The perception of visual illusions is a powerful diagnostic of implicit integration of global information. Many illusions occur when length, size, orientation, or luminance are misjudged because neighboring visuospatial information cannot be ignored. We asked if people with Williams syndrome (WS), a rare genetic disorder that results in severely impaired global visuospatial construction abilities, are also susceptible to the context of visual illusions. Remarkably, we found that illusions influenced WS individuals to the same degree as normal adults, although size discrimination was somewhat impaired in WS. Our results are evidence that illusions are a consequence of the brain's bias to implicitly integrate visual information, even in a population known to have difficulty in explicitly representing spatial relationships among objects. Moreover, these results suggest that implicit and non-implicit integration of spatial information have different vulnerabilities in abnormal development.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ArditiAChoJ, 2007“Letter case and text legibility in normal and low vision”Vision Research472499–2505
2.
AtkinsonJBraddickOAnkerSCurranWAndrewRWattam-BellJBraddickF, 2003“Neurobiological models of visuospatial cognition in children with Williams syndrome: measures of dorsal-stream and frontal function”Developmental Neuropsychology23139–172
3.
BellugiULichtenbergerLMillsDGalaburdaAKorenbergJ R, 1999“Bridging cognition, the brain and molecular genetics: evidence from Williams syndrome”Trends in Neurosciences22197–207
4.
BihrleA MBellugiUDelisDMarksS, 1989“Seeing either the forest or the trees: dissociation in visuospatial processing”Brain and Cognition1137–49
5.
BondarkoV MSemenovL A, 2004“Size estimation in Ebbinghaus illusion in adults and children of different age”Fiziologya Cheloveka3031–37 (in Russian)
6.
BrunoNBernadisP, 2002“Dissociating perception and action in Kanizsa's compression illusion”Psychonomic Bulletin & Review9723–730
7.
ChisumH JFitzpatrickD, 2004“The contribution of vertical and horizontal connections to the receptive field center and surround in V1”Neural Networks17681–693
8.
CorenSGirgusJ S, 1978Seeing is Deceiving: The Psychology of Visual Illusion (Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; distributed by Halsted Press) pp xiii, 255
9.
CurranWBraddickO JAtkinsonJWattam-BellJAndrewR, 1999“Development of illusory-contour perception in infants”Perception28527–538
10.
DainiRAngelelliPAntonucciGCappaS FVallarG, 2002“Exploring the syndrome of spatial unilateral neglect through an illusion of length”Experimental Brain Research144224–237
11.
DeruelleCManciniJLivetM OCasse-PerrotCde SchonenS, 1999“Configural and local processing of faces in children with Williams syndrome”Brain and Cognition41276–298
12.
EaglemanD M, 2001“Visual illusions and neurobiology”Nature Reviews of Neuroscience2920–926
13.
FarranE K, 2005“Perceptual grouping ability in Williams syndrome: evidence for deviant patterns of performance”Neuropsychologia43815–822
14.
FarranE KJarroldC, 2003“Visuospatial cognition in Williams syndrome: reviewing and accounting for the strengths and weaknesses in performance”Developmental Neuropsychology23173–200
15.
GriceS JHaanM DHalitHJohnsonM HCsibraGGrantJKarmiloff-SmithA, 2003“ERP abnormalities of illusory contour perception in Williams syndrome”NeuroReport141773–1777
16.
GrossbergSMingollaERossW D, 1997“Visual brain and visual perception: how does the cortex do perceptual grouping?”Trends in Neurosciences20106–111
17.
GunnACoryEAtkinsonJBraddickOWattam-BellJGuzzettaACioniG, 2002“Dorsal and ventral stream sensitivity in normal development and hemiplegia”NeuroReport13843–847
18.
HadjikhaniNChabrisC FJosephR MClarkJMcGrathLAharonIFeczkoETager-FlusbergHHarrisG J, 2004“Early visual cortex organization in autism: an fMRI study”NeuroReport15267–270
19.
HessRFieldD, 1999“Integration of contours: new insights”Trends in Cognitive Sciences3480–486
20.
HoffmanJ ELandauBPaganiB, 2003“Spatial breakdown in spatial construction: evidence from eye fixations in children with Williams syndrome”Cognitive Psychology46260–301
21.
JordanHReissJ EHoffmanJ ELandauB, 2002“Intact perception of biological motion in the face of profound spatial deficits: Williams syndrome”Psychological Science13162–167
22.
