This note examines the purported impact of conventional socioeconomic and social environment factors on annual, state-level suicide rates. Results from an inductive fixed-effects (covariance) analysis, of state-level time-series/cross-section data for the period 1985-95, do little to support Durkheim's social causes hypothesis that aggregate socioeconomic factors matter in explaining state suicide rates. A possible source of heterogeneity-aggregation bias is identified raising questions surrounding past inferences made in aggregate suicide research. The data and empirical method support a mounting sentiment of an abiding ecological fallacy in the suicide literature. Implications of this investigation call for a shift in research focus and method to a smaller unit of analysis (for example, individual-level, controlling for key social processes).
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Baltagi, B. (1995) Econometric Analysis of Panel Data. London: John Wiley & Sons.
2.
Bevilacqua, L. (1996) Was Adler right? The issue of suicide, 1937-1996: a review of the literature, Individual Psychology, 52, pp. 378-385.
3.
Breault, K.D. (1986) Suicide in America: a test of Durkheim's theory of religious and family integration, 1933-1980, American Journal of Sociology, 92, pp. 628-656.
4.
Breault, K.D. (1995) Was Durkheim right?: A critical survey of the empirical literature on Le Suicide, in: D. Lester (Ed.) Celebrating the Centennial of Durkheim's Le Suicide, pp. 35-62. Philadelphia, PA: Charles Press.
5.
Breault, K.D. and Kposowa, A. (1987) Explaining divorce in the United States: a study of 3,111 counties, 1980, Journal of Marriage and the Family , 49, pp. 549-558.
6.
Burnley, I. (1994) Differential and spatial aspects of suicide mortality in New South Wales and Sydney, 1980 to 1991, Australian Journal of Public Health, 18, pp. 293-304.
7.
Burr, J., Mccall, P. and Powel-Griner, E. (1994) Catholic religion and suicide: The mediating effects of divorce, Social Science Quarterly , 75, pp. 300-318.
8.
Center For Disease Control (2001) Suicide prevention fact sheet. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control , Center for Disease Control, Washington, DC, January.
9.
Cheung, Y., Yip, P. and Kposowa, A. (2000) Marital status and suicide: some common methodological problems, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 54, pp. 878-879.
10.
Congdon, P. (1996) Suicide and parasuicide in London: a small-area study, UrbanStudies, 33, pp.137-158.
11.
Cutchin, M. and Churchill, R. (1999) Scale, context, and causes of suicide in the United States, Social Sciences Quarterly, 80, pp. 97-114.
12.
Cutright, P. and Fernquist, R. (2000) Effects of societal integration, period, region, and culture of suicide on male age-specific suicide rates: 20 developed countries, 1955-1989, Social Science Research, 29, pp. 148-172.
13.
Durkheim, E. (1897/1951) Suicide: A Study in Sociology . New York: Free Press.
14.
Hausman, J.A. (1978) Specification tests in econometrics, Econometrica, 46, pp. 1251-1271.
15.
Hood-Williams, J. (1996) Studying suicide, Health and Place , 2, pp. 167-177.
16.
Klein, R. and Schoenborn, C. (2001) Age adjustment using projected U.S. population. CDC Statistical Notes No. 20, National Center for Health Statistics, Washington, DC.
17.
Kposowa, A. (2000) Marital status and suicide in the National Longitudinal Mortality Study, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health , 54, pp. 254-261.
18.
Kposowa, A., Breault, K.D. and Singh, G. (1995) White male suicide in the United States: a multivariate individual-level analysis, Social Forces, 74, pp. 315-325.
19.
Lester, D. (1995) Suicide and alternative measures of domestic integration , Psychological Reports, 77, p. 1322.
20.
Lester, D. (1999) Correlates of regional suicide rates: a meta-analysis , Omega, 38, pp. 99-102.
21.
Lester, D. and Clarke, R. (1991) Note on suicide and increased availability of handguns in the U.S., Social Science & Medicine, 32, pp.1311-1323.
22.
Platt, S., Micciolo, R. and Tansella, M. (1992) Suicide and unemployment in Italy, Social Science and Medicine, 34, pp. 1191-1201.
23.
South, S. (1984) Racial differences in suicide: the effect of economic convergence, Social Science Quarterly, 65, pp. 172-180.
24.
Stack, S. (2000) Suicide: a 15-year review of the sociological literature , Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, 30, pp. 145-179.
25.
Thompson, A., Barnsley, R. and Dyck, R. (1999) A new factor in youth suicide: the relative age effect, Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 44, pp. 82-101.
