We examined a variant of the anomalous motion illusion. In a series of experiments, we ascertained luminance contrast to be the critical factor. Low-contrast random dots showed longer latency than high-contrast ones, irrespective of whether they were dark or light (experiments 1–3). We conjecture that this illusion may share the same mechanism with the Hess effect, which is characterised by visual delay of a low-contrast, dark stimulus in a moving situation. Since the Hess effect is known as the monocular version of the Pulfrich effect, we examined whether illusory motion in depth could be observed if a high-contrast pattern was projected to one eye and the same pattern of low-contrast was presented to the other eye, and they were binocularly fused and swayed horizontally. Observers then reported illusory motion in depth when the low-contrast pattern was dark, but they did not when it was bright (experiment 4). Possible explanations of this inconsistency are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AnstisS, 2001“Footsteps and inchworms: Illusions show that contrast affects apparent speed”Perception30785–794
2.
AnstisS, 2004“Factor affecting footsteps: contrast can change the apparent speed, amplitude and direction of motion”Vision Research442171–2178
3.
AnstisSRogersB J, 1986“Illusory continuous motion from oscillating positive – negative patterns: implications for motion perception”Perception15627–640
AshidaH, 2002“Spatial frequency tuning of the Ouchi illusion and its dependence on stimulus size”Vision Research421413–1420
6.
AshidaHSakuraiKKitaokaA, 2005“A new variant of the Ouchi illusion reveals Fourier-component-based processing”Perception34381–390
7.
BackusB TOruçI, 2005“Illusory motion from change over time in the response to contrast and luminance”Journal of Vision51055–1069
8.
BlakemoreM RSnowdenR J, 1999“The effect of contrast upon perceived speed: a general phenomenon?”Perception2833–48
9.
BressanPVezzaniS, 1995“A new motion illusion related to the aperture problem”Perception241165–1176
10.
CampbellF WMaffeiL, 1981“The influence of spatial frequency and contrast on the perception of moving patterns”Vision Research21713–721
11.
CavanaghPTylerC WFavreauO E, 1984“Perceived velocity of moving chromatic gratings”Journal of the Optical Society of America A1893–899
12.
ConwayR BKitaokaAYazdanbakhshAPackC CLivingstoneM S, 2005“Neural basis for a powerful static motion illusion”Journal of Neuroscience255651–5656
13.
DienerH CWistE RDichgansJBrandtT, 1976“The spatial frequency effect on perceived velocity”Vision Research16169–172
14.
DodwellP CHarkerG SBeharI, 1968“Pulfrich effect with minimal differential adaptation of the eyes”Vision Research81431–1443
15.
FaubertJHerbertA M, 1999“The peripheral drift illusion: A motion illusion in the visual periphery”Perception28617–621
16.
FermüllerCPlessRAloimonosY, 1997“Families of stationary patterns producing illusory movement; insights into the visual system”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B264795–806
17.
FermüllerCPlessRAloimonosY, 2000“The Ouchi illusion as an artifact of biased flow estimation”Vision Research4077–96
18.
FraserAWilcoxK J, 1979“Perception of illusory movement”Nature281565–566
19.
GegenfurtnerK RHawkenM J, 1996“Perceived velocity of luminance, chromatic and non-Fourier stimuli: Influence of contrast and temporal frequency”Vision Research361281–1290
20.
GoriSHamburgerK, 2006“A new motion illusion: The Rotating-Tilted-Lines illusion”Perception35853–857
21.
GoriSHamburgerKSpillmannL, 2006“Reversal of apparent rotation in the Enigma-figure with and without motion adaptation and the effect of T-junctions”Vision Research463267–3273
22.
