1988) Interdistrict migration in Great Britain 1980-81: a multistream model with a commuting option, Environment and Planning A, 20, pp. 907-924.
33.
Gordon, I. (1990) Housing and labour market constraints on migration across the North-South divide, in: J. Ermisch (Ed.) Housing and the National Economy, pp. 75-89. Aldershot : Avebury.
34.
Gordon, I. (1999) Move on up the car: dealing with structural unemployment in London. Local Economy, May, pp. 87-95.
35.
Gordon, I. (2002) Unemployment and spatial labour markets: strong adjustment and persistent concentration, in: R. Martin and P. Morrison (Eds) Geographies of Labour Market Inequality, pp. 55-82. London : Taylor and Francis.
36.
Gordon, I. and Vickerman, R. (1982) Opportunity, preference and constraint: an approach to the analysis of metropolitan migration, UrbanStudies, 19, pp. 247-261.
37.
Gordon, P., Kumar, A. and Richardson, H.W. (1989) The spatial mismatch hypothesis: some new evidence, UrbanStudies, 26, pp. 315-326.
38.
Green, A.E. (1994) The role of migration in labour market adjustment: the British experience in the 1980s, Environment and Planning A, 26, pp. 1563-1577.
39.
Green, A.E. and Turok, I. (2000) Employability, adaptability and flexibility: changing labour market prospects, Regional Studies, 34, pp. 599-600.
40.
Ham, M. VanHooimeijer, P. and Mulder, C. (2001) Urban form and job access: disparate realities in the Randstad, Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geograpfie , 92, pp. 231-246.
41.
Hanson, S., Kominiak, T. and Carlin, S. (1997) Assessing the impact of location on women's labor market outcomes: a methodological exploration, Geographical Analysis, 29(4), pp. 281-297.
42.
Hawkins, K. (1987) Unemployment. 3rd edn. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
43.
Hasluck, C. (1987) Urban Unemployment. London: Longman.
44.
Hill, E.W. and Bier, T. (1989) Economic restructuring: earnings, occupations, and housing values in Cleveland, Economic Development Quarterly , 3(2), pp. 123-144.
45.
Hillage, J. and Pollard, E. (1998) Employability: developing a framework for policy analysis. Research Report No. 85. Department for Education and Employment, London.
46.
Holtham, G. and Mayhew, K. (1996) Tackling Long-term Unemployment. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
47.
Holzer, H.J. (1991) The spatial mismatch hypothesis: what has the evidence shown?, UrbanStudies, 28(1), pp. 105-122.
48.
Holzer, H.J., Ihlanfeldt, K.R. and Sjoquist, D.L. (1994) Work, search and travel among White and Black youth , Journal of Urban Economics, 35, pp. 320-345.
49.
Houston, D.S. (1998) "Job proximity and the urban unemployment problem: do suitable nearby jobs improve neighbourhood employment rates?" A comment, UrbanStudies, 35(12), pp. 2353-2357.
50.
Houston, D.S. (2001) Testing the spatial mismatch hypothesis in the United Kingdom using evidence from firm relocations, in: D. Pitfield (Ed.) Transport Planning, Logistics, and Spatial Mismatch, pp. 134-151. London: Pion.
51.
Hoyt, H. (1939) The Structure and Growth of Residential Neighbourhoods in American Cities. Washington, DC: Federal Housing Administration.
52.
Hughes, G. and McCormick, B. (1981) Do council housing policies reduce migration between regions?, The Economic Journal, 91, pp. 919-937.
53.
Hughes, G. and Nolan, B. (1997) Segmented labour markets and earnings in Ireland , Economic and Social Review, 28, pp. 1-22.
54.
Hughes, M.A. (1989) Misspeaking truth to power: a geographical perspective on the "underclass" fallacy, Economic Geography, 65(3), pp. 187-207.
55.
Ihlanfeldt, K.R. and Sjoquist, D.L. (1989) The impact of job decentralisation on the economic welfare of central city Blacks, Journal of Urban Economics , 26, pp. 110-130.
56.
Ihlanfeldt, K.R. and Sjoquist, D.L. (1990) Job accessibility and racial differences in youth employment rates, The American Economic Review, March, pp. 267-276.
57.
Ihlanfeldt, K.R. and Sjoquist, D.L. (1998) The spatial mismatch hypothesis: a review of recent studies and their implications for welfare reform, Housing Policy Debate, 9(4), pp. 849-892.
58.
Immergluck, D. (1998a) Job proximity and the urban unemployment problem: do suitable nearby jobs improve neighbourhood employment rates?, UrbanStudies, 35(1), pp. 7-23.
59.
Immergluck, D. (1998b) Neighborhood economic development and local working: the effect of nearby jobs on where residents work, Economic Geography, 74(2), pp. 170-187.
60.
Jargowsky, P.A. (1997) Poverty and Place: Ghettos, Barrios and the American City. New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
61.
Johnston-Anumonwo, I. (1995) Racial differences in the commuting behaviour of women in Buffalo, 1980-1990, Urban Geography, 16(1), pp. 23-45.
62.
