Housing allowances are provided in the US by the federal government under Section 8 of the 1974 Housing and Community Development Act. This paper compares the design of Section 8 certificates and vouchers with that of Canadian housing allowances and with aspects of design in many other developed nations. Distinguishing elements of Section 8 are discussed: its minimum standards condition, its use of a three-way contract in which both the government housing agency and the tenant pays a private landlord, its availability to only a limited number of eligibles, the absence of a percentage-of-rent element in its formulas and the low required contribution of its recipients. It is argued on the basis of an array of diverse evidence that these characteristics lead to perverse housing consumption effects, stigma, rent inflation and unnecessary restrictions on recipient choice. The paper also addresses the standard objections to dropping the minimum standards condition and to incorporating a percentage-of-rent element in the formula.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Apgar JR.,W.C. (1990) Which housing policy is best?, Housing Policy Debate, 1 pp. 11-32.
2.
Arnott, R. (1989) Housing vacancies, thin markets, and idiosyncratic tastes, Journal of Real Estate Finance andEconomics, 2, pp. 5-30.
3.
Benjamin, J.D., Chinloy, P. and Sirmans, G.S. (2000) Housing vouchers, tenant quality, and apartment values, Journal of Real Estate Finance andEconomics, 20, pp. 37-48.
4.
Bird, E.J. (1996) Exploring the stigma of food stamps. Paper No. 1097-96, Institute for Research on Poverty Discussion, University of Wisconsin.
5.
Blanc, M. and Bertrand, L. (1996) France, in: P. Balchin (Ed.) Housing Policy in Europe, pp. 125-145. London : Routledge.
6.
Bradbury, K.L. and Downs, A. (1981) Do Housing Allowances Work?Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
7.
Burchell, R.W. and Listokin, D. (1995) Influences on United States housing policy, Housing Policy Debate, 6, pp. 559-617.
8.
Cage, R. (1994) How does rental assistance influence spending behaviour? , Monthly Labor Review, May, pp. 17-28.
9.
Colwell, P.F. and Dehring, C.A. (1995) Problems with Section 8 rental assistance, Illinois Real Estate Letter, Fall, pp. 1-5.
10.
COMSOC (Ontario Ministry of Community and Social Services) (1988a) Analysis of Shelter Subsidy Expenditures from 1981 to 1988. Income Maintenance Branch (draft).
11.
COMSOC (Ontario Ministry of Community and Social Services) (1988b) Transitions: Report of the Social Assistance Review Committee. Toronto: Queen's Printer .
12.
Dreier, P. and Hulchanski, J.D. (1993) The role of nonprofit housing in Canada and the United States: some comparisons, Housing Policy Debate, 4, pp. 43-80.
13.
van Dyk, N. (1995) Financing social housing in Canada, Housing Policy Debate, 6, pp. 815-848.
14.
Fallis, G. (1980) Housing programs and income distribution in Ontario . Research Study, Ontario Economic Council, Ontario.
15.
Fallis, G. and Murray, A. (1990) Housing the Homeless and Poor: New Partnerships among the Private, Public and Third Sectors. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
16.
Friedman, J. and. Weinberg, D.H. (1982) The Economics of Housing Vouchers. New York: Academic Press.
17.
Grigsby, W.G. (1990) Housing finance and subsidies in the United States, UrbanStudies, 27, pp. 831-845.
18.
Hanushek, E.A. and Quigley, J.M. (1979) The dynamics of the housing market: a stock adjustment model of housing consumption, Journal of Urban Economics, 6(1), pp. 90-111.
19.
Hanushek, E.A. and Quigley, J.M. (1981) Consumption aspects, in: K. L. BRADBURY and A. DOWNS, Do Housing Allowances Work?, pp. 185-240. Washinton, DC: The Brookings Institution.
20.
Henderson, J.V. and Ioannides, Y.M. (1983) A model of housing tenure choice, American Economic Review, March, pp. 98-113.
21.
Howenstine, E.J. (1986) Housing Vouchers: An International Analysis. New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research, Rutgers University.
22.
Hungerford, T.L. (1996) The dynamics of housing assistance spells, Journal of Urban Economics, 39, pp. 193-208.
23.
Kemp, P.A. (1990) Income-related assistance with housing costs: a cross-national comparison, UrbanStudies, 27, pp. 795-808.
24.
Kemp, P.A. (1997) A Comparative Study of Housing Allowances. UK Department of Social Security Research Report No. 60. London: The Stationery Office.
25.
Kemp, Peter A. (2000) 'Shopping Incentives' and Housing Benefit Reform . York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation .
26.
Kemp, P.A. and Leather, P. (2000) Housing Benefit Reform: Price Incentives. York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation.
27.
Kemp, P.A. and McLaverty, P. (1998) Private tenants and 'perverse incentives' in the housing benefit scheme, Environment and Planning C, 16, pp. 395-409.
28.
Kennedy, S.D. and Finkel, M. (1987) Report of the First Year Findings for the Freestanding Housing Voucher Demonstration . Cambridge, MA: ABT Associates .