GregoryR L, 1993“A comment: Mackay Rays shimmer due to accommodation changes”Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, Series B253123
23.
von GrünauM W, 1975a“The ‘fluttering heart’ and spatio-temporal characteristics of color processing—I: Reversibility and the influence of luminance”Vision Research15431–436
24.
von GrünauM W, 1975b“The ‘fluttering heart’ and spatio-temporal characteristics of color processing—II. Lateral interactions across the chromatic border”Vision Research15437–440
25.
von GrünauM W, 1976“The ‘fluttering heart’ and spatio-temporal characteristics of color processing—III: Interactions between the systems of the rods and the long-wavelength cones”Vision Research16397–401
26.
GurnseyRPagéG, 2006“Effects of local and global factors in the Pinna illusion”Vision Research461823–1837
27.
GurnseyRSallyS LPotechinCManciniS, 2002“Optimising the Pinna – Brelstaff illusion”Perception311275–1280
28.
GuthS L, 1964“The effect of wavelength on visual perceptual latency”Vision Research4567–578
29.
HarkerG S, 1967“A saccadic suppression explanation of the Pulfrich phenomenon”Perception & Psychophysics2423–426
30.
von HelmholtzH, 1867/1962Treatise on Physiological Opticsvolume 2 (New York: Dover, 1962); English translation by SouthallJ P C for the Optical Society of America (1925) from the 3rd German edition of Handbuch der physiologischen Optik (first published in 1867, Leipzig: Voss)
31.
HessC, 1904“Untersuchungen über den Erregungsvorgang im Sehorgan bei kurz- und bei längerdauernder Reizung”Pflüger's Archiv für die gesamte Physiologie101226–262
32.
HineT JCookMRogersG T, 1995“An illusion of relative motion dependent upon spatial frequency and orientation”Vision Research353093–3102
33.
HineT JCookMRogersG T, 1997“The Ouchi illusion: an anomaly in the perception of rigid motion for limited spatial frequencies and angles”Perception & Psychophysics59448–455
34.
HowardI PRogersB J, 1995Binocular Vision and Stereopsis (New York: Oxford University Press)
35.
IchikawaMMasakuraYMunechikaK, 2006“Dependence of illusory motion on directional consistency in oblique components”Perception35933–946
36.
JuleszBWhiteB, 1969“Short-term visual memory and the Pulfrich phenomenon”Nature222639–641
37.
KhangB-GEssockE A, 1997a“A motion illusion from two-dimensional periodic patterns”Perception26585–597
38.
KhangB-GEssockE A, 1997b“Apparent relative motion from a checkerboard surround”Perception26831–846
39.
KhangB-GEssockE A, 2000“Apparent swinging motion from a 2-D sinusoidal pattern”Perception29453–459
40.
KitaokaA, 2005Trick Eyes Graphics (Tokyo: Kanzen)
41.
KitaokaA, 2006“Anomalous motion illusion and stereopsis”Journal of Three-dimensional Images (Japan)209–14
42.
KitaokaAAshidaH, 2003“Phenomenal characteristics of the peripheral drift illusion”Vision (Journal of the Vision Society of Japan)15261–262
43.
KitaokaAAshidaH, 2004“A new anomalous motion illusion: the ‘central drift illusion’”, paper presented at the 2004's winter meeting of the Vision Society of Japan, Kogakuin University, Tokyo, Japan (http://www.psy.ritsumei.ac.jp/∼akitaoka/VSJ04w.html)
44.
KitaokaAPinnaBBrelstaffG, 2001“New variations of the spiral illusion”Perception30637–646
45.
von KriesJ, 1896“Über die Wirkung kurzdauernder Lichtreize auf das Sehorgan” Zeitschrift für Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane1281–101; “Appendix II: Theories of Vision”, in Treatise on Physiological Opticsvolume 3 (New York: Dover, 1962); English translation by SouthallJ P C for the Optical Society for America (1925) from the 3rd German edition of Handbuch der physiologischen Optik (Hamburg: Voss, 1910) pp 426–454
46.
KumarTGlaserD A, 2006“Illusory motion in Enigma: A psychophysical investigation”Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA1031947–1952
47.
LeviantI, 1996“Does ‘brain-power’ make Enigma spin?”Proceedings of Royal Society of London, Series B263997–1001
48.
