Response Selection in Spatial Choice Reaction: Further Evidence against Associative Models

Abstract

In a “consistent” spatial choice reaction task the same spatial relationship obtains between each stimulus and its correct response. In an “inconsistent” task this is not so. While Duncan (1977a) found both easy (spatially corresponding) and difficult (spatially opposite) responses to be slowed in inconsistent tasks, Smith (1977) found this only for the corresponding responses, the reverse holding for opposites. Reasons for this discrepancy are examined. The result of Smith (1977) depends on the use of different numbers of alternative responses in consistent and inconsistent tasks, a situation allowing no useful comparison between the two. Effects of consistency are related to others in the literature. The general conclusion is that, in these tasks, response selection is based not on a list of associations between individual stimuli and responses, but on operations or rules each of which will generate a set of stimulus–response pairs.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bertelson

(1961). Sequential redundancy and speed in a serial two-choice responding task. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 13, 90–102.

Duncan

(1976). “Association” and “Decision”: S-R Compatibility in Choice Reaction Tasks Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Oxford.

Duncan

(1977a). Response selection rules in spatial choice reaction tasks In Dornic

Attention and Performance VI Hillsdale, N. J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Duncan

(1977b). Response selection errors in spatial choice reaction tasks. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 29, 415–23.

Forrin

(1975). Naming latencies to mixed sequences of letters and digits. Rabbitt

P. M. A.

Dornic

(Eds.), Attention and Performance V London: Academic Press.

Forrin

Morin

R. E.

(1966). Effect of contextual associations upon selective reaction-time in a numeral-naming task. Journal of Experimental Psychology 71, 40–6.

Forrin

Morin

R. E.

(1967). Effects of context on reaction time to optimally coded signals. In Sanders

A. F.

(Ed.), Attention and Performance I Amsterdam: North-Holland.

Hawkins

H. L.

MacKay

S. L.

Holley

S. L.

Friedin

B. D.

Cohen

S. L.

(1973). Locus of the relative frequency effect in choice reaction time. Journal of Experimental Psychology 101, 90–9.

Hick

W. E.

(1952). On the rate of gain of information. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 4, 11–26.

10.

Leonard

J. A.

(1959). Tactual choice reactions: I. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 11, 76–83.

11.

Morin

R. E.

Forrin

(1962). Mixing of two types of S-R associations in a choice reaction time task. Journal of Experimental Psychology 64, 137–41.

12.

Nickerson

R. S.

(1973). Can characters be classified directly as digits vs. letters or must they be identified first? Memory and Cognition 1, 477–84.

13.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

(1966). Errors and error correction in choice-response tasks. Journal of Experimental Psychology 71, 264–72.

14.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

(1967). Learning to ignore irrelevant information. American Journal of Psychology 80, 1–13.

15.

Rabbitt

P. M. A.

Vyas

(1973). What is repeated in the “repetition effect”? In Kornblum

(Ed.), Attention and Performance IV London: Academic Press.

16.

Shaffer

L. H.

(1965). Choice reaction with variable S-R mapping. Journal of Experimental Psychology 70, 284–8.

17.

Smith

(1977). Studies of compatibility and a new model of choice reaction time. In Dornic

(Ed.), Attention and Performance VI Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

18.

Theios

(1973). Reaction time measurements in the study of memory processes: Theory and data. In Bower

G. H.

(Ed.), The Psychology of Learning and Motivation: Advances in Research and Theory London: Academic Press VII.

19.

Theios

(1975). The components of response latency in simple human information processing tasks. In Rabbitt

P. M. A.

Dornic

(Ed.), Attention and Performance V London: Academic Press.

20.

Welford

A. T.

(1958). Ageing and human skill London: Oxford University Press.