Madness has resisted a satisfactory categorisation for 2, 000 years or more. During the last century attempts to define and understand schizophrenia as an entity within that disorder have failed. This article explores some of the reasons why this may have happened, in particular considering whether the syndrome that we now call schizophrenia has changed in recent years and whether it existed at all four centuries ago. It is based on the author's experience and upon contemporary case histories.
References
1.
MerskeyH.ShafranB.Political hazards in the diagnosis of ‘sluggish schizophrenia’Brit J Psychiat148, 1986247–56
WalkerA. S.Clinical Problems of War, Australian War Memorial, Canberra1952707
4.
BenjaminJ. D.A method for distinguishing, and evaluating formal thinking disorders in schizophrenia in KasaninJ. S. (ed.), Language and Thought in Schizophrenia, University of California Press, Los Angeles, 194465–88
5.
HaslamJ.Observations on Madness and Insanity, 2nd edn, J. Callow, London1809, 64–7
6.
PrichardJ.C.A Treatise on Insanity and Other Disorders Affecting the Mind, Haswell, Barrington and Haswell, Philadelphia, 1837, 71
7.
KraepelinE.Clinical psychiatry in DefendorffA. R. (ed.), Lehrbuch der Psychiatrie, 6th edn, 1899, Macmillan, New York, 1904152–160, cited in M. D. Altschule, The Development of Traditional Psychopathology, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1976, 258–80
8.
WillisJ. H.BannisterD.The diagnosis and treatment of schizophrenia. A questionnaire study of psychiatric opinionBrit J Psychiat111, 19651165
9.
MellorC. S.First rank symptoms of schizophreniaBrit J Psychiat117, 197015–23
10.
CarrV.WaleJ.Schizophrenia: an information processing modelAust and NZ J Psychiat20, 1986136
11.
PrilipkoL. L.Biological studies of schizophrenia in EuropeSchizophrenia Bulletin12, 198683–100
12.
ZubinJ.MagazinerJ.SteinhaverS. R.The metamorphosis of schizophrenia from chronicity to vulnerabilityPsychological Medicine13, 1983551–71
13.
RomanoJ.On the nature of schizophrenia: changes in the observer as well as in the observedSchizophrenia Bulletin4, 1977532
14.
StollerA.EmmersonR.Psychiatric memorabilia — early Victoria psychiatry, Australian and New Zealand supplement, in History of Medicine3, 19741
15.
HareE. H.Masturbatory insanity: the history of an ideaJ Ment Sci108, 19621–25
16.
HareE. H.Was insanity on the increase?Brit J Psychiat142, 1983439–55
17.
HaslamJ.Observations on InsanityRivington, London, 1798
18.
HaslamJ.Observations on Insanity2nd ednRivington, London, 1809
19.
YellowleesD.Masturbation, inTukeD. Hack, A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, Churchill, London, 1892, 784–6
20.
ArnoldT.Observations on the Nature, Kinds, Causes and Prevention, of InsanityRichard Phillips, London, 1806
21.
GalenC. G.Opera omnia, ed. KühnC. G., Oeuvres de Galien 1821–1833, cited in O. Diethelm, Medical Dissertations of Psychiatric Interest Published before 1750, S. Karger, Basel, 1971, 72–73
22.
RogersD.The motor disorders of severe psychiatric illness: a conflict of paradigmsBrit J Psychiat147, 1958221–37
23.
PerfectW.Annals of Insanity. Comprising a Selection of Curious and Interesting Cases in the Different Species of Lunacy, Melancholy or Madness, 5th edn, the author, London (no date)
24.
DufourJ. M.Essai sur les Operations de l'Entendement Humaine et surles Maladies, Merlin, Amsterdam, 1770, 357, cited by M. D. Altschule, The Development of Traditional Psychopathology, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1976, 221
25.
LockeJ.An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, Vol. 1, 19th edn, T. Longman, London, 140–1, cited in M. D. Altschule, The Development of Traditional Psychopathology, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1976, 35–6
26.
MacdonaldM.Mystical Bedlam: Madness, Anxiety and Healing in Seventeenth-Century EnglandCambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1981
27.
MacdonaldM.Mystical Bedlam: Madness, Anxiety and Healing in Seventeenth-Century England, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge1981131
28.
MacdonaldM.Mystical Bedlam: Madness, Anxiety and Healing in Seventeenth-Century England, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge1981143
29.
BurtonR.The Anatomy of MelancholyJ. M. Dent and Sons, London, 1932
30.
MacdonaldM.Mystical Bedlam: Madness, Anxiety and Healing in Seventeenth-Century England, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge1981248–9
31.
AquinasSt T.Summa Theologica, Ia. lxxviii 3–4 and ad 2, from St Thomas Aquinas, Philosophical Texts, tr. T. Gilby, Oxford University Press, New York, 1951 cited by W. S. Sahakian, History of Psychology, F. E. Peacock, Iasca, Illinois, 1968, 24
32.
CombeG.The Constitution of Man Considered in Relation to External Objects, Daniel Appleton and Co, New York, 1838, 52–3
33.
MacalpineI.HunterR.George III and the Mad BusinessPantheon Books, New York, 1969
34.
SidetaM. Cited by Aetus (Tetrabil) II, Sermo II, cap. II; in turn cited by O. Diethelm, Medical Dissertations of Psychiatric Interest Published before 1750, S. Karger, Basel, 1971, 20–1
35.
DiethelmO.Medical Dissertations of Psychiatric Interest Published before 1750, S. Karger, Basel197137
HallidayA.SIRA General View of the Present Stale of Lunatics and Lunatic Asylums in Great Britain and Ireland etc. 1829, cited by W. A. F. Brown, What Asylums Were, Are and Used to Be, Adam and Charles Black, Edinburgh, 1837
38.
GrahamT. J.Modern Domestic Medicine: A Popular Treatise, 9th edn, London, 1844557