KáldyZKovácsI, 2003“Visual context integration is not fully developed in 4-year-old children”Perception32657–666
23.
KapadiaM KItoMGilbertC DWestheimerG, 1995“Improvement in visual sensitivity by changes in local context: parallel studies in human observers and in V1 of alert monkeys”Neuron15843–856
24.
Karmiloff-SmithAThomasMAnnazDHumphreysKEwingSBraceNDuurenMPikeGGriceSCampbellR, 2004“Exploring the Williams syndrome face-processing debate: the importance of building developmental trajectories”Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines451258–1274
25.
KourtziZToliasA SAltmannC FAugathMLogothetisN K, 2003“Integration of local features into global shapes: monkey and human fMRI studies”Neuron37333–346
26.
Krinsky-McHaleS JKittlerPBrownW TJenkinsE CDevennyD A, 2005“Repetition priming in adults with Williams syndrome: age-related dissociation between implicit and explicit memory”American Journal of Mental Nephrology110482–496
27.
LandauBHoffmanJ EKurzN, 2006“Object recognition with severe spatial deficits in Williams syndrome: sparing and breakdown”Cognition100483–510
28.
LenhoffH MWangP PGreenbergFBellugiU, 1997“Williams syndrome and the brain”Scientific American277(6) 68–73
29.
LeviD MKleinS A, 1990“The role of separation and eccentricity in encoding position”Vision Research30557–585
30.
LeviD MKleinS AYapY L, 1988“‘Weber's law’ for position: unconfounding the role of separation and eccentricity”Vision Research28597–603
31.
MervisC BRobinsonB FBertrandJMorrisC AKlein-TasmanB PArmstrongS C, 2000“The Williams syndrome cognitive profile”Brain and Cognition44604–628
32.
Meyer-LindenbergAKohnPMervisC BKippenhanJ SOlsenR KMorrisC ABermanK F, 2004“Neural basis of genetically determined visuospatial construction deficit in Williams syndrome”Neuron43623–631
33.
MondlochC JGeldartSMaurerDde SchonenS, 2003“Developmental changes in the processing of hierarchical shapes continue into adolescence”Journal of Experimental Child Psychology8420–40
34.
MooreC MEgethH, 1997“Perception without attention: evidence of grouping under conditions of inattention”Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance23339–352
35.
MurrayS OBoyaciHKerstenD, 2006“The representation of perceived angular size in human primary visual cortex”Nature Neuroscience9429–434
36.
MurrayS OKerstenDOlshausenB ASchraterPWoodsD L, 2002“Shape perception reduces activity in human primary visual cortex”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA9915164–15169
37.
PalomaresMLandauBEgethH, 2008“Visuospatial interpolation in typically developing children and in people with Williams Syndrome”Vision Research482439–2450
38.
PaniJ RMervisC BRobinsonB F, 1999“Global spatial organization by individuals with Williams Syndrome”Psychological Science10453–458
39.
PaulB MStilesJPassarottiABavarNBellugiU, 2002“Face and place processing in Williams syndrome: evidence for a dorsal–ventral dissociation”NeuroReport131115–1119
40.
PlaistedKDoblerVBellSDavisG, 2006“The microgenesis of global perception in autism”Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders36107–116
41.
QuinnP CBhattR SBrushDGrimesASharpnackH, 2002“Development of form similarity as a Gestalt grouping principle in infancy”Psychological Science13320–328
42.
ReissA LEckertM ARoseF EKarchemskiyAKeslerSChangMReynoldsM FKwonHGalaburdaA, 2004“An experiment of nature: brain anatomy parallels cognition and behavior in Williams syndrome”Journal of Neuroscience245009–5015
43.
ReissJ EHoffmanJ ELandauB, 2005“Motion processing specialization in Williams syndrome”Vision Research453379–3390
44.
RoparDMitchellP, 1999“Are individuals with autism and Asperger's syndrome susceptible to visual illusions?”Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines401283–1293
45.
Tager-FlusbergHPlesa-SkwererDFajaSJosephR M, 2003“People with Williams syndrome process faces holistically”Cognition8911–24
46.
VicariSBellucciSCarlesimoG A, 2001“Procedural learning deficit in children with Williams syndrome”Neuropsychologia39665–677