29.
Khadduri, J. and Martin, M. (1997) Mixed income housing in the HUD multifamily stock , Cityscape, 3(2), pp. 33-69.
30.
Koebel, C.T. ( 1997) Housing conditions of low-income families in the private, unassisted housing market in the United States, Housing Studies , 12, pp. 201-213.
31.
Krashinsky, M. (1995) Putting the poor to work: why 'Workfare' is an idea whose time has come, in: J. Richards and W. G. Watson (Eds) Helping the Poor, pp. 91-120. Toronto : C. D. Howe Institute.
32.
Malpezzi, S. and Green, R.K. (1996) What has happened to the bottom of the US housing markets, UrbanStudies, 33, pp. 1807-1820.
33.
Mayo, S.K. (1986) Sources of inefficiency in subsidized housing programs: a comparison of U. S. and German experience, Journal of Urban Economics, 20, pp. 229-249.
34.
Michelson, W. and van Vliet, W. (2000) The sociology of housing , in: S. Quah and A. Sales (Eds) International Handbook of Sociology. London : Sage Publications Ltd. (forthcoming).
35.
Minuk, M. and Davidson, K. (1981) A report on the research findings of the MHRC 1981 Shelter Allowance Programs Review. (draft). Winnipeg: Manitoba Housing and Renewal Corporation.
36.
Morrison, P.S. (1995) The geography of rental housing and the restructuring of housing assistance in New Zealand, Housing Studies, 10, pp. 39-56.
37.
Murray, A. (1990) Homelessness: the people, in: G. FALLIS and A. MURRAY Housing the Homeless and Poor: New Partnerships among the Private, Public and Third Sectors, pp. 6-48. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
38.
"Name withheld by request" (1996) My life as a Section 8 landlord, Illinois Real Estate Letter, Winter, p. 14.
39.
Newman, S.J. and Schnare, A.B. (1989) Reassessing shelter assistance: the interrelationship between welfare and housing programs, in: S. Rosenberry and C. Hartman (Eds) Housing Issues of the 1990s, pp. 121-148. New York: Praeger.
40.
Olsen, E.O. and Crews, A.D. (1996) Are Section 8 housing subsidies too high? Paper presented to the New Orleans Meetings of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association, January 1997 ( Department of Economics, Charlottesville, Virginia ).
41.
Ontario, Advisory Group On New Social Assistance Legislation (1992) Time for Action: Principal Report. Report on Legislative Reform. Toronto: Queen's Printer.
42.
Painter, G. (1997) Welfare reform: what can we learn from the rationing of housing assistance. Paper presented to the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association Meetings in New Orleans. (Los Angeles: University of Southern California School of Public Administration).
43.
Phipps, S. (1999) Economics and the well-being of Canadian children , Canadian Journal of Economics, 32, pp. 1135-1163.
44.
Pomeroy, S.P. (1995) A Canadian perspective on housing policy, Housing Policy Debate, 6, pp.619-653.
45.
Quebec, Gouvernement De (1984) Memoir au Conseil des Minstres de Monsieur Guy Tardif, Ministre de l'Habitation et de la Protection du consommateur. Quebec.
46.
Richmond, D. (1996) In defense of public housing, The Globe and Mail , Toronto edn, 9 February, p. A21.
47.
Runge, D. (1991) Memorandum on housing allowances (labelled Dallard Runge-FRPO-91/ 11/18). Ontario Regional Office, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Toronto.
48.
Steele, M. (1985) Canadian Housing Allowances: An Economic Analysis. Ontario Economic Council Research Study. Toronto: University of Toronto Press for Ontario Economic Council.
49.
Steele, M. (1995) Two kinds of Canadian housing allowance, 1980 to 1993: an evaluation. Research Paper 191, Centre for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto.
50.
Steele, M. (1998) Canadian Housing allowances inside and outside the welfare system, Canadian Public Policy—Analyse de Politiques, 24, pp. 209-232.
51.
Strazheim, M. (1981) Participation, in: K. L. BRADBURY and A. DOWNS Do Housing Allowances Work?, pp. 113-145. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution.
52.
Tomann, H. (1996) Germany, in: P. Balchin (Ed.) Housing Policy in Europe, pp. 51-66. London : Routledge.
53.
Turner, M.A., Popkin, S. and Cunningham, M. (2000) Section 8 Mobility and Neighbourhood Health. Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
54.
Vale, L. (1996) Public Housing redevelopment: seven kinds of success , Housing Policy Debate, 7, pp. 491-534.
55.
Wallace, J.E. (1995) Financing affordable housing in the United States , Housing Policy Debate, 6, pp. 785-814.
56.
Weicher, J.C. (1996) Problems with Section 8: a comment, Illinois Real Estate Letter, Winter, pp. 8-11.
57.
Weicher, J.C. (1997) Privatizing Subsidized Housing. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
58.
Wexler, M.E. (1996) A comparison of Canadian and American housing policies , Urban Studies, 33, pp. 1909-1921.