LitA, 1949“The magnitude of the Pulfrich stereophenomenon as a function of binocular differences of intensity at various levels of illumination”American Journal of Psychology62159–181
49.
LythgoeR, 1938“Some observations on the rotating pendulum”Nature141474
50.
MacKayD M, 1957“Moving visual images produced by regular stationary patterns”Nature180849–850
51.
MatherG, 2000“Integration biases in the Ouchi and other visual illusions”Perception29721–727
52.
MatherGMurdochL, 1999“Second-order processing of four-stroke apparent motion”Vision Research391795–1802
53.
MurakamiIKitaokaAAshidaH, 2006“A positive correlation between fixation instability and the strength of illusory motion in a static display”Vision Research462421–2431
54.
Naor-RazGSekulerR, 2000“Perceptual dimorphism in visual motion from stationary patterns”Perception29325–335
55.
Nguyen-TriDFaubertJ, 2003“The fluttering-heart illusion: a new hypothesis”Perception32627–634
56.
OuchiH, 1977Japanese Optical and Geometrical Art (Mineola, NY: Dover)
57.
PetrovY APoppleA V, 2002“Effects of negative afterimages in visual illusions”Journal of the Optical Society of America A191107–1111
58.
PinnaBBrelstaffG J, 2000“A new visual illusion of relative motion”Vision Research402091–2096
59.
PinnaBSpillmannL, 2002“A new illusion of floating motion in depth”Perception311501–1502
60.
PinnaBSpillmannL, 2005“New illusions of sliding motion in depth”Perception341441–1458
61.
PrestrudeA M, 1971“Visual latencies at photopic levels of retinal luminance”Vision Research11351–361
PrestrudeA MBakerH D, 1971“Light adaptation and visual latency”Vision Research11363–369
64.
PulfrichC, 1922“Die Stereoskopie im Dienste der isochromen und heterochromen Photometrie”Naturwissenschaften10553–564, 569–574, 596–601, 714–722, 735–743, 751–761
65.
RogersB JAnstisS M, 1972“Intensity versus adaptation and the Pulfrich stereophenomenon”Vision Research12909–928
66.
SmithA TEdgarG K, 1990“The influence of spatial frequency on perceived temporal frequency and perceived speed”Vision Research301467–1474
67.
SpillmannLHeitgerFSchullerS, 1986“Apparent displacement and phase unlocking in checkerboard patterns”, paper presented at the 9th European Conference on Visual Perception, Bad Nauheim
68.
StandingL GDodwellP CLangD, 1968“Dark adaptation and the Pulfrich effect”Perception & Psychophysics4118–120
69.
StoneL SThompsonP, 1992“Human speed perception is contrast dependent”Vision Research321535–1549
70.
ThompsonP G, 1982“Perceived rate of movement depends on contrast”Vision Research22377–380
71.
WadeN J, 1977“Distortions and disappearances of geometrical patterns”Perception6407–433
72.
WilliamsJ MLitA, 1983“Luminance-dependent visual latency for the Hess effect, the Pulfrich effect, and simple reaction time”Vision Research23171–179
73.
WilliamsD WSekulerR, 1984“Coherent global motion percepts from stochastic local motions”Vision Research2455–62
74.
WilsonH R, 1994“Models of two-dimensional motion perception”, in Visual Detection of Motion Eds SmithA TSnowdenR J (London: Academic Press) pp 219–251
75.
WilsonJ AAnstisS M, 1969“Visual delay as a function of luminance”American Journal of Physiology82350–358
76.
ZankerJ M, 2004“Looking at Op Art from a computational viewpoint”Spatial Vision1775–94
77.
ZankerJ MDoyleMWalkerR, 2003“Gaze stability of observers watching Op Art pictures”Perception321037–1049
78.
ZankerJ MWalkerR, 2004“A new look at Op art: towards a simple explanation of illusory motion”Naturwissenschaften91149–156