Kain, J. (1968) Housing segregation, Negro unemployment and metropolitan segregation, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 82, pp. 175-197.
63.
Kasarda, J.D. (1990) City jobs and residents on a collision course: the urban underclass dilemma, Economic Development Quarterly , 4(4), pp. 313-319.
64.
Kasper, H. (1983) Toward estimating the incidence of journey-to-work costs, UrbanStudies, 20, pp. 197-208.
65.
Kawabata, M. (2003) Job access and employment among low-skilled autoless workers in US metropolitan areas, Environment and Planning A, 35, pp. 1651-1668.
66.
Kitching, R. (1990) Migration behaviour among the unemployed and low skilled, in: J. H. Johnson, and J. Salt (Eds) Labour Migration, pp. 172-190. London : David Fulton Publishers Ltd.
67.
Layard, R. (1997) Sweden's road back to full employment, Economic and Industrial Democracy, 18(1), pp. 99-118.
68.
Layard, R. and Nickell, S. (1987) The labour market, in: R. Dornbusch and R. Layard (Eds) The Performance of the British Economy, pp. 131-179. Oxford : Clarendon Press.
69.
Lee, P. ( 1994) Housing and spatial deprivation: relocating the underclass and the new urban poor, Urban Studies, 31(7), pp. 1191-1209.
70.
Maclennan, D. (1999) Decentralisation and residential choices in european cities: the roles of state and market, in: A. A. Summers, P. Cheshire, and L. Senn (Eds) Urban Change in the United States and Western Europe: Comparative Analysis and Policy precode , pp. 529-551. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.
71.
Madden, J.F. (1981) Why women work closer to home, UrbanStudies, 18, pp. 181-194.
72.
Mair, D. and Miller, A.G. (1989) Urban Unemployment: A Causal Modelling Approach., UrbanStudies, 26, pp. 379-396.
73.
Manacorda, M. and Petrongolo, B. (1999) Skill mismatch and unemployment in OECD countries , Economica, 66(262), pp. 181-207.
74.
Manning, N. (1995) Earnings, unemployment and house prices: some results for British counties, Scottish Journal of Political Economy , 42(4), pp. 428-442.
75.
Martin, B. (1994) Understanding class segmentation in the labor market: an empirical study of earnings determination in Australia, Work, Employment and Society, 8, pp. 357-385.
76.
Martin, R. and Morrison, P. (2002) Thinking about the geographies of labour, in: R. Martin and P. Morrison (Eds) Geographies of Labour Market Inequality , pp. 3-20. London: Taylor and Francis.
77.
Massey, D. (1984) Spatial Divisions of Labour: Social Structures and the Geography of Production. London: Macmillan.
78.
Massey, D.S. (1996) The age of extremes: concentrated affluence and poverty in the twenty-first century, Demography, 33(4), pp. 395-412.
79.
Mcgregor, A. (1977) Intra-urban variations in unemployment duration: a case study, UrbanStudies, 14, pp. 303-313.
80.
McGregor, A. and McConnachie, M. (1995) Social exclusion, urban regeneration and economic reintegration, Urban Studies, 32(10), pp. 1587-1600.
81.
McLafferty, S. and Preston, V. (1996) Spatial mismatch and employment in a decade of restructuring, Professional Geographer, 8(4), pp. 420-431.
82.
McLafferty S. and Preston, V. (1997) Gender, race and the determinants of commuting: New York in 1990, Urban Geography, 18(3), pp. 192-212.
83.
McNabb, R. and Whitfield, K. (1998) Testing for segmentation: an establishment-level analysis, Cambridge Journal of Economics, 22, pp. 347-365.
84.
McQuaid, R.W. and Lindsay, C. (2002) The 'employability gap': long-term unemployment and barriers to work in buoyant labour markets, Environment and Planning C, pp. 613-628.
85.
McQuaid, R.W. and Lindsay, C. (2005) The concept of employability, Urban Studies, 42(2), pp. 197-219.
86.
McQuaid, R.W., Greig, M. and Adams, J. (2001) Unemployed job seeker attitudes towards potential travel-to-work times, Growth and Change, 32(3), pp. 355-368.
87.
Megbolugbe, I.F., Hoek-Smit, M.C. and Linneman, P.D. (1996) Understanding neighbourhood dynamics: a review of the contributions of William G. Grigsby, UrbanStudies , 33(10), pp. 1779-1795.
88.
Metcalf, D. and Richardson, R. (1976) Unemployment in London, in: G. D. N. Worswick (Ed.) The Concept and Measurement of Involuntary Unemployment, pp. 203-220. London: George Allen and Unwin.
89.
Millington, J. (1995) Age and inter-county net migration in Great Britain , Applied Economic Letters, 2(4), pp. 107-109.
90.
Minford, P., Peel, M. and Ashton, P. (1987) The Housing Morass. London: Institute of Economic Affairs.
91.
Molho, I. (1995) Migrant inertia, accessibility and local unemployment , Economica, 62, pp. 123-152.
92.
Moss, P. and Tilly, C. (1996) "Soft" skills and race: an investigation of Black men's employment problems, Work and Occupations, 23(3), pp. 252-276.
93.
Newman, P. and Denman, J. (1995) A guide to statistics on job centre vacancies and placings, Labour Market Trends, November, pp. 419-423.
94.
Oecd (Organisation For Economic Cooperation And Development) (1994) The Jobs Study: Facts, Analysis, Strategies . Paris: OECD.
95.
O'Regan, K.M. (1993) The effect of social networks and concentrated poverty on Black and Hispanic youth unemployment, Annals of Regional Science, 27(4), pp. 327-342.
96.
O'Regan, K.M. and Quigley, J.M. (1998) Where youth live: economic effects of urban space on employment prospects, Urban Studies, 35(7), pp. 1187-1205.
97.
Ottersten, E.K., Lindh, T. and Mellander, E. (1999) Evaluating firm training, effects on performance and labour demand, Applied Economics Letters, 6(7), pp. 431-437.
98.
Owen, D. and Green, A. (1999) The role of spatial and skills mismatches in understanding the labour market experience of minority ethnic groups in Great Britain. Paper presented at the Regional Studies Association International Conference, University of the Basque Country, Bilbao, September.
99.
Peck, J. (1999) New labourers? Making a New Deal for the 'workless class'. Environment and PlanningC, 17(3), pp. 345-372.
100.
Pugh, M. (1998) Barriers to work: the spatial divide between jobs and welfare recipients in metropolitan areas. Discussion Paper. Center on Urban and Metropolitan Policy, The Brookings Institution , Washington, DC.
101.
Raphael, S. (1998) The spatial mismatch hypothesis and black youth joblessness: evidence from the San Francisco Bay area, Journal of Urban Economics, 43, pp. 79-111.
102.
Robinson, P. (1991) Unemployment and local labour markets: an overview , in: P. Robinson (Ed.) Unemployment and Local Labour Markets, pp. 1-18. Aldershot: Avebury.
103.
Ross, S.L. (1998) Racial differences in residential and job mobility: evidence concerning the spatial mismatch hypothesis, Journal of Urban Economics, 43, pp. 112-135.
104.
Russo, G., Rietveld, P., Nijkamp, P. and Gorter, C. (1996) Spatial aspects of the recruitment behaviour of firms: an empirical investigation, Environment and Planning A, 28, pp. 1077-1093.
105.
Sanchez, T.W. (1999) The connection between public transit and employment: the cases of Portland and Atlanta, Journal of the American Planning Association, 65(3), pp. 284-296.
106.
Shen, Q. (1998) Location characteristics of inner-city neighbourhoods and employment accessibility of low-wage workers, Environment and Planning B, 25, pp. 345-365.
107.
Social Exclusion Unit (1998) Bringing Britain Together: A National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal. London: HMSO.
108.
Summers, A.A. (1999) Urban America and western Europe: are they different ?, in: A. A. Summers, P. Cheshire and L. Senn (Eds) Urban Change in the United States and Western Europe. Comparative Analysis and Policy, pp. 1-11. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute Press.
109.
Thomas, J.M. (1998) Ethnic variation in commuting propensity and unemployment spells: some UK evidence, Journal of Urban Economics, 43, pp. 385-400.
110.
Thompson, M.A. (1997) The impact of spatial mismatch on female labour force participation, Economic Development Quarterly, 11(2), pp. 138-145.
111.
Thrift, N. and Olds, K. (1996) Refiguring the economic in economic geography, Progress in Human Geography, 20, pp. 311-337.
112.
Toothill, J.N. (1961) Inquiry into the Scottish Economy. Edinburgh: Scottish Council, Development and Industry .
113.
Turner, S.C. (1997) Barriers to a better break: employer discrimination and spatial mismatch in metropolitan Detroit, Journal of Urban Affairs, 19(2), pp. 123-141.
114.
Turok ,I. and Edge, N. (1999) The Jobs Gap in Britain's Cities. Bristol: The Policy Press/Joseph Rowntree Foundation .
115.
Turok ,I. and Webster, D. (1998) The new deal: jeopardised by the geography of unemployment ?, Local Economy, 12(4), pp. 309-328.
116.
Vipond, J. (1980) Intra-urban unemployment differentials in Sydney, 1971, Urban Studies, 17, pp. 131-138.
117.
Vipond, J. (1984) The intra-urban unemployment gradient: the influence of location on unemployment, UrbanStudies, 21, pp. 377-388.
118.
Webster, D. (1994) Home and workplace in the Glasgow conurbation. Working Paper, Glasgow City Housing.
119.
Webster, D. (1997) The 'L-U curve'. Occasional Paper No. 36, Centre for Housing Research and Urban Studies, University of Glasgow .
120.
Wilson, W.J. (1987) The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, the Underclass and Public Policy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
121.
Zax, J.S. (1991) Compensation for commutes in labor and housing markets, Journal of Urban Economics, 30, pp. 192-207.
122.
Zhang, Z. (1998) Indirect tests of the spatial mismatch hypothesis in the Cleveland PMSA: a labour market perspective, Urban Affairs Review, 33(5), pp. 712-723.
